Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-m9pkr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-08T09:27:01.889Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Criminal Class Revisited

Recidivism and Punishment in Ontario, 1871–1920

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 January 2016

Helen Boritch
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Much of the renewed interest in the history of crime and punishment over the past two decades has centered on various aspects of the nineteenth-century notion of a criminal class. Although recidivism was widely regarded as the defining feature of the criminal class, little of this research has focused on systematic investigations of either differences between recidivists and the rest of the prison population or the nature and extent of recidivism-related differences in sentence outcomes. This article examines these two issues using data on offenders committed to Middlesex County Jail, Ontario, from 1871 to 1920. The results show that while recidivists differed from first-time committals to prison in terms of a number of sociodemographic and case-related characteristics, they bore little resemblance to contemporary stereotypes about the criminal class. In addition, the findings reveal both similarities and noteworthy differences with respect to the factors associated with harsher sentencing outcomes for recidivists and nonrecidivists.

Type
Articles
Information
Social Science History , Volume 29 , Issue 1 , spring 2005 , pp. 137 - 170
Copyright
Copyright © Social Science History Association 2005 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Adler, Jeffrey S. (1994) “The dynamite, wreckage, and scum in our cities: The social construction of deviance in industrial America.” Justice Quarterly 11: 33–49.Google Scholar
Allen, Richard (1968) “The social gospel and the reform tradition in Canada, 1890–1928.” Canadian Historical Review 49: 381–99.Google Scholar
Armstrong, Frederick H., and Brock, Daniel J. (1974) “The rise of London: A study of urban evolution in nineteenth-century Ontario,” in Armstrong, Frederick H., Stevenson, Hugh A., and Donald Wilson, J. (eds.) Aspects of Nineteenth-Century Ontario. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Beattie, John M. (1977) “Attitudes towards crime and punishment in Upper Canada, 1830–1850: A documentary study.” Working Paper, Centre of Criminology, University of Toronto.Google Scholar
Bellomo, J. Jerald (1972) “Upper Canadian attitudes towards crime and punishment (1832–1851).” Ontario History 64: 11–26.Google Scholar
Boritch, Helen (1992) “Gender and criminal court outcomes: An historical analysis.” Criminology 30: 293–325.Google Scholar
Craven, Paul (1983) “Law and ideology: The Toronto Police Court 1850-80,” in Flaherty, David H. (ed.) Essays in the History of Canadian Law, vol. 2. Toronto: University of Toronto Press for the Osgoode Society: 248–307.Google Scholar
Davis, Jennifer (1980) “The London garotting panic of 1861: A moral panic and the creation of a criminal class in mid-Victorian England,” in Gatrell, V. A. C., Lenman, Bruce, and Parker, Geoffrey (eds.) Crime and the Law: The Social History of Crime in Western Europe since 1500. London: Europa: 190–213.Google Scholar
Emsley, Clive (1996) “Albion’s felonious attractions: Reflections upon the history of crime in England,” in Emsley, Clive and Knafla, Louis A. (eds.) Crime History and Histories of Crime: Studies in the Historiography of Crime and Criminal Justice in Modern History. Westport, CT: Greenwood: 66–85.Google Scholar
Fingard, Judith (1984) “Jailbirds in mid-Victorian Halifax,” in Waite, Peter B., Oxner, Sandra, and Barnes, Thomas Garden (eds.) Law in a Colonial Society: The Nova Scotia Experience. Toronto: Carswell: 81–102.Google Scholar
Friedman, Lawrence M., and Percival, Robert V. (1981)The Roots of Justice: Crime and Punishment in Alameda County, California, 1870–1910. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Garland, David (1990) Punishment and Modern Society: A Study in Social Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Garton, Stephen (1996) “The convict taint: Australia and New Zealand,” in Emsley, Clive and Knafla, Louis A. (eds.)Crime History and Histories of Crime: Studies in the Historiography of Crime and Criminal Justice in Modern History. Westport, CT: Greenwood: 271–90.Google Scholar
Gatrell, V. A. C. (1980) “The decline of theft and violence in Victorian and Edwardian England,” in Gatrell, V. A. C., Lenman, Bruce, and Parker, Geoffrey (eds.) Crime and the Law: The Social History of Crime in Western Europe since 1500. London: Europa: 238–337.Google Scholar
Goldsmith, Larry (1997) “History from the inside out: Prison life in nineteenth-century Massachusetts.” Journal of Social History 31: 109–25.Google Scholar
Graff, Harvey J. (1977a) “Crime and punishment in the nineteenth century: A new look at the criminal.” Journal of Interdisciplinary History 7: 477–91.Google Scholar
Graff, Harvey J. (1977b) “‘Pauperism, misery, and vice’: Illiteracy and criminality in the nineteenth century.” Journal of Social History 11 245–68.Google Scholar
Gurr, Ted Robert (1981) “Historical trends in violent crime: A critical review of the evidence,” in Morris, Norval and Tonry, Michael H. (eds.) Crime and Justice: An Annual Review of Research. Chicago: University of Chicago Press: 295–353.Google Scholar
Hahn, Nicholas F. (1980) “Too dumb to know better: Cacogenic family studies and the criminology of women.”Criminology 18: 3–25.Google Scholar
Harring, Sidney L. (1983) Policing a Class Society: The Experience of American Cities, 1865-1915. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
Hershberg, Theodore, and Dockhorn, Robert (1976) “Occupational classification.” Historical Methods Newsletter 9: 59–97.Google Scholar
Hershberg, Theodore, Katz, Michael, Blumin, Stuart, Glasco, Laurence, and Griffin, Clyde (1973) “Occupation and ethnicity in five nineteenth-century cities: A collaborative inquiry.” Historical Methods Newsletter 7: 174–216.Google Scholar
Homel, Gene H. (1981) “Denison’s law: Criminal justice and the police court in Toronto, 1877–1921.” Ontario History 73: 171–87.Google Scholar
Hosmer, David W., and Lemeshow, Stanley (1989)Applied Logistic Regression. New York: John Wiley and Sons.Google Scholar
Houston, Susan Elizabeth (1974) “The impetus to reform: Urban crime, poverty and ignorance in Ontario 1850–1875.”PhD diss., University of Toronto.Google Scholar
Katz, Michael B. (1972) “Occupational classification in history.” Journal of Interdisciplinary History 3: 63–68.Google Scholar
Katz, Michael B., Doucet, Michael J., and Stern, Mark J. (1982) The Social Organization of Early Industrial Capitalism. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Knafla, Louis A. (1996) “Structure, conjuncture, and event in the historiography of modern criminal justice history,” in Emsley, Clive and Knafla, Louis A. (eds.) Crime History and Histories of Crime: Studies in the Historiography of Crime and Criminal Justice in Modern History. Westport, CT: Greenwood: 33–44.Google Scholar
Lane, Roger (1980) “Urban homicide in the nineteenth century: Some lessons for the twentieth,” in Inciardi, James A. and Faupel, Charles E. (eds.) History and Crime: Implications for Criminal Justice Policy. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage: 91–109.Google Scholar
Lohdi, Abdul Q., and Tilly, Charles (1973) “Urbanization, crime and collective violence in nineteenth-century France.” American Journal of Sociology 70: 396–418.Google Scholar
McGahan, Peter (1988) Crime and Policing in Maritime Canada. Fredericton, NB: Goose Lane Editions.Google Scholar
McKanna, Clare V. (1985) “Ethnics and San Quentin prison registers: A comment on methodology.” Journal of Social History 19: 477–82.Google Scholar
McLean, Lorna (1996) “Common criminals, simple justice: The social construction of crime in nineteenth-century Ontario, 1840–81.” PhD diss., University of Ottawa.Google Scholar
Monkkonen, Eric (1977) The Dangerous Class: Crime and Poverty in Columbus, Ohio, 1860–1885. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Monkkonen, Eric (1979) “Systematic criminal justice history: Some suggestions.” Journal of Interdisciplinary History 9: 451–64.Google Scholar
Monkkonen, Eric (1980) “The quantitative historical study of crime and criminal justice,” in Inciardi, James A. and Faupel, Charles E. (eds.) History and Crime: Implications for Criminal Justice Policy. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage: 53–73.Google Scholar
Monkkonen, Eric (1981a) “A disorderly people: Urban order in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.” Journal of American History 68: 539–59.Google Scholar
Monkkonen, Eric (1981b) Police in Urban America, 1860–1920. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Morrison, T. R. (1976) “‘Their proper sphere’: Feminism, the family and child-centered reform in Ontario, 1875–1900.”Ontario History 63: 45–74.Google Scholar
Nicholas, Stephen, ed. (1988) Convict Workers: Reinterpreting Australia’s Past. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Oliver, Peter (1988) “‘A terror to evil-doers’: The Central Prison and the ‘criminal class’ in late nineteenth-century Ontario,” in Hall, Roger, Westfall, William, and MacDowell, Laurel Sefton (eds.) Patterns of the Past: Interpreting Ontario’s History. Toronto: Dundurn: 206–37.Google Scholar
Oliver, Peter (1998) “Terror to Evil-doers”: Prisons and Punishments in Nineteenth-Century Ontario. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Philips, David (1977) Crime and Authority in Victorian England: The Black Country 1835–1860. London: Croom Helm.Google Scholar
Phillips, Jim (1996) “Crime and punishment in the dominion of the north: Canada from New France to the present,” in Emsley, Clive and Knafla, Louis A. (eds.) Crime History and Histories of Crime: Studies in the Historiography of Crime and Criminal Justice in Modern History. Westport, CT: Greenwood: 163–99.Google Scholar
Pisciotta, Alexander W. (1994) Benevolent Repression: Social Control and the American Reformatory-Prison Movement. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Pitsula, James (1980) “The treatment of tramps in late nineteenth-century Toronto.” Canadian Historical Association Papers: 116–32.Google Scholar
Province of Ontario (1891) Report of the Commission Appointed to Enquire into the Prison and Reformatory System of Ontario. Toronto: Warwick and Sons.Google Scholar
Rafter, Nicole Hahn (1990) Partial Justice: Women, Prisons and Social Control. 2nd ed. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.Google Scholar
Rude, George (1985) Criminal and Victim: Crime and Society in Early Nineteenth-Century England. Oxford, U.K.: Clarendon.Google Scholar
Rutherford, Paul, ed. (1974) Saving the Canadian City: The First Phase, 1880–1920. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Schneider, John C. (1980) Detroit and the Problem of Order, 1830–1880: A Geography of Crime, Riot and Policing. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.Google Scholar
Slone, Neal (1993) “Evaluating court statistics as a data source for studying nineteenth-century crime.”Historical Methods 26: 85–93.Google Scholar
Stevenson, S. J. (1986) “The ‘habitual criminal’ in nineteenth-century England: Some observations on the figures.”Urban History Yearbook 13: 37–51.Google Scholar
Thorner, Thomas, and Watson, Neil B. (1984) “Keeper of the King’s peace: Colonel G. E. Saunders and the Calgary Police Magistrate’s Court, 1911–1932.” Urban History Review 12: 45–55.Google Scholar
Tobias, J. J. (1967) Crime and Industrial Society in the Nineteenth Century. New York: Schocken.Google Scholar
Tombs, Robert (1980) “Crime and the security of the state: The ‘dangerous classes’ and insurrection in nineteenth-century Paris,” in Gatrell, V. A. C., Lenman, Bruce, and Parker, Geoffrey (eds.)Crime and the Law: The Social History of Crime in Western Europe since 1500. London: Europa: 214–37.Google Scholar
Valverde, Mariana (1991) The Age of Light, Soap and Water: Moral Reform in English Canada, 1885–1925. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart.Google Scholar
Weaver, John C. (1988) “Crime, public order and repression: The Gore District in upheaval, 1832–1851,” in Macleod, R. C. (ed.) Lawful Authority: Readings on the History of Criminal Justice in Canada. Toronto: Copp Clark Pitman: 22–48.Google Scholar
Weaver, John C. (1995) Crime, Constables and Courts: Order and Transgression in a Canadian City, 1816–1970. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.Google Scholar
Weinberger, Barbara (1990) “The criminal class and the ecology of crime.” Historical Social Research 15: 121–39.Google Scholar
Weiner, Martin J. (1990) Reconstructing the Criminal: Culture, Law, and Policy in England, 1830–1914. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Wetherell, Donald G. (1979) “To discipline and train: Adult rehabilitation programs in Ontario Prisons, 1874–1900.”Histoire Sociale/Social History 12: 145–65.Google Scholar
Zedner, Lucia (1991) Women, Crime and Custody in Victorian England. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar