February 1998, “Law Without Law…Or Something Like That”

This morning I read one of the papers you gave me last week (“Information is Inevitably Physical”) and was reminded of your interest in the idea that the laws of physics may not be written in stone once and for all…but instead may be contingent upon the particular details of the universe itself…and indeed may be evolutionary à la Peirce, Wheeler, Lee Smolin, etc. At least one version or other of this kind of thing has intrigued me for some time (essentially since meeting John Wheeler in 1985). It's been sort of a hidden hobby, somewhat connected with separating the wheat from the chaff in quantum mechanics. My personal writings on the subject are now pretty voluminous, though not yet tight enough in substance that I show them to too many: most are in the form of emails to colleagues such as you.

Anyway, if you're interested, perhaps I'll compile a small compendium and send it your way when I get back from Tokyo March 15 – I'm travelling essentially every moment until then. May be this will help us open a dialog to pinpoint where some real progress might be made.

In the meantime let me tip you off to another article on the subject that I ran across recently: S. S. Schweber: “The Metaphysics of Science at the End of a Heroic Age,” in Experimental Metaphysics, edited by R. S. Cohen, M. Horne, and J. Stachel (Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1997), pp. 171–198.