Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-24T15:59:01.809Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Reframing the Guardianship Dilemma: How the Military’s Dual Disloyalty Options Imperil Dictators

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 March 2022

JACK PAINE Open the ORCID record for JACK PAINE [Opens in a new window]
JACK PAINE*
Affiliation:
University of Rochester, United States
*
Jack Paine, Associate Professor, Department of Political Science, University of Rochester, United States, jackpaine@rochester.edu.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Dictators confront a guardianship dilemma: military agents are needed to defeat mass outsider movements, but these agents can overthrow the ruler from within. In existing theories, rulers prioritize coup-proofing measures unless they anticipate strong outsider threats. Then dictators prioritize military competence. I reframe the guardianship dilemma around the central idea that militaries can choose between dual disloyalty options. In addition to staging a coup, militaries can defect by not fending off popular uprisings or rebellions. Dictators fear competent militaries not primarily because of their coup threat but instead because they often survive intact following a regime transition. Low motivation for competent militaries to save the ruler undermines their rationale of guarding against outsider threats, even if they pose a low coup threat. Consequently, rulers prioritize competence under narrow circumstances. Only radically oriented outsider movements that pose an existential threat to all regime elites induce loyalty from a competent military.

Type
Research Article
Information
American Political Science Review , Volume 116 , Issue 4 , November 2022 , pp. 1425 - 1442
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the American Political Science Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Acemoglu, Daron, Ticchi, Davide, and Vindigni, Andrea. 2010. “Persistence of Civil Wars.” Journal of the European Economic Association 8 (2–3): 664–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bellin, Eva. 2012. “Reconsidering the Robustness of Authoritarianism in the Middle East.” Comparative Politics 44 (2): 127–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Besley, Timothy, and Robinson, James A.. 2010. “Quis Custodiet Ipsos Custodes? Civilian Control over the Military.” Journal of the European Economic Association 8 (2–3): 655–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blaydes, Lisa. 2018. State of Repression: Iraq under Saddam Hussein. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brancati, Dawn. 2016. Democracy Protests: Origins, Features, and Significance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burgess, Stephen. 2014. “From Failed Power Sharing in Rwanda to Successful Top-Down Military Integration.” In New Armies from Old: Merging Competing Military Forces after Civil Wars, ed. Licklider, Roy, 87–102. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.Google Scholar
De Bruin, Erica. 2020. How to Prevent Coups D’État: Counterbalancing and Regime Survival. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Dixon, Jeffrey S., and Sarkees, Meredith Reid. 2015. A Guide to Intra-State Wars: An Examination of Civil, Regional, and Intercommunal Wars, 1816-2014. Washington, DC: CQ Press.Google Scholar
Dragu, Tiberiu, and Lupu, Yonatan. 2018. “Collective Action and Constraints on Repression at the Endgame.” Comparative Political Studies 51 (8): 1042–73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Egorov, Georgy, and Sonin, Konstantin. 2011. “Dictators and their Viziers: Endogenizing the Loyalty-Competence Trade-Off.” Journal of the European Economic Association 9 (5): 903–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Finer, S.E. 1997. The History of Government: Ancient Monarchies and Empires. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Geddes, Barbara. 1999. “What Do We Know About Democratization after Twenty Years?” Annual Review of Political Science 2: 115–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Geddes, Barbara, Wright, Joseph, and Frantz, Erica. 2018. How Dictatorships Work: Power, Personalization, and Collapse. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Greitens, Sheena Chestnut. 2016. Dictators and Their Secret Police: Coercive Institutions and State Violence. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harkness, Kristen A. 2016. “The Ethnic Army and the State.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 60 (4): 587–616.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hassan, Mai. 2020. Regime Threats and State Solutions: Bureaucratic Loyalty and Embeddedness in Kenya. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kirschke, Linda. 2000. “Informal Repression, Zero-Sum Politics, and Late Third Wave Transitions.” Journal of Modern African Studies 38 (3): 383–405.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Levitsky, Steven, and Way, Lucan A.. 2010. Competitive Authoritarianism: Hybrid Regimes after the Cold War. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lorentzen, Peter, Fravel, M. Taylor, and Paine, Jack. 2017. “Qualitative Investigation of Theoretical Models: The Value of Process Tracing.” Journal of Theoretical Politics 29 (3): 467–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lugard, Sir F. D. 1922. The Dual Mandate in British Tropical Africa. Edinburgh: William Blackwood and Sons.Google Scholar
Lyall, Jason. 2020. Divided Armies: Inequality and Battlefield Performance in Modern War. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Marinov, Nikolay, and Goemans, Hein. 2014. “Coups and Democracy.” British Journal of Political Science 44 (4): 799–825.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McMahon, R. Blake, and Slantchev, Branislav L.. 2015. “The Guardianship Dilemma: Regime Security through and from the Armed Forces.” American Political Science Review 109 (2): 297–313.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Meisner, Maurice. 1999. Mao’s China and after: A History of the People’s Republic. New York: Simon and Schuster.Google Scholar
Meng, Anne. 2020. Constraining Dictatorship: From Personalized Rule to Institutionalized Regimes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Meng, Anne, and Paine, Jack. Forthcoming. “Power Sharing and Authoritarian Stability: How Rebel Regimes Solve the Guardianship Dilemma.” American Political Science Review.Google Scholar
Myerson, Roger B. 2008. “The Autocrat’s Credibility Problem and Foundations of the Constitutional State.” American Political Science Review 102 (1): 125–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nalepa, Monika. 2010. Skeletons in the Closet: Transitional Justice in Post-Communist Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nolutshungu, Sam C. 1996. Limits of Anarchy: Intervention and State Formation in Chad. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press.Google Scholar
Paine, Jack. 2021. “The Dictator’s Powersharing Dilemma: Countering Dual Outsider Threats.” American Journal of Political Science 65 (2): 510–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Paine, Jack. 2022. “Replication Data for: Reframing the Guardianship Dilemma: How the Military’s Dual Disloyalty Options Imperil Dictators.” Harvard Dataverse. Dataset. https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/TJK8QV.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Powell, Jonathan M. 2014. “Trading Coups for Civil War: The Strategic Logic of Tolerating Rebellion.” African Security Review 23 (4): 329–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Quinlivan, James T. 1999. “Coup-Proofing: Its Practice and Consequences in the Middle East.” International Security 24 (2): 131–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Riedl, Rachel Beatty, Slater, Dan, Wong, Joseph, and Ziblatt, Daniel. 2020. “Authoritarian-Led Democratization.” Annual Review of Political Science 23: 315–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ritter, Emily Hencken, and Conrad, Courtenay R.. 2016. “Preventing and Responding to Dissent: The Observational Challenges of Explaining Strategic Repression.” American Political Science Review 110 (1): 85–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roessler, Philip. 2016. Ethnic Politics and State Power in Africa: The Logic of the Coup-Civil War Trap. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roessler, Philip, and Ohls, David. 2018. “Self-Enforcing Power Sharing in Weak States.” International Organization 72 (2): 423–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sudduth, Jun Koga. 2017. “Strategic Logic of Elite Purges in Dictatorships.” Comparative Political Studies 50 (13): 1768–1801.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Svolik, Milan W. 2013. “Contracting on Violence: The Moral Hazard in Authoritarian Repression and Military Intervention in Politics.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 57 (5): 765–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Talmadge, Caitlin. 2015. The Dictator’s Army: Battlefield Effectiveness in Authoritarian Regimes. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tyson, Scott A. 2018. “The Agency Problem Underlying Repression.” Journal of Politics 80 (4): 1297–1310.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
van Dam, Nikolaos. 2011. The Struggle for Power in Syria: Politics and Society under Asad and the Ba’th Party. London: I. B. Tauris.Google Scholar
White, Peter B. 2020. “The Perils of Peace: Civil War Peace Agreements and Military Coups.” Journal of Politics 82 (1): 104–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zakharov, Alexei V. 2016. “The Loyalty-Competence Trade-Off in Dictatorships and Outside Options for Subordinates.” Journal of Politics 78 (2): 457–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Supplementary material: Link

Paine Dataset

Dataset

https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/TJK8QV
Link
Supplementary material: PDF

Paine supplementary material

Paine supplementary material

Download Paine supplementary material(PDF)
PDF 252.6 KB
Submit a response

Comments

No Comments have been published for this article.