Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-qs9v7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-12T02:27:14.213Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Political Economy of Gubernatorial Smokestack Chasing: Bad Policy and Bad Politics?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 January 2021

Robert C. Turner
Robert C. Turner*
Affiliation:
Skidmore College
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Why do states persist in offering large financial incentives to induce firms to relocate to or expand in the state, a practice commonly derided as “smokestack chasing?” The conventional wisdom is that while these incentives have little effect on firms' business decisions in the long term, they are a good political strategy for governors seeking to improve economic conditions and political support in the short term. I test these hypotheses by examining the economic and electoral impact of industrial recruitment policies in Wisconsin, Virginia, Michigan, North Carolina, Maryland, Indiana, and Kentucky. I find, first, that these policies pay immediate dividends for governors by increasing county-level job growth and per capita income prior to the next election. Second, governors recruit firms strategically to relocate to counties that opposed them in the previous election. But, third, this industrial recruitment does not increase electoral support for the governor. In fact, the more success a governor has in recruiting firms or jobs to a county, the fewer votes he or she receives in it in the next election.

Type
Research Article
Information
State Politics & Policy Quarterly , Volume 3 , Issue 3 , September 2003 , pp. 270 - 293
Copyright
Copyright © The American Political Science Association, 2003

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Area Development On-Line. 2003. “2003 State Incentives.” Site and Facility Planning.http://www.area-development.com/past/0103/features/state_4.html.Google Scholar
Arend, Mark. 2002. “And the Winner Is …” Site Selection Magazine, March.http://www.siteselection.com/issues/2002/mar/p138/.Google Scholar
Atkeson, Lonna Rae, and Partin, Randall. 1995. “Economic and Referendum Voting: A Comparison of Gubernatorial and Senatorial Elections.” American Political Science Review 89:634–647.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Atkinson, Robert D. 1993. “The Next Wave in Economic Development.” Economic Development Commentary, 17 (Spring):12–18.Google Scholar
Atkinson, Robert D. 2000. “Developing State Economies.” Blueprint Magazine, June 1.http://www.ndol.org/blueprint/summer/2002/atkinson3.html.Google Scholar
Bartik, Timothy J. 1990. “The Market Failure Approach to Regional Economic Development.” Economic Development Quarterly 4:361–371.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bartik, Timothy. 1993. “Who Benefits from Local Job Growth: Migrants or Original Residents?” Regional Studies 27:297–311.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Bartik, Timothy J. 1995. “Economic Development Incentive Wars.” Upjohn Institute Employment Research, Spring:1-4.Google Scholar
Barkley, David L., and McNamara, Kevin T.. 1994. “Manufacturers' Location Decisions: Do Surveys Provide Helpful Insights?” International Regional Science Review 17:23–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beyle, Thad. 1996. “Governors, the Middlemen and Women in our Political System.” In Politics in the American States: A Comparative Analysis. ed. Gray, Virginia and Jacob, Herbert. Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly.Google Scholar
Blair, John P., and Premus, Robert. 1987. “Major Factors in Industrial Location: A Review.” Economic Development Quarterly 1:72–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brace, Paul. 1993. State Government and Economic Performance. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
Buchholz, David. 1999 “Incentives: Are They Really ‘Zero Sum‘?” Accountability: The Newsletter of the Business Incentives Clearinghouse 1:1–5.Google Scholar
Burnier, DeLysa. 1992. “Becoming Competitive: How Policymakers View Incentive Based Economic Development Policy.” Economic Development Quarterly 6:14–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burstein, Melvin L. and Rolnick, Arthur J.. 1995. “Congress Should End the Economic War Among the States.” Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis: The Region March:3-19.Google Scholar
Cable, Greg, Feiock, Richard C., and Kim, Jaehoon. 1993. “The Consequences of Institutionalized Access for Economic Development Policy Making in the U.S.” Economic Development Quarterly 7:91–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carsey, Thomas M., and Wright, Gerald C.. 1998. “State and National Factors in Gubernatorial and Senatorial Elections.” American Journal of Political Science 42:994–1002.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chernow, Ron. 1978. “The Rabbit That Ate Pennsylvania.” Mother Jones, January.Google Scholar
Chi, Keon. 1997. “State Business Incentives: Trends and Options for the Future.” Council of State Governments, Lexington, KY, 1-6.Google Scholar
Chubb, John E. 1988. “Institutions, the Economy, and the Dynamics of State Elections.” American Political Science Review 82:133–155.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clarke, Marianne K. 1986. Revitalizing State Economies. Washington, DC: National Governors' Association.Google Scholar
Cobb, James. 1982. The Selling of the South. Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State University Press.Google Scholar
Corporation for Enterprise Development. 1994. Bidding for Business: Are Cities and States Selling Themselves Short? Washington, DC: CFED.Google Scholar
Eisinger, Peter. 1988. The Rise of the Entrepreneurial State: State and Local Economic Development Policy in the United States. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Eisinger, Peter. 1995. “State Economic Development in the 1990s: Politics and Policy Learning.” Economic Development Quarterly 9:146–158.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Elkin, Stephen L. 1987. City and Regime in the American Republic. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Feiock, Richard C., and Clingermayer, James. 1986. “Municipal Representation, Executive Power, and Economic Development Policy Activity.” Policy Studies Journal 15:211–229.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fisher, Peter, and Peters, Alan. 1998. Industrial Incentives: Competition Among American States and Cities. Kalamazoo, MI: W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fosler, R. Scott, ed. 1988. The New Economic Role of the American States. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Goss, Ernest, and Phillips, Joseph. 1999. “Do Business Tax Incentives Contribute to a Divergence in Economic Growth?” Economic Development Quarterly 13:217–228.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Grady, Dennis. 1988. “Governors and Markets: Corporate Recruitment from the Gubernatorial Perspective.” In Market-Based Public Policy, ed. Hula, Richard. London: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Graham, Otis. 1993. Losing Time: The Industrial Policy Debate. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Grant, Don S., Wallace, Michael, and Pitney, William D.. 1995. “Measuring State-Level Economic Development Programs, 1970-1992.” Economic Development Quarterly 9:134–145.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thornton, Grant. 1989. The 10th Annual Manufacturing Climates Study. Chicago: Grant Thornton.Google Scholar
Hagstrom, Jerry, and Guskind, Robert. 1984. “Playing the State Ranking Game—A New National Pastime Catches On.” National Journal, June 30:1268–1274.Google Scholar
Hansen, Susan B. 2001. “The Impact of a Low-Wage Strategy on State Economic Development.” State Politics and Policy Quarterly 1:227–254.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hanson, Russell. 1993. “Bidding for Business: A Second War Between the States?” Economic Development Quarterly 7:183–198.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Herzik, Eric. 1983. “The Governors and Issues: A Typology of Concerns.” State Government 51:58–62.Google Scholar
Herzik, Eric B. 1991. “Policy Agendas and Gubernatorial Leadership.” In Gubernatorial Leadership and State Policy, eds. Herzik, Eric B. and Brown, Brent W.. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.Google Scholar
Hibbs, Douglas. 1987. The American Political Economy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Hinckley, Barbara, and Hsu, Fiona. 2000. Minding the Candy Store: State Audits of Economic Development. Washington, DC: Good Jobs First.Google Scholar
Jones, Bryan, and Bachelor, Lynn. 1986. The Sustaining Hand. Lawrence, KA: University of Kansas Press.Google Scholar
King, Desmond S. 1990. “Economic Activity and the Challenge to Local Government.” In Challenges to Local Government, eds. King, Desmond S. and Pierre, Jon. London: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
King, Gary. 1988. “Statistical Models for Political Science Event Counts: Bias in Conventional Procedures and Evidence for the Exponential Poisson Regression Model.” American Journal of Political Science 32:838–863.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leicht, Kevin, and Craig Jenkins, J.. 1994. “Three Strategies of State Economic Development: Entrepreneurial, Industrial Recruitment, and Deregulation Policies in the American States.” Economic Development Quarterly 9:256–269.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leyden, Kevin M., and Borrelli, Stephen A.. 1995. “The Effect of State Economic Conditions on Gubernatorial Elections: Does Unified Government Make a Difference?” Political Research Quarterly 48:275–291.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Long, J. Scott. 1997. Regression Models for Categorical and Limited Dependent Variables. Thousand Oaks, CA: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Lowery, David, and Gray, Virginia. 1992. “Holding Back the Tide of Bad Economic Times.” Social Science Quarterly 73:483–495.Google Scholar
Lowery, David, and Gray, Virginia. 1995. “The Compensatory Impact of State Industrial Policy: An Empirical Assessment of Midterm Effects.” Social Science Quarterly 76:438–446.Google Scholar
Lynch, Robert G. 1996. Do State and Local Tax Incentives Work? Washington, DC: Economic Policy Institute.Google Scholar
Mahtesian, Charles. 1994. “Romancing the Smokestack.” Governing Magazine, November: 36-40.Google Scholar
Mayer, Kenneth R. 1991. The Political Economy of Defense Contracting. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Mayer, Kenneth R. 1995. “Electoral Cycles in Federal Government Prime Contract Awards: State-Level Evidence from the 1988 and 1992 Presidential Elections.” American Journal of Political Science 39:162–185.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mayhew, David. 1974. The Electoral Connection. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Milward, H. Brinton, and Newman, Heidi. 1989. “State Incentive Packages and Industrial Location Decisions.” Economic Development Quarterly 3:203–222.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nordhaus, William. 1989. “Alternative Approaches to the Political Business Cycle.” Review of Economic Studies 42:169–190.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Noto, Nonna A. 1991. “Trying to Understand the Economic Development Official's Dilemma.” In Competition Among State and Local Governments, eds. Kenyon, D. and Kincaid, J.. Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press.Google Scholar
Marwick, Peat. 1995. “Business Incentives and Tax Credits: A Boon For Business or Corporate Welfare?” Peat Marwick Business Incentive Group, September.Google Scholar
Peterson, Paul. 1995. The Price of Federalism. Washington, DC: Brookings.Google Scholar
Regan, Edward V. 1988. Government, Inc: Creating Accountability for Economic Development Programs. Washington, DC: Government Finance Research Center of the Government Finance Officer Association.Google Scholar
Rubin, Herbert. 1988. “Shoot Anything that Flies; Claim Anything that Falls: Conversations with Economic Development Practitioners.” Economic Development Quarterly 2:236–251.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ross, Doug, and Friedman, Robert E.. 1990. “The Emerging Third Wave: New Economic Development Strategies in the '90s.” The Entrepreneurial Economy Review 9:3–10.Google Scholar
Schmenner, Roger W. 1982. Making Location Decisions. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
Schweke, William. 1999. “The Challenge of Finding a Federal Solution.” Accountability: The Newsletter of the Business Incentives Clearinghouse 2:1–10.Google Scholar
Simon, Dennis M. 1989. “Presidents, Governors, and Electoral Accountability.” Journal of Politics 51:286–304.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Spicer, David Eddy, and King, David. 1996. “North Carolina and the Battle for Business.” Case #1351.0. Cambridge, MA: JFK School of Government, Case Studies in Public Policy and Management.Google Scholar
Swanstrom, Todd. 1985. The Crisis of Growth Politics. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.Google Scholar
Tufte, Edward R. 1980. Political Control of the Economy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
United States Census Bureau. Various years. County Business Patterns. Washington, DC: United States Census Bureau.Google Scholar
United States Census Bureau. Various years. USA Counties. Washington, DC: United States Census Bureau.Google Scholar
Vaughn, Robert, Pollard, Robert, and Dyer, Barbara. 1984. The Wealth of States: Policies for a Dynamic Economy. Washington, DC: Council of State Planning Agencies.Google Scholar
Wolkoff, Michael J. 1991. “Redistricting Interjurisdictional Competition: Is There a Will and a Way to Cool the Fires?” State Tax Notes, December 9.Google Scholar
Wolman, Harold. 1988. “Local Economic Development Policy: What Explains the Divergence Between Policy Analysis and Political Behavior?” Journal of Urban Affairs 10:19–28.Google Scholar
Wolman, Harold, Spitzley, with David. 1996. “The Politics of Local Economic Development.” Economic Development Quarterly 10:115–151.CrossRefGoogle Scholar