Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-2xdlg Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-29T01:18:49.596Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Impartial Judges? Race, Institutional Context, and U.S. State Supreme Courts

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 January 2021

Chris W. Bonneau  and
Heather Marie Rice
Chris W. Bonneau
Affiliation:
University of Pittsburgh
Heather Marie Rice
Affiliation:
University of Pittsburgh
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

We address a fundamental question in judicial politics: other factors being equal, do African-American judges behave differently than white judges? Many presume that white judges differ from their minority counterparts in terms of sentencing, deliberation, and propensity to overturn decisions. However, to date, little empirical evidence exists to suggest systematic differences in behavior between these judges. Here, we utilize the newly created judge-level U.S. State Supreme Court Database to assess whether judicial decisionmaking is affected by the race of the judge. Looking at all criminal cases decided by U.S. state supreme court judges from 1995 to 1998, we find evidence of differences between white and non-white judges, but only in states lacking an intermediate appellate court. This finding suggests the effects of race on judicial decisionmaking are conditioned by the institutional structure of the court system.

Type
Research Article
Information
State Politics & Policy Quarterly , Volume 9 , Issue 4 , Winter 2009 , pp. 381 - 403
Copyright
Copyright © 2009 by the Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Allen, David W., and Wall, Diane E.. 1987. “The Behavior of Women State Supreme Court Justices: Are They Tokens or Outsiders?” Justice System Journal 12:232–44.Google Scholar
Arceneaux, Kevin T., Bonneau, Chris W., and Brace, Paul. 2008. “Judging Under Constraint: Institutions and State Court Decisionmaking.” Paper Presented at the Annual Meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, April 3–6.Google Scholar
Beiner, Theresa M. 1999. “What Will Diversity on the Bench Mean for Justice?” Michigan Journal of Gender and Law 6:113–52.Google Scholar
Bonneau, Chris W. 2001. “The Composition of State Supreme Courts, 2000.” Judicature 85:26–31.Google Scholar
Bonneau, Chris W., Brace, Paul, and Arceneaux, Kevin. 2006. Individual-Level State Supreme Court Database. www.ruf.rice.edu/~pbrace/statecourt/index.html. (13 October).Google Scholar
Brace, Paul, Sims-Butler, Kellie, Arceneaux, Kevin, and Johnson, Martin. 2002. “Public Opinion in the American States: New Perspectives Using National Survey Data.” American Journal of Political Science 46:173–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brace, Paul, and Hall, Melinda Gann. 1995. “Studying Courts Comparatively: The View from the American States.” Political Research Quarterly 48:5–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brace, Paul, and Hall, Melinda Gann. 1997. “The Interplay of Preferences, Case Facts, Context, and Rules in the Politics of Judicial Choice.” The Journal of Politics 59:1206–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brace, Paul, Langer, Laura, and Hall, Melinda Gann. 2000. “Measuring the Preferences of State Supreme Court Judges.” The Journal of Politics 62:387–413.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Davis, Sue. 1986. “The Impact of President Carter's Judicial Selection Reforms: A Voting Analysis of the U.S. Court of Appeals.” American Politics Quarterly 14:328–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Etienne, Margaret. 2005. “Parity, Disparity, and Adversariality: First Principles of Sentencing.” Stanford Law Review 58:309–22.Google Scholar
Farhang, Sean, and Wawro, Gregory. 2004. “Institutional Dynamics on the U.S. Court of Appeals: Minority Representation Under Panel Decision Making.” Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization 20:299–330.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Glaberson, William. 2006. “In Tiny Courts of N.Y., Abuses of Law and Power.” New York Times, September 25.Google Scholar
Goldman, Sheldon. 1979. “Should There Be Affirmative Action for the Judiciary?” Judicature 62:488–94.Google Scholar
Goldman, Sheldon. 1997. Picking Federal Judges: Lower Court Selection from Roosevelt through Reagan. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Gottschall, Jon. 1983. “Carter's Judicial Appointments: The Influence of Affirmative Action and Merit Selection on Voting on the U.S. Court of Appeals.” Judicature 67:164–73.Google Scholar
Hall, Melinda Gann. 1992. “Electoral Politics and Strategic Voting in State Supreme Courts.” The Journal of Politics 54:427–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hall, Melinda Gann. 1995. “Justices as Representatives: Elections and Judicial Politics in the American States.” American Politics Quarterly 23:485–503.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hall, Melinda Gann. 2001. “State Supreme Courts in American Democracy: Probing the Myths of Judicial Reform.” American Political Science Review 95:315–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hall, Melinda Gann, and Brace, Paul. 1994. “The Vicissitudes of Death by Decree: Forces Influencing Capital Punishment Decisionmaking in State Supreme Courts.” Social Science Quarterly 75:136–51.Google Scholar
Hurwitz, Mark S., and Lanier, Drew Noble. 2001. “Women and Minorities on State and Federal Appellate Benches, 1985 and 1999.” Judicature 85:84–92.Google Scholar
Hurwitz, Mark S., and Lanier, Drew Noble. 2003. “Explaining Judicial Diversity: The Differential Ability of Women and Minorities to Attain Seats on State Supreme and Appellate Courts.” State Politics and Policy Quarterly 3:329–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ifill, Sherrilynn A. 2000. “Racial Diversity on the Bench: Beyond Role Models and Public Confidence.” Washington and Lee Review 57:405–95.Google Scholar
Kalven, Harry Jr., and Zeisel, Hans. 1966. The American Jury. Boston, MA: Little, Brown.Google Scholar
Keiser, Lael R., Wilkins, Vicky M., Meier, Kenneth J., and Holland, Catherine. 2002. “Lipstick and Logarithms: Gender, Identity, Institutional Context, and Representative Bureaucracy.” American Political Science Review 96:553–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
King, Gary, Tomz, Michael, and Wittenberg, Jason. 2000. “Making the Most of Statistical Analyses: Improving Interpretation and Presentation.” American Journal of Political Science 44:341–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leader, Shelah G. 1977. “The Policy Impact of Elected Women Officials.” In The Impact of the Electoral Process, eds. Cooper, Joseph and Maisel, Louis. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.Google Scholar
Mitchell, John B. 1980. “The Ethics of the Criminal Defense Attorney: New Answers to Old Questions.” Stanford Law Review 32:293–337.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nicholson-Crotty, Jill, and Meier, Kenneth J.. 2002. “Gender, Representative Bureaucracy, and Law Enforcement: The Case of Sexual Assault.” Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, Boston, MA.Google Scholar
Pitkin, Hanna. 1967. The Concept of Representation. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Preuhs, Robert R. 2006. “The Conditional Effects of Minority Descriptive Representation: Black Legislators and Policy Influence in the American States.” The Journal of Politics 68:585–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Preuhs, Robert R. 2007. “Descriptive Representation as a Mechanism to Mitigate Policy Backlash: Latino Incorporation and Welfare Policy in the American States.” Political Research Quarterly 60:277–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roberts, Julian V., and Stalans, Loreta J.. 1997. Public Opinion, Crime, and Criminal Justice. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.Google Scholar
Segal, Jeffrey A. 1984. “Predicting Supreme Court Cases Probabilistically: The Search and Seizure Cases, 1962–1981.” American Political Science Review 78:891–900.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Segal, Jeffrey A., and Spaeth, Harold J.. 2002. The Supreme Court and the Attitudinal Model Revisited. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, Michael David. 1983. Race Versus the Robe: The Dilemma of Black Judges. New York, NY: National University Publications.Google Scholar
Smith, Susan Moloney. 1994. “Diversifying the Judiciary: The Influence of Gender and Race on Judging.” University of Richmond Law Review 28:179–204.Google Scholar
Spohn, Cassia. 1990a. “The Sentencing Decisions of Black and White Judges: Expected and Unexpected Similarities.” Law & Society Review 24:1197–1216.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Spohn, Cassia. 1990b. “Decision Making in Sexual Assault Cases: Do Black and Female Judges Make a Difference?” Women & Criminal Justice 2:83–105.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Spohn, Cassia, and Welch, Susan. 1986. “The Effect of the Impact of Prior Record in Judge's Sentencing Decisions.” Justice Quarterly 3:389–408.Google Scholar
Steffensmeier, Darrell, and Britt, Chester L.. 2001. “Judges' Race and Judicial Decision Making: Do Black Judges Sentence Differently?” Social Science Quarterly 82:749–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Steffensmeier, Darrell, and Hebert, Chris. 1999. “Women and Men Policymakers: Does the Judge's Gender Affect the Sentencing of Criminal Defendants?” Social Forces 77:1163–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tate, C. Neal. 1981. “Personal Attribute Models of Voting Behavior of U.S. Supreme Court Justices: Liberalism in Civil Liberties and Economics Decisions, 1946–1978.” American Political Science Review 75:355–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tobias, Carl. 1990. “The Gender Gap on the Federal Bench.” Hofstra Law Review 19:171–84.Google Scholar
Uhlman, Thomas. 1978. “Black Elite Decision Making: The Case of Trial Judges.” American Journal of Political Science 22:884–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walker, Thomas G., and Barrow, Deborah J.. 1985. “The Diversification of the Federal Bench: Policy and Process Ramifications.” The Journal of Politics 47:596–617.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Welch, Susan. 1985. “Are Women More Liberal Than Men in the U.S. Congress?” Legislative Studies Quarterly 10:125–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Welch, Susan, Combs, Michael, and Gruhl, John. 1988. “Do Black Judges Make a Difference?” American Journal of Political Science 32:126–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wilkins, Vicky M. 2007. “Exploring the Causal Story: Gender, Active Representation, and Bureaucratic Priorities.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 17:77–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wilkins, Vicky M., and Keiser, Lael R.. 2006. “Linking Passive and Active Representation for Gender: The Case of Child Support Agencies.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 16:87–102.CrossRefGoogle Scholar