Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-s2hrs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-17T16:38:43.409Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

‘Adventure, Heterodoxy and Knavery’: Queensland's Electoral Experience

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 February 2016

Get access

Extract

I have drawn the title for this paper, which celebrates the 100-year anniversary of the abolition of plural voting in Queensland, from S.R. Davis, who described the electoral experience of the Australian states as:

A mixture of three things — adventure, heterodoxy and knavery. Between them, the States have fathered a crop of electoral devices, confounded their textbook behaviour, and at times and in places used them with a skill which even a fun-fair poker machine proprietor could admire.

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1 Davis, S.R. (ed.), The Government of the Australian States (Melbourne: Longman, 1960): 565.Google Scholar

2 Grofman, B. Lijphart, A., ‘Introduction’, in Grofman, B. Lijphart, A. (eds), Electoral Laws and Their Political Consequences (New York: Agathon Press, 1986): 23.Google Scholar

3 Sawer, M., ‘Pacemakers for the World?’ in Sawer, M. (ed.), Elections Full Free and Fair (Sydney: Federation Press, 2001): 127.Google Scholar

4 Waterson, D.W., Squatter, Selector Storekeeper: A History of the Darling Downs (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 1968): 246.Google Scholar

5 Sawer, ‘Pacemakers for the World?’: 67.Google Scholar

6 Sawer, ‘Pacemakers for the World?’: 23.Google Scholar

7 I have used the modern spelling throughout. The party adopted the American spelling ‘Labor’ in 1912, although both continued to be used.Google Scholar

8 QPD, Legislative Assembly, 14 June 1892: 337.Google Scholar

9 QPD, Assembly 19 November 1942: 1277.Google Scholar

10 Hughes, C.A., The Government of Queensland (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 1980): 87.Google Scholar

11 QPD Assembly, 19 November 1942: 1223.Google Scholar

12 Hughes, The Government of Queensland: 104.Google Scholar

13 QPD, 5 December 1962: 2227.Google Scholar

14 Electoral Commission of Queensland, Queensland Election 2001, Ballot Paper Survey (Brisbane, March 2002): 10.Google Scholar

15 Queensland Year Book, 1960, cited in A History of the Queensland Zonal Electoral System (Brisbane: Electoral and Administrative Review Commission, 1990).Google Scholar

16 QPD debates, Assembly, 29 September 1905: 124.Google Scholar

17 QPD, 29 September: 122.Google Scholar

18 QPD, Legislative Council, 10 January 1905: 80Google Scholar

19 QPD, Assembly, 30 September 1905: 147.Google Scholar

20 QPD, Assembly, 30 September 1905: 139.Google Scholar

21 QPD, Legislative Council, 25 November 1914: 2179.Google Scholar

22 QPD, Legislative Assembly, 3 November 1914: 1674.Google Scholar

23 Grofman and Lijphart, Electoral Laws and Their Political Consequences: 23.Google Scholar

24 EARC: 2.Google Scholar

25 QPD, Assembly, 30 September 1905: 141.Google Scholar

26 Wear, R., ‘The Weighting Game’, in Prasser, S., Wear, R. Nethercote, J. (eds), Corruption and Reform: The Fitzgerald Vision (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 1990): 259.Google Scholar

27 Quoted in Watson, D., Recollections of a Bleeding Heart (New York: Knopf, 2002): 271.Google Scholar

28 Davis, The Government of the Australian States: 264.Google Scholar

29 Hughes, C.A., ‘The Electoral Redistribution of 1977', in Cribb, M. Bridson Boyce, P.J. (eds), Politics in Queensland 1977 and Beyond (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 1980); B. Stevens, ‘Reform of the State Electoral System’, in The Goss Government, Promise and Performance of Labor in Queensland (Melbourne: Macmillan, 1993): 131.Google Scholar

30 Hughes, The Government of Queensland: 88; Hughes, ‘The Electoral Redistribution of 1977': 48.Google Scholar

31 QPD, Assembly, 16 September 1931: 837.Google Scholar

32 Fadden, A., They Called Me Artie (Brisbane: Jacaranda, 1967): 37.Google Scholar

33 Coaldrake, P., Working the System (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 1989): 37.Google Scholar

34 Coaldrake, Working the System: 30; EARC: 23Google Scholar

35 Fitzgerald, R. Thornton, H., Labor in Queensland: From the 1880s to 1988 (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 1989): 55.Google Scholar

36 Fitzgerald and Thornton, Labor in Queensland: 257.Google Scholar

37 QPD, 29 March 1949: 2279.Google Scholar

38 QPD, 1948–49: 2331.Google Scholar

39 Reynolds, P., ‘Problems and Prospects for Electoral Reform after Fitzgerald’, in Prasser, Wear and Nethercote, Corruption and Reform: 245.Google Scholar

40 QPD, March 1949: 2004Google Scholar

41 Callaghan, Allan, cited in Wear, R., Johannes Bjelke-Petersen: The Lord's Premier (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 2002).Google Scholar

42 EARC: 35.Google Scholar

43 QPD, 25 November 1958: 1627.Google Scholar

44 ’… One Vote, One “Value”’, Courier-Mail, 6 May 1958.Google Scholar

45 Reynolds, ‘Problems and Prospects for Electoral Reform after Fitzgerald’: 245.Google Scholar

46 Quoted in EARC: 31Google Scholar

47 Quoted in Wells, D., The Deep North (Brisbane: Outback Press, 1979): 87.Google Scholar

48 EARC: 40.Google Scholar

49 Quoted in EARC: 40.Google Scholar

50 Fitzgerald Report (1989): 127.Google Scholar

51 EARC: 39Google Scholar

52 Reynolds, ‘Problems and Prospects for Electoral Reform’: 246.Google Scholar

53 QPD, 10 April 1985: 5117.Google Scholar

54 Jaensch, D., ‘The Bjelke-mander’, in Patience, A. (ed.), The Bjelke-Petersen Premiership, 1968–1983, Issues in Public Policy (Melbourne: Longman Cheshire, 1985); J. Kelly, ‘Vote Weightage and Quota Gerrymanders in Queensland, 1931–1971, The Australian Quarterly, 43(2) (1971): 54.Google Scholar

55 QPD 1984–85, vol. 298: 4512.Google Scholar

56 Hughes, The Government of Queensland: 83.Google Scholar

57 Wear, Johannes Bjelke-Petersen: 220.Google Scholar

58 Quoted in Chamberlin, G., Canberra Survey, 29(11) (November 1976).Google Scholar

59 Wear, Johannes Bjelke-Petersen, 222.Google Scholar

60 Quoted in Reynolds, ‘Problems and Prospects for Electoral Reform after Fitzgerald’: 247.Google Scholar

61 Preston, N., Peter Douglas Beattie, the Inclusive Populist in Murphy, D., Joyce, R., Cribb, M. Wear, R. (eds), The Premiers of Queens land (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 2003): 419.Google Scholar

62 For an account of how deeply flawed the US system was, see Sawer, ‘Pacemakers for the World?’: v.Google Scholar