In the book of Problemata, attributed to Aristotle, the following question is asked (xv. 3): “Why do all men, both barbarians and Hellenes, count up to 10 and not to some other number?” It is suggested, among several answers of great absurdity, that the true reason may be that all men have ten fingers: “using these, then, as symbols of their proper number (viz. 10), they count everything else by this scale.” The writer then adds “Alone among men, a certain tribe of Thracians count up to 4, because, like children, they cannot remember a long sum neither have they any need for a great quantity of anything.”

It is natural to regret that an author who at so early a date was capable of writing this passage, was not induced to ask himself more questions and to collect more facts on the same and similar subjects. Had he done so, he might have anticipated, by some two thousand years, the modern method of research into prehistoric times and might have attempted, with every chance of success, a hundred problems which cannot now be satisfactorily treated. In the fourth century B. c. and for long after, half the Aryan peoples were still barbarous and there must still have survived, even among Greeks and Italians, countless relics of primitive manners, forming a sure tradition of the past. Nearly all these materials, so abundant in Aristotle's day, are irretrievably lost to us and the primeval history of Aryan culture depends now chiefly on the evidence supplied by comparative philology. It is so with the art of calculation.