No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Evil and Religious Pluralism: The Eschatological Resolution
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 28 February 2024
Extract
When Antony Flew in the 1950’s declared that religious assertions died ‘a death of a thousand qualifications’, he was expressing frustration in the face of a dogged refusal by theologians to relinquish cherished beliefs. No matter what conundrum the atheist camp hurled at the theists, they found (to their considerable consternation) that the theologians had moved the goalposts just that little further away. Although the debate following Flew’s comments addressed crucial questions concerning the meaningfulness of religious statements, it also highlighted, in my view, the durability and resilience of religious beliefs and assertions in the mind of the believer. Flew’s point was that religious believers, despite being surrounded by confusing and contradictory evidence, refuse to give up their notions and convictions concerning the divine. It is this resilience in the face of cognitive and experiential difficulties that forms the background of the following discussion.
As part of this paper I will be briefly looking at John Hick’s treatment of the problem of evil and be comparing this with his response to the problems of religious diversity. The purpose for such a comparison is not to provide an exhaustive look at these separate issues in relation to each other. Neither am I concerned to engage in recalcitrant hair-splitting regarding various ideas put forward by Hick. However, I will be showing how differently Hick has treated both problems and lead into a consideration of how the eschatological dimension of his thinking can result in a wholly different ‘solution’ to the question of religious diversity. I contend that the means are available to treat both questions in similar ways because of one highly significant factor—the possibility of further opportunities beyond death.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © 1997 Provincial Council of the English Province of the Order of Preachers
References
1 See Flew, A. Theology and Falsification’ in Flew, A. & Maclnlyre, A., New Essays in Philosophical Theology, (SCM Press, 1955).Google Scholar
2 Hume, D., Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, ed. Bell, M. (Penguin, 1990), p. 108–109.Google Scholar
3 see, Griffin, D. Creation out of Chaos and the Problem of Evil’ in ed. Davis, S., Encountering Evil, (T.&.T. Clark, 1994), pp. 101–119.Google Scholar
4 Hick, J., Hick's Response to Critiques in Encountering Evil, p. 63.Google Scholar
5 see Hick, J., Evil and the God of Love, (Macmillan, 1966; 2nd edn. 1977).Google Scholar
6 Hick, J., An Interpretation of Religion, (Macmillan, 1989) p. 246.Google Scholar
7 Ibid, p. 294–295.
8 Hick, J. in ed. Hewitt, H., Problems in the Philosophy of Religion, (Macmillan, 1991), p. 24–25.Google Scholar
9 Cantwell Smith, W. The Christian in a Religiously Plural World’ in eds. Hick, J. & Hebblethwaite, B., Christianity and Other Religions, (Fount, 1980), p. 94Google Scholar. Taken from ed. Oxtoby, W.G., Religious Diversity: Essays by Wilfred Cantwell Smith, (Harper & Row, 1976).Google Scholar
10 Sharpe, E. J. describes such a ‘total life‐stance’ as ‘a totally explicit set of values which affect everything, in this world and (in its own terms) beyond it.’Google Scholar Understanding Religion, (Duckworth, 1992) p. 27.Google Scholar
11 Gillis, C. in Problems of the Philosophy of Religion, p. 40.Google Scholar
12 Hay, D., Religious Experience Today, (Mowbray, 1990), p. 35.Google Scholar
13 Tillich, P., The Shaking of the Foundations (First published by SCM Press, 1949. Pelican, 1962) p. 67.Google Scholar
14 Taylor, J.V., ‘The Theological Basis of Interfaith Dialogue’ in Christianity and Other Religions, p. 225. Originally delivered as the first Lambeth Interfaith Lecture on 2 November 1977.Google Scholar
15 Tillich, P., The Shaking of the Foundations, p. 64.Google Scholar
16 Ibid, p. 60.
17 Tillich, P., Dynamics of Faith, (Allen & Unwin, 1957), p. 52.Google Scholar
18 Ward, K.. Truth and Religious Diversity’, Religious Studies, 26, 1990, p. 7.Google Scholar
19 I discuss the need for further research into this aspect of religious experience in ‘Religious Surveying: Commonality Between Traditions’, The Scottish Journal of Religious Studies, Vol. XVL No. 2, Autumn 1995.Google Scholar
20 See Part V ‘A Possible Human Destiny’ in Hick, J. Death and Eternal Life, (Macmillan, 1985, 2nd edn).Google Scholar
21 Ward, K., ‘Truth and Religious Diversity’, p. 18.Google Scholar