In 1908, rumours began to circulate in New York’s theatrical circles that the variety stage comedian Eddie Foy planned to change his name to Mr Edwin Fitzgerald, because he felt he required a more distinguished moniker before venturing into the legit by undertaking the role of Hamlet. When asked about the rumour, Foy would answer:

Despite the remark that ‘no artist can be sure of success in Shakespearian drama’, Eddie Foy could be sure of success on the variety stage, where he had long enjoyed starring roles across the country as a comedian in musical shows and vaudeville. Whether playing a comic chef (Hotel Topsey Turvey), jailer (The Strollers), or sandman (Piff Paff Pouf ), a travelling hypnotist (Paracelsus Noodle in The Wild Rose), a dog-trainer and would-be earl ( Jim Cheese in The Earl and the Girl), a head gardener (Artie Choke in The Orchid), or Sister Anne in Mr Bluebeard, Jr, Eddie Foy was a godsend to management because his shows made money. And Foy required money since he and his third wife (his first two wives had died) were raising a large family: eight children in all. (Later Foy and his family formed a famously successful vaudeville act, called the Seven Little Foys.) When Eddie Foy played on a vaudeville bill, he was a well-paid headliner.