Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-rkxrd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-22T11:26:58.105Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Vicars Choral and Chaplains in Northern European Cathedrals 1100–1250

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

Julia Barrow
Julia Barrow*
Affiliation:
University of Birmingham
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The purpose of this paper is to take a preliminary look at a phenomenon which began to occur over much of northern Europe in the twelfth and early thirteenth centuries: the emergence of vicars choral and chaplains in cathedrals and collegiate churches. Studying the two groups together makes sense since they both acted as replacements for the senior clerics, that is the canons, in the churches where they served. In theory, the vicars chiefly served in choir and the chaplains at altars which had often hitherto been served (we may presume) by canons. In fact it is very difficult to separate vicars from chaplains since the terms were often used interchangeably at the time, and, furthermore, charters establishing these positions often specify that vicars choral would additionally serve altars and that chaplains would also attend the hours. For example, when Bishop Hugh of Wells of Lincoln ordained a chantry at the altar of St Hugh to be served by a priest chaplain and a deacon and subdeacon he laid down that the deacon and subdeacon should be chosen from among the vicars of the choir and subsequent arrangements for this chantry show that the deacons and subdeacons in the choir served for a week at a time. The emergence of vicars choral and chaplains is not of major significance in itself, since these men very rarely rose to positions of any importance, but an explanation of why they were felt ro be necessary is essential to a study of clerical ministry in the middle ages.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History , Volume 26: The Ministry: Clerical and Lay , 1989 , pp. 87 - 97
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 1989

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Research for this paper has been made possible through post-doctoral fellowships generously awarded by the British Academy and the Alexander von Humboldt-Stiftung, Bonn.

2 Foster, C. W. and Major, K., eds. The Registrum Antiquissimum of the Cathedral Church of Lincoln, 12 vols (Lincoln Record Society, 1931-73), 2, no. 362 Google Scholar. See also Israel, F. and Möllenbcrg, W., eds, Urkundcnbuch des Eratifts Magdeburg (Magdeburg, 1937), no. 403, dated 1185 Google Scholar.

3 Moraw, Cf. P., ‘Uber Typologie, Chronologie und Geographie der Stiftskirche im deutschen Mittelalter’, in Untersuchungen zu Kloster und Stift, ed. Max-Planck-Institut für Geschichte (Göttingen, 1980), especially p. 22 Google Scholar.

4 Philippi, Cf. F., ed., Osnabrücker Urkundenbuch, 4 vols (Osnabrück, 1892-1902), 1, no. 276 (dated 1147 Google Scholar), Remling, F. X., ed., Urkundenbuch zur Geschichte der Biuhöfe zu Speyer, 2 vols (repr. Aalen, 1970), 1, no. 139 Google Scholar, datable c. 1220, and Ehmck, D. R and von Bippen, W., eds, Bremisches Urkndenbuch, 5 vols (Bremen, 1873-1902), 1, no. 167 Google Scholar, dated 1231. Alfred Haverkamp has recendy suggested that the layout of the city of Trier was pardy influenced by liturgical considerations, in particular the organization of processions: ‘“Heilige Städte” im hohen Mittelalter’, in F. Graus, ed., Mentalitäten im Mittelalter. Meihodische und inhallliche Probleme (Sigmaringen, 1987).

5 Beyer, H., Eltester, L. and Goerz, A., eds, Urkundenbuch zur Geschichte der jetzt die preufiischen Regierungsbezirke Coblenz und Trier bildenden Mittelrheinischen Territorien (henceforward UBMRh), 3 vols (Coblenz, 1860-1874), 2, no. 269 Google Scholar.

6 Ibid., 1, nos. 411, 455.

7 Duchet, T. and Giry, A., eds, Cartulaires de l‘église de Térouane, Société des Antiquaires de la Morinie (St-Omer, 1881), no. 50 Google Scholar, dated 1173; H. A. Erhard, ed., RegestaHisloriae Westfaliae, 2 vols (Münster, 1847–51), 2, no. 307, datable 1155 X 1559; R. Wilmans et al., eds, Westfälisches Urkundenbuch, 3–10 (Münster, 1859–1940), 3, no. 212, dated 1225.

8 Caesarius of Heisterbach, Dialogus Miraculorum, ed. Strange, J., 2 vols (Cologne and Bonn, 1851), 1, Dist VI, c. 5 Google Scholar.

9 Bormans, S. and Schoolmeesteis, E, eds, Cartulaire de l‘église Saint-Lambert de Liège (Brussels, 1893), 1, no. 84 Google Scholar, dated 1203; E. Poncelet, ed. Actes des Princes-Evêques de Liège: Hugues de Pierre-pont, 1200–1229 (Brussels, 1941), no. 20, dated 1203; J. Barbier, ‘Documents extraits du cartulaire du chapitre de Saint-Aubain, à Namur’, Analectes pour servir à l‘histoire de la Belgique, 11 (1874), p. 99, no. 1 (dated December 1207).

10 For Lichfield, see VCH Staffordshire, 3, p. 142; for Salisbury, Jones, W. R. H., ed., Vetus Registrum Sarisberiense, 2 vols, RS (1883–4), 2, pp. 18, 41–2 Google Scholar.

11 Edwards, K., The English Secular Cathedrals in the Middle Ages (2 edn., Manchester, 1967), p. 41 Google Scholar.

12 Bradshaw, H. and Wordsworth, C., eds, Statutes of Lincoln Cathedral, 3 vols (Cambridge, 1892-1902), 2, p. 58 Google Scholar.

13 Reg. Ant., 1, no. 300.

14 Calendar of the Manuscripts of the Dean and Chapter of Wells, I, Historical Manuscripts Commission (London, 1907), p. 31. In Salisbury’s 1219 statutes it was laid down that individual canons had to replace their vicars, when these died, within three months and a day: Vetus Registrum Sarisberiense, 2, p. 21.

15 Cartulahes de l‘église de Térouane, nos. 37, 48.

16 Barbier, J., ‘Documents extraits du carrulaire du chapitre de St-Aubain, à Namur, concernant le village de Mellet (Hainaut)’, Analectes pour servir à l‘histoire ecclésiastique de Belgique, 5 (1868), pp. 200–3 Google Scholar. In a similar vein, see the statutes drawn up for Le Mans cathedral in 1220: Broussillon, A. Bertrand de, ed., Cartulaire de l‘évêchedu Mans, 965–1786, Société des archives historiques du Maine, 9 (Le Mans, 1908), pp. 26–9 Google Scholar.

17 Urkundenbuch des Erzstifts Magdeburg, no. 342, dated 1173; Westf. UB., 2, no. 417, concerning the Alter Dom in Münster, dated 1181. An Osnabriick charter of 1217 refers to three specialized singers: F. Philippi, ed., Osnabrücker Urkundenbuch, 2, no. 77.

18 Ehmck, D. R. and Bippen, W. von, eds, Bremisches Urkundenbuch, 1, no. 162 Google Scholar, concerning St Willehad’s. See also Muller, S. and Bouman, A. C, eds, Oorkondenboek van het Stick Utrecht tot 1301 (Utrecht, 1920), no. 440, of 1163 Google Scholar.

19 Janicke, K., ed., Urkundenbuch des Hochstifts Hildesheim, 1 (1896, repr. Osnabrück, 1965), no. 62, dated 1019 Google Scholar.

20 Munich, Bayerisches Hauptstaatsarchiv, Bamberger Urkunde no. 324; Brackmann, A., ‘Urkundliche Geschichte des Halberstadter Domkapitels im Mittelalter’, Zeitschrift des Harz-Vereins für Geschichte und Altertumskunde, 32 (1899), pp. 1–147 Google Scholar, here p. 9; J. Pycke, Le chapitre cathedral Notre-Dame de Tournai de la fin du XIe à la fin du XIIIe siècle (Louvain and Brussels, 1986), p. 244.

21 Lacomblet, T.J., ed., Urkundenbuch für die Geschichte des Niederrheins, 4 vols (Düsseldorf, 1840-58), 1, no. 187 Google Scholar, dated 1052; E. Hautcoeur, ed., Cartulaire de l‘Eglise collégiale de St-Pierre de Lille (Lille, 1894), no. I, of the mid-eleventh century; Munich, Bayerisches Hauptstaatsarchiv, Bamberger Urkunde no. 324; for a reference to Arras in 1214, see Pycke, J., Le chapitre cathédral Notre-Dame de Tournai, p. 243 Google Scholar. An ordination list for the diocese of Hildesheim in 1203 states that 21 acolytes, 3 subdeacons, 4 deacons and 6 priests were ordained at Hildesheim cathedral: Urkundenbuch des Hochstifts Hildesheim, 1, no. 582.

22 Pycke, J., Notre-Dame, p. 245 Google Scholar.

23 Cartulaire de St-Lambert, i, no. 84, dated 1203; Cartulaire de l‘Eglise collégiale de St-Pierre de Lille, no. 80, dated 1205.

24 PL cciv. 721.

25 See n. 9 above. A similar preoccupation can be seen at Cologne: Groten, M., Priorenkolleg und Domkapitel von Köln im hohen Mittelalter (Bonn, 1980), p. 221 Google Scholar–Groten assumes that this was because of a decline in the number of canons seeking ordination as priests, but it is more likely simply to have been that demand for masses was outstripping the supply of priests.

26 Urkundenbuch des Erzslifls Magdeburg, no. 403.

27 Westf. UB, 2, no. 539; 3, no. 27.

28 Ibid., 3, no. 239.

29 Cartulaire de St-Lambert, no. 87, dated 1204 and no. 59, dated 1182.

30 Cartulaires de l‘église de Térouane, no. 16, dated 1136.

31 Carlulaire de St-Lambert, no. 87, dated 1204; Monumenta Boica, ed. Academia Scientianim Boica, vol. 38, pt. 2 (Munich, 1829), pp. 111–16 (1160), 117–19 (1163), concerning Passau cathedral; Newman, W. M., Charters of St-Fursy of Péronne (Cambridge, Mass., 1977), no. 57, dated 1196 Google Scholar.

32 Westf. UB, 2, no. 417.

33 Barrow, J., ‘Education and the Recruitment of Cathedral Canons in England and Germany, 1100–1225’, to appear in Viator, 20 (1989 Google Scholar).

34 von Guttenberg, E. Freiherr and Wendehorst, A., eds, Urban und Wirtschaftsordnungen des Domstifts Zu Bamberg (Würzburg, 1969), pp. 146–8 Google Scholar.

35 Bremisches Urkundenbuch, 1, no. 101, dated 1206; Doll, E., Die Kollegiatstifte St. Blasius und St. Cyriacus zu Braunschweig (Braunschweig, 1967 Google Scholar); A de Charmasse, ed., Cartulaire de l‘église d’Autun (Parisand Autun, 1865), pp. 167-70 (1247); Cartulaire de l’Eglise collégiale de St. Pierre de Lille, no. 38 (1183 – 1187) and no. 100 (1212); M. Srimming and P. Acht, eds, Mainzer Urkundenbuch, 2 vols in 3 (Darmstadt, 1932–71), 2, pt. 2, no. 653a (1196); Calendar of the Manuscripts of the Dean and Chapter of Wells, 1, p. 53.

36 Barbier, J., ‘Documents extraits du cartulaire du chapitre de Saint-Aubain’, pp. 102–3, no. 4 (1212 Google Scholar).

37 A whole year’s worth of masses for deceased canons at Bremen cathedral: Bremisches Urkundenbuch, 1, no. 101 (1206).

38 Cartulaire de L’église d’Autun, no. 29, 1195; Cartulaire de St-Lambert, 1, nos. 76 (1200), 137 (1223); Charters of St-Fursy of Péronne, no. 136.

39 Thimister, O.J., ed., Cartulaire ou recueil de chartes et documents inedits de l‘église collégiale de St-Paul, actuellement Cathedrale de Liège (Liège, 1878), p. 32 Google Scholar (before 1203).

40 Barbier, J., ‘Extraits du Cartulaire du chapitre de St-Aubain, Namur’, Analectes pour servir à L‘histoire ecclésiastique de Belgique, 5 (1868), p. 480 Google Scholar; Cartulaire de St-Lambert, no. 116 (1215); Cartulaire de L‘Eglise collégiale de St-Pierre de Lille, no. 44 (1189).

41 Westf. UB, 4, no. 185, and 6. no. 59.

42 Muller, S. and Bouman, A. C., eds, Oorkondenboek van het Sticht Utrecht tot 1301 (Utrecht, 1920), no. 530(1196 Google Scholar).

43 Cartulaire de l‘Eglise collégiale de St-Pierre de Lille, no. 24.

44 Vetus Registrum Sarisberiense, 1, pp. 275–314.

45 With Hereford in 1195: BL, Add. MS 15668, fol. 50.

46 Bec made a prebendal arrangement with Wells before 1199: Calendar of the Manuscripts of the Dean and Chapter of Wells, 1, p. 489, and in 1208 with Salisbury: Vetus Registrum Sarisberiense, 1, pp. 189–90.

47 Mayr-Harting, Henry, ed., The Acta of the Bishops of Chichester (CYS, 1964), pp. 154–5 Google Scholar, no. 97, datable 1198 X 1204.

48 Montebourg made a prebendal arrangement with Salisbury in 1213: Vetus Registrum Sarisberiense, 1, pp. 224–6.

49 Cormeilles made a prebendal arrangement with Hereford between 1216 and 1219: Evreux, Archives-Départementales de l‘Eure, H 590, fol. 325v.

50 The Acta of the Bishops of Chichester, p. 43.

51 Cartlaire de St-Lambert, 1, no. 59 (1182); UBMRh 1, no. 455; Bremisches Urkundenbuch, 1, nos. 101, 128.

52 Westf. UB, 2, no. 539, 3, no. 27.

53 Mainzer Urkundenbuch, 2, pt 2, no. 653a.