Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-g7gxr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-04T05:01:54.343Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

China-Bound for Jobs? The Influences of Social Connections and Ethnic Politics in Taiwan

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 September 2010

Ming-Chang Tsai
Affiliation:
National Taipei University. Email: mtsai@mail.ntpu.edu.tw
Chin-fen Chang
Affiliation:
Academia Sinica. Email: chinfen@gate.sinica.edu.tw

Abstract

Taiwan has long been recognized as a labour-absorbing society, but today approximately 3 per cent of its population is working in China, an increasingly important destination for regional immigration. In this article we go beyond conventional immigration economics to examine how social connections and ethnic politics affect Taiwanese motivations to move to China for employment. Results from a national random-sample survey conducted in 2005 are used to analyse the willingness and potentiality of Taiwanese to work in China. The findings indicate that besides human capital factors, social networks and political/ethnic identity offer insights to understanding migrations among Taiwanese, as well as why the vast majority have so little interest in going China-bound.

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © The China Quarterly 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Hugo, Graeme, “International migration in the Asian-Pacific region: emerging trends and issues,” in Massey, Douglas S. and Taylor, J. Edward (eds.), International Migration: Prospects and Policies in a Global Market (New York: Oxford University Press, 2004), pp. 77103CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Graeme Hugo and Charles Stahl, “Labour export strategies in Asia,” in ibid. pp. 174–200; Massey, Douglas, Arango, Joaquín, Hugo, Graeme, Kouaouchi, Ali, Pellegrino, Adela and Taylor, J. Edward, World in Motion: Understanding International Migration at the End of the Millennium (Oxford: Clarendon, 1998)Google Scholar; Stahl, Charles W., “International labour migration in East Asia: trends and policy issues,” in Iredale, Robyn, Hawksley, Charles and Castles, Stephen (eds.), Migration in the Asian Pacific: Population, Settlement and Citizenship Issues (Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, 2003), pp. 2954.Google Scholar

2 Laodong tongji yuebao (Labour Statistics Monthly Bulletin) (Taipei: Council of Labour Affairs, Republic of China, March 2009), p. 156.

3 This 2005 estimate is from the Straits Exchange Foundation, a semi-governmental agency that represents Taiwan in negotiations with the Chinese government. See http://www.seftb.org/mhypage.exe?HYPAGE=news_old_content.asp&idx=175, accessed 18 August 2008. Other estimates of this group vary, however, ranging between 750 thousand and one million. See Tsai, Ming-Chang and Tzeng, Rueyling, “Ershi nian lai liang'an shehui jiaoliu” (“Social interflows across the Strait in the last two decades”), in You, Ying-Long (ed.), Jin ershi nian liang'an guanxi de fazhan yu bianjian (The Development and Change of Cross-Strait Relationships in the Last 20 Years) (Taipei: Straits Exchange Foundation, 2008), pp. 269–95.Google Scholar

4 Iguchi, Yasushi, “The movement of the high-skilled in Asia: present situation and future prospect,” in Migration and the Labour Market in Asia: Recent Trends and Policies (OECD Publishing, 2002), pp. 2950Google Scholar; Stahl, “International labour migration in East Asia.”

5 Tzeng, Rueyling, “International labour migration through multinational enterprises,” International Migration Review, Vol. 29, No. 1 (1995), pp. 139–54.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed

6 The antagonism reflects the legacy of the Chinese Communist Party takeover. The Nationalist government moved to Taiwan with two million followers during 1949 and 1951.

7 Chiu, Hei-Yuan, Ding, Ting-yu, Lin, Cheng Yi and Tsai, Ming-Chang, Dalu tanqin ji fang wen de yingxiang (The Influence of Visiting Mainland China) (Taipei: Institute for National Policy Research, 1989).Google Scholar

8 Tsai, Ming-Chang, “Dalu gainian de shehui jiangou” (“The social construction of Mainland China: an analysis of viewpoints of group leaders on Taiwan”), Guoli Taiwan daxue shehuixue kan (National Taiwan University Journal of Sociology), No. 20 (1990), pp. 85106.Google Scholar

9 Bureau of Foreign Trade press release, 24 February 2006.

11 Zhongguo tongji nianjian (China Statistical Yearbook 2008) (Beijing: National Bureau of Statistics of China, 2008). See http://www.sei.gov.cn/hgjj/yearbook/2008/indexCh.htm, accessed 6 April 2009. Note that many Taiwan firms register in the British Virgin Islands, so the official figure for investment in China might be substantially underestimated. See Wang, Hong-zen, “China's skilled labour on the move: how Taiwan business mobilize ethnic resources in Asia,” Asian Survey, No. 48 (2008), pp. 265–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

12 The southward movement during Lee Teng-hui's presidency (1988–2000, particularly during the late 1990s) reflected the Taiwan government's desire to avoid economic dependence on China. Vietnam attracted most Taiwanese investment in this region (ibid.).

13 Berger, Suzanne and Lester, Richard K., “Globalization and the future of the Taiwan miracle,” in Berger, Suzanne and Lester, Richard K. (eds.), Global Taiwan: Building Competitive Strengths in a New International Economy (Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe, 2005), pp. 332;Google ScholarChang, Chia-Ming, Taishang zai Suzhou: quanqiuhua yu zaidihua de kaocha (Taiwanese Businessmen in Soochow: a Study of Globalization and Localization) (Taipei: Laureate Press, 2006).Google Scholar

14 Tsai-Lung Hung, “The features of Taiwan firm's investment in China, its rights protection and future development,” in Ying-Long You, The Development and Change of the Cross-Strait Relationships, pp. 207–46.

15 Steinfeld, Edward S., “Cross-straits integration and industrial catch-up: how vulnerable is the Taiwan miracle to an ascendant Mainland?” in Berger, Suzanne and Lester, Richard K. (eds.), Global Taiwan: Building Competitive Strengths in a New International Economy (Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe, 2005), pp. 228–79.Google Scholar

16 Liang, Zai, “The age of migration in China,” Population and Development Review, No. 27 (2001), pp. 499524.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

17 Wu, Jieh-min, “Yazha renxing kongjian: shenfen chaxu yu Zhongguo shi duozhong boxue” (“Human space squeezed: differential status and multiple exploitation in China”), Taiwan shehui yanjiu jikan (Taiwan: A Radical Quarterly in Social Studies), No. 39 (2000), pp. 144.Google Scholar

18 Iguchi, “The movement of the high-skilled in Asia.”

19 Zweig, David, Chen, Changgui and Rosen, Stanley, “Globalization and transnational human capital: overseas and returnee scholars to China,” The China Quarterly, No. 179 (2004), pp. 735–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

20 Bail, Hélène Le and Shen, Wei, “The return of the ‘brains’ to China: what are the social, economic, and political impacts?” in Asie Visions 11 (Paris: Insitut Français des Relations Internationales, 2008).Google Scholar

21 Zweig, Chen and Rosen, “Globalization and transnational human capital.”

22 Xiang, Biao, “Productive outflow of skills: what India and China can learn from each other,” Asian Population Studies, No. 3 (2007), pp. 115–33.Google Scholar

23 Yeoh, Brenda S.A. and Willis, Katie, “Singaporean and British transmigrants in China and the cultural politics of ‘contact zones’,” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, No. 31 (2005), pp. 269–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

24 Deng, Jian-Bang, “Tanxing xia de xianzhi: lijie Zhongguo Taigan de kuajie gongzuo liudong yu shenghuo anpai” (“Constraints on flexibility: understanding transnational mobility and living arrangements of Taiwanese highly skilled migrants in China”), Yanjiu Taiwan (Journal of Taiwan Studies), No. 3 (2008), pp. 136.Google Scholar

25 Bhattacharya, Prabir C., “Rural-to-urban migration in LDCs: a test of two rival models,” Journal of International Development, No. 14 (2002), pp. 951–72;CrossRefGoogle ScholarBorjas, George J., “Economic theory and international migration,” International Migration Review, No. 23 (1989), pp. 457–85.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed

26 Chen, Jun-Lang and Huang, Shin-tsung, “Taishang zhi Taiji ganbu renli ziyuan guihua” (“Human resource management of Taiwanese cadres in Taiwanese businesses in China”), Huaren jingji yanjiu (Journal of Chinese Economic Research), Vol. 4, No. 2 (2006), pp. 2134.Google Scholar

27 Shen, Hsiu-Hua, “The first Taiwanese wives and the Chinese mistresses: the international division of labour in familial and intimate relations across the Taiwan Strait,” Global Networks, No. 5 (2005), pp. 419–37;CrossRefGoogle Scholar Tsai and Tzeng, “Social interflows across the strait in the last two decades.”

28 Wang, Hong-zen, “Social capital or human capital? Professionals in overseas Taiwanese firms,” Journal of Contemporary Asia, No. 32 (2002), pp. 346–62;CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed Hong-zen Wang, “China's skilled labour on the move.”

29 Zweig, David, “Competing for talent: China's strategies to reverse the brain drain,” International Labour Review, No. 145 (2006), pp. 6589;CrossRefGoogle ScholarDeVoretz, Don and Zweig, David, “An overview of 21st-century Chinese ‘brain circulation’,” Pacific Affairs, No. 81 (2008), pp. 171–73;CrossRefGoogle ScholarXiang, Biao, “Emigration from China: a sending country perspective,” International Migration, No. 41 (2003), pp. 2148;Google Scholar Le Bail and Shen, “The return of the ‘brains’ to China.”

30 Fawcett, James T., “Networks, linkages, and migration systems,” International Migration Review, No. 23 (1989), pp. 671–80;CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMedPortes, Alejandro, “Immigration theory for a new century: some problems and opportunities,” International Migration Review, No. 31 (1997), pp. 799825.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed

31 Palloni, Alberto, Massey, Douglas, Ceballos, Miguel, Espinosa, Kristin and Spittel, Michael, “Social capital and international migration: a test using information on family networks,” American Journal of Sociology, No. 106 (2001), pp. 1262–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

32 Coleman, James S., “Social capital in the creation of human capital,” American Journal of Sociology, No. 94 (1988), pp. s95s120;CrossRefGoogle ScholarLin, Nan, Social Capital: a Theory of Social Structure and Action (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

33 Katz, Eliakim and Stark, Oded, “International migration under asymmetric information,” The Economic Journal, No. 97 (1987), pp. 718–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

34 Palloni et al., “Social capital and international migration”; Massey, Douglas and Espinosa, Kristin E., “What's driving Mexico-US migration? A theoretical, empirical and policy analysis,” American Journal of Sociology, No. 99 (1997), pp. 14921533.Google Scholar

35 Massey et al., World in Motion.

36 Chen and Huang, “Human resource management of Taiwanese cadres in Taiwanese businesses in China”; Hsu, Yuan-Pai, “Dalu Taishang feizhiduhua jiaoyi chengben zhi fenxi” (“The analyses on non-institutional transaction cost of Taiwan's enterprises in Mainland China”), Journal of Social Sciences, Vol. 13, No. 1 (2005), pp. 95124.Google Scholar

37 Tseng, Yen-Fen, “Chinese ethnic economy: San Gabriel Valley, Los Angeles County,” Journal of Urban Affairs, No. 16 (1994), pp. 169–89;CrossRefGoogle ScholarTseng, Yen-Fen, “Beyond ‘little Taipei’: the development of Taiwanese immigrant businesses in Los Angeles,” International Migration Review, No. 29 (1995), pp. 3358.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

38 Hsiao, Hsin-Huang Michael and Kung, I-Chun, “History, characteristics and future prospect of overseas Taiwanese firms,” in Hsiao, Hsin-Huang Michael, Wang, Hong-Zen and Kung, I-Chun (eds.), Taiwanese Business in Southeast Asia: Network, Identity and Globalization (Taipei: Asia-Pacific Research Program, Academia Sinica, 2002), pp. 1132;Google Scholar Hong-zen Wang, “China's skilled labour on the move.”

39 Portes, “Immigration theory for a new century”; Portes, Alejandro and DeWind, Josh, “A cross-Atlantic dialogue: the progress of research and theory in the study of international migration,” in Portes, Alejandro and DeWind, Josh (eds.), Rethinking Migration: New Theoretical and Empirical Perspectives (New York: Berghahn, 2007), pp. 326.Google Scholar

40 As Chen Shui-Bian stated in his book-length campaign pamphlets for two presidential elections (Chen, Shui-Bian, Taiwan zhi zi (The Son of Taiwan) (Taichung: Morning Star Press, 2000);Google ScholarChen, Shui-Bian, Xiangxin Taiwan: A Bian zongtong xiang renmin baogao (Believe in Taiwan: President A Bian Reports to the People) (Taipei: Eurasian Press, 2004)Google Scholar), he attempted to take “positive management” as its policy position, rather than passive deregulation as the KMT regime was deemed to practise.

41 In terms of ethnic group distribution, Han Chinese make up more than 95% of the population in Taiwan, followed by various indigenous populations.

42 Wang, Fu-Chang, “Zuqun jiechu zhihui? Haishi zuqun jingzheng? Bensheng minnanren zuqun yishi neihan yu diqu chayi moshi zhi jieshi” (“Ethnic contact or ethnic competition? Explaining regional differences in ethnic consciousness among Holos in Taiwan”), Taiwan shehuixue (Taiwanese Sociology), No. 4 (2002), pp. 1174;Google ScholarWu, Nai-The, “Rentong chongtu he zhengzhi xinren: Xian jieduan Taiwan zuqun zhengzhi de hexin nanti” (“Identity conflict and political trust: ethnic politics in contemporary Taiwan”), Taiwan shehuixue, No. 4 (2002), pp. 75118.Google Scholar

43 Nai-The Wu, “Identity conflict and political trust.”

44 “Ma Ying-jeou's remarks at the international reception,” 4 March 2008. See http://www.kuomintangnews.org/client/eng/NewsArtical.php?REFDOCID=00arbvpqri7wxrro&TYPIDJump=00ardbyruqn4r9sb, accessed 31 July 2008.

45 Tian-lin Lu, “The effects of trade activities across the strait on Taiwanese labours (in Chinese),” The Labour (2006), http://enews.url.com.tw//archiveRead.asp?scheid=40758, accessed 26 October 2006.

46 Chen, Chih-Jou Jay and Yu, Te-Lin, “Taiwan minzhong dui wailai pei'ou yimin zhengce de taidu” (“Public attitudes toward Taiwan's immigration policy”), Taiwan shehuixue, No. 10 (2005), pp. 95148.Google Scholar

47 Liberty Times, “A conspiracy to mobilize Mainlander brides to affect the presidential election,” 2 December 2002.

48 Palloni et al., “Social capital and international migration.”

49 Granovetter, Mark, “The strength of weak ties,” American Journal of Sociology, No. 78 (1973), pp. 1360–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

50 Since the dependent variable is measured on ordinal scale, the ordered logistic regression technique is used to capture the ranking order in response (Long, J. Scott, Regression Models for Categorical and Limited Dependent Variables (Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 1997)Google Scholar). Table 3 is modelled using the same method.

51 While life cycle is proposed as a potential factor affecting migratory behaviour (Stephen Castles, “The factors that make and unmake migration policies,” in Portes and DeWind, Rethinking Migration, pp. 29–61), its most relevant measures (wife's employment status and number of minor children) were not determined as significantly affecting our analysis.

52 Three measures were used to represent human capital: education, employment position and tenure. Education was categorized as junior high school or below (22.0%), senior high school (33.9%), university or college (37.8%) and graduate degree or higher (6.3%). The first group was designated as a dummy reference.

53 As the migrant workers are expected to benefit from labour market demands and compensation according to their skill, expertise, and/or financial capital levels, we expected to find a strong association between employment position and willingness to work outside Taiwan, and that respondents who owned production facilities or equipment would be more likely to move. We therefore established three categories for business ownership: firms with six or more employees (2.9% of the sample), firms with five or fewer employees (5.1%), and self-employed with no employees (9.9%). Respondents who described themselves as employees were classified as managers (6.2%), highly skilled professionals (outside supervisory positions) (8.4%), semi-skilled technicians (19.1%), clerical (22.7%) or lower-grade (manual) workers (25.7%). The last group is used as reference in dummy design.

54 Since the public sector in Taiwan provides better job security and benefits, our expectation was that employees in government offices and public enterprises (12.2% of the sample) would be less likely to consider migration than those in the private sector. A dummy variable was established to capture this difference. We also predicted that employees with more work experience would be more reluctant than those with less to migrate for work purposes, and therefore added number of years with paid employment to our analysis.

55 We also examined data from unemployed respondents and found that they were not more likely to migrate.

56 We coded these five categories as dummy variables in our regression model to investigate the influence of each.

57 Hong-zen Wang, “China's skilled labour on the move.”

58 The exclusion of indigenous residents of Taiwan reduced the sample size by approximately 2%.

59 We speculated that a combination of ethnicity and social connections would generate greater motivation to seek employment in China, with Mainlanders especially able to mobilize their social connections. To examine this combined effect, we introduced an interaction variable using a Mainlander dummy and a social connection as its elements (Tables 2 and 3). The results did not identify any statistically significant effects for these variables (not shown to save space).

60 We conducted another specification check by analysing data from respondents who had not worked in China. Results from a regression estimation showed similar outcomes (Tables 2 and 3) (data not shown). The key factors of human capital, social connections and ethnic politics only produced similar results when potential emigrants were considered.

61 We provide two relevant interviews to show how ethnic identity can be mobilized to reduce the psychological distance between a would-be Taiwan migrant and mainland China, in contrast to the hesitation in associating with China as observed in the late 1980s. “I am a wai-sheng (“outside the province”) person, my grandfather, grandmother, grandfather-in-law are KMT members. My parents are influenced by them and work in the government. All my family members support me to come to mainland China to develop [career]” (male in his late 20s, working in China after obtaining a degree from a prestigious university in the US). (Shi Wei, “Zai Beijing dabing de rizi: san ge Taiwanren zai Beijing shenghuo de suan tian ku la” (“The days of working hard in Beijing: the sweet and sour of three Taiwanese living in Beijing”), Nihao Taiwan wang (How Are You Taiwan Net) (2008), http://www.am684.cn/jl/jlzt/jldt/200805/t20080504_351622.htm, accessed 13 April 2009). Such attachments with mainland China can be mediated via personal identify and passed down to younger generations: “In the beginning, I came to mainland China for a try. My knowledge of mainland China is mainly from books I read when I was little or from what I heard from elders. Because my parents were from mainland China, I have relatively more feeling for it, so I guess I should come over and see it” (male, mid-30s, with a PhD in law from a university in China, decided to stay and currently teaches in a college) (Xiang Xi Luo, Xunzhao lixing: Taiwan zhengyao mingren fangtan lu (Searching for Rationality: Interviews with Political and Social Celebrities) (Hong Kong: China Review Academic Publishers, 2006), http://www.chinareviewnews.com/crn-webapp/cbspub/secDetail.jsp?bookid=3959&secid=4026, accessed 13 April 2009).

62 Stark, Oded and Bloom, David, “The new economics of labour migration,” American Economic Review, No. 75 (1985), pp. 173–78;Google ScholarStark, Oded and Taylor, J. Edward, “Migration incentives, migration types: the role of relative deprivation,” The Economic Journal, No. 101 (1991), pp. 1163–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar