Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-24T22:39:55.197Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Architecture of St Davids Cathedral: Chronology, Catastrophe and Design

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 April 2011

Roger Stalley
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

This article reassesses the design of the nave of St Davids Cathedral in the light of modern scholarship, arguing that the cathedral has been a victim of an overly historicist approach to architectural writing. New documentary evidence is presented, including information about the existence of two churches on the site. Anomalies in the west bay are defined and some of the explanations offered by Lovegrove (1922, 1926) are rejected. Following an analysis of the design, the background of the scheme is firmly located in an English west-country environment and suggestions of French influence are dismissed. Although a vault may have been envisaged when the nave was first begun, it is unlikely that a stone vault was ever erected. Nonetheless, the design of the nave emerges as a more significant and creative piece of architecture than is generally realized.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 82 , September 2002 , pp. 13 - 32
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 2002

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Aubert, M 1947. L'Architecture Cistercienne en France, 2 vols, ParisGoogle Scholar
Bideault, M and Lautier, C 1987. Ile de France Gothique: Les églises de la vallée de l'Oise at du Beauvaisis, ParisGoogle Scholar
Bony, J 1949. ‘French influences on the origin of English Gothic architecture’, J Warburg Courtauld Inst., 12, 1–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bony, J 1965. ‘Origines des piles anglaises à futs en délit’, in Gedankschrift Ernst Gall (eds Kuhn, M and Grodecki, L), 95–122, MunichGoogle Scholar
Bony, J 1979. The English Decorated Style, LondonGoogle Scholar
Brakspear, H 1931. ‘A west country school of masons’, Archaeologia, 81, 1–18CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brewer, J S (ed) 1861. Giraldi Cambrensis Opera, Rolls Series, LondonGoogle Scholar
Davies, R R 1987. Conquest, Coexistence and Change, Wales 1063–1415, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Draper, P 1999. ‘St David's Cathedral: provincial or metropolitan?’, in Pierre, lumière, couleur. Ètudes d'histoire de l'art du Moyen Âge en l'honneur d'Anne Prache (eds Joubert, F and Sandron, D), 103–16, ParisGoogle Scholar
Engel, U 1998. ‘Two-storeyed elevations: the choir of Southwell Minster and the west country’, in Southwell and Nottinghamshire, Medieval Art, Architecture and Industry (ed Alexander, J S), Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans, 21, 33–43Google Scholar
Evans, S and Worsley 1981. Eglwys Gadeiriol Tyddewi/St Davids Cathedral, 1181–1981, St DavidsGoogle Scholar
Evans, W 1986. ‘St David's Cathedral: the forgotten centuries’, J Welsh Eccles Hist., 3, 73–92Google Scholar
Halsey, R 1988. ‘The 12th-century church of St Frideswide's Priory’, Oxoniensia., 53, 115–67Google Scholar
Hoey, L 1986. ‘Pier alternation in Early English Gothic architecture’, J Brit Archaeol Ass, 139, 45–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hoey, L 1989. ‘Pier form and vertical wall articulation in English Romanesque architecture’, J Soc Architect Historians., 48, 258–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar
James, H 1996–1997. ‘The cult of St David in the middle ages’, J Pembrokeshire Hist Soc., 7, 5–25Google Scholar
Jones, W B and Freeman, E E 1852–1856. The History and Antiquities of Saint David's, London (reprinted in facsimile, Haverford-west, 1998)Google Scholar
Kidson, P 1967. ‘Church and Hospital of St Cross’, Archaeol J., 123, 215–16Google Scholar
Kightly, C 1988. A Mirror of Medieval Wales. Gerald of Wales and his Journey of 1188, CardiffGoogle Scholar
Lehmann-Brockhaus, O 1955. Lateinische Schriftquellen zur Kunst in England, Wales und Schottland, vom Jahre 901 bis zum Jahre 1307, 5 vols, MunichGoogle Scholar
Lovegrove, E W 1922. ‘St Davids Cathedral’, Archaeol Cambrensis., 77, 360–82Google Scholar
Lovegrove, E W 1926. ‘The cathedral church of St Davids’, Archaeol J., 83, 255–83CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lowe, B J and Mason, E J 1987. ‘Keynsham Abbey: excavations 1961–1985’, Somerset Archaeol Natur Hist., 131, 81–156Google Scholar
Malone, C M 1973. West English Gothic architecture 1175–1250’. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of California, BerkeleyGoogle Scholar
Newman, J 1995. The Buildings of Wales: Glamorgan, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Orrin, G R 1988. Medieval Churches of the Vale of Glamorgan, CowbridgeGoogle Scholar
Pevsner, N and Lloyd, D 1967. The Buildings of England: Hampshire and the Isle of Wight, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Robinson, D M and Platt, C 1998. Strata Florida Abbey, Talley Abbey, Cadw, CardiffGoogle Scholar
Robinson, J A 1928. ‘Documentary evidence relating to the building of the cathedral church of Wells (c 1186–1242)’, Archaeol J., 85, 1–17CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sampson, J 1998. Wells Cathedral West Front, StroudGoogle Scholar
Scott, A B and Martin, F X (eds) 1978. Expugnatio Hibernica, The Conquest of Ireland by Giraldus Cambrensis, DublinGoogle Scholar
Sharpe, E nd. The Ornamentation of the Transition Period of British Architecture, LondonGoogle Scholar
Stalley, R 1979, ‘The medieval sculpture of Christ Church Cathedral, Dublin’, Archaeologia, 106, 107–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stalley, R 1984. ‘Irish Gothic and English fashion’, in The English in Medieval Ireland (ed Lydon, J), 65–86, DublinGoogle Scholar
Stalley, R 1987. The Cistercian Monasteries of Ireland, London and New YorkGoogle Scholar
Stalley, R 2000 The construction of the medieval cathedral, c 1030–1250’, in Christ Church Cathedral, Dublin, A History (ed Milne, K), 53–74, DublinGoogle Scholar
Thorpe, L (ed) 1978. The Journey through Wales and The Description of Wales, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Thurlby, M and Harrison, S 1997. ‘An architectural history’, in A Definitive History of Dore Abbey (eds Shoesmith, R and Richardson, R), 45–62Google Scholar
Thurlby, M and Hearn, M 1997. ‘Previously undetected wooden ribbed vaults in medieval Britain’, J Brit Archaeol Ass., 150, 48–58Google Scholar
Thurlby, M and Kusaba, Y 1991. ‘The nave of Saint Andrew at Steyning: a study of variety in design in twelfth-century architecture in Britain’, Gesta., 30 (2), 163–75CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Trollope, E 1873. ‘The architectural remains of Louth Park Abbey’, Associated Architect Societies Reports and Papers., 12, 22–5Google Scholar
Turvey, R 1996–1999. 'The death and burial of an excommunicate prince: The Lord Rhys and the cathedral church of St Davids, J Pembrokeshire Hist Soc, 7 (1996–7), 26–49, and 8 (1998–9), 5–26Google Scholar
Vaughan, R 1986. Chronicles of Matthew Paris, GloucesterGoogle Scholar
Williams, J (ed) 1860. Annales Cambriae, Rolls Series, LondonGoogle Scholar
Wilson, C 1978. ‘he sources of the late twelfth-century work at Worcester Cathedral’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Worcester Cathedral (ed Borg, A), Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans, 1, 80–90Google Scholar
Wilson, C 1985. ‘Abbot Serlo's church at Gloucester, 1089–1100: its place in Romanesque architecture’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Gloucester and Tewkesbury (eds Heslop, T and Sekules, V), Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans, 7, 52–83Google Scholar
Wilson, C 1986. ‘The Cistercians as ‘missionaries of Gothic’, in Cistercian Art and Architecture in the British Isles (eds Norton, C and Park, D), 86–116, CambridgeGoogle Scholar