B - The Book of Signs
from PART III - ARGUMENT AND STRUCTURE
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 December 2009
Summary
FIRST EPISODE. THE NEW BEGINNING (ii. i–iv. 42)
Chapters ii. i–iv. 42 contain two distinct narratives, and two passages of discourse, all of which prove to have, in a broad sense, a common theme: a theme which may perhaps best be characterized by Paul's aphorism, τ dρχαiα παρfλθεγ I7delta;ōv γγōγεγ καιγ (II Cor. v. 17). In ii. 1–10 water is replaced by wine; in ii. 14–19 a new temple is foretold; the dialogue with Nicodemus in ch. iii is about new birth; the dialogue with the Samaritan woman in ch. iv contrasts both the ραρ of Jacob with ‘living water’, and the ancient cults of Jerusalem and Gerizim with the worship iv γ πγεUματι καì ληθíc for which the time is ripe. We may therefore best treat these two chapters as forming a single complex act or episode, consisting of two (σημεíα, or significant actions, and two discourses developing their significance.
(i) The narrative of the Miracle of Cana, ii. 1–11, presents, at the very beginning of the Book of Signs, a particularly striking example of a feature of this gospel which will frequently recur. We may call it the Johannine irony. On the face of it we have here a naive tale about a marvel at a village wedding. There is realism in the story, an eye for character and for seemingly trivial detail (the stone waterpots hold from seventeen to twenty-five gallons apiece); there is even a touch of homely humour in the remark of the dρχιτρíκλιγō, ‘Everyone puts the best wine on the table first, and brings on the poor stuff when the company is drunk; but you have kept your good wine to the last.’
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The Interpretation of the Fourth Gospel , pp. 297 - 389Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1953