Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- FOREWORD
- PREFACE
- INTRODUCTION
- 1 A DIAGRAM FOR OBJECT-ORIENTED PROGRAMS
- 2 CONSTRUCTING ABSTRACTIONS FOR OBJECT-ORIENTED APPLICATIONS
- 3 PLAYRGOUND: AN OBJECT ORIENTED SIMULATION SYSTEM WITH AGENT RULES FOR CHILDREN OF ALL AGES
- 4 A LABORATORY FOR TEACHING OBJECT-ORIENTED THINKING
- 5 THINK LIKE AN OBJECT
- 6 WHY STUDY SMALLTALK IDIOMS?
- 7 THE DREADED SUPER
- 8 ABSTRACT CONTROL IDIOMS
- 9 VALUEMODEL IDIOMS
- 10 COLLECTION IDIOMS
- 11 AN OBJECTWORKS\SMALLTALK 4.1 WRAPPER IDIOM
- 12 A SHORT INTRODUCTION TO PATTERN LANGUAGE
- 13 WHOLE LOTTA SMALLTALK: THE TECHNOLOGY
- 14 INSTANCE-SPECIFIC BEHAVIOR: HOW AND WHY
- 15 INSTANCE-SPECIFIC BEHAVIOR: DIGITALK IMPLEMENTATION AND THE DEEPER MEANING OF IT ALL
- 16 TO ACCESSOR OR NOT TO ACCESSOR
- 17 INHERITANCE: THE REST OF THE STORY
- 18 INHERITANCE: THE REST OF THE STORY (CONT.)
- 19 HELPER METHODS AVOID UNWANTED INHERITANCE
- 20 IT'S NOT JUST THE CASE
- 21 CRC: FINDING OBJECTS THE EASY WAY
- 22 DEATH TO CASE STATEMENTS
- 23 WHERE DO OBJECTS COME FROM?
- 24 PATTERNS AND SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT
- 25 DISTRIBUTED SMALLTALK
- 26 WHERE DO OBJECTS COME FROM? FROM VARIABLES AND METHODS
- 27 BIRDS, BEES, AND BROWSERS—OBVIOUS SOURCES OF OBJECTS
- 28 USING PATTERNS: DESIGN
- 29 PATTERNS GENERATE ARCHITECTURES
- 30 SIMPLE SMALLTALK TESTING
- 31 ARCHITECTURAL PROTOTYPE: TELEVISION REMOTE CONTROL
- 32 DEMAND LOADING FOR VISUALWORKS
- 33 GARBAGE COLLECTION REVEALED
- 34 WHAT? WHAT HAPPENED TO GARBAGE COLLECTION?
- 35 SUPER + 1
- 36 CLEAN CODE: PIPE DREAM OR STATE OF MIND?
- 37 A MODEST META PROPOSAL
- 38 USES OF VARIABLES: TEMPS
- 39 VARIABLES OF THE WORLD
- 40 PATTERNS 101
- 41 FAREWELL AND A WOOD PILE
- AFTERWORD
- INDEX
22 - DEATH TO CASE STATEMENTS
Smalltalk Report, January, 1994
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 04 August 2010
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- FOREWORD
- PREFACE
- INTRODUCTION
- 1 A DIAGRAM FOR OBJECT-ORIENTED PROGRAMS
- 2 CONSTRUCTING ABSTRACTIONS FOR OBJECT-ORIENTED APPLICATIONS
- 3 PLAYRGOUND: AN OBJECT ORIENTED SIMULATION SYSTEM WITH AGENT RULES FOR CHILDREN OF ALL AGES
- 4 A LABORATORY FOR TEACHING OBJECT-ORIENTED THINKING
- 5 THINK LIKE AN OBJECT
- 6 WHY STUDY SMALLTALK IDIOMS?
- 7 THE DREADED SUPER
- 8 ABSTRACT CONTROL IDIOMS
- 9 VALUEMODEL IDIOMS
- 10 COLLECTION IDIOMS
- 11 AN OBJECTWORKS\SMALLTALK 4.1 WRAPPER IDIOM
- 12 A SHORT INTRODUCTION TO PATTERN LANGUAGE
- 13 WHOLE LOTTA SMALLTALK: THE TECHNOLOGY
- 14 INSTANCE-SPECIFIC BEHAVIOR: HOW AND WHY
- 15 INSTANCE-SPECIFIC BEHAVIOR: DIGITALK IMPLEMENTATION AND THE DEEPER MEANING OF IT ALL
- 16 TO ACCESSOR OR NOT TO ACCESSOR
- 17 INHERITANCE: THE REST OF THE STORY
- 18 INHERITANCE: THE REST OF THE STORY (CONT.)
- 19 HELPER METHODS AVOID UNWANTED INHERITANCE
- 20 IT'S NOT JUST THE CASE
- 21 CRC: FINDING OBJECTS THE EASY WAY
- 22 DEATH TO CASE STATEMENTS
- 23 WHERE DO OBJECTS COME FROM?
- 24 PATTERNS AND SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT
- 25 DISTRIBUTED SMALLTALK
- 26 WHERE DO OBJECTS COME FROM? FROM VARIABLES AND METHODS
- 27 BIRDS, BEES, AND BROWSERS—OBVIOUS SOURCES OF OBJECTS
- 28 USING PATTERNS: DESIGN
- 29 PATTERNS GENERATE ARCHITECTURES
- 30 SIMPLE SMALLTALK TESTING
- 31 ARCHITECTURAL PROTOTYPE: TELEVISION REMOTE CONTROL
- 32 DEMAND LOADING FOR VISUALWORKS
- 33 GARBAGE COLLECTION REVEALED
- 34 WHAT? WHAT HAPPENED TO GARBAGE COLLECTION?
- 35 SUPER + 1
- 36 CLEAN CODE: PIPE DREAM OR STATE OF MIND?
- 37 A MODEST META PROPOSAL
- 38 USES OF VARIABLES: TEMPS
- 39 VARIABLES OF THE WORLD
- 40 PATTERNS 101
- 41 FAREWELL AND A WOOD PILE
- AFTERWORD
- INDEX
Summary
There are two notable points to make about this paper. First, it is one of the first times Ward and I published any pattern-related material (we presented some stuff at OOPSLA 87 in Orlando, I in Norm Kerth's “Where Do Objects Come From” workshop, Ward on a panel). Second, it argues that the worst problem of reuse is one of communication, not technology or economics.
The paper started out life as a Tektronix technical report. Ward and I had the habit of writing up just about everything we did as a TR. After we had written this, I think we submitted it as a position paper for some conference or workshop. Somehow, JOOP got hold of a copy and contacted us about publishing it.
The paper can be summed up as: “We created two sets of abstractions. The first was communicated as literate source code. The second was communicated as patterns for its reuse. The first set of objects was misused; the second was used correctly. We conclude that the problem of reuse is one of effectively communicating the intent of the code.”
Hold on a sec.…
Before I finish bashing case statements, I'd like to return to the scene of an earlier crime, my perfidious assault on that bastion of Smalltalk orthodoxy, the ubiquitous accessor method. (Whew! That's a tenbuck sentence if I ever seen one.) I argued that the violation of encapsulation provided by accessor methods more than offset any benefit of inheritance reuse.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Kent Beck's Guide to Better SmalltalkA Sorted Collection, pp. 213 - 218Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1997