Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Preface
- 1 Moral argument and moral theory
- 2 Utilitarianism and contractualism
- 3 Utilitarianism and animal suffering
- 4 Utilitarianism and the harm of killing
- 5 Contractualism and animals
- 6 Animals and rational agency
- 7 Contractualism and character
- 8 Animals and conscious experience
- Conclusion
- Notes
- Index
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Preface
- 1 Moral argument and moral theory
- 2 Utilitarianism and contractualism
- 3 Utilitarianism and animal suffering
- 4 Utilitarianism and the harm of killing
- 5 Contractualism and animals
- 6 Animals and rational agency
- 7 Contractualism and character
- 8 Animals and conscious experience
- Conclusion
- Notes
- Index
Summary
The animal rights movement has gained considerable momentum in recent years, fuelled, in part, by the theoretical arguments of moral philosophers. Indeed, it is striking that almost all of the books and articles recently published on this issue have argued in favour of the moral standing of animals. This is not because the consensus amongst moral philosophers as a whole is that animals have rights. It is rather because, for one reason or another, most of those who take the opposite view have chosen to remain silent. This book is written in an attempt to redress the balance.
My view is that the case for the moral standing of animals is weak, and that the contrary case is, by contrast, very powerful. In fact, I regard the present popular concern with animal rights in our culture as a reflection of moral decadence. Just as Nero fiddled while Rome burned, many in the West agonise over the fate of seal pups and cormorants while human beings elsewhere starve or are enslaved. This reaction is, to a degree, understandable. For animal sufferers are always blameless, and the steps necessary to improve their situation are generally plain. Our response to human suffering, in contrast, is often complicated by the suspicion that the victims, or their political representatives, are at least partially responsible for their fate, and by knowledge of the fearsome complexity of the economic and social problems involved in such issues as famine relief.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The Animals IssueMoral Theory in Practice, pp. xi - xivPublisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1992