Last updated 10th July 2024: Online ordering is currently unavailable due to technical issues. We apologise for any delays responding to customers while we resolve this. For further updates please visit our website https://www.cambridge.org/news-and-insights/technical-incident
We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 August 2016
This article examines the public culture of military associations, and their veteran membership, in inter-war Glasgow. It follows their parades and beery reunions to consider the public meanings of such acts. That these claims to civic recognition were met by a congregation of civic elements allows us to view the inter-war creation of civic identity from a new and enlightening vantage point. But this culture also allows us to encompass the vitality, and distinctly urban character, of the memory of the Great War within inter-war society. Cities provided alternative channels for the veteran associational impulse to the British Legion, which has generally been seen as synonymous with the veterans’ movement in Britain. War memory, too, had a distinct urban form and character that needs to be acknowledged within wider literature. This is the story of the ‘civic veteran’ and the social and cultural contexts that made him.
1 Purseigle, P., ‘Beyond and below the nations: towards a comparative history of local communities at war’, in Macleod, J. and Purseigle, P. (eds.), Uncovered Fields: Perspectives in War Studies (Boston, MA, 2004), 95–123 Google Scholar; Winter, J. and Robert, J.-L. (eds.), Capital Cities at War: Paris, London, Berlin 1914–1919, vols. I and II (Cambridge, 1997–2007)Google Scholar; Goebel, S. and Keene, Derek (eds.), Cities into Battlefields: Metropolitan Scenarios, Experiences and Commemorations of Total War (Farnham, 2011)Google Scholar.
2 Gregory, A., The Silence of Memory: Armistice Day 1919–1946 (Oxford, 1994)Google Scholar; King, A., Memorials of the Great War in Britain: The Symbolism and Politics of Remembrance (Oxford, 1998)Google Scholar; Connelly, M., The Great War, Memory and Ritual: Commemoration in the City and East London, 1916–1939 (London, 2001)Google Scholar.
3 S. Goebel, ‘Commemorative cosmopolis: transnational networks of remembrance in post-war Coventry’, in Goebel and Keene (eds.), Cities into Battlefields, 163–83.
4 Beaven, B., Visions of Empire: Patriotism, Popular Culture and the City 1870–1939 (Manchester, 2012)Google Scholar.
5 Trainor, R., ‘The “decline” of British urban governance since 1850: a reassessment’, in Morris, R.J. and Trainor, R. (eds.), Urban Governance: Britain and Beyond since 1750 (Aldershot, 2000), 28–46 Google Scholar; Wildman, C., ‘Urban transformation in Liverpool and Manchester, 1918–1939’, Historical Journal, 55 (2012), 119–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hulme, T., ‘Putting the city back into citizenship: civics education and local government in Britain, 1918–1945’, Twentieth Century British History, 26 (2015), 26–51 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
6 McVeigh, S. and Cooper, N., ‘Introduction’, in McVeigh, S. and Cooper, N. (eds.), Men after War (New York, 2013), 7 Google Scholar.
7 For differing perspectives on Scottish recruitment in the voluntary phase, see D.R. Young, ‘Voluntary recruitment in Scotland, 1914–1915’, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Glasgow, 2001, and Coetzee, D., ‘Measures of enthusiasm: new avenues in quantifying variations in voluntary enlistment in Scotland, August 1914 – December 1915’, Local Population Studies, 74 (2005), 16–35 Google Scholar.
8 Young, ‘Voluntary recruitment in Scotland’, 277.
9 Dewey has shown that the most protected industries were mining, transport, metals and agriculture: Dewey, P.E., ‘Military recruiting and the British labour force during the First World War’, Historical Journal, 27 (1984), 218 CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Scottish rates post-conscription found in J. Winter, ‘Britain's lost generation of the First World War’, Population Studies, 31 (1977), 450–1. For discussion of Glasgow's role in the war economy, see Lee, C.H., ‘The Scottish economy’, in MacDonald, C.M.M. and McFarland, E.W. (eds.), Scotland and the Great War (East Linton, 1999), 11–35 Google Scholar.
10 Return Showing the Numbers of Parliamentary and Local Government Electors on the First Register Compiled under the Representation of the People Act, 1918, ordered by the House of Commons, to be printed, 18 Nov. 1918. Thanks to Dr Stuart Halifax for bringing this source to my attention.
11 Glasgow City Archives (GCA), town clerk's papers, D-TC 1/15/28, Bruce Murray Series (BMS) 28, Glasgow Herald, 4 Nov. 1927.
12 GCA, D-TC 1/15/30, BMS 30, Glasgow Herald, 17 May 1929.
13 Harper, M., Emigration from Scotland between the Wars: Exile or Opportunity? (Manchester, 1998), 135–46Google ScholarPubMed.
14 Evans, N.J., ‘The emigration of skilled male workers from Clydeside during the interwar period’, International Journal of Maritime History, 18 (2006), 255–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
15 Harper has suggested that many of those immigrating from the dominions in the 1930s were those who had been part of the exodus of the 1920s – Emigration from Scotland, 10.
16 Glynn, S. and Booth, A., Modern Britain: An Economic and Social History (London, 1996), 92–3CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
17 Ward, S.R., ‘The British veterans ticket of 1918’, Journal of British Studies, 8 (1968), 155–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
18 McLean, I., The Legend of Red Clydeside (Edinburgh, 1983), 118 Google Scholar.
19 Annual Report of the British Legion Scotland, Pro Patria, The British Legion Scottish Journal, Nov. 1930.
20 Barr, N., ‘”The most happy and cordial relations continue to exist”: the Scottish ex-service movement in the inter-war years’, War & Society, 29 (2010), 47–70 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
21 Barr, N., The Lion and the Poppy: British Veterans, Politics and Society (London, 2005), 57–86 Google Scholar.
22 For the history of Regimental Associations, see French, D., Military Identities: The Regimental System, the British Army, and the British people, c. 1870–2000 (Oxford, 2005), 80–1CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
23 The Thin Red Line, Oct. 1924, 2.
24 The Royal Tank Corps Journal, Feb. 1932, 274.
25 Daily Record, 4 Oct. 1934, 10.
26 Barr, The Lion and the Poppy, 58.
27 London Scottish Regimental Gazette, Dec. 1936, 292.
28 Highland Light Infantry Chronicle (HLIC), Jul. 1926, 128. It is likely that the majority of these would have been veteran members, rather than the members of the depot based in Maryhill barracks, Glasgow.
29 See Cabar Faidh, May 1926, Appendix. List of Members (Glasgow branch).
30 Ibid., Dec. 1938, 35.
31 The Sapper, Dec. 1928, Association News, Glasgow branch.
32 Membership rolls of Glasgow branch published in 79th News, 1920–39. These did not include men whose career with the colours had recently finished. These became a relatively rich source of manpower in 1929 after Major H.C. Methuen inaugurated the ‘Serving Members Scheme’, which linked new reservists with branch representatives. See 79th News, Jul. 1929, 29; Jan. 1934, 65.
33 GCA, D-TC 1/15/20, BMS 20, 64, Glasgow Herald, 12 Dec. 1927.
34 The Borderers Chronicle, 20 Sep. 1926, 37; 30 Sep. 1929, 117.
35 HLIC, Apr. 1926, 80.
36 Chalmers, T., An Epic of Glasgow: History of the Fifteenth Battalion (Glasgow, 1934), 89 Google Scholar.
37 The association was running an annual golf competition, as well as a reunion gathering, in 1938. GCA, TD1670/1/31, Glasgow Chamber of Commerce Minutes, 12 Jan. 1937 – 19 Dec. 1938, Presidents’ Advisory Committee Meeting, 11 Nov. 1938.
38 Glasgow Herald, 24 Nov. 1924, 9.
39 79th News, Jan. 1931, 97.
40 Glasgow University Library Special Collections (GULSC), MS Gen 1376/14/13 6th QOCH Reunion Club Membership Roll.
41 Cabar Faidh, Jun. 1937, 314.
42 The Bulletin & Scots Pictorial, 25 Nov. 1935, 12; Red Hackle, Jan. 1939, 125.
44 Although regimental, Territorial and service associations may have competed for, or shared, members, the rolls of QOCH Association and the members of the 6th QOCH suggests the latter was not typical.
45 Spiers, E., ‘The Scottish soldier at war’, in Cecil, H. and Liddle, P. (eds.), Armageddon: The First World War Experienced (London, 1996), 314–15Google Scholar.
46 For Helen McCartney's findings regarding recruiting and drafting procedures, see McCartney, H., Citizen Soldiers: The Liverpool Territorials in the First World War (Cambridge, 2005), 62–5CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For the exploration of these issues within Scottish Command, see E.K. O'Keeffe, ‘Localities of memory, localities of mobilisation: British military communities and the Great War, 1919–39’, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, Queen Mary University London, 62–3.
47 Grateful thanks to Dr Niall Barr for his guidance on affiliation. In 1936, there were 8 regimental associations officially affiliated with the Legion; this had risen to 19 by 1959. Malcolm, George of Poltalloch, We Will Remember. Historical Record of the British Legion in Scotland (Edinburgh, 1959), 19 and 113Google Scholar.
48 See Barr, “The most happy and cordial relations”’, 56, and Lion and the Poppy, 99–114.
49 Devine, T.M., The Scottish Nation: A Modern History (London, 2012), 361 Google Scholar.
50 GCA, SR22/40, Glasgow Police Records, Chief Constable's Annual Report, 1938.
51 GCA SR22/14, Licensing Register Billiards Halls.
52 O'Keeffe, ‘Localities’, 131.
53 Young, ‘Voluntary recruitment in Scotland’, 294.
54 O'Keeffe, ‘Localities’, 126.
55 Horne, J., ‘Beyond cultures of victory and defeat’, in Eichenberg, J. and Newman, J.P.O. (eds.), The Great War and Veterans Internationalism (Basingstoke, 2013), 212 Google Scholar.
56 Goebel, S., The Great War and Medieval Memory: War, Remembrance and Medievalism in Britain and Germany, 1914–1940 (Cambridge, 2007), 6 Google Scholar.
57 See Priestley, J.B., English Journey (Ilkley, 2009), 157–62Google Scholar; Grieves, K., ‘Remembering an ill-fated venture: the Fourth Battalion, Royal Sussex Regiment at Suvla Bay and its legacy, 1915–1918’, in Macleod, F. (ed.), Gallipoli: Making History (London, 2004), 110–24Google Scholar.
58 Gregory, The Silence of Memory, 51–86, 127–8. See also Connelly, The Great War, Memory and Ritual, 264.
59 Findlay, B., ‘Intimate strangers: clubs, pubs and the forging of Glasgow's corporate identity’, Recherches Anglaises et Nord-Américaines, 40 (2007), 149–62Google Scholar.
60 Glasgow Herald, 30 Sep. 1928, 5.
61 Burnett, J., England Eats Out: A Social History of Eating Out in England from 1830 to the Present (Harlow, 2004), 195 Google Scholar.
62 To compare, the HLI's officers’ annual dinner in the Ca' D'oro in 1923 cost 13s 6d per ticket for non-members and 9s for those who had paid a subscription.
63 Johnston, R., Clydeside Capital, 1870–1920: A History of Employers (East Linton, 2000), 101–3Google Scholar.
64 Scottish Country Life, Nov. 1926, 380.
65 Caterer & Hotel Keeper Gazette, 20 Apr. 1928, 126.
66 The Bulletin, 3 Feb. 1922, 21.
67 GULSC, MS Gen 1376, papers of the 6th Cameron Highlanders Reunion Club, Minute Book 1931–74, Annual Report for 1931.
68 Daily Record, 9 May 1929, 12.
69 Jackson, I., The Provincial Press and the Community (Manchester, 1971)Google Scholar; Hutchison, I.G.C., ‘Scottish Unionism between the wars’, in Macdonald, C.M.M. (ed.), Unionist Scotland, 1800–1997 (Edinburgh, 1998), 81 Google Scholar.
70 Smyth, J.J., ‘Resisting Labour: Unionists, Liberals, and Moderates in Glasgow between the wars’, Historical Journal, 46 (2003), 375–401 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
71 Glasgow Herald, 16 Nov. 1929, 7.
72 Glasgow Herald, 4 Nov. 1929, 4.
73 Gallagher, T. and Walker, G., ‘Protestantism and Scottish politics’, in Gallagher, T. and Walker, G. (ed.), Sermons and Battle Hymns: Popular Protestant Culture in Modern Scotland (Edinburgh, 1990), 96–101 Google Scholar.
74 Glasgow Herald, 22 Nov. 1930, 11; Quarterly Journal of the Royal Chaplains Department (London, 1934), 526–7.
75 GH, 12 Nov. 1934, 13.
76 Gunn, S., The Public Culture of the Victorian Middle Class: Ritual and Authority in the English Industrial City, 1840–1914 (Manchester, 2000), 182 Google Scholar.
77 Davies, A., ‘”They sing that song”: football and sectarianism in Glasgow during the 1920s and 1930s’, in Flint, J. and Kelly, J. (eds.), Bigotry, Football and Scotland (Edinburgh, 2013), 50–64 Google Scholar.
78 See Gregory's arguments regarding the apolitical claims of war remembrance during Armistice Day in The Silence of Memory, 131 and ch. 5.
79 GCA, G1/3/1/ Lord Provost's papers, War Memorial Files, First Meeting of the War Memorial Committee, 26 May 1919.
80 Chalmers, T., A Saga of Scotland, History of the 16th HLI (Glasgow, 1930), 57–68 Google Scholar.
81 Daily Record, 16 Nov. 1934, 22.
82 Honeyman, K., ‘Following suit: men, masculinity, and gendered practices in the clothing trade in Leeds, England, 1890–1940’, Gender & History, 14 (2002), 429 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
83 Ugolini, L., Men and Menswear: Sartorial Consumption in Britain 1880–1939 (Aldershot, 2007), 108–13Google Scholar.
84 Gallacher, W., Revolt on the Clyde: An Autobiography (London, 1978), 202 Google Scholar.
85 Glasgow Herald, 5 Sep. 1927, 13.
86 GCA, G1/3/25, Lord Provost's papers, Civic & Empire Week, 1931, Lord Provost's Engagements.
87 The Covenanter, Nov. 1930, 93.
88 O'Keeffe, E.K., ‘The Great War and “military memory”: war and remembrance in the civic public sphere, 1919–1939’, Journalism Studies, 17 (2016), 432–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
89 The Bulletin & Scots Pictorial, 6 Sep. 1926, 2.
90 Daily Record, 6 Jul. 1925, 11.
91 GCA, BMS 30, 118; Glasgow Herald, 23 Nov. 1931.
92 The Bulletin & Scots Pictorial, 1 Jun. 1931, 14.
93 Daily Record, 5 Sep. 1927, 9.
94 Daily Record, 6 Jul. 1925, 11.
95 See photographs in the Daily Record, 6 Jul. 1925, 20; The Bulletin & Scots Pictorial, 6 Jul. 1925, 2.
96 Arthur, J.W. and Munro, I.S., Seventeenth Highland Light Infantry Record of War Service 1914–1918 (Glasgow, 2006), 76 Google Scholar.
97 GCA, Glasgow Corporation Minutes, C1/3/98, Apr.–Nov. 1938, Finance Committee 10 Jun. 1938, 2049.
98 The Bulletin & Scots Pictorial, 28 Jun. 1938, 28.
99 Cohen, D., The War Come Home: Disabled Veterans in Britain and Germany, 1914–1939 (Berkeley, 2001), 29–60 Google Scholar; McCarthy, H. and Thane, P., ‘The politics of association in industrial society’, Twentieth Century British History, 22 (2011), 217–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
100 Brown, S.J., ‘“A victory for God”: the Scottish Presbyterian churches and the general strike of 1926’, Journal of Ecclesiastical History, 42 (1991), 596–617 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
101 Macleod, J., ‘“By Scottish hands, with Scottish money, on Scottish soil”: the Scottish National War Memorial and national identity’, Journal of British Studies, 29 (2010), 74–96 Google Scholar.
102 McFarland, E., ‘The Great War’, in Devine, T.M. and Wormauld, J. (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Modern Scottish History 1500–2000 (Oxford, 2012), 553–68Google Scholar.
