No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Re-Making the English Organ: Musical and Liturgical Contexts, 1830–1870
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 17 June 2015
Abstract
The article describes the evolution of the English organ under the influence of changes in musical style and liturgical practice between 1830 and 1870. A preliminary discussion of the Georgian organ and the performance conventions of its players provides a benchmark against which to measure the ensuing changes. S.S. Wesley is taken as a case study with reference to changes made to the Hereford Cathedral organ in 1832; it is argued that these reflect Wesley's musical priorities, a point that is further illustrated by a consideration of the registration markings found in the original manuscripts of ‘The Wilderness’ (1832) and ‘Blessed be the God and Father’ (1834). They also demonstrate an innovative use of the pedals.In the following section the influence of Mendelssohn is discussed. His performances of Bach in England during the 1830s and 1840s promoted a radical change is organ design and performance practice; the C-compass organs with German pedal divisions built by (among others) William Hill were ideal instruments both for Bach's organ music and for Mendelssohn's own organ sonatas which combined classical form with a romantic sensibility.The concluding section reviews developments in the years 1850–70. It considers changes in console design and the growing taste for orchestral registers, even in church organs. Choral accompaniments also became more orchestral in character, and a number of representative examples from Ouseley's Special Anthems (1861, 1866) are discussed. Liturgical changes after 1850 are also considered, together with their impact on the role of the organ in worship.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2015
References
1 Bicknell, Stephen, The History of the English Organ (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996)Google Scholar: 213.
2 Bicknell, , History of the English Organ, 213Google Scholar.
3 Thistlethwaite, Nicholas, The Making of the Victorian Organ (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990)Google Scholar: 12–13.
4 Warren, Joseph, ed., Hamilton's Catechism of the Organ, second edition (London: Robert Cocks, 1842)Google Scholar: 52.
5 Done, Joshua, A Complete Treatise on the Organ (London: Balls & Son, c. 1840)Google Scholar: 41.
6 Marsh, John, Eighteen voluntaries for the organ, to which is prefix'd an explanation of the different stops of the organ (London: Preston, 1791)Google Scholar.
7 Marsh, Eighteen voluntaries.
8 Greeves, Henry, ‘An Organist of the Old School – Mr. Thomas Parratt’, Musical Opinion 16/4 (1893)Google Scholar: 407.
9 Jebb, John, The Choral Service of the United Church of England and Ireland (London: 1843)Google Scholar: 232.
10 Temperley, Nicholas, ‘Cathedral music’, in The Romantic Age, 1800–1914, edited Nicholas Temperley, Vol. 5 of The Athlone History of Music in Britain (London: Athlone Press, 1981)Google Scholar: 176–9.
11 Cathedral choirs at the end of the Georgian period had fewer singers than their Victorian successors: few had more than 10 or 12 boys, and the effectiveness of the adult singers was often compromised by their non-attendance or old age.
12 The term ‘console’ was originally applied to keyboards detached from the main body of the organ and enclosed, with the drawstops and pedals, in their own free-standing casing. Cavaillé-Coll's reversed consoles offered a prototype (though they had their predecessors in central Europe). By the early-twentieth century the term was commonly applied to keyboards and drawstops located in the traditional position at the front of the organ case, too.
13 Blewitt, Jonas, A Complete Treatise on the Organ (London: Longman & Broderip, [1794])Google Scholar: 2.
14 Thistlethwaite, , Making of the Victorian Organ, 16–18Google Scholar.
15 Blewitt, , Complete Treatise, 7Google Scholar.
16 Done, Complete Treatise, 71–5; Warren, , Hamilton's Catechism of the Organ, 47–48Google Scholar, Ex. 43.
17 Lady [Mary] Elvey, Life and Reminiscences of George J. Elvey (London: Sampson Low, Marston & Company, 1894): 316–17.
18 Hereford Cathedral Archives: Chapter Acts, vol. 8 (1814–34): 365.
19 Hereford Cathedral: Chapter Acts, vol. 8, 372–3.
20 Hereford Cathedral: Chapter Acts, vol. 8, 383.
21 See, Shaw, Watkins, The Organs and Organists of Hereford Cathedral (Hereford: Friends of Hereford Cathedral, 1976)Google Scholar, 28–30.
22 See, Thistlethwaite, , Making of the Victorian Organ, 52–54Google Scholar; Bicknell, , History of the English Organ, 220–223Google Scholar.
23 For example, in the final movement (‘Fugue’) of Voluntary XII of William Russell's Twelve Voluntaries, for the Organ or Piano Forte [Set 1] (London: Clementi, [1805]): 48–9. A later example is found in bars 140–160 and 169–175 of Samuel Wesley's ‘Fuga’ (1826), in, Wesley, Samuel, Six voluntaries and fugues for organ, ed. Robin Langley (London: Oxford University Press, 1980)Google Scholar: 32.3.
24 Russell, Twelve voluntaries [Set 1], second movement (‘Andantino’), 30. The pedals, coupled to the Great stopped diapason, play a trio with the Swell hautboy [LH] and Choir cremona [RH] for 12 bars.
25 See, for example, Voluntaries XV and XXIV in William Russell, Twelve Voluntaries for the Organ or Piano Forte [Set 2] (London: Clementi, [1812]).
26 For a discussion of this, see, Thistlethwaite, , Making of the Victorian Organ, 14–23Google Scholar, 96–105.
27 The other was the remarkable instrument in St James’, Bristol (1824): see, Thistlethwaite, , Making of the Victorian Organ, 457–458Google Scholar.
28 Bishop claimed it as his ‘invention’ and seems first to have used it c. 1820; see, Thistlethwaite, , Making of the Victorian Organ, 112Google Scholar.
29 This was the reason given by John Gray for replacing the Great upperwork at Christchurch Cathedral, Oxford (originally by ‘Father’ Smith) in 1847.
30 Thistlethwaite, , Making of the Victorian Organ, 54Google Scholar.
31 Horton, Peter, Samuel Sebastian Wesley, a Life (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004)Google Scholar: 38–44, 51–4.
32 Horton, , Wesley, 39–40Google Scholar.
33 Hereford Cathedral: MS C.9.xii, 52–73Google Scholar; Wesley, Samuel Sebastian, Anthems, vol. 1 (London: Addison & Hollier, 1853Google Scholar): 65–100.
34 Horton, , Wesley, 40–41Google Scholar.
35 Hereford Cathedral: Chapter Acts, vol. 8 (1814–34): 383.
36 Bumpus, John S., A History of English Cathedral Music, vol. 2 (London: T. Werner Laurie, [1908]): 370Google Scholar; the two judges were respectively R.J.S. Stevens and Dr William Crotch. See, Horton, , Wesley, 45–49Google Scholar.
37 Thistlethwaite, , Making of the Victorian Organ, 135–143Google Scholar, 372–3.
38 Gatens, William J., Victorian Cathedral Music in Theory and Practice (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986)Google Scholar: 110.
39 Little, William A., Mendelssohn and the Organ (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar: 246, 256–9, 262–3, 278.
40 The Musical World 20 (1845): 358.
41 Little, Mendelssohn and the Organ; Yearsley, David, Bach's Feet: the Organ Pedals in European Culture (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2012)CrossRefGoogle Scholar. See also, Thistlethwaite, Nicholas, ‘Mendelssohn und die englische Orgel’, in “Diess herrliche, imponirende Instrument”: Die Orgel im Zeitalter Felix Mendelssohn Bartholdys, ed. Anselm Hartinger, Christoph Wolff and Peter Wollny (Wiesbaden: Breitkopf & Härtel, 2011)Google Scholar: 175–86.
42 The dates are suggested by the collaboration of Dr Gauntlett and William Hill; though other players and builders adopted the principles of the ‘German System’ during the 1840s, Gauntlett and Hill were the pioneers and worked together on at least 21 instruments, commencing with Christ Church, Newgate Street in 1838. See, Nicholas Thistlethwaite, ‘The Hill-Gauntlett Revolution: an Epitaph?’, BIOS Journal 16 (1992): 50–59.
43 See, Thistlethwaite, , Making of the Victorian Organ, 181–214Google Scholar.
44 The Musical World 8 (1838), 101.
45 Paul and Carl Mendelssohn Bartholdy, eds; Grace Maxwell [Lady] Wallace, trans., Letters of Felix Mendelssohn Bartholdy from 1833 to 1847 (London: Longmans, Green & Co., 1863): 281.
46 F.G. Edwards, ‘Mendelssohn's Organ Sonatas’, Proceedings of the Musical Association, twenty-first session (1894–5), 5; the performance took place in Joseph Walker's organ workshop in Francis Street, Tottenham Court Road, London in April 1846.
47 Edwards, F.G., ‘Mendelssohn's Organ Sonatas’, 5Google Scholar.
48 The Musical Times 34 (1893): 81.
49 The Hill organ was ordered in March 1848 (London Metropolitan Archives: St Mary-at-Hill Vestry Minutes, vol. 4 (1843–80), 16 March 1848). However, it is clear from the Minutes that major repairs to the building were ongoing in December 1848, when the Vestry resolved to mortgage property to pay for them, and it was not until the following year that the major contractors, including Hill, were paid (Annual Accounts, 1848–49; no paging). The organ would not have been installed until the builders’ work was finished, and it is a reasonable assumption that this would therefore have been in the first half of 1849.
50 See also David Yearsley's discussion of the use of the pedal in this sonata: Yearsley, , Bach's Feet, 214–221Google Scholar.
51 Little, , Mendelssohn and the Organ, 329Google Scholar, 331–2, 381–2, 384.
52 Little, , Mendelssohn and the Organ, 280–283Google Scholar.
53 Yearsley, , Bach's Feet, 213Google Scholar.
54 The Musical World 9 (1838): 247.
55 The Musical World 9 (1838): 247.
56 Hopkins, Edward J. and Rimbault, Edward F., The Organ, its History and Construction, first edition (London: Robert Cocks, 1855)Google Scholar: 262.
57 The attempt by The College of Organists in 1881 to resolve the issues surrounding pedal design was only partly successful because it failed to accommodate the views of those like W.T. Best whose preference was for the radiating and concave pedal board championed by Henry Willis and used as early as 1854 (Winchester Cathedral) and 1855 (Liverpool, St George's Hall). Concave pedal boards with parallel keys were also favoured by some influential organists, including Walter Parratt. See, Report of the Council of the College of Organists (London: 1881): 4–5.
58 Hopkins and Rimbault, The Organ, first edition, 266.
59 Thistlethwaite, Nicholas, Birmingham Town Hall Organ (Birmingham: Birmingham City Council, 1984)Google Scholar: 20.
60 The Birmingham stops heads were 51 mm in diameter, and St Mary-at-Hill's were 45 mm; the later Victorian norm was around 35 mm. See: Thistlethwaite, , Making of the Victorian Organ, 253Google Scholar.
61 Hopkins, and Rimbault, , The Organ, 266–267Google Scholar.
62 Hopkins, and Rimbault, , The Organ, 267Google Scholar.
63 Hopkins, and Rimbault, , The Organ, 268Google Scholar.
64 Whitchurch Parish Church, Shropshire: an organ by Jackson of Liverpool; Henry Willis included angled jambs in the St George's Hall, Liverpool instrument (1855).
65 Westminster Abbey, rebuilt by Hill in 1848; Hopkins and Rimbault, The Organ, 267.
66 Lincoln's Inn Chapel, London, new organ by Hill (terraced); Buckingham Palace, Ballroom organ, by Gray & Davison (sloping).
67 Introduced to England by Kirtland & Jardine in the mid-1850s: Thistlethwaite, Making of the Victorian Organ, 304, 370–71.
68 Musical Opinion 13 (1890), 470.
69 Audsley, George Ashdown, The Art of Organ-Building (New York: Dodd, Mead & Co., 1905)Google Scholar, vol. 2, 246
70 Elise Polko, trans. Grace Maxwell [Lady] Wallace, Reminiscences of Felix Mendelssohn-Bartholdy – a Social and Artistic Biography (London: Longmans, Green & Co., 1869): 235.
71 Philippe d'Anchald, ‘Charles Spackman Barker: a Reassessment of the Earlier Years of his Career’, BIOS Journal 33 (2009): 16–19.
72 Thistlethwaite, , Making of the Victorian Organ, 351–359Google Scholar.
73 Thistlethwaite, , Making of the Victorian Organ, 365–366Google Scholar.
74 See, McVicker, William and Wickens, David, ‘Thoughts on the Inclusion of the Tierce rank in English Mixture Stops, 1660–1940’, BIOS Journal 32 (2008)Google Scholar, 123–45.
75 Pole, William, Musical Instruments in the Great Industrial Exhibition of 1851 (London, 1851)Google Scholar, 67.
76 The Musical World 33 (1855), 130.
77 Edwards, F.G., ‘John Stainer’, The Musical Times 39 (1901)Google Scholar, 308.
78 Sir Frederick Arthur Gore Ouseley, Special anthems for certain seasons and festivals of the United Church of England and Ireland, vol. 1 (London: Robert Cocks, 1861), vol. 2 (London: Novello, 1866).
79 As in Hopkins’ two early services in F and A (London: J. Alfred Novello, [1852]), which, as well as including clear pedal markings, are carefully registered.
80 Ouseley, Special Anthems, vol. 1, 61–8, 158–66.
81 Ouseley, Special Anthems, vol. 2, 27.
82 The Pyramidon was a register of Ouseley's invention and included by Flight in his organ for St Michael's College, Tenbury (1856). The pipes were made of wood, in the form of an inverted pyramid; a pipe no more than 3′ tall produced a 16′ tone. The Tenbury register was a rare example, and sounded at 32′ pitch. Hopkins and Rimbault, The Organ, third edition (1877): 135.
83 Dibble, Jeremy, John Stainer, a Life in Music (Woodbridge: Boydell Press, 2007)Google Scholar: 62.
84 Ouseley, Special Anthems, vol. 2, 137–53.
85 Gatens, Victorian Cathedral Music, 60–64.
86 Gatens, , Victorian Cathedral Music, 171Google Scholar, citing Stainer, John, The Present State of Music in England (Oxford, 1889): 11–12Google Scholar.
87 The Choir and Musical Record 2 (1864): 113–14.
88 Spark, William, Henry Smart: his Life and Works (London: William Reeves, 1881): 229–230Google Scholar.
89 Temperley, Nicholas, The Music of the English Parish Church (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1979)Google Scholar, vol. 1, 284–5.
90 Temperley, Music of the English Parish Church, vol. 1, 314.
91 Curwen, J. Spencer, Studies in Worship-Music (London: J. Curwen, 1880)Google Scholar, 95.
92 Curwen, , Worship-Music, 94Google Scholar.
93 Temperley, Music of the English Parish Church, vol. 1, 279.
94 Dibble, Jeremy, Charles Villiers Stanford (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002)Google Scholar: 103.