Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-767nl Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-09T01:49:26.598Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Valuing Pollution: Problems of Price in the Commodification of Nature

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2023

Joy Paton  and
Gareth Bryant
Joy Paton
Affiliation:
University of Sydney
Gareth Bryant
Affiliation:
University of Sydney
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In recent years, ‘environmental economics’ has provided the dominant logic underpinning policies for ‘sustainable development’ in the form of government managed price-based and rights-based mechanisms. The advocacy of property rights in environmental management is taken further in the libertarian ‘free market’ approach and this ‘privatisation’ perspective is reflected in the growing use of property rights instruments in climate change policy. This article examines the efficacy of using economic instruments in the environmental context where ‘market ecology’ promotes the commodification of environmental ‘goods’ and ‘bads’ and their management by market forces. It argues that the pricing of ‘nature’ or its useful properties is a crude abstraction that implies ecological values can be alienated, but this is incompatible with the material and relational qualities of such values. The limits of this conceptualisation are further demonstrated through an examination of the Kyoto Protocol’s Clean Development Mechanism (CDM), a price and property rights instrument which enables private project developers in developing countries to produce carbon credits in order to offset greenhouse gas pollution in developed countries. The evident negative social and environmental effects flowing from implementation of the CDM reinforce the limitations of economic logic in the environmental context.

Keywords

Q01Q51Q54D61D62Clean Development Mechanismclimate changecommodification of natureenvironmental economics
Type
Symposium
Information
The Economic and Labour Relations Review , Volume 23 , Issue 1: Carbon Markets: Inherent Limitations and Complementary Policies , February 2012 , pp. 87 - 106
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Afrika-Europa Netwerk et al. (2011) Open Letter: UK Government must withdraw authorisation for Aguan and Lean CDM projects linked to assassinations and other human rights abuses in Honduras, 4 Feb 2011, available: http://www.cdm-watch.org/?p=1648 [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Anderson, T. L. (1988) ‘Free market environmentalism: Rethinking the way we think’, CIS Policy Report, August/September, pp. 19–23.Google Scholar
Anderson, T. L., Leal, D. R. (1991) Free Market Environmentalism, Westview Press Inc., Boulder Colorado.Google Scholar
Arnsperger, C., Varoufakis, Y. (2006) ‘What is neoclassical economics? The three axioms responsible for its theoretical oeuvre, practical irrelevance and, thus, discursive power’, Post-autistic Economics Review, (38), available: http://www.paecon.net/PAEReview/issue38/contents38.htm [accessed 10 December 2011].CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Australian Government (2011) Securing a clean energy future: The Australian Government’s climate change plan, available: http://www.cleanenergyfuture.gov.au/wp-content/uploads/2011/07/Consolidated-Final.pdf [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Barry, N. P. (1987) On Classical Liberalism and Libertarianism, St. Martin’s Press, New York.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beder, S. (2001) ‘Neoliberal think tanks and free market environmentalism’, Environmental Politics, 10(2), pp. 128–133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beder, S. (2006) Environmental Principles and Policies: An Interdisciplinary Approach, University of New South Wales Press Limited, Sydney.Google Scholar
Bernstein, S. (2002) ‘Liberal environmentalism and global environmental governance’, Global Environmental Politics, 2(3), pp. 1–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Böhm, S., Dabhi, S. (eds) (2009) Upsetting the Offset: The Political Economy of Carbon Markets, MayFlyBooks, London.Google Scholar
Bromley, D. W. (2007) ‘Environmental regulations and the problem of sustainability: Moving beyond market failure’, Ecological Economics, 63(4), pp. 676–683.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bumpus, A., Liverman, D. (2008) ‘Accumulation by decarbonization and the governance of carbon offsets’, Economic Geography, 84(2), pp. 127–155.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
CDM Watch (2010) The Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) toolkit: A resource for citizens, activists and NGOs, available: http://www.cdm-watch.org/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2010/04/CDM_Toolkit.pdf [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
CDM Watch (2011a) Newsletter, 2, April 2011, available: http://www.cdm-watch.org/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/cdm_watch_newsletter_2_april_2011.pdf [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
CDM Watch (2011b), Newsletter, 4, July 2011, available: http://www.cdm-watch.org/?attachment_id=2121 [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Coase, R. E. (1960) ‘The problem of social cost’, The Journal of Law and Economics, 3, October, pp. 1–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cordato, R. (2004) ‘Toward an Austrian theory of environmental economics’, The Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics, 7(1), pp. 3–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cote, D. (2010) ‘Perpetuating an unwelcome dump’ in Bullard, N. (ed.) Clean Development Mechanism Projects in the Philippines, Focus on the Global South, Quezon City.Google Scholar
Dabhi, S. (2009) ‘Where is climate justice in India’s first CDM project?’ in Böhm, S., Dabhi, S. (eds) Upsetting the Offset: The Political Economy of Carbon Markets, MayFlyBooks, London.Google Scholar
Dasgupta, P. (1990) ‘The environment as a commodity’, Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 6(1), pp. 51–67.Google Scholar
Di Ruzza, R., Halevi, J. (2004) ‘How to look at economics critically: Some suggestions’ in Fullbrook, E. (ed.) A guide to what’s wrong with economics, Anthem Press, London.Google Scholar
Docena, H. (2010) ‘Subsidizing destructive practices’ in Bullard, N. (ed.) Clean Development Mechanism Projects in the Philippines, Focus on the Global South, Quezon City.Google Scholar
Dryzek, J. S. (1997) The Politics of the Earth: Environmental Discourse, Oxford University Press, Oxford.Google Scholar
Edwards, S. (1987) ‘In defense of environmental economics’, Environmental Ethics, 9(1), pp. 73–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
European Comission (2011) 2010 Compliance Data, available: http://ec.europa.eu/clima/policies/ets/registries/docs/compliance_2010_en.xls [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Exportadora del Atlántico (2011) Project Design Document: Aguan biogas recovery from Palm Oil Mill Effluent (POME) ponds and biogas utilisation — Exportadora del Atlántico, Aguan/Honduras, available: http://cdm.unfccc.int/UserManagement/FileStorage/HQZSI48U9VWTRXL2D1A5MBCY0O6G7K [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Friedman, J. (1992) ‘Politics or scholarship?’, Critical Review, 6 (2–3), pp. 429–445.Google Scholar
Garnaut, R. (2011) The Garnaut Review 2011: Australia in the Global Response to Climate Change: Final Report, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Ghosh, S., Sahu, S. K. (eds) (2011) The Indian Clean Development Mechanism: Subsidizing and Legitimizing Corporate Pollution: An Overview of CDM in India with Case Studies from Various Sectors, DISHA, Kolkata.Google Scholar
Ghouri, N. (2009) ‘The great carbon credit con: Why are we paying the Third World to poison its environment?’, Daily Mail, 1 June 2009, available: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/home/moslive/article-1188937/The-great-carbon-credit-eco-companies-causing-pollution.html [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Gowdy, J., Erickson, J. D. (2005) ‘The approach of ecological economics’, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 29(2), pp. 207–222.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gujarat Fluorochemicals Limited (2005) CDM project design document: Project for GHG emissions by thermal oxidation of HFC 23, available: http://cdm.unfccc.int/UserManagement/FileStorage/FS_59491890 [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Hamilton, C. (1997) ‘Foundations of ecological economics’ in Diesendorf, M., Hamilton, C. (eds) Human Ecology, Human Economy, Allen and Unwin, St. Leonards.Google Scholar
Haya, B. (2007) ‘Failed mechanism: How the CDM is subsidizing hydro developers and harming the Kyoto Protocol’, International Rivers, available: http://www.internationalrivers.org/files/Failed_Mechanism_3.pdf [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (2001) Climate Change 2001: The Scientific Basis, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
International Emissions Trading Association (2010) Response to EB56 call for input on CERs in the CDM, 8 October 2011, available: http://www.ieta.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=173:response-to-eb56-call-for-input-on-cers-in-the-cdm&catid=24:position-papers&Itemid=91 [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Kovel, J. (2002) The Enemy of Nature: The End of Capitalism or the End of the World?, Zed Books, London.Google Scholar
Leff, E. (2002) ‘Alternatives to environmental neo-liberalism’, Tierramerica, available: http://www.tierramerica.net/2002/0728/igrandesplumas.shtml [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Lohmann, L. (2006) Carbon Trading: A Critical Conversation on Climate Change, Privatization and Power, Dag Hammasrkjold Foundation, Uddevalla, Sweden.Google Scholar
Lohmann, L. (2010) ‘Uncertainty markets and carbon markets: Variations on Polanyian themes’, New Political Economy, 15(2), pp. 225–254.Google Scholar
Majone, G. (1989) Evidence, Argument and Persuasion in the Policy Process, Yale University Press, New Haven.Google Scholar
Meiners, R. E., Yandle, B. (eds) (1993) Taking the Environment Seriously, Rowman and Littlefield, Lanham MD.Google Scholar
Mitchell, W. C., Simmons, R. T. (1994) Beyond Politics: Markets, Welfare, and the Future of Bureaucracy, Westview Press, Boulder CA.Google Scholar
Montalban Methane Project Corporation (2009) Project Design Document: Montalban Landfill Methane Recovery and Power Generation Project, available: http://cdm.unfccc.int/UserManagement/FileStorage/27401SFWYM3R65LTZDXJ89CGIEVKQU [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Mulberg, J. (1992) ‘Who rules the market? Green versus ecosocialist economic programmes: A response to Eckersley’, Political Studies, 40(2), pp. 334–341.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nandi, D., Pardhi, V., Ghosh, S., Yasmin, H. (2009) ‘Capitalizing power on cursed land: The inside story of the Reliance Sasan Power Ltd’, Mausam 1–2 (2–5), pp. 41–46.Google Scholar
OECD (1994) Managing the Environment: The Role of Economic Instruments, Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, Paris.Google Scholar
Paton, J. (2008) ‘What’s left of sustainable development?’, Journal of Australian Political Economy, 62, pp. 94–119.Google Scholar
Paton, G. J. (2011) Seeking Sustainability: On the Prospect of an Ecological Liberalism, Routledge, New York.Google Scholar
Pearce, D. (1976) Environmental Economics, Longman, London.Google Scholar
Pearce, D. W. (1992) ‘Green economics’, Environmental Values, 1(1), pp. 3–13.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pearce, D. W., Turner, R. K. (1990) Economics of Natural Resources and the Environment, Harvester Wheatsheaf, New York.Google Scholar
Pigou, A. C. (1932 [1920]) The Economics of Welfare, Fourth edition, Macmillan and Co. Limited, London.Google Scholar
Polanyi, K. (1971) ‘Carl Menger’s two meanings of ‘economic’ in Dalton, G. (ed.) Studies in Economic Anthropology, American Anthropological Association, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
Polanyi, K. (2001) The Great Transformation: The Political and Economic Origins of our Time, Second edition, Beacon Press, Boston.Google Scholar
Quiggin, J. (2006) Stern and the critics on discounting, available: http://www.skep-ticalscience.com/pics/quiggin6.pdf [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Rosewarne, S. (1993) ‘Selling the environment: A critique of market ecology’ in Rees, S., Rodley, G., Stilwell, F. (eds) Beyond the Market: Alternatives to Economic Rationalism, Pluto Press Australia, Leichhardt NSW.Google Scholar
Rosewarne, S. (2002) ‘Towards an ecological political economy’, Journal of Australian Political Economy, 50, December, pp. 179–199.Google Scholar
Sachs, J. (2008) Confronting global challenges, Keynote Address, China Update, Delivered 14 July 2008, Australian National University, Canberra, available: http://www.crawford.anu.edu.au/chinaupdate/2008/ [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Sagoff, M. (1994a) ‘Four dogmas of environmental economics’, Environmental Values, 3, pp. 285–310.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sagoff, M. (1994b) ‘Environmentalism vs. value subjectivism: Rejoinder to Anderson and Leal’, Critical Review, 8(3), pp. 467–473.Google Scholar
Sasan Power Limited (2010) CDM project design document: Greenhouse gas emission reductions through super-critical technology, available: http://cdm.unfccc.int/filestorage/B63M2CDLXIGU91OQRAZY07E4F8SPKT/Sasan%20PDD.pdf?t=WVB8MTI5MDU2MDQ1Ni45OA==|4bK-kyOtSDYLOvY4QBwLfDnCGJA= [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Smith, T. (1995) ‘The case against free market environmentalism’, Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Economics, 8(2), pp. 126–144.Google Scholar
Starr, L. (2011) ‘UN-backed coal power station linked to deforestation and land grabbing’, The Ecologist, 29 November 2011, available: http://www.theecologist.org/News/news_analysis/1145313/unbacked_coal_power_station_linked_to_deforestation_and_land_grabbing.html [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Stavins, R., Whitehead, B. (1992) ‘Dealing with pollution: Market based incentives for environmental protection’, Environment, 34(7), pp. 7–11, 29–42.Google Scholar
Stern, N. (2006) The Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
UNEP (2007) ‘GEO Indicators’, Global Environmental Outlook Year Book, United Nations Environment Program, available: http://www.unep.org/geo/yearbook/yb2007/ [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (1992) United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.Google Scholar
United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (1997) The Kyoto Protocol.Google Scholar
United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (2001) The Marrakech Accords.Google Scholar
WCED (1987) Our Common Future: World Commission on Environment and Development (The Brundtland Report), Oxford University Press, Oxford.Google Scholar
World Bank (2010) 10 years of experience in carbon finance: Insights from working with the Kyoto mechanisms, available: http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTCARBONFINANCE/Resources/10_Years_of_Experience_in_Carbon_Finance_Corrected.pdf [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
World Bank (2011) State and trends of the carbon market 2011, Washington DC, June 2011, available: http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTCARBONFINANCE/Resources/State_and_Trends_Updated_June_2011.pdf [accessed 10 January 2012].Google Scholar
Worldwatch Institute (2002) State of the World 2002: A Worldwatch Institute Report on Progress toward a Sustainable Society, W. W. Norton and Company, New York.Google Scholar