Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Preface
- A Note on United Nations Committees
- Abbreviations
- 1 A Public Relations Imperative
- 2 Promises, Promises
- 3 Pranks in Paris and Geneva
- 4 Courting the Commissar
- 5 Saving Europe's Jews – Our Way
- 6 Smoke and Mirrors at the YMCA
- 7 The Ship that Launched a Nation
- 8 Cocktails at the Consulate
- 9 Causing Chaos
- 10 Denying the Undeniable
- 11 A Peace-Loving State?
- 12 Joining the World with Fingers Crossed
- 13 Israel: 1, United Nations: 0
- 14 A Phantom Attack
- 15 Sabras in Sinai: Pardon My French
- 16 Suez Smoke-Screen
- 17 Mr. Nasser, Please Attack
- 18 Abba Eban's Finest Hour
- 19 Old Issues, New Lies
- 20 An Organization Turned Sinister
- 21 Prevarication Pays
- Notes
- Bibliography
- Index
6 - Smoke and Mirrors at the YMCA
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 January 2016
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Preface
- A Note on United Nations Committees
- Abbreviations
- 1 A Public Relations Imperative
- 2 Promises, Promises
- 3 Pranks in Paris and Geneva
- 4 Courting the Commissar
- 5 Saving Europe's Jews – Our Way
- 6 Smoke and Mirrors at the YMCA
- 7 The Ship that Launched a Nation
- 8 Cocktails at the Consulate
- 9 Causing Chaos
- 10 Denying the Undeniable
- 11 A Peace-Loving State?
- 12 Joining the World with Fingers Crossed
- 13 Israel: 1, United Nations: 0
- 14 A Phantom Attack
- 15 Sabras in Sinai: Pardon My French
- 16 Suez Smoke-Screen
- 17 Mr. Nasser, Please Attack
- 18 Abba Eban's Finest Hour
- 19 Old Issues, New Lies
- 20 An Organization Turned Sinister
- 21 Prevarication Pays
- Notes
- Bibliography
- Index
Summary
On February 25, 1947, British Foreign Secretary Ernest Bevin stood before the House of Commons in London to say that Britain had failed to find any solution for Palestine. “The course of events has led His Majesty's Government to decide that the problem of Palestine must be referred to the United Nations,” Bevin announced. “The problem of Palestine is a very vexed and complex one. There is no denying the fact that the Mandate contained contradictory promises,” Bevin conceded. “In the first place it promised the Jews a National Home, and, in the second place it declared that the rights and position of the Arabs must be protected. Therefore, it provided for what was virtually an invasion of the country by thousands of immigrants, and at the same time said that this was not to disturb the people in possession. The question therefore arose whether this could be accomplished without a conflict, and events in the last 25 years have proved that it could not.” The only respect in which Bevin's statement was not forthright was contained in this last sentence. Bevin made it appear that it took the British government twenty-five years to realize that it had taken on contradictory and irreconcilable obligations. As we saw in Chapter Three, it had known that since at least 1923.
Britain's solution was to ask the newly formed United Nations to devise a solution for Palestine. In April 1947, Britain asked the United Nations to formulate proposals on Palestine. The Charter of the United Nations did not make it entirely clear what powers the United Nations had to deal with Palestine, but Britain had run out of solutions on its own. As a permanent member of the UN Security Council, Britain would not be entirely out of the picture. The Security Council deals with threats to the peace, and Palestine appeared headed for trouble.
The Jewish Agency immediately geared up to encourage the United Nations, in line with the Biltmore Program, to make Palestine into a Jewish state. Realism required, however, that it allow for the Arabs to have a state as well, so Palestine would have to be split. The matter would go to the General Assembly in the first instance, and votes on what were considered “important questions” required a two-thirds majority.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The International Diplomacy of Israel's FoundersDeception at the United Nations in the Quest for Palestine, pp. 46 - 61Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2016