Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T06:08:25.513Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

DEATH BY COMBAT AT THE DAWN OF THE BRONZE AGE? PROFILING THE DAGGER-ACCOMPANIED BURIAL FROM RACTON, WEST SUSSEX

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 July 2017

Stuart Needham ,
James Kenny ,
Garrard Cole ,
Janet Montgomery ,
Mandy Jay ,
Mary Davis  and
Peter Marshall
Stuart Needham
Affiliation:
Stuart Needham, Langton Fold, North Lane, South Harting, West Sussex GU31 5NW, UK. Email: sbowman1@waitrose.com
James Kenny
Affiliation:
James Kenny, Archaeology Officer, Chichester District Council, East Pallant House, 1 East Pallant, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 1TY, UK. Email: jkenny@chichester.gov.uk
Garrard Cole
Affiliation:
Garrard Cole, UCL Institute of Archaeology, 31-4 Gordon Square, London WC1H 0PY, UK. Email: tcrngco@ucl.ac.uk
Janet Montgomery
Affiliation:
Janet Montgomery, Department of Archaeology, University of Durham, Durham DH1 3LE, UK. Email: janet.montgomery@durham.ac.uk
Mandy Jay
Affiliation:
Mandy Jay, Department of Archaeology, University of Durham, Durham DH1 3LE, UK. Email: mandy.jay@durham.ac.uk
Mary Davis
Affiliation:
Mary Davis, 61 Talbot Street, Cardiff CF11 9BX. Email: mary.davis77@ntlworld.com
Peter Marshall
Affiliation:
Peter Marshall, Chronologies, 25 Onslow Road, Sheffield S11 7AF, UK. Email: pete@chronologies.co.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

A previously unresearched Early Bronze Age dagger-grave found in 1989 at Racton, West Sussex, is profiled here through a range of studies. The dagger, the only grave accompaniment, is of the ‘transitional’ Ferry Fryston type, this example being of bronze rather than copper. Bayesian analysis of relevant radiocarbon dates is used to refine the chronology of the earliest bronze in Britain. While the Ferry Fryston type was current in the earlier half of the twenty-second century bc, the first butt-riveted bronze daggers did not emerge until the second half. The Racton dagger is also distinguished by its elaborate rivet-studded hilt, an insular innovation with few parallels.

The excavated skeleton was that of a senior male, buried according to the appropriate rites of the time. Isotopic profiling shows an animal-protein rich diet that is typical for the period, but also the likelihood that he was brought up in a region of older silicate sedimentary rocks well to the west or north west of Racton. He had suffered injury at or close to the time of death; a slice through the distal end of his left humerus would have been caused by a fine-edged blade, probably a dagger. Death as a result of combat-contested leadership is explored in the light of other injuries documented among Early Bronze Age burials. Codified elite-level combat could help to explain the apparent incongruity between the limited efficacy of early dagger forms and their evident weapon-status.

Type
Papers
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 97 , September 2017 , pp. 65 - 117
Copyright
© The Society of Antiquaries of London 2017 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Allen, M J, Gardiner, J and Sheridan, A (eds) 2012. Is there a British Chalcolithic: people, place and polity in the later third millennium, Prehistoric Society Research Paper 4, Oxbow, Oxford Google Scholar
Annable, F K and Simpson, D D A 1964. Guide Catalogue of the Neolithic and Bronze Age Collections in Devizes Museum, Wiltshire Archaeological and Natural History Society, Devizes Google Scholar
Ashbee, P 1957. ‘The great barrow at Bishop’s Waltham, Hampshire’, Proc Prehist Soc, 23, 137–166 Google Scholar
Baker, L, Sheridan, J A and Cowie, T G 2003. ‘An Early Bronze Age “dagger grave” from Rameldry Farm, near Kingskettle, Fife’, Proc Soc Antiq Scot, 133, 85–123 Google Scholar
Barclay, A and Halpin, C 1999. Excavations at Barrow Hills, Radley, Oxfordshire. Vol I: the Neolithic and Bronze Age monument complex, (Oxford University Committee for Archaeology, Thames Valley Landscapes, Vol 11, Oxbow, Oxford Google Scholar
Bell, D 2014. ‘A radiocarbon date for an Irish Bronze Age halberd’, PAST, 76, 15–16 Google Scholar
Beyneix, A 2012. ‘Neolithic violence in France: an overview’, in R Schulting and L Fibiger (eds), Sticks, Stone and Broken Bones: Neolithic violence in a European perspective, 207–222, Oxford University Press, Oxford CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boston, C 2007. ‘The human remains’, in Brown et al, 311–325 Google Scholar
Boyle, A and Harman, M 1999. ‘The human remains’, in Barclay and Halpin 1999, 171–183 Google Scholar
Bray, P 2012. ‘Before 29Cu became copper: tracing the recognition and invention of metalleity in Britain and Ireland during the third millennium BC’, in Allen et al 2012, 56–70 Google Scholar
Brettell, R, Evans, J, Marzinzik, S, Lamb, A and Montgomery, J 2012. ‘Impious easterners: can oxygen and strontium isotopes serve as indicators of provenance in early medieval European cemetery populations?’, Eur J Archaeol, 15, 117–145 Google Scholar
Brown, F, Howard-Davis, C, Brennand, M, Boyle, A, Evans, T, O’Connor, S, Spence, A, Heawood, R and Lupton, A 2007. The Archaeology of the A1 (M) Darrington to Dishforth DBFO Road Scheme, Lancaster Imprints (Oxford Archaeology North) 12, Lancaster Google Scholar
Brudevold, F and Söremark, R 1967. ‘Chemistry of the mineral phase of enamel’, in A E W Miles (ed), Structural and Chemical Organization of Teeth, vol 2, 247–278, Academic Press, London Google Scholar
Burrow, S 2012. ‘A date with the Chalcolithic in Wales: a review of radiocarbon measurements for 2450–2100 cal bc’, in Allen et al 2012, 172–192 Google Scholar
Butler, C 1991. ‘The excavation of a Beaker bowl barrow at Pyecombe, West Sussex’, Sussex Archaeol Coll, 129, 1–28 Google Scholar
Case, H J 1966. ‘Were Beaker people the first metallurgists in Ireland?’ Palaeohistoria, 12, 141–177 Google Scholar
Chenery, C A and Evans, J A 2011. ‘A summary of the strontium and oxygen isotope evidence for the origins of Bell Beaker individuals found near Stonehenge’, in Fitzpatrick 2011, 185–190 Google Scholar
Chenery, C A, Pashley, V, Lamb, A L, Sloane, H J and Evans, J A 2012. ‘The oxygen isotope relationship between the phosphate and structural carbonate fractions of human bioapatite’, Rapid Commun Mass Sp, 26, 309–319 Google Scholar
Clarke, D L 1970. Beaker Pottery of Britain and Ireland, 2 vols, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Google Scholar
Corfield, M 2012. ‘The decoration of Bronze Age dagger handles with gold studs’, in J R Trigg (ed) Of Things Gone but not Forgotten: essays in archaeology for Joan Taylor, 75–93, BAR Int Ser 2434, Oxford Google Scholar
Cunnington, E 1857. ‘Account of a barrow on Roundway Hill near Devizes, opened in April 1855’, Wiltshire Archaeol Natur Hist Mag, 3, 185–188 Google Scholar
Darling, W G, Bath, A H and Talbot, J C 2003. ‘The O and H stable isotopic composition of fresh waters in the British Isles. 2: surface waters and groundwater’, Hydrolog Earth Syst Sc, 7 (2),183–195 Google Scholar
Daux, V, Lécuyer, C, Héran, M-A, Amiot, R, Simon, L, Fourel, F, Martineau, F, Lynnerup, N, Reychler, H and Escarguel, G 2008. ‘Oxygen isotope fractionation between human phosphate and water revisited’, J Hum Evol, 55 (6),1138–1147 Google Scholar
Duday, H 2009. The Archaeology of the Dead: lectures in archaeothanatology, Oxbow, Oxford Google Scholar
Elliott, T A and Grime, G W 1993. ‘Examining the diagenetic alteration of human bone material from a range of archaeological burial sites using nuclear microscopy’, Nucl Instrum Meth B, 77, 537–547 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Evans, J A and Chenery, C A 2011. ‘Isotope studies’, in Fitzpatrick 2011, 32 Google Scholar
Evans, J A, Chenery, C A and Montgomery, J 2012. ‘A summary of strontium and oxygen isotope variation in archaeological tooth enamel excavated from Britain’, J Anal Atom Spectrom, 27, 754–764 Google Scholar
Evans, J G, Atkinson, R J C, O’Connor, T and Green, H S 1983. ‘Stonehenge: the environment in the Late Neolithic and the Early Bronze Age and a Beaker-Age burial’, Wiltshire Archaeol Natur Hist Mag, 78, 7–30 Google Scholar
Fahy, E M 1954. ‘Bronze Age cemetery at Ballyenahan North, Co. Cork’, J Cork Hist Archaeol Soc, 59, 42–49 Google Scholar
Fitzpatrick, A P 2011. The Amesbury Archer and the Boscombe Bowmen: Bell Beaker burials on Boscombe Down, Amesbury, Wiltshire, Great Britain. Excavations at Boscombe Down, Vol I, Wessex Archaeology Report 27, Salisbury Google Scholar
Fox, C and Grimes, W F 1928. ‘Corston Beacon: an Early Bronze Age cairn in south Pembrokeshire’, Archaeol Cambr, 83, 137–174 Google Scholar
Gardiner, J, Allen, M J, Powell, A, Harding, P, Lawson, A, Loader, E, McKinley, J, Sheridan, A and Stevens, C 2007. ‘A matter of life or death: Late Neolithic, Beaker and Early Bronze Age settlement and cemeteries at Thomas Hardye School, Dorchester’, Proc Dorset Natur Hist Archaeol Soc, 128, 17–52 Google Scholar
Garwood, P 2003. ‘Round barrows and funerary traditions in Late Neolithic and Bronze Age Sussex’, in D Rudling (ed), Archaeology of Sussex to AD 2000, 47–68, University of Sussex, Heritage Publications, Brighton Google Scholar
Gerloff, S 1975. The Early Bronze Age Daggers in Great Britain, and a reconsideration of the Wessex Culture, Prähistorische Bronzefunde, VI/2, Munich Google Scholar
Gerloff, S 2004. ‘The dagger from grave 4013/12’, in Lambrick and Allen 2004, 82–86 Google Scholar
Green, C and Rollo-Smith, S 1984. ‘The excavation of eighteen round barrows near Shrewton, Wiltshire’, Proc Prehist Soc, 50, 255–318 Google Scholar
Greenwell, W and Rolleston, G 1877. British Barrows: a record of the examination of sepulchral mounds in various parts of England, Clarendon Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Guilaine, J and Zammit, J 2005. The Origins of War, Blackwell, Oxford Google Scholar
Hadman, J and Coombs, D 1973. ‘An Early Bronze Age burial at Perio’, Durobrivae, 1, 24–26 Google Scholar
Hancock, R G V, Grynpas, M D and Pritzker, K P H 1989. ‘The abuse of bone analyses for archaeological dietary studies’, Archaeometry, 31 (2),169–179 Google Scholar
Harbison, P 1969. The Daggers and the Halberds of the Early Bronze Age in Ireland, Prähistorische Bronzefunde, VI/1, Munich Google Scholar
Harman, M 2004. ‘The human remains’, in Lambrick and Allen 2004, 457–463 Google Scholar
Hawley, W 1909–10. ‘Note of barrows in South Wilts’, Wiltshire Archaeol Natur Hist Mag, 36, 615–628 Google Scholar
Henderson, D 2003. ‘The human bone’, in Baker et al 2003, 89 Google Scholar
Henshall, A S 1963–4. ‘A dagger grave and other cist burials at Ashgrove, Methilhill, Fife’, Proc Soc Antiq Scot, 97, 166–179 Google Scholar
Henshall, A S 1968. ‘Scottish dagger graves’, in J M Coles and D D A Simpson (eds), Studies in Ancient Europe: essays presented to Stuart Piggott, 173–195, Leicester University Press, Leicester Google Scholar
Hoare, R C 1812. The Ancient History of South Wiltshire, William Miller, London Google Scholar
Jay, M, Parker Pearson, M, Richards, M P, Nehlich, O, Montgomery, J, Chamberlain, A and Sheridan, A 2012. ‘The Beaker People Project: an interim report on the progress of the isotopic analysis of the organic skeletal material’, in Allen et al 2012, 226–236 Google Scholar
Kellner, C M and Schoeninger, M J 2007. ‘A simple carbon isotope model for reconstructing prehistoric human diet’, Am J Phys Anthropol, 133, 1112–1127 Google Scholar
Kenny, J 1989. ‘Westbourne: Racton Park Farm’, Archaeol Chichester District, for 1989, 42–43 Google Scholar
Kinnes, I A 1985. Beaker and Early Bronze Age Grave Groups, British Bronze Age Metalwork, Associated Finds Series, A7–16, British Museum Publications, London Google Scholar
Kinnes, I A 1994. Beaker and Early Bronze Age Grave Groups, British Bronze Age Metalwork, Associated Finds Series, A17–A30, British Museum Press, London Google Scholar
Kinnes, I A and Longworth, I H 1985. Catalogue of the Excavated Prehistoric and Romano-British Material in the Greenwell Collection, British Museum Publications, London Google Scholar
Kirk, W and McKenzie, J 1953–5. ‘Three Bronze Age cist burials in NE Scotland’, Proc Soc Antiq Scot, 88, 1–14 Google Scholar
Knüsel, C J, Wastling, V, Ogden, A R and Lynnerup, N 2013. ‘The physical analysis of Gristhorpe Man: a Bronze Age osteobiography’, in Melton et al 2013, 96–123 Google Scholar
Lambrick, G and Allen, T 2004. Gravelly Guy, Stanton Harcourt: the development of a prehistoric and Romano-British community, Thames Valley Landscapes Monograph 21, Oxford Archaeology, Oxford Google Scholar
Leeds, E T 1938. ‘Beakers of the Upper Thames district’, Oxoniensia, 3, 7–30 Google Scholar
Martin, E, Pendleton, C and Plouvier, J 1993. ‘Archaeology in Suffolk 1992’, Proc Suffolk Inst Archaeol Hist, 38, 79–101 Google Scholar
McKinley, J I 2011. ‘Human remains’, in Fitzpatrick 2011, 77–87 Google Scholar
Mercer, R 2006. ‘By other means? The development of warfare in the British Isles 3000–500 BC’, J Conflict Archaeol, 2, 119–151 Google Scholar
Melton, N D, Montgomery, J and Knüsel, CJ (eds) 2013. Gristhorpe Man: a life and death in the Bronze Age, Oxbow, Oxford Google Scholar
Millard, A R, Roberts, C and Hughes, S S 2005. ‘Isotopic evidence for migration in Medieval England: the potential for tracking the introduction of disease’, Soc Biol & Hum Aff, 70, 15–16 Google Scholar
Mortimer, J R 1905. Forty Years’ Researches in British and Saxon Burial Mounds of East Yorkshire, Brown & Sons, London Google Scholar
Needham, S P 1996. ‘Chronology and periodisation in the British Bronze Age’, in K Randsborg (ed), Absolute Chronology: archaeological Europe 2500–500 BC, 121–140, Acta Archaeologica 67, Munksgaard, Copenhagen Google Scholar
Needham, S P 2002. ‘Analytical implications for Beaker metallurgy in north-west Europe’, in M Bartelheim, E Pernicka and R Krause (eds), Die Anfänge der Metallurgie in der Alten Welt, 99–133, Forschungen zur Archäometrie und Altertumswissenschaf 1, Freiberg Google Scholar
Needham, S P 2004. ‘Migdale-Marnoch: sunburst of Scottish metallurgy’, in I A Shepherd and G J Barclay (eds), Scotland in Ancient Europe: the Neolithic and Early Bronze Age of Scotland in their European context, 217–245, Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, Edinburgh Google Scholar
Needham, S 2007. ‘The dagger blade and hilt furnishings from Site D (Ferry Fryston), burial 2245’, in Brown et al 2007, 279–289 Google Scholar
Needham, S 2012. ‘Case and place for the British Chalcolithic’, in Allen et al 2012, 1–26 Google Scholar
Needham, S 2013. ‘Low-flanged Early Bronze Age axe’, in S Willis (ed), The Roman Roadside Settlement and Multi-Period Ritual Complex at Nettleton and Rothwell, Linconshire, Volume 1, 162–167, University of Kent, Canterbury Google Scholar
Needham, S 2015a. ‘A revised classification and chronology for daggers and knives’, in Woodward and Hunter 2015, appendix I (CD)Google Scholar
Needham, S 2015b. ‘Items of personal adornment II: gold and the regalia from Bush Barrow’, in Woodward and Hunter 2015, 209–260 Google Scholar
Needham, S 2015c. ‘Typo-chronology [of pommels]’, in Woodward and Hunter 2015, 45–46 Google Scholar
Needham, S P, Lawson, A J and Green, H S 1985. Early Bronze Age Hoards, British Bronze Age Metalwork, Associated Finds Series A1–6, British Museum Publications, London Google Scholar
Needham, S P, Parfitt, K and Varndell, G (eds) 2006. The Ringlemere Cup: precious cups and the beginning of the Channel Bronze Age, British Museum Research Publication 163, London Google Scholar
Needham, S, Lawson, A J and Woodward, A 2010. ‘A noble group of barrows: Bush Barrow and the Normanton Down Early Bronze Age cemetery two centuries on’, Antiq J, 90, 1–39 Google Scholar
Needham, S, Davis, M, Gwilt, A, Lodwick, M, Parkes, P and Reavill, P 2015. ‘A hafted halberd excavated at Trecastell, Powys: from undercurrent to uptake – the emergence and contextualisation of halberds in Wales and north-west Europe’, Proc Prehist Soc, 81, 1–41 Google Scholar
Newall, R S 1930–2. ‘Barrow 85 Amesbury (Goddard’s list)’, Wiltshire Archaeol Natur Hist Mag, 45, 432–458 Google Scholar
Northover, J P 1982. ‘The exploration of the long-distance movement of bronze in Bronze and Early Iron Age Europe’, Bull London Inst Archaeol, 19, 45–72 Google Scholar
Northover, P 2004. ‘The Early Bronze Age metalwork’, in Lambrick and Allen 2004, 88–90 Google Scholar
O’Brien, W 2004. Ross Island: mining, metal and society in Early Ireland, Bronze Age Studies 6, National University of Ireland, Galway Google Scholar
Pare, C 2000. ‘Bronze and the Bronze Age’, in C F E Pare (ed), Metals Make the World go Round: the supply and circulation of metals in Europe, 1–38, Oxbow, Oxford Google Scholar
Parker Pearson, M, Sheridan, A and Needham, S 2013. ‘Bronze Age tree-trunk coffin graves in Britain’, in Melton et al 2013, 29–66 Google Scholar
Penhallurick, R D 1986. Tin in Antiquity, The Institute of Metals, London Google Scholar
Piggott, S 1963. ‘Abercromby and after: the Beaker cultures of Britain re-examined’, in I L Foster and L Alcock (eds), Culture and Environment: essays in honour of Sir Cyril Fox, 53–91, Routledge, London Google Scholar
Pollard, A M, Pellegrini, M and Lee-Thorp, J A 2011. ‘Technical note: some observations on the conversion of dental enamel d18Op values to d18Ow to determine human mobility’, Am J Phys Anthropol, 145 (3),499–504 CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Rohl, B and Needham, S P 1998. The Circulation of Metal in the British Bronze Age: the application of lead isotope analysis, Occasional Paper 102, British Museum, London Google Scholar
Rynne, E 1972. ‘Tanged dagger from Derrynamanagh, Co. Galway’, J Roy Soc Antiq Ireland, 102, 240–243 Google Scholar
Sanderson, E M 1991. ‘The inhumation’, in Butler 1991, 18–20 Google Scholar
Schmidt, P K and Burgess, C B 1981. The Axes of Scotland and Northern England, Prähistorische Bronzefunde IX/7, Munich Google Scholar
Sheridan, A and Northover, P 1993. ‘A Beaker period copper dagger from the Sillees River near Ross Lough, Co. Fermanagh’, Ulster J Archaeol, 56, 61–69 Google Scholar
Smith, I F 1991. ‘Round barrows Wilsford cum Lake G51–G54: excavations by Ernest Greenfield in 1958’, Wiltshire Archaeol Natur Hist Mag, 84, 11–39 Google Scholar
Standish, C D, Dhuime, B, Hawkesworth, C J and Pike, A W G 2014. ‘New insights into the source of Irish Chalcolithic and Early Bronze Age gold through lead isotope analysis’, in H Meller, R Risch and E Pernicka (eds), Metalle der Macht: Frühes Godl und Silber, 209–222, Tagungen des Landesmuseums für Vorgeschichte 11, Halle (Saale) Google Scholar
Stirland, A 1990. ‘Human remains’, in A D Russel, ‘Two Beaker burials from Chilbolton, Hampshire’, Proc Prehist Soc, 56, 153–172 Google Scholar
Stockhammer, P W, Massy, K, Knipper, C, Friedrich, R, Kromer, B, Lindauer, S, Radosavljević, J, Wittenborn, F and Krause, J 2015. ‘Rewriting the central European Early Bronze Age chronology: evidence from large-scale radiocarbon dating’, PLoS ONE 10 (10): e0139705 doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0139705 Google Scholar
Thorne, A 2015. ‘Secrets of the high woods: airborne laser scanning in the South Downs National Park’, Sussex Past and Present, December, 4–5 Google Scholar
Thorpe, I J N 2006. ‘Fighting and feuding in Neolithic and Bronze Age Britain and Ireland’, in T Otto, H Thrane and H Vandkilde (eds), Warfare and Society: archaeological and social anthropological perspectives, 141–165, Aarhus University Press, Aarhus Google Scholar
Thorpe, N 2013. ‘Warfare in the European Bronze Age’, in H Fokkens and A Harding (eds), The Oxford Handbook of the European Bronze Age, 234–247, Oxford University Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Underwood, E J 1977. Trace Elements in Human and Animal Nutrition, Academic Press, London Google Scholar
Vaquer, J and Remcourt, M 2012. ‘Les poignards en cuivre et les poignards en silex dans les dotations funéraires chalcolithiques du midi de la France’, in M Sohn and J Vaquer (eds), Sépultures collectives et mobiliers funéraires de la fi n du Néolithique en Europe occidentale, 239–271, Archives d’Écologie Préhistorique, Toulouse Google Scholar
Vine, P M 1982. The Neolithic and Bronze Age Culture of the Middle and Upper Trent Basin, BAR Brit Ser 105, Oxford Google Scholar
Wainwright, G J 1962. ‘The excavation of an earthwork at Castell Bryn-Gwyn, Llanidan parish, Anglesey’, Archaeol Cambr, 111, 25–58 Google Scholar
Wang, Q, Roberts, B W, Wilkin, N and Strekopytov, S 2016. ‘Tin ingots from a probable Bronze Age shipwreck off the coast of Salcombe, Devon: composition and microstructure’, J Archaeol Sci, 67, 80–92 Google Scholar
Wells, C 1977. ‘The human bones’, in P Donaldson, ‘The excavation of a multiple round barrow at Barnack, Cambridgeshire, 1974–1976’, Antiq J, 57, 197–231 Google Scholar
Whittle, A, Atkinson, R J C, Chambers, R and Thomas, N 1992. ‘Excavations in the Neolithic and Bronze Age complex at Dorchester-on-Thames, Oxfordshire, 1947–1952 and 1981’, Proc Prehist Soc, 58, 143–201 Google Scholar
Wiltshire Heritage Museum, Devizes, ‘Cunnington Letters Book IX’Google Scholar
Woodward, A and Hunter, J 2015. Ritual in Early Bronze Age Grave Goods: an examination of ritual and dress equipment from Beaker Age and Early Bronze Age graves in Britain, Oxbow, Oxford Google Scholar
Supplementary material: File

Needham supplementary material

Needham supplementary material

Download Needham supplementary material(File)
File 6.5 MB