Hostname: page-component-5c6d5d7d68-thh2z Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-08-16T13:34:28.898Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“Monstrous Propositions” of a Dominican

Rodolph Suffield & David Urquhart on the Morality of War

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2024

Tony Cross
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

When, as a student at Oxford, Johnson “took up Law’s Serious Call. . . expecting to find it a dull book”, he found it “quite an overmatch” for him. Taking up David Urquhart’s Effect on the World of the Restoration of Canon Law ... a Vindication of the Catholic Church against a Priest, I found myself in somewhat similar case—struck by the moral passion and remorseless logic. Urquhart’s luckless opponent was the Dominican friar, Fr. Rodolph Suffield—celebrated English Dominican preacher of the 1860s. Urquhart (1805-77) was an eccentric Scottish aristocrat, a Protestant papalist, who succeeded in pushing his concern over the morality of war on to the preparatory documentation of the first Vatican Council. Suffield (1821-91), by the late 1860s profoundly antagonistic to ultramontanism, left the Church to become a Unitarian minister shortly after the promulgation of the Infallibility Decree. It is perhaps timely to recall their contestation as contemporary British foreign policy impales itself upon the horns of its current moral dilemmas.

Type
Article
Information
New Blackfriars , Volume 82 , Issue 959 , January 2001 , pp. 23 - 34
Copyright
Copyright © 2001 Provincial Council of the English Province of the Order of Preachers

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Urquhart, David: Effect on the World of the Restoration of the Canon Law, being a Vindication of the Catholic Church against a Priest (London, Diplomatic Review Office 1869) p.41Google Scholar—hereafter EWRCL

2 Boswell, James: Life of Johnson (Everyman Edn. 1949) vol. 1 p.33Google Scholar

3 EWRCL—op.cit.

4 Bishop, M.C.: Memoir of Mrs. Urquhart (London, Kegan Paul 1897) p.45Google Scholar

5 vide e.g. Melancon, G.: Peaceful Intentions. the First British Trade Commission in China 1833–35 (Historical Review vol. 73 No. 180 ) pp. 33–47 Google Scholar

6 EWRCG op.cit. p.60

7 EWRCM op.cit. p.70

8 Denbigh, Earl of: Letter to The Times 3 Dec. 1867

9 Urquhart, D.: Appel d'un Protestant au Pape pour le rétablissement du Droit Public des Nations (Paris, Douniol 1869)Google Scholar [edns. also in English and Latin] hereafter Appel

10 Robinson, G.: David Urquhart (Oxford, Blackwell 1920) p. 266Google Scholar

11 Vattel, E. de: Droits des Gens (1758) trans. 1834

12 Urquhart, D.: Appel p.22

13 vide e.g. Taylor, A.J.P.: The Trouble Makers (Penguin 1957)Google Scholar and, more recently and outrageously: Wheen, K.: Karl Marx (4th Estate 1999)Google Scholar

14 Urquhart, Harriet: Letter to R. Poore 24 June 1869 from St. Gervais—David Urquhart Papers—Balliol College—hereafter DUP

15 Denbigh, Earl of Letter to Harriet Urquhart 15 Sept. 1869 from Taymount Park, DUP

16 Suffield, Robert Rodolph: Letter to C. Jones 25 Aug. 1869 from Husbands Bosworth, DUP

17 Newman, J.H.: Letter to Henry Wilberforce 13 Aug. 1870 in Letters & Diaries of John Henry Newman vol. 25 p. 181 Google Scholar

18 Ferraris.: Bibliothèque Ouverte ou Arsenal Canonique (ed. with notes by monks of Monte Cassino 1844)

19 Denbigh, Earl of: Letter to Suffield dated 25 Oct. 1869 (privately printed)

20 Anon.: The Crown of Jesus (compiled by Frs. Suffield, R.R. and Palmer, C.F.R.), (London, Richardson 1862)Google Scholar

21 Suffield, R.R.: Letter to Lord Denbigh (printed but not published 1869)

22 The Tablet vol. 34 No. 1533, 28 Aug. 1869 pp. 405–406

23 Suffield, R.R. & Urquhart, D.: The Right of the Soldier to Absolution (printed not published 1869)Google Scholar

24 Urquhart, H.: Letter to R. Poore 24 June 1869 from St. Gervais, DUP

25 EWRCL p. 54—Abbé Jullion quoted by Abbé Defourny in Letter to David Urquhart 5 Aug. 1869 from Beaumont en Argonne, DUP

26 EWRCL p.38

27 Robinson, G. op.cit. p. 268

28 Acta et Decreta app. XXV

29 vide Cross, T.: From Friar to Free Christian—Martineau's Hand in Suffield's ‘Apostacy’ (Transactions of the Unitarian Historical Society vol. XXI No. 4 , April 1998 pp. 296–301 Google Scholar)

30 Robinson, G.: op.cit. p. 295

31 Urquhart, F.F.: David Urquhart. the Law of Nations & the Vatican Council (Oxford, Blackwell 1918Google Scholar—reprinted from The Dublin Review 1917) p.7

32 Urquhart, F.F.: op.cit. p.26