No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
‘Isaiah's Call to England': Doubts about Prophecy in Nineteenth-Century Britain
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 16 June 2016
Abstract
Prophetic thought in nineteenth-century Britain has often been presented as divided between those mostly evangelical constituencies who ‘believed' in its literal fulfilment in the past, present or future and those who ‘doubted' such interpretations. This essay seeks to question that division by tracking the uses of one set of prophetic passages, those concerning the ‘Ships of Tarshish’ mentioned in Isaiah 60: 9 and elsewhere. It examines their appropriation from the late eighteenth century onwards by those seeking prophetic-providential justification for the British maritime empire. Next it shows how such such ideas fuelled missionary expansion in the years after 1815, suggesting that by mid-century that there was a growing spectrum of ways in which such passages were used by religious commentators. The final section shows how biblical critics seeking to bolster the integrity of the Bible as a text reconstructed the geographical and economic settings for these passages, establishing their historical veracity as they did so but in the process undermining their supernaturally predictive status. Thus one way of bolstering ‘faith’ – the study of prophetic fulfilments – was rendered doubtful by another. By the end of our period Tyre and Tarshish retained much of their homiletic punch as metaphors for the sin brought by trade and luxury, but those who saw them as literal proxies for Britain were in the minority.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Studies in Church History , Volume 52: DOUBTING CHRISTIANITY: THE CHURCH AND DOUBT , June 2016 , pp. 381 - 397
- Copyright
- Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 2016
References
1 Chamberlain, Walter, Isaiah's Call to England: Being an Exposition of Isaiah the Eighteenth (London, 1860), iv–vGoogle Scholar.
2 Ibid. 333, 341–4; 357–9.
3 Ibid. 423, 203–29.
4 Ibid. 227.
5 Ibid. 422–4.
6 Hilton, Boyd, A Mad, Bad, and Dangerous People? England, 1783–1846 (Oxford, 2006), 397–406Google Scholar.
7 [Conybeare, W. J.], ‘Church Parties’, Edinburgh Review 98 (1853), 273–342, at 297Google Scholar.
8 Chamberlain, Isaiah, x.
9 , J. and Venn, J. A., Alumni Cantabrigienses, 2: From 1752 to 1900, 6 vols (Cambridge, 1940–54), 2: 3Google Scholar.
10 Chamberlain, Walter, A Plain Reply to Bishop Colenso (London, 1863)Google Scholar.
11 See, for example, Spence, Martin, Heaven on Earth: Reimagining Time and Eternity in Nineteenth-Century British Evangelicalism (Eugene, OR, 2015)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
12 Quarterly Journal of Prophecy 12 (1860), 395–7; see also London Review and Weekly Journal of Politics, Literature, Art, and Society, 4 October 1862, iv.
13 Elliott, like Chamberlain, was a learned man, a one-time fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge, who ended his days as incumbent of St Mark's, Kemptown, in well-heeled Brighton: see Bateman, J., The Life of the Rev. Henry Venn Elliott (London, 1868)Google Scholar.
14 Gribben, Crawford and Stunt, Timothy C. F., ‘Introduction’ to eidem, eds, Prisoners of Hope? Aspects of Evangelical Millennialism in Britain and Ireland, 1800–1880 (Carlisle, 2004), 1–17Google Scholar; see also Brown, Ralph, ‘Victorian Anglican Evangelicalism: The Radical Legacy of Edward Irving’, JEH 58 (2007), 675–704Google Scholar.
15 Oliver, W. H., Prophets and Millennialists: The Uses of Biblical Prophecy in England from the 1790s to the 1840s (Auckland, 1978), 239–40Google Scholar.
16 Stanley, Arthur Penrhyn, The Life and Correspondence of Thomas Arnold, 2 vols (London, 1844), 1: 65, 177–80Google Scholar.
17 The erstwhile Brethren leader Benjamin Wills Newton was especially scornful of Elliott's argument: see Newton, Benjamin Wills, Aids to Prophetic Enquiry, 3rd edn (London, 1881), 241 nGoogle Scholar.
18 Minton, Samuel, The Merchants of Tarshish, or, England, America, and Russia in the Last War (London, 1868), ivGoogle Scholar.
19 See Ledger-Lomas, Michael, ‘Conder and Sons: Dissent and the Oriental Bible in Nineteenth-Century Britain’, in idem and Mandelbrote, Scott, eds, Dissent and the Bible in Britain, c.1650–1950 (Oxford, 2013), 205–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
20 The recent literature on this is vast. Highlights include Walsham, Alexandra, Providence in Early Modern England (Oxford, 1999), 281–325Google Scholar; Ihalainen, Pasi, Protestant Nations Redefined: Changing Perceptions of National Identity in the Rhetoric of the English, Dutch and Swedish Churches, 1685–1772 (Leiden, 2005)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Coffey, John, Exodus and Liberation: Deliverance Politics from John Calvin to Martin Luther King Jr. (Oxford, 2014), 25–78Google Scholar. None of this should imply that providentialism was the preserve of Protestants; see, for instance, Marjorie Reeves's seminal study, The Influence of Prophecy in the Later Middle Ages: a Study in Joachimism (Oxford, 1969).
21 Coffey, Exodus and Liberation, 36–7.
22 Defoe, Daniel, The Lay-Man's Sermon upon the Late Storm (London, 1704), 6Google Scholar.
23 E.g. Stennett, Samuel, A Sermon in Commemoration of the Great Storm of Wind (London, 1788)Google Scholar.
24 Pratt, J. H., ed., Eclectic Notes: or, Notes of Discussions on Religious Topics at the Meetings of the Eclectic Society, London, during the Years 1798–1814, 2nd edn (London, 1865), 330Google Scholar.
25 Korshin, Paul J., Typologies in England, 1650–1820 (Princeton, NJ, 1982)Google Scholar.
26 Walsham, Providence, 299.
27 Ruskin, John, The Stones of Venice: The Foundations (London, 1851), 1Google Scholar.
28 Newton, Thomas, Dissertations on the Prophecies, 3 vols (London, 1766), 1: 314–51Google Scholar, extensively cited travellers’ accounts by Richard Pococke, Thomas Shaw and Henry Maundrell; Horne, Thomas Hartwell's Landcape Illustrations of the Bible, 2 vols (London, 1836; unpaginated)Google Scholar, supplemented these with accounts from modern travellers, including William Jowett and James Silk Buckingham.
29 Melville, Herman, Moby-Dick; or, The Whale (New York, 1851), 46 (ch. 9)Google Scholar.
30 For Bochart, see Shalev, Zur, Sacred Words and Worlds: Geography, Religion, and Scholarship, 1550–1700 (Leiden, 2012), 141–204CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
31 And in variations elsewhere: see 2 Chron. 9: 21.
32 Horne, George, A Commentary on the Book of Psalms, new edn (London, 1849), 283Google Scholar.
33 See Lewis, Donald M., The Origins of Christian Zionism (Cambridge, 2009), 25–48Google Scholar, for a useful summary of seventeenth-century puritan interest in the subject.
34 Verete, Mayir, ‘The Restoration of the Jews in English Protestant Thought 1790–1840’, Middle Eastern Studies 8 (1972), 3–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Matar, Nabil, ‘The Controversy over the Restoration of the Jews’, Durham University Journal 87 (1990), 29–44Google Scholar.
35 Semmel, Stuart, Napoleon and the British (New Haven, CT, 2004), 72–106Google Scholar.
36 Leighton, C. D. A., ‘Antichrist's Revolution: Some Anglican Apocalypticists in the Age of the French Wars’, JRH 24 (2002), 125–42CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
37 Kett, Henry, History the Interpreter of Prophecy, 2 vols, 4th edn (London, 1801), 2: 291–2 nGoogle Scholar.
38 Wedgwood, Ralph, The Book of Remembrance (London, 1814), 46Google Scholar.
39 Frere, James Hatley, A Combined View of the Prophecies of Daniel, Esdras and St John, 2nd edn (London, 1815), 114Google Scholar.
40 Bicheno, James, The Restoration of the Jews, the Crisis of all Nations, 2nd edn (London, 1807), 227–35Google Scholar.
41 ‘Eben-Ezer’ [Ebenezer Aldred], The Little Book (London, 1811), 69.
42 ‘Sermons in Aid of the Waterloo Subscription’, Critical Review 5th ser. 2 (1815), 523–8; see also ‘Art. VII’, Monthly Repository 11 (1816), 216–17.
43 Bickersteth, Edward, A Scripture Help (London, 1825), 240–1Google Scholar; Clarke, Adam, The New Testament of Our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, 2 vols (New York, 1831), 2: 1048Google Scholar; Keith, Alexander, Signs of the Times, 2 vols, 2nd edn (Edinburgh, 1832), 2: 120–9Google Scholar; Elliott, Edward Bishop, Horae Apocalypticae, 3 vols, 3rd edn (London, 1847), 3: 329–30Google Scholar.
44 Gidney, W. T., The History of the London Society for Promoting Christianity amongst the Jews, from 1809 to 1908 (London 1908), 51–200Google Scholar; Lewis, Christian Zionism, 67–106.
45 Hodder, Edwin, The Life and Work of the Seventh Earl of Shaftesbury, 2 vols (London, 1886), 1: 378Google Scholar. He was conflating Isa. 43: 6 and 60: 9.
46 Birks, T. R., Memoir of the Rev. Edward Bickersteth, 2 vols, 2nd edn (London, 1852), 2: 182–3Google Scholar.
47 Cuninghame, William, The Political Destiny of the Earth, as revealed in the Bible, 3rd edn (London, 1842), xiiGoogle Scholar.
48 Britain's acquisition of Cyprus (‘Kittim’) particularly excited E. J. Hytche, ‘The Ships of Tarshish’, The Prophetic News and Israel's Watchman, April 1881, 89–91. Americans who disapproved of the British empire dwelt with gloomy relish on the vengeance promised to all nations, predicting divine leniency for their own land alone because of its favourable treatment of Jewish immigrants: Peters, George N. H., The Theocratic Kingdom, 3 vols (New York, 1884), 2: 778–80Google Scholar.
49 Ollivant, Alfred, The Duty of a Christian Nation to her Colonies and Foreign Dependencies (Cambridge, 1850), 27Google Scholar.
50 For accounts of the spectacle, see Illustrated London News, 17 June 1843; 5 June 1847.
51 Sumner, Charles Richard, The Duties of a Maritime Power (London, 1824), 21Google Scholar.
52 Mant, Richard, The Sovereignty of God in the Natural World, and the Agency of Man, Practically Considered (London, 1818)Google Scholar, Whewell, William, A Sermon Preached on Trinity Monday . . . 1835 (London, 1835), 17–18Google Scholar.
53 Lee, Samuel, An Inquiry into the Nature, Progress, and End of Prophecy (London, 1849)Google Scholar.
54 ‘Ships of Tarshish’, Naval Journal and Sailor's Magazine 10 (1837–8), 346–7.
55 Pusey, E. B., The Minor Prophets (London, 1860), 267Google Scholar.
56 Gidney, London Society, 16.
57 Creasy, Edward S., History of England from the Earliest to the Present Time, 5 vols (London, 1869), 1: 18Google Scholar.
58 See Wheeler, Michael, The Old Enemies (Cambridge, 2006), 51–76Google Scholar.
59 Max Müller, F., ‘Are there Jews in Cornwall?’, in idem, Chips from a German Workshop, 4 vols (London, 1867–75), 4: 299–329Google Scholar; Bannister, John, Jews in Cornwall (Truro, 1867)Google Scholar.
60 See Wilson, John, Our Israelitish Origin (London, 1840)Google Scholar, for one of the earliest developed statements of this position.
61 Wright, William Aldis, ‘Metals’, in Smith, William, ed., Dictionary of the Bible, 3 vols (London, 1860–3), 2: 341–3Google Scholar; John Saul Howson, ‘Ship’, ibid. 2: 1282–7; Edward Hayes Plumptre, ‘Solomon’, ibid. 2: 1342–54; Edward Twisleton, ‘Tarshish’, ibid. 2: 1438–41.
62 Tennent, James Edward, ‘Tarshish’, in Encyclopaedia Britannica, 22 vols (Edinburgh, 1853–60), 21: 26–8Google Scholar; see also William Houghton, ‘Peacocks’, in Smith, ed., Dictionary, 2: 763–4.
63 Twisleton, ‘Tarshish’, 1441.
64 Tennent, ‘Tarshish’, 28.
65 See, for instance, Renan, Ernest, Mission de Phénicie (Paris, 1864)Google Scholar; Gladstone, William Ewart, Juventus Mundi: The Gods and Men of the Heroic Age, 2nd edn (London, 1870)Google Scholar, especially 119–50; Rawlinson, George, History of Phoenicia (London, 1889)Google Scholar.
66 Arnold, Matthew, The Great Prophecy of Israel's Restoration, 4th edn (London, 1875), xxixGoogle Scholar.
67 Ibid. xxvii.
68 Ibid. xxxv–xxxvi.
69 For a good recent summary, see Blair, Kirstie, Form and Faith in Victorian Religion and Poetry (Oxford, 2012), 1–20; see also, in this volume, eadem, ‘Reforming the Religious Sonnet: Poetry, Doubt and the Church in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries’, 427–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
70 Bebbington, D. W., ‘The Advent Hope in British Evangelicalism since 1800’, Scottish Journal of Religious Studies 9 (1988), 103–14Google Scholar.
71 The Times, 17 July 1897, 13. It was later sung to the tune Melita (‘Eternal Father, Strong to Save’), which had strong maritime connections.
72 See, for example, ‘Is America in Bible Prophecy?’, at: <https://www.raptureready.com/featured/ice/AmericaInBibleProphecy.html>, last accessed 8 August 2015.