Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-gb8f7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-26T18:49:22.106Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Protestant Missions, Cuban Nationalism and the Machadato

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 December 2015

Jason M. Yaremko
Jason M. Yaremko*
Affiliation:
University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Before the Spanish-Cuban-American War of 1898, Protestantism and Cuban nationalism coexisted relatively comfortably and even naturally, the function of a Protestant movement under Spanish colonialism that, unlike the rest of Latin America, was run not by North American or English missionaries, but by Cuban ministers. After United States intervention in 1898, U.S. interests were imposed on virtually every sector of Cuban society, including organized Protestantism, influencing Cuba's development for at least the next half-century. Preempted by U.S. intervention, Cuban nationalism, in both its ecclesiastical and secular dimensions, endured and intensified with the deepening of Cubans' dependency on the U.S. Politically, Cuban nationalism was expressed in growing protests and demands for a more genuine independence by abrogating the Platt Amendment and otherwise ending U.S. interventionism. Ecclesiastically, Cubans pushed for a greater role in Protestant church affairs, and toward Cubanization of the Church. Protestant missions thus confronted a rising nationalism within and outside the Church. By 1920, eastern Cuba, the cradle of Cuban independence, became the epicenter of this struggle.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Americas , Volume 56 , Issue 3 , January 2000 , pp. 53 - 75
Copyright
Copyright © Academy of American Franciscan History 2000

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Clymer, Kenton J., Protestant Missionaries in the Philippines, 1898–1916: An Inquiry into the American Colonial Mentality (Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 1986), pp. 114–115.Google Scholar Clymer’s masterful analysis includes the important distinction between the ecclesiastical and political dimensions of nationalism which missionaries confronted in foreign fields. Clymer’s work here has in no small way influenced my own.

2 Ayala, César J., “Social and Economic Aspects of Sugar Production in Cuba, 1880–1930,” Latin American Research Review 30:1 (1995); p. 110;Google Scholar see also Buell, Raymond Leslie, et al., Problems of the New Cuba: Report of the Commission on Cuban Affairs (New York: Foreign Policy Association, Inc., 1935).Google Scholar

3 Ibid.

4 Ibid.

5 Pérez, Louis A. Jr., “La Chambelona: Political Protest, Sugar, and Social Banditry in Cuba, 1914-1917,” Inter-American Economic Affairs 31:4 (Spring 1978), pp. 27–28.Google Scholar

6 Thomas, Hugh, Cuba, the Pursuit of Freedom (New York: Harper & Row, 1971), p. 533.Google Scholar

7 See Pérez, Louis A. Jr., Lords of the Mountain: Social Banditry and Peasant Protest in Cuba, 1878-1918 (Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, 1989).Google Scholar

8 Ramos, Marcos A., Protestantism and Revolution in Cuba (Miami: University of Miami, 1989), p.23.Google Scholar

9 George McDonell to David W. Carter, 14 May 1900; Warren A. Candler to H.B. Someillán, 6 May 1901; Warren A. Candler to H.W. Penny, 15 September 1903, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, Emory Special Collections Department, Robert Woodruff Library, Emory University, Atlanta, Georgia (Hereafter, ESCD).

10 A Suárez, J.M. Hernandez, Á. Alonso to W.R. Lambuth, “Letter of the Cuban Preachers to the Secretary of the Board of Missions,” 1909, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD.

11 B.F Gilbert to Candler, 14 September 1907; Gilbert to Candler, 3 December 1907; Easton Clements to Candler, 4 October 1909; Hubert Baker to Candler, Santiago, 7 October 1909; Clements to Candler, 25 September 1911, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD. Missionaries reacted incredulously to Cuban protests, labelling some Cuban pastors “mercenaries” and suggesting that such reform initiatives were “more dangerous” than “open persecution.”

12 Grose, Howard E., Advance in the Antilles (New York: Eaton and Maine, 1910), pp. 130–131.Google Scholar

13 See American Friends Board of Foreign Missions (AFBFM) Annual Report.

14 See annual reports from Methodist Episcopal Church, South (MECS), Anuario Cubano: Registro oficial de la Conferencia Anual de Cuba de la Iglesia Metodista Episcopal del Sur.

15 See reports from the American Baptist Home Mission Society (ABHMS) Annual Report of the Board, and Actas de la Convención Bautista de Cuba Oriental (CBCO).

16 Ramos, pp. 24–25. Mission schools characteristically attracted much greater numbers of Cuban students than the churches did converts, at times by as much as several hundred percentage points. The principal missions in eastern Cuba accounted for well over 10,000 students by the late 1930s. Mission reports and correspondence strongly suggest that Cuban graduates of these schools, most of whom did not become Protestants, nonetheless lent their support in numerous ways, from financial aid for Protestant buildings to presidential endorsement of Protestant schools and programs. For a more comprehensive discussion of the above, see Yaremko, Jason, “United States Protestant Missions in Eastern Cuba, 1898–1935: Salvation and Conflict in the Cradle of Independence” (Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Manitoba, Manitoba, 1996).Google Scholar

17 Neblett, Sterling A., Methodism’s First Fifty Years in Cuba (Wilmore: Asbury College, 1976), p. 112.Google Scholar

18 Detweiler, Charles S., The Waiting Isles: Baptist Missions in the Caribbean (Philadelphia: Judson Press, 1930), pp. 84 and 88–89.Google Scholar

19 Moseley, H.R., “A Call for Help,” Missions (August 1910), p. 537.Google Scholar

20 Routledge to Detweiler, 13 April 1925, ABHMS Correspondence, Cuba, American Baptist His-torical Society, Valley Forge, Pennsylvania (Hereafter, ABHS).

21 Candler to H.H. White, 11 January 1929, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD.

22 Ibid.

23 Sterling Neblett to Lavens M. Thomas, 24 January 1929, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD.

24 Candler to Hubert W. Baker, 8 June 1906, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD.

25 O.E. Goddard to Easton E. Clements, 29 May 1931; O.K. Hopkins, Sterling Neblett to O.E. God-dard, 22 June 1931, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD.

26 H.B. Bardwell to Candler,. 11 March 1919, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD.

27 Detweiler, , The Waiting Isles, pp. 74–75.Google Scholar

28 Hilty, Hiram, Friends in Cuba (Richmond: Friends United Press, 1977), p. 103.Google Scholar

29 Zenas Martin to Eva Haworth, 17 November 1924; Martin to Haworth, 22 March 1925, Martin and Haworth Papers, Friends Historical Collection, Guilford College, Greensboro, North Carolina (Here-after, FHC).

30 Ibid.

31 Hilty, , Friends in Cuba, p. 100.Google Scholar

32 Ibid., pp. 104–105.

33 Ibid., p. 106.

34 Susan Martin to Eva and Samuel Haworth, 23 January 1926, Martin and Haworth Papers, FHC.

35 Emma P. Martínez to B. Willis Beede, Puerto Padre, 6 July 1930, Wider Ministries of Friends United Meeting Papers, Lilly Library, Earlham College, Richmond, Indiana (Hereafter, WMFUMP).

36 Neblett, , Methodism’s First Fifty Years in Cuba, p. 184.Google Scholar

37 ABHMS Annual Report, 87th Sess., 1919 (New York, 1919), 56; ABHMS Annual Report, 89th Sess., 1921 (New York, 1921), p. 61.

38 ABHMS Annual Report, 93rd Sess., 1926 (New York, 1926), pp. 64–65.

39 ABHMS Annual Report, 94th Sess., 1927 (New York, 1927), pp. 43–44.

40 Clements to Goddard, 27 July 1926, Cuban Conference Correspondence, United Methodist Church Archives, General Commission on Archives and History, Drew University, Madison, New Jersey (Hereafter, UMCA).

41 Ibid.

42 Neblett to Candler, 14 September 1928, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD.

43 Neblett to Candler, 5 July 1928; Neblett to Candler, 14 September 1928; Neblett, “Committee on Nationalism—Cuba to the General Committee on Nationalism, Summary of Answers to the Questionaire,” 3 October 1928, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD.

44 Ibid.

45 Ibid.

46 Neblett to Candler, 5 July 1928, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD.

47 Neblett, Representative of the Committee on Nationalism in Cuba, to the General Committee on Nationalism, report, April 16, 1929, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD.

48 Ibid.

49 Neblett, , Methodism’s First Fifty Years, p. 114.Google Scholar

50 Neblett, Representative of the Committee on Nationalism in Cuba, to the General Committee on Nationalism, 16 April 1929, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD.

51 Ramos, pp. 29–34.

52 Goddard to Hopkins, Neblett, 13 August 1931, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD.

53 Maurice Daily to Alfred W. Wasson, 31 October 1939, Cuban Conference Correspondence, UMCA.

54 Emma P. Martínez to B. Willis Beede, Puerto Padre, 15 April 1928, WMFUMP.

55 Martínez to Beede, Puerto Padre, 23 November 1930; Martínez to Beede, Puerto Padre, 24 December 1930; Martínez to Beede, Puerto Padre, 31 August 1931, WMFUMP.

56 Emma P. Martínez to B. Willis Beede, Puerto Padre, 23 November 1930, FHC.

57 Evans to W.G. Gram, Camagüey, 22 May 1929, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD.

58 A. Suárez, J.M. Hernandez, A. Alonso, to W.R. Lambuch, “Letter of the Cuban Preachers,” 2 October 1909, ESCD; Robert Routledge to Charles S. Detweiler, 17 October 1924, ABHMS Correspon-dence, Cuba, ABHS.

59 Actas de la CBCO, 1932, pp. 103–106, 119, 125 and 131; Actas de la CBCO, 1935, p. 112; Rout-ledge to Detweiler, Cristo, 18 April 1938, ABHS.

60 Davis, J. Merle, The Cuban Church in a Sugar Economy (New York: International Missionary Council, 1942), pp. 77–78.Google Scholar

61 Ibid.

62 Ibid.

63 Henry Cox to Merle L. Davis, 7 April 1939, WMFUMP.

64 Ibid.

65 Parallels between the Cuban and Philippine mission experiences at some levels prove striking. See Clymer, Protestant Missionaries in the Philippines, 1898–1916.

66 Liss, Sheldon, Roots of Revolution: Radical Thought in Cuba (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1987), pp. 62–64;Google Scholar Pérez, Louis A. Jr., Cuba: Between Reform and Revolution, 2nd Ed. (New York: Oxford University Press, 1995), pp. 236 and 241–244.Google Scholar

67 Pérez, , Cuba: Between Reform and Revolution, p. 245.Google Scholar

68 Carr, Barry, “Mill Occupations and Soviets: The Mobilisation of Sugar Workers in Cuba, 1917–1933,” Journal of Latin American Studies 28 (1996), pp. 130–131.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

69 Zenas Martin to Eva and Samuel Haworth, 19 February 1917; Zenas Martin to Eva and Samuel Haworth, 8 April 1917; Zenas Martin to Eva and Samuel Haworth, 5 May 1917; Martin and Haworth Family Papers, FHC.

70 Zenas Martin to Eva and Samuel Haworth, 5 May 1917, FHC.

71 Benjamin, Jules R., The United States and the Origins of the Cuban Revolution: Empire of Liberty in an Age of National Liberation (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1990), p. 85.Google Scholar

72 Ibid.; American Friends Board of Foreign Missions (AFBFM) Annual Report, 1932 (Richmond, 1932), 23–24.

73 Benjamin, , The United States and the Origins of the Cuban Revolution, p. 84–85.Google Scholar

74 Clements to Goddard, 27 July 1926, Cuba Conference Correspondence, UMCA.

75 ABHMS Annual Report, 94th Sess., 1927 (New York, 1927), p. 44; ABHMS Annual Report, 97th Sess., 1930 (New York, 1930), pp. 46–l69.

76 Letter (n.a.) to E.H. Rawlings, 10 August 1925; Neblett to Wasson, 20 May 1936; “Reverend and Mrs. Daily are now serving in the Eastern District of Cuba,” Methodist Episcopal Church, South (MECS) newsletter, 1 March 1940, Cuban Conference Correspondence, UMCA.

77 ABHMS Annual Report, 97th Sess., 1930 (New York), p. 69–70.

78 ABHMS Annual Report, 1940, (New York, 1940), p. 49.

79 AFBFM Annual Report, 1932 (Richmond, 1932), pp. 23–24.

80 Zenas Martin to Susan Martin, 11 July 1902, Martin and Haworth Family Papers, FHC; Hilty, , Friends, p. 10.Google Scholar

81 Martin to Samuel and Eva Haworth, 1 May 1921; Zenas Martin, “Christmas in a Canefield,” n.d.; Martin to Eva and Samuel Haworth, February 1927; Martin to Eva and Samuel Haworth, 25 May 1926; Martin to Eva and Samuel Haworth, 30 March 1930, Martin and Haworth Family Papers, FHC.

82 Martin to Samuel Haworth, 23 February 1925; Martin to Eva and Samuel Haworth, 29 October 1925, Martin and Haworth Family Papers, FHC.

83 Susan Martin to Zenas Martin, 17 July 1907, Martin and Haworth Family Papers, FHC.

85 “The Memory Books of Sylvester and May Mather Jones,” 1900–1960, p. 263, Sylvester and May Mather Jones Papers, FHC.

86 Benjamin, , The United States and the Origins of the Cuban Revolution, p. 77.Google Scholar

87 Ibid., pp. 80–82.

88 Susan Martin to Eva and Samuel Haworth, 13 May 1917; Martin to Eva Haworth, 16 July 1917, Martin and Haworth Family Papers, FHC.

89 ABHMS Annual Report, 1928 (New York, 1928), pp. 39 and 56; ABHMS Annual Report, 1930 (New York, 1930), pp. 45–46; MECS , Anuario Cubano, 1927, Registro oficial de la Conferencia Anual de Cuba de la Iglesia Metodista Episcopal del Sur (AC) (Habana, 1927), pp. 62–63 and 68; MECS, AC, 1931 (Habana, 1931), p. 32; AFBFM Annual Report, 1931, pp. 23–27.

90 “El General Machado oyo misa en el pueblo del Cobre,” El Mensajero 7 (July, 1926), p. 15; “Mensajeros de Santiago de Cuba,” El Mensajero 8 (August, 1926), p. 15.

91 Neblett, , Methodism’s First Fifty Years, p. 147.Google Scholar

92 Detweiler, , Charles, S., “La etica Cristiana: El Cristiano y el gobierno,” El Mensajero 10 (December, 1929), pp. 15–16.Google Scholar

93 Neblett, , Methodism’s First Fifty Years, p. 170.Google Scholar

94 Detweiler, , “La etica Cristiana: El Cristiano y el gobierno,” pp. 15–16.Google Scholar

95 ABHMS Annual Report, 99th. Sess., 1932 (New York, 1932), p. 43.

96 MECS, AC, 1918 (Habana, 1918), 30–31; MECS, AC, 1936 (Habana, 1936), pp. 22–23.

97 AFBFM Annual Report, 1935 (Richmond, 1935), p. 12.

98 Goddard to Candler, 27 April 1928, Warren Aiken Candler Papers, ESCD.

99 See chapters 5 and 6, in Jason M. Yaremko, “United States Protestant Missions in Eastern Cuba, 1898–1935.”

100 Santana, Alfredo, “El esperanza de Cuba,” El Mensajero 11 (June 1924), p. 8; Actas de la Convención Bautista de Cuba Oriental (CBCO), Estadisticas Anuales, 1924, pp. 94–97; Actas de la CBCO,1925, p. 155.Google Scholar

101 Actas de la CBCO, 1925, 155; Actas de la CBCO, 1928, pp. 75–82.

102 Ibid.

103 Neblett, , Methodism’s First Fifty Years, p. 170.Google Scholar