4 - Toward an Aesthetic of Tongzhi Camp
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 November 2020
Summary
Abstract
This chapter investigates the significance and articulation of tongzhi camp. It first unpacks the nebulous concept of “gay sensibility” by supplementing it with a structure of feeling mediated by gay shame and gay melancholy, alongside their particular ramifications in a Chinese cultural setting. It then examines how such a queer structure of feeling is potentially transformed into camp expressions in Corner's (2001) and Splendid Float (2004), directed by lesbian-identifying filmmaker Zero Chou. This chapter finally analyzes the way camp is adapted by Tsai Ming-liang in The Hole (1998) into a powerful implement that negotiates heteronormativity by playing on the mechanism of the homosexual closet: homosexual presence thus becomes imbricated in the audio-visual expressions that characterize the film's patent tongzhi camp style.
Keywords: tongzhi camp, gay shame, gay melancholy, Zero Chou, The Hole
In the previous chapter I mapped out the dissemination of mass camp impulse in Hong Kong from the 1960s, and its discursive formation from the late 1970s. I pointed out that while camp in Hong Kong has been mainly understood as a penchant for excessive stylizations and the overly conventionalized, denotations of gender parody – alongside their homosexual connotations – somehow did not constitute a salient dimension of that local camp discourse in its early stage. A notable change, however, took place during the second half of the 1980s, when Chow Yun-fat's star vehicle The Eighth Happiness (1988) played a crucial part in bringing into public awareness a camp appreciation accentuated by gender bending and gender parody. Since the late 1980s, Hong Kong people would often simply use the English word “camp” to describe effeminate men with strong homosexual overtones.
Responding to this tendency to equate sissies and gay men through camp, Xiaomingxiong (a.k.a. Samshasha, 1954-2006), a Hong Kong-based cultural critic and pioneering gay historian, published four essays in late 1988 in his column on gay film culture (“xiong ying ji”) in the popular Film Biweekly (Dianying shuang zhoukan). His essays compounded the issue of camp in a number of ways. First, he discussed the historical figure Qu Yuan (338-278 BC), a revered official and poet best known for his Li sao (Encountering Sorrow), an epic written before his suicide that exhorts the king to distance himself from those maneuvering deviously in his court.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Publisher: Amsterdam University PressPrint publication year: 2020