Hostname: page-component-84b7d79bbc-l82ql Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-26T07:18:59.870Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Pozharskii's Grave and the Search for the Russian Nation in the Nineteenth Century

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 August 2023

Susan Smith-Peter Open the ORCID record for Susan Smith-Peter [Opens in a new window]
Susan Smith-Peter*
Affiliation:
College of Staten Island/ City University of New York, susan.smithpeter@csi.cuny.edu
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Prince D.M. Pozharskii, who together with Kuz΄ma Minin helped to end the Time of Troubles in 1612-13, has been the focus of commemoration for centuries and has come to symbolize the defense of the Russian nation. This article focuses on three moments of his commemoration in the nineteenth century: the classical Pozharskii, as seen in the monument on Red Square, the nationalist Pozharskii, which reimagined him almost as a saint of the nation, and the regionalist Pozharskii, which presented him as a heroic forerunner of the zemstvo and the self-directed action of the Russian people. Using a wide variety of sources, the article shows how Pozharskii's grave and its commemoration were the focus of contention over what the Russian nation was and ought to be: composed of loyal and unquestioning subjects of the tsars, saint-like warriors, or a people that was self-governing at the local level. It also argues for the importance of including local narratives and sources in the historical narrative, as this was where the demand for self-government was most clearly made. Dead bodies can spark lively discussions, and when the body is Pozharskii's, the stakes can be as high as the meaning of the Russian nation itself.

Type
Articles
Information
Slavic Review , Volume 82 , Issue 1 , Spring 2023 , pp. 69 - 89
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Association for Slavic, East European, and Eurasian Studies

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. According to the monastery historian L. Sakharov, the grave markers were removed and the tented roof in stone over the grave destroyed by Archimandrite Efrem in 1765 and 1766 while in a rage about the secularization of the monastery's lands. Sakharov, Leonid I., Istoricheskoe opisanie Suzdal΄skogo pervoklassnogo Spaso-Evfimieva monastyria (Vladimir, 1878), 10Google Scholar.

2. Aleksei Sergeevich Uvarov, ed., Sbornik melkikh trudov: Izd. ko dniu 25-letiia so dnia konchiny, vol. 4: Materialy dlia biografii i stat΄i po teoreticheskim voprosam (Moscow, 1910), 27–28.

3. Leonid Andreevich Beliaev, Rodovaia usypal΄nitsa kniazei Pozharskikh i Khovanskikh v Spaso-Evfimievom monastyre Suzdalia: 150 let izucheniia (Moscow, 2013).

4. Dunning, Chester S. L., Russia's First Civil War: The Time of Troubles and the Founding of the Romanov Dynasty (University Park, Penn., 2001), 438–39Google Scholar.

5. Ibid., 441.

6. This narrative is mainly drawn from Dunning, Russia's First Civil War, as well as Maureen Perrie, Pretenders and Popular Monarchism in Early Modern Russia: The False Tsars of the Time of Troubles (Cambridge, Eng., 1995); Sergei Fedorovich Platonov, The Time of Troubles: A Historical Study of the Internal Crises and Social Struggle in Sixteenth- and Seventeenth-Century Muscovy, trans. John T. Alexander (Lawrence, 1970); Vasilii Osipovich Kliuchevsky, A Course in Russian History: The Seventeenth Century (Chicago, 1968); G. Edward Orchard, “The Election of Michael Romanov,” The Slavonic and East European Review 67, no. 3 (July 1989): 378–402; and Ivan Zabelin, Minin i Pozharskii (Moscow, 1883).

7. Zorin, Andrei, By Fables Alone: Literature and State Ideology in Late-Eighteenth–Early-Nineteenth- Century Russia, trans. Levitt, Marcus C. with Monnier, Nicole and Schlaffy, Daniel (Boston, 2014), 178–79CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8. Russell Martin, “‘The Encounter between Personal Commitment and Scholarly Curiosity’: A Reappreciation of Sergei Fedorovich Platonov's Ocherki po istorii smuty,” Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History 15, no. 4 (Fall 2014): 837–52.

9. Dunning, Russia's First Civil War; Gruber, Isaiah, Orthodox Russia in Crisis: Church and Nation in the Time of Troubles (DeKalb, 2012)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Perrie, Maureen, “Recent Western Historiography of the Time of Troubles in Russia,” Vestnik SPBGU. Istoriia 63, no. 1 (January 2018): 244–61CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

10. Iurii Anatol΄evich Ivanov, “Kniaz΄ Pozharskii: Vchera, segodnia, zavtra (Istoriograficheskii etiud),” Pozharskii iubileinyi al΄manakh: Vypusk no. 2 “K 10-letiiu iavleniia v grade Iuzhe ikony Presviatoi Bogoroditsy Neopalimaia kupina” (2007): 5–11; A. A. Selin, “Smutnoe vremia v istoriografii poslednikh let,” in A. I. Filiushkin, Smutnoe vremia v Rossii: Konflikt i diakog kul΄tur (St. Petersburg, 2012).

11. Elena Vishlenkova, “Picturing the Russian National Past in the Early 19th Century,” Jahrbücher für Geschichte Osteuropas 60, no. 4 (2012): 489–509; ibid., Vizual΄noe narodovedenie imperii, ili “uvidet΄ russkogo dano ne kazhdomu,” (Moscow, 2011); Richard Wortman, Scenarios of Power: Myth and Ceremony in Russian Monarchy, 2 vols. (Princeton, 1995–2000); Zorin, By Fables.

12. Beliaev, Rodovaia usypal΄nitsa.

13. A. L. Bamalov, I. A. Voromnikova, eds. Kniga ob izbranii na prevysochaishii prestol velikogo Rossiiskogo tsarstviia velikogo gosudaria tsaria i velikogo kniazia Mikhaila Fedorovicha, vseia Velikaiia Rossii samoderzhtsa: Iz sobraniia Muzeev Moskovskogo Kremlia: Issledovaniia, kommentarii, tekst (Moscow, 2012), 23.

14. Whittaker, Cynthia, Russian Monarchy: Eighteenth-Century Rulers and Writers in Political Dialogue (DeKalb, 2003), 31Google Scholar.

15. Wortman, Scenarios of Power, 1:32.

16. Ibid., 37; Batalov, Kniga, 33.

17. Wortman, Scenarios of Power, 1:37.

18. Mikhail Lomonosov, Polnoe sobranie sochinenii, vol. 6 (Moscow, 1952), 373.

19. Valerii Shamshurin, Minin i Pozharskii—Spasiteli Otechestva (Moscow, 1997), 190.

20. Zorin, By Fables, 157.

21. N. V. Timofeeva et al., “Issledovanie pamiatnika Mininu i Pozharskomu,” Khudozhestvennoe nasledie 13 (1990): first page of plates; Zorin, By Fables, 158; Richard Wortman, “Solntsev, Olenin, and the Development of a Russian National Aesthetic,” in Cynthia H. Whittaker, ed., Visualizing Russia: Fedor Solntsev and Crafting a National Past (Leiden, Netherlands, 2010), 17–40.

22. Zorin, By Fables, 178–79.

23. Schmidt, Albert J., The Architecture and Planning of Classical Moscow: A Cultural History (Philadelphia, 1989), 156–58Google Scholar.

24. Kupriianov, Aleksandr Ivanov, Gorodskaia kul΄tura russkoi provintsii: Konets XVIII—pervaia polovina XIX veka (Moscow, 2007), 384Google Scholar.

25. Lincoln, W. Bruce, Nicholas I: Emperor and Autocrat of All the Russias (Bloomington, 1989), 86–87Google Scholar.

26. Hamburg, Gary M., Russia's Path toward Enlightenment: Faith, Politics, and Reason, 1500–1801 (New Haven, 2016), 718CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

27. Hamburg, Russia's Path; Derek Offord, “Nation-Building and Nationalism in Karamzin's History of the Russian State,” Journal of Russian History and Historiography 3 (January 2010): 1–50.

28. Nikolai Mikhailovich Karamzin, Istoriia gosudarstva Rossiiskogo, vol. 12.

29. Nikolai Karamzin, “O liubvi k otechestvu i narodnoi gordosti,” http://az.lib.ru/k/karamzin_n_m/text_0330.shtml (accessed March 31, 2023).

30. Chester Dunning, “The Tsar's Red Pencil: Nicholas I and Censorship of Pushkin's Boris Godunov,” Slavic and East European Journal 54, no. 2 (June 2010): 238–54.

31. Kirill Koval΄dzhi, ed., Zapiski A. O. Smirnovoi, urozhdennoi Rosset s 1825 po 1845 gg. (Moscow, 1999), 95.

32. On Adam Smith's influence on Nicholas, see Susan Smith-Peter, Imagining Russian Regions: Subnational Identity and Civil Society in Nineteenth Century Russia (Leiden, Netherlands, 2018).

33. Smith-Peter, Imagining Russian Regions.

34. Nathaniel Knight, “Ethnicity, Nationality and the Masses: Narodnost΄ and Modernity in Imperial Russia,” in David Hoffmann and Yanni Kotsonis, eds., Russian Modernity: Politics, Knowledge, Practices (New York, 2000), 41-64, here 43.

35. Ibid., 50.

36. J. Laurence Black, “Nicholas Karamzin's ‘Opinion’ on Poland: 1819,” The International History Review 3, no. 1 (January 1981): 1-19, here 12.

37. Ibid., 1.

38. David B. Saunders, “Historians and Concepts of Nationality in Early Nineteenth-Century Russia,” The Slavonic and East European Review 60, no. 1 (January 1982): 44–62, here 61.

39. Maksim Mikhailovich Shevchenko, “Poniatie ‘teoriia ofitsial΄noi narodnosti’ i izuchenie vnutrennei politiki imperatora Nikolaia I,” Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. 8. Istoriia, no. 4 (2002): 89–104.

40. Nicholas V. Riasanovsky, Nicholas I and Official Nationality in Russia, 1825–1855 (Berkeley, 1959).

41. Cynthia Whittaker, The Origins of Modern Russian Education: An Intellectual Biography of Count Sergei Uvarov, 1786–1855 (DeKalb, 1984); Alexei Miller, The Romanov Empire and Nationalism: Essays in the Methodology of Historical Research (Budapest, 2008), 139–59; Shevchenko, “Poniatie;” Zorin, By Fables, 325–58.

42. Miller, Romanov Empire; Shevchenko, “Poniatie.”

43. Zorin, By Fables; Whittaker, Origins of Modern Russian.

44. Miller, Romanov Empire, 141–42.

45. Ibid., 151.

46. Uvarov, Sbornik melkikh trudov, 41.

47. Mikhail Pogodin, “Issledovanie o meste pogrebeniia Kn. D. M. Pozharskago,” Moskvitianin, no. 19 (1852), otd. III: 39.

48. Vladimirskiia Gubernskiia Vedomosti (hereafter VGV), 1838, no. 37.

49. Ivan Vasil΄evich and Piotr Vasil΄evich Kireevskii, Polnoe sobranie sochinenii: v 4 tomakh (Kaluga, 2006), 2: 227.

50. Gosudarstvennyi arkhiv Rossiiskoi Federatsii (hereafter GARF), fond (f.) 649 (Mikhail Nikolaevich, Velikii kniaz΄), opis΄ (op.) 1, delo (d.) 770, list (ll.) 6ob-7ob (Dokumenty o g. Suzdale Vladimirskoi gubernii); VGV, 1838, no. 37.

51. Uvarov, Sbornik melkikh trudov, 26–27.

52. Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi arkhiv drevnikh aktov (hereafter RGADA), f. 1203 (Spaso-Evfimiev monastyr’), op. 1, viaz. 302, d. 14 (O priselke v bratstvo byvshego professora Tverskoi seminarii Ioasafa Gaponova).

53. RGADA, f. 1203, op. 1, viaz. 302, d. 14.

54. RGADA, f. 1203, op. 1, viaz. 303, d. 1 (O vozobnovlenii proizvodstva magisterskogo oklada ieromonakhu Ioasafu Gaponovu).

55. K. T. Iusupova, “Zhizneopisanie i trudy Arseniia Elassonskogo,” Kafedra vizantiiskoi i novogrecheskoi filologii: Nauchno-teoreticheskii zhurnal, no. 1–2 (3) (2018): 168–77.

56. VGV, 1849, no. 10.

57. K. N. Tikhonravov, “Mogila kniazia Dmitriiа Mikhailovichа Pozharskogo v Suzdal΄skom Spaso-Evfimievskom monastyre,” Trudy Vladimirskoi uchenoi arkhivnoi kommissii 12 (1910): 22–23. On shifting views towards Catholicism, see Paul W. Werth, The Tsar's Foreign Faiths: Toleration and the Fate of Religious Freedom in Imperial Russia (Oxford, 2014).

58. See Ph. A. Demetracopoulos, “On Arsenios, Archbishop of Elasson,” Byzantinoslavica 42 (1981): 145–53; George-Julius Papadopoulos and Claudia Jensen, “‘A Confusion of Glory’: Orthodox Visitors as Sources for Muscovite Musical Practice (Late 16th–mid 17th Century),” Intersections 26, no. 1 (2005): 3–33.

59. A. Dmitrevskii, Arkhiepiskop Elassonskii Arsenii i memuary ego iz russkoi istorii (Kiev, 1899), 161.

60. Ioasaf, Kniaz΄ Dmitrii Mikhailovich Pozharskii i Arsenii Arkhiepiskop Suzdal΄skii (Vladimir, 1854), 3.

61. Ibid., 8.

62. L. S. Klein, Istoriia Rossiiskoi arkheologii: Ucheniia, shkoly i lichnosti (St. Petersburg, 2014), 300.

63. Ibid., 301.

64. Whittaker, Origins of Modern Russian, 237, 243.

65. Uvarov, Sbornik melkikh trudov, 185.

66. Klein, Istoriia Rossiiskoi arkheologii, 308–9.

67. Ibid., 323.

68. RGADA, f. 1203, op. 1, viaz. 310, n. 44 (O vosstanovlenii usypal΄nitsy Kn. Pozharskikh), l. 5.

69. Iu. P. Savel΄ev, “Vizantiiskii stil’” v arkhitekture Rossii: Vtoraia polovina XIX—nachalo XX veka (Moscow, 2005), 13.

70. Savel΄ev, “Vizantiiskii stil΄,” 9; Wortman, “Alexei Olenin.”

71. RGADA, f. 1203, op. 1, viaz. 310, n. 44, l. 7.

72. Ibid.

73. Suzdal΄ i ego dostopamiatnosti (Moscow, 1912), 72.

74. Rosalind P. Blakesley, The Russian Canvas: Painting in Imperial Russia, 1757–1881 (New Haven, 2016), 55.

75. N. N. Ushakov, ed., Sputnik po drevnemu Vladimiru i gorodam Vladimirskoi gubernii (Vladimir, 1913), 196–97.

76. N. Barsukov, Zhizn΄ i trudy M. P. Pogodina, vol. 21 (St. Petersburg, 1907), 410; Patrice M. Dabrowski, Poland: The First Thousand Years (DeKalb, 2014), 335.

77. Barsukov, Zhizn΄ i trudy, 411–12.

78. Ibid., 417–18.

79. Sakharov, Istoricheskoe opisanie, 63.

80. Blakesley, The Russian Canvas, 230–39.

81. L. Sakharov, “Suzdal΄sko-Nizhegorodskoe torzhestvo nashikh dnei,” Nizhegorodskiia gubernskiia vedomosti, no. 21, May 22, 1885, 3.

82. RGADA, f. 1203, op. 1, viaz. 310, n. 44, l. 124ob.

83. Sakharov, “Suzdal΄sko-Nizhegorodskoe torzhestvo,” 5.

84. Ibid.

85. Sakharov, Istoricheskoe opisanie Suzdal΄skogo pervoklassnogo Spaso-Evfimieva monastyria (Vladimir, 1870); Sakharov, Istoricheskoe opisanie (Vladimir, 1878); A. V. Smirnov, Urozhentsy i deiateli Vladimirskoi gubernii, poluchivshie izvestnost΄ na razlichnykh poprishchakh obshchestvennoi pol΄zy, vol. 4 (Vladimir, 1910), 220.

86. RGADA, f. 1203, op. 1, viaz. 310, n. 44, l. 136.

87. Ibid., ll. 20–22.

88. Catherine Evtuhov, Portrait of a Russian Province: Economy, Society, and Civilization in Nineteenth-Century Nizhnii Novgorod (Pittsburgh, 2011), 241.

89. Ibid., 18.

90. Ibid., 233; Anne Lounsbery, Life is Elsewhere: Symbolic Geography in the Russian Provinces, 1800–1917 (Ithaca, 2019), 168–71.

91. A. Gatsiskii, “Suzdal΄sko-Nizhegorodskoe torzhestvo nashikh dnei,” Nizhegorodskiia gubernskiia vedomosti, no. 20, May 15, 1885, 2.

92. Ibid.

93. Ibid.

94. T. F. Pirozhkova, ed., Zapiski Aleksandra Ivanovicha Kosheleva (1812–1883 gody) (Moscow, 2002), 17.

95. Francis Wcislo, Reforming Rural Russia: State, Local Society, and National Politics, 1855–1914 (Princeton, 1990), 99.

96. Gatsiskii, “Suzdal΄sko-Nizhegorodskoe torzhestvo,” 2.

97. Ibid.

98. Maria Evgen΄evna Rodina, D. M. Pozharskii: Vechnaia pamiat΄ i trava zabveniia (Vladimir, 2007), 15.

99. S. P. Gordeev, Spaso-Efimiev monastyr΄ v Suzdale (Moscow, 2006), 27.

100. “Dmitrii Medvedev otkryl mavzolei Pozharskogo v Suzdale (Vladimirskaia oblast΄),” regnum, at https://regnum.ru/news/1221644.html (accessed March 31, 2023).

101. Marielle Wijermars, Memory Politics in Contemporary Russia: Television, Cinema and the State (London, 2019), 122–63.