Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Preface to the first edition
- Introduction to the new edition
- Part I The setting
- Part II A world view
- 3 A counterrevolution of values
- 4 The “English way of life”?
- 5 The wrong path?
- Part III Toward behavior
- Part IV Industrialism and English values
- Appendix: British retardation – the limits of economic explanation
- Notes
- Index
5 - The wrong path?
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 07 May 2010
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Preface to the first edition
- Introduction to the new edition
- Part I The setting
- Part II A world view
- 3 A counterrevolution of values
- 4 The “English way of life”?
- 5 The wrong path?
- Part III Toward behavior
- Part IV Industrialism and English values
- Appendix: British retardation – the limits of economic explanation
- Notes
- Index
Summary
England certainly saw in recent centuries a progress in the sense of a process … it was imperial in a mercantile manner; it seems now to be ending in [a] paradise of plutocrats … But anyone attempting to show that this process affecting England actually was England, has to face and answer [the] very arresting fact … that every great Englishman with the gift of expression whom the world recognizes as specially English, and as speaking for many Englishmen, was either in unconscious contradiction to that trend or (more often) in furious revolt against it.
—G. K. ChestertonBy now it should seem clear to the reader that the vision of a tranquilly rustic and traditional national way of life permeated English life, and that any understanding of British economic development must take account of that fact. Nonetheless, the other facts could not be denied; the vision was not secure. Industrialism had of course been born in England; there was no wishing that fact away. But the legitimacy of that birth could be denied: Industrialism and the industrial spirit could be seen as not truly English, and, indeed, as a profound menace to the survival of “Englishness.” A cultural polarity gradually emerged between Englishness, identified with the pastoral vision (the “green and pleasant land”), and industrialism (the “dark satanic mills”). The vision was felt to be precarious, being eroded bit by bit by the advance of industry. The power of the Machine was invading and blighting the Shire.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2004