The ‘just war’ doctrine in the past

The Roman origins

The distinction between ‘just war’ (bellum justum) and ‘unjust war’ (bellum injustum) can be traced back to the jus fetiale. This body of law existed in ancient Rome, from the days of the kings until the late republican era. The fetiales were a college of priests charged with a number of duties, some of which pertained to the inception of war.

Cicero stated that it may be gathered from the code of the fetiales that no war is considered just, unless it is preceded by an official demand for satisfaction or warning, and a formal declaration has been made. It follows that two indispensable conditions of a procedural nature had to be met before the commencement of hostilities. The first requisite was that a demand be addressed to the opponent, insisting on satisfaction for the grievance caused to Rome (such satisfaction taking the form of restitution, withdrawal of forces, etc.), with a fixed time allowed for a proper response. The second condition was that a formal declaration of war had to be issued. The declaration entailed an elaborate ceremony, culminating in a spear being hurled across the Roman frontier into the enemy's territory, and including the recital of ancient legal formulas recorded in detail by Livy.