Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-xm8r8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-05T22:23:22.608Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

A ‘sort’ of self-denial: United States policy toward the Antarctic, 1950–59

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 October 2009

Jason Kendall Moore
Affiliation:
506 East Fourth Street, Suite 507, Cincinnati, OH 45202, USA

Abstract

United States policy toward the Antarctic in the 1950s culminated in the treaty that bears the continent's name — the same treaty that continues to govern relations in the far south. Washington succeeded in promoting the admirable objectives of scientific advancement and international cooperation. In doing so, it also forfeited what many officials believed to be the more important objective of formalizing a national sovereignty claim to halt further erosion of the rights associated with its mammoth expeditions. Trapped by having repeated their non-claimancy, nonrecognition policy, which Secretary of State Charles E. Hughes had announced in 1924, US officials scrambled for alternatives. They finally chose to formalize their policy-making paralysis, rather than a claim, by proposing a treaty that called for a political status quo moratorium, in accord with the Chilean Escudero Plan. That decision impressed some experts as unwise, but it was sufficiently expedient to win the signatures needed for ratification.

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2001

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Department of State. 1947. Admiral Richard E. Byrd to Admiral Chester Nimitz, Chief of Naval Operations, [and Department of State]. Memorandum on press conference. 15 04 1947. Columbus, Ohio: Byrd Polar Research Center.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1948a. Division of Northern European Affairs. Memorandum. 7 09 1948. Central decimal file 800.014.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1948b. Ambassador Claude Bowers, Embassy in Santiago, to Secretary of State. 18 02 1948. Central decimal file 800.014.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1948c. Embassy in Santiago to Division of European Affairs and Office of American Republic Affairs. 19 07 1948. Central decimal file 800.014.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1950a. Office of British Commonwealth and Northern European Affairs to Office of North and West Coast Affairs. 4 01 1950.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1950b. Office of North and West Coast Affairs. Memorandum. 9 03 1950.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1950c. Embassy of the Soviet Union to Department of State. 8 06 1950.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1950d. Office of British Commonwealth and Northern European Affairs. Memorandum. 16 08 1950.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1950e. Office of British Commonwealth and Northern European Affairs. Memorandum. 12 07 1950.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1950f. Office of North and West Coast Affairs. Memorandum. 7 08 1950.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1950g. Office of North and West Coast Affairs. Memorandum. 13 06 1950.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1950h. Embassy in Oslo to Department of State. 21 06 1950.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1950i. Embassy in Quebec City to Department of State. 24 01 1950.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1950j. Office of North and West Coast Affairs to Bureau of Inter-American Affairs. 4 05 1950.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1951a. Embassy in Santiago to Department of State. 10 01 1951.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1951b. Embassy in Santiago to Department of State. 12 03 1951.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1951c. Secret policy statement: Polar regions. 1 07 1951.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1952a. Special Adviserfor Geography, Boggs, Sheldon W., to Bureau of Inter-American Affairs, et al. 10 01 1952.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1952b. Bureau of European Affairs to Office of the Deputy Undersecretary of State. 15 07 1952.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1952c. Special AdviserforGeography, Sheldon W. Boggs, to Office of South American Affairs. 8 01 1952.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1952d. Embassy of Chile to Department of State. 16 01 1952.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1952e. Department of State to Embassy of Chile. 16 01 1952.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1952f. Special Adviser for Geography, Boggs, Sheldon W. et al. Memorandum. 16 01 1952.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1952g. Office of South American Affairs to Bureau of European Affairs. 14 02 1952.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1952h. Bureau of Inter-American Affairs. Memorandum. 11 03 1952.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953a. Embassy in Buenos Aires to Department of State. 23 02 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953b. Embassy in Buenos Aires to Secretary of State. 22 02 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953c. Ambassador Claude Bowers, Embassy in Santiago, to Secretary of State. 20 02 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953d. Embassy in Buenos Aires to Secretary of State. 23 02 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953e. Ambassador Claude Bowers, Embassy in Santiago, to Secretary of State. 24 02 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953f. Ambassador Claude Bowers, Embassy in Santiago, to Secretary of State. 20 03 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953g. Acting Secretary of State to Embassy in London. 10 04 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953h. Ambassador Claude Bowers, Embassy in Santiago, to Secretary of State. 26 03 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953i. Secretary of State to Embassies in Santiago, Buenos Aires, and London. 22 02 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953j. Secretary of State to Embassy in Santiago. 3 04 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953k. Ambassador Claude Bowers, Embassy in Santiago, to Secretary of State. 1 04 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953l. Ambassador Claude Bowers, Embassy in Santiago, to Secretary of State. 31 03 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953m. Ambassador Claude Bowers, Embassy in Santiago, to Secretary of State. 4 04 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953n. Ambassador Claude Bowers, Embassy in Santiago, to Secretary of State. 16 03 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953o. Embassy in London to Department of State. 16 07 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953p. Ambassador Claude Bowers, Embassy in Santiago, to Secretary of State. 24 02 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953q. Office of South American Affairs to Bureau of Inter-American Affairs. 19 08 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953r. Office of British Commonwealth and Northern European Affairs, et al. Ad Hoc Committee on Antarctica. Memorandum. 23 04 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953s. Assistant Secretary of State to Secretary of Interior. 10 04 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1953t. Office of South American Affairs. Memorandum. 10 04 1953.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1954a. Embassy in Buenos Aires to Department of State. 5 08 1954.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1954b. Acting Secretary of State to Representative Charles E. Bennett. 21 06 1954.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1955a. Embassy in Santiago to Department of State. 16 05 1955.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1955b. Office of British Commonwealth and Northern European Affairs. Memorandum. 25 05 1955.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1955c. Bureau of Inter-American Affairs to Operations Coordinator, Office of the Undersecretary of State. Memorandum. 19 05 1955.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1955d. Bureau of European Affairs, et al. Memorandum. 4 10 1955.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1955e. Office of British Commonwealth and Northern European Affairs, et al. Memorandum. 10 10 1955.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1955f. National Security Council. NSC 5528: Antarctica. 12 12 1955. Records of the Policy Planning Staff.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1955g. Representative Ralph E. Flanders to Assistant Secretary of State Thurston B. Morton. 28 04 1955.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1955h. Assistant Secretary of State Thurston B. Morton to Representative Ralph E. Flanders. 5 05 1955.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956a. US Mission at the United Nations to Secretary of State. 31 08 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956b. Embassy in Santiago to Department of State. 24 04 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956c. Executive Secretariatto Bureau of Far Eastern Affairs. 14 02 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956d. Australian Embassy in Washington to Department of State. 9 02 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956e. Office of United Nations Political and Security Affairs, et al. Memorandum. 5 03 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956f. Acting Secretary of State to US Mission at the United Nations, et al. 8 03 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956g. US Mission at the United Nations to Secretary of State. 28 09 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956h. Office of British Commonwealth and Northern European Affairs, et al. Memorandum. 12 03 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956i. Acting Secretary of State to US Mission at the United Nations, et al. 3 09 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956j. US Mission at the United Nations to Secretary of State. 14 09 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956k. Preliminary position paper on Antarctica. 7 08 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956l. Embassy in Canberra to Department of State. 19 03 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956m. Acting Secretary of State, et al. Memorandum. 9 11 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956n. Office of United Nations Political and Security Affairs to Office of Inter-American Regional Political Affairs. Memorandum. 5 09 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1956o. Department of State to Embassy in Santiago. 14 09 1956.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957a. Office of Inter-American Regional Political Affairs. Memorandum. 22 01 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957b. Bureau of International Organization Affairs to Bureau of Inter-American Affairs. 6 03 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957c. Office of Inter-American Regional Political Affairs. Memorandum. 22 01 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957d. Office of Inter-American Regional Political Affairs. Memorandum. 31 01 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957e. Office of Inter-American Regional Political Affairs to Office of British Commonwealth and Northern European Affairs. Memorandum. 21 02 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957f. Assistant Secretary of Defense to Deputy Undersecretary of State. 19 04 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957g. Bureau of International Organization Affairs to Bureau of Inter-American Affairs, et al. 13 05 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957h. Office of Inter-American Regional Political Affairs. Memorandum. 12 06 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957l. Office of Inter-American Regional Political Affairs. Memorandum. 6 02 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957j. Office of Inter-American Regional Political Affairs to Department of Defense. 6 02 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957k. Undersecretary of State to Office of Inter-American Regional Political Affairs, et al. Memorandum. 14 06 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957l. Office of Inter-American Regional Political Affairs, et al. Memorandum. 23 08 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957m. Embassy in Canberra to Department of State. 30 08 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957n. Secretary of State to US Embassies in London, Canberra and Wellington. 14 09 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957o. Office of Inter-American Regional Political Affairs, et al. Memorandum. 19 09 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957p. Embassy in Santiago to Department of State. 17 09 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957q. Special Adviser on Antarctic Affairs, Daniels, Ambassador Paul C. et al. Memorandum. 8 11 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957r. Embassy in Buenos Aires to Department of State. 8 04 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957s. Embassy in Santiago to Department of State. 26 07 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957t. Embassy in Santiago to Department of State. 30 09 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957u. Embassy in Santiago to Department of State. 22 11 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957v. Special Adviser on Antarctic Affairs, Daniels, Ambassador Paul C. et al. Memorandum. 8 01 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957w. Office of British Commonwealth and Northern European Affairs to Bureau of European Affairs. 3 06 1957.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1957x. Office of Inter-American Regional Political Affairs. Memorandum. 3 10 1957. Central decimal file 399.829.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958a. Office of Inter-American Regional Political Affairs. Memorandum. 9 06 1958. Central decimal file 399.829.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958b. Embassy in Canberra to Department of State. 24 06 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958c. Special Adviser on Antarctic Affairs, Daniels, Ambassador Paul C.. Memorandum. 28 01 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958d. Embassy in Santiago to Department of State. 18 02 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958e. Embassy in Santiago to Department of State. 13 02 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958f. British Embassy to Department of State. 13 02 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958g. Embassy in London to Secretary of State. 12 02 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958h. Embassy in Santiago to Secretary of State. 19 02 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958i. Secretary of State to Embassies in the American Republics, et al. 27 02 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958J. Department of State to Representatives of Argentina, Australia, Belgium, Chile, France, Japan, Norway, New Zealand, South Africa, USSR, and the United Kingdom. 24 03 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958k. Secretary of State to Embassy in London. 31 03 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958l. British Foreign Office to Department of State. 22 05 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958m. Secretary of State to Embassy in Paris. 25 04 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958n. Office of the Deputy Undersecretary of State to Secretary of State. 28 05 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958o. Secretary of State to all American diplomatic posts. 20 06 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958p. Secretary of State to Embassy in New Dehli. 11 06 1958. Central decimal file 399.829.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958q. Secretary of State to Embassy in Wellington. 14 07 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958r. Antarctic Conference preparations. Memorandum. 2 10 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958s. Embassy in Canberra to Secretary of State. 6 06 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958t. Representatives of Argentina, Australia, Chile, New Zealand, United Kingdom, and the United States. Memorandum of Conversation. 15 08 1958. Central decimal file 399.829.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958u. Special Adviser on Antarctic Affairs, Daniels, Ambassador Paul C. et al. Memorandum. 6 03 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958v. Embassy in Paris to Secretary of State. 15 09 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958w. Embassy in Santiago to Secretary of State. 1 04 1958.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958x. Office of Western European Affairs. Memorandum. 8 07 1958. Central decimal file 399.829.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958y. Daniels, Ambassador Paul C. et al. Memorandum. 16 10 1958. Central decimal file 399.829.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1958z. Daniels, Ambassador Paul C. et al. Memorandum. 11 07 1958. Central decimal file 399.829.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1959a. Draft position paperon Antarctic Conference. 4 05 1959.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1959b. Bureau of Far Eastern Affairs to Office of the Deputy Undersecretary of State. 22 04 1959.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1959c. Bureau of European Affairs to Office of the Deputy Undersecretary of State. 21 04 1959. Central decimal file 399.829.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1959d. Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for International Organization Affairs. Memorandum. 24 04 1959. Central decimal file 399.829.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1959e. Bureau of Inter-American Affairs, et al. Memorandum. 20 03 1959. Central decimal file 399.829.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1959f. Bureau of Inter-American Affairs, et al. Memorandum. 2 11 1959, Central decimal file 399.829.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1959g. Bureau of African Affairs. Memorandum. 24 11 1959. Central decimal file 399.829.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1959h. Embassy in Buenos Aires to Department of State. 3 11 1959. Central decimal file 399.829.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1959i. Undersecretary of State to American diplomatic posts. 10 12 1959.Google Scholar
Department of State. 1991. Foreign relations of the United States, 1958–1960. Volume 2: The United Nations and general international matters. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.Google Scholar
Moore, J.K. 1999. Tethered to an iceberg: United States policy toward the Antarctic, 1939–1949. Polar Record 35 (193): 125134.Google Scholar