Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-28T07:54:28.841Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The African Orthodox Church: An Analysis of Its First Decade

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Warren C. Platt
Warren C. Platt
Affiliation:
Mr. Platt is an Episcopal priest and librarian in the Research Libraries of the New York Public Library, New York, New York.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The African Orthodox church, an expression of religious autonomy among black Americans, had its genesis in the work and thought of George Alexander McGuire, a native of Antigua, whose religious journey and changing ecclesiastical affiliation paralleled his deepening interest in and commitment to the cause of Afro-American nationalism and racial consciousness. Born in 1866 to an Anglican father and a Moravian mother, George Alexander McGuire was educated at Mico College for Teachers in Antigua and the Nisky Theological Seminary, a Moravian institution in St. Thomas, Virgin Islands (then the Danish West Indies). In 1893 McGuire, having served a pastorate at a Moravian church in the Virgin Islands, migrated to the United States, where he became an Episcopalian. In 1897 he was ordained a priest in that church and, in the succeeding decade, served several parishes, including St. Thomas Church in Philadelphia, which was founded by Absalom Jones. His abilities and skills were recognized, and in 1905 he became the archdeacon for Colored Work in the Episcopal Diocese of Arkansas. Here he became involved with various plans—none of which bore fruit—which would have provided for the introduction of black bishops in the Episcopal church to assist in that church's work of evangelization among black Americans. It is believed, however, that McGuire was influenced by the different schemes which were advanced, and that he “almost certainly carried away from Arkansas the notion of a separate, autonomous black church, and one that was episcopal in character and structure, as one option for black religious self-determination and one avenue for achieving black independence.”

Type
Research Article
Information
Church History , Volume 58 , Issue 4 , December 1989 , pp. 474 - 488
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 1989

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Newman, Richard, “The Origins of the African Orthodox Church,” in Black Power and Black Religion: Essays and Reviews, ed. Newman, Richard (West Cornwall, Conn., 1987), p. 85.Google Scholar Material on the African Orthodox church is limited; however, researchers are advised to consult Newman's article, which carefully delineates those intellectual and social concerns which stimulated Bishop McGuire's behavior and quickened his resolve to found a black church imbued with catholic principles. Terry-Thompson, Arthur C., The History of the African Orthodox Church (New York, 1956),Google Scholar provides salient material on the founding of the church (including documents), but the author's membership in the church necessitates that one use this work with care. The Negro Churchman, the church's periodical during its early years, has been published in a reprint edition: The Negro Churchman: The Official Organ of the African Orthodox Church, 2 vols. (Millwood, N.Y., 1977).Google Scholar See also White, Gavin, “Patriarch McGuire and the Episcopal Church,” Historical Magazine of the Protestant Episcopal Church 38 (06 1969): 109–142;Google ScholarRushing, Byron, “A Note on the Origin of the African Orthodox Church,” Journal of Negro History 57 (1972): 37–39;CrossRefGoogle ScholarBurkett, Randall K., Black Redemption: Churchmen Speak for the Garvey Movement (Philadelphia, 1978);Google Scholar and idem, Garveyism as a Religious Movement: The Instil utionalizalion of a Black Civil Religion (Metuchen, N.J., 1978). A succinct analysis of the church may be found in Piepkorn, Arthur C., Profiles in Belief: The Religious Bodies of the United States and Canada, vol. 1, Roman Catholic, Old Catholic, and Eastern Orthodox (San Francisco, 1977), pp. 92–94.Google Scholar

2. Newman, , “Origins of the African Orthodox Church,” p. 88.Google Scholar

3. Terry-Thompson, , History of the African Orthodox Church, p. 53.Google Scholar

4. Ibid., p. 51.

5. Newman, , “Origins of the African Orthodox Church,” p. 92.Google Scholar

6. Terry-Thompson, , History of the African Orthodox Church, p. 57.Google Scholar For more on Vilatte and the phenomenon of the episcopi vagantes, see Anson, Peter F., Bishobs at Large (London, 1964).Google Scholar

7. Terry-Thompson, . History of the African Orthodox Church, pp. 57–58.Google Scholar Archbishop Vilatte had previously ordained McGuire deacon on 26 September 1920 and priest on 27 September 1921 at the Church of Our Lady of the Good Death in Chicago. This action, of course, indicated Vilatte's doubts about the validity of the Anglican orders which McGuire had previously received. Vilatte also ordained the Reverend William Robertson to the diaconate and priesthood on the same days; Robertson was himself consecrated bishop on 18 November 1923 in New York City and thus became the second person elevated to the episcopate in the African Orthodox church. Robertson succeeded McGuire to the leadership of the church upon the latter's death in 1934.

8. Newman, , “Origins of the African Orthodox Church,” pp. 89–90.Google Scholar

9. Terry-Thompson, , History of the African Orthodox Church, p. 129.Google Scholar

10. Ibid., p. 131.

11. Burkett, , Black Redemption, p. 7.Google Scholar

12. Ibid., p. 7.

13. An examination of The Negro Churchman indicates that the seventy-four clergy ordained by McGuire included twenty former Anglicans, two former Moravians, one former Methodist, five former Protestants (denominations not given), and one former Roman Catholic; no information is available on the previous church affiliation of other ordinands. McGuire's previous ecclesiastical affiliation and the theological and liturgical emphases of the African Orthodox church might lead some observers to classify it as a racial branch of the Episcopal church. If this term is to be applied, however, it must be with qualifications. McGuire's choice of name for the new body (which did not include any variants on “Episcopal” or “Anglican”), the fact of the Vilatte (as opposed to an Anglican) succession, and the stated affinity of the church with Eastern Orthodoxy—all militate against the unqualified employment of this designation.

14. The 1922, 1925, 1928, and 1931 General Conventions of the Episcopal church mentioned neither McGuire nor the African Orthodox church. These conventions (especially that of 1931) did discuss evangelizing the Negro but were unable to reach a consensus on the most appropriate means for doing so.

15. “Rise! Stand Upon Thy Feet!” The Negro Churchman 6 (03. 1928): 5.Google Scholar

16. Garrett, F. A., “Why I Entered the African Orthodox Church,” The Negro Churchman 6 (07 1928): 1–2.Google Scholar

17. Garrett, F. A., “Why I Entered the African Orthodox Church,” The Negro Churchman 6 (08. 1928)Google Scholar: 3 (a continuation of Garrett's article from the July 1928 issue). Garrett overlooked the fact that the Methodist Episcopal church did appoint its first black bishop (Matthew Clair) in 1920.

18. McGuire, George A., “Patriarch's Address,” The Negro Churchman 6 (10 1928)Google Scholar: 3. Bishop McGuire assumed the title of Patriarch Alexander (that being his middle name) to indicate his responsibilities over the two Provinces (America and South Africa) which then composed the African Orthodox church.

19. McGuire, George A., “The Bishop's Sermon at the Ordination of Rev. F. A. Toote to the Priesthood,” The Negro Churchman 1 (05 1923): 4.Google Scholar

20. Robinson, Richard G., “Philadelphia Confirmation,” The Negro Churchman 6 (07 1928): 3.Google Scholar

21. Grant, Reginald, “Our Grace Needs Our Church,” The Negro Churchman 3 (10 1925): 8.Google Scholar

22. For information on the establishment and organization of the African Orthodox church in Africa, see Newman, Richard, “Archbishop Daniel William Alexander and the African Orthodox Church,” in Black Power and Black Religion, pp. 109–130.Google Scholar Articles on the founding of the African branch of the church appeared in The Negro Churchman from 1925 through 1927.

23. On this matter, see “Peace in Separation,” The Negro Churchman 1 (04 1923): 2–;Google Scholar and McGuire, George A., “Liberia's Appeal to the Western Negro,” The Negro Churchman 1 (05 1923): 1–2.Google Scholar

24. McGuire, George A., “Extract from Primate's Address: General Synod, 1930,” The Negro Churchman 8 (11 1930): 1;Google ScholarValentine, Robert A., “A Part of the Whole and the Whole of a Part,” The Negro Churchman 8 (09. 1930): 6.Google Scholar

25. “Racial Understandings,” The Negro Churchman 1 (06 1923): 2.Google Scholar

26. “Historical Facts, 1921, 1925,” The Negro Churchman 5 (08 1927): 03.Google Scholar The constitution of the church was formally adopted at its First General Synod in 1921.

27. “Our Episcopal Succession,” The Negro Churchman 1 (01 1923): 2.Google Scholar

28. McGuire, , “Bishop's Sermon,” p. 3.Google Scholar See also McGuire, George A., “The Episcopalians and Archbishop Vilatte,” The Negro Churchman 1 (08 1923): 3–5;Google Scholar and “Certificate of Consecration of Bishop McGuire,” The Negro Churchman 1 (08 1923): 2.Google Scholar

29. Terry-Thompson, , History of the African Orthodox Church, p. 44.Google Scholar

30. “Instruction for Confirmation Classes,” The Negro Churchman 9 (02 1931): 3.Google Scholar

31. Terry-Thompson, , History of the African Orthodox Church, p. 44.Google Scholar

32. Toote, F. A., “An Instruction for Confirmation Classes,” The Negro Churchman 2 (02 1924): 3–7;Google Scholar and “Instruction for Confirmation Classes,” The Negro Churchman 9 (02 1931): 1–4.Google Scholar

33. “Resume of Fourth General Synod,” The Negro Churchman 2 (09-10 1924): 4.Google Scholar

34. Terry-Thompson, , History of the African Orthodox Church, p. 134.Google Scholar

35. McGuire, George A., “Patriarch's Address,” p. 5;Google ScholarAbbott, E. A., “A Review of ‘The Negro Churchman’ for March, 1928,” The Negro Churchman 6 (04-05 1928): 7.Google Scholar

36. The Divine Liturgy and Other Rites and Ceremonies of the Church According to the Use of the African Orthodox Church (New York, 1945), pp. 18–50.Google Scholar While the text of the Divine Liturgy was largely derived from Anglican sources (with some additions from the Roman Rite), the actual order of the rite as well as the ceremonial were based upon the Tridentine Mass of the Roman Catholic church. The vestments employed at celebrations of the Divine Liturgy were Western style.

37. “Proceedings of the Third General Synod,” The Negro Churchman 1 (09-10. 1923): 2.Google Scholar

38. Toote, , “Instruction for Confirmation Classes,” p. 4;Google Scholaribid., pp. 5–6.

39. Garrett, F. A., “Is Title ‘African’ Orthodox Correct?” The Negro Churchman 7 (01 1929): 4.Google Scholar

40. “S. Agnes Church, New York City,” The Negro Churchman 7 (01 1929): 5Google Scholar The growth of the African Orthodox church in the United States was modest. In 1926 it reported 1,568 members in thirteen parishes; in 1936 it reported 1,952 members in the same number of parishes. Members were concentrated in New England, New York, and Florida; in 1936 approximately 20 percent of the membership was under thirteen years of age. For these statistics, see United States Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, Religious Bodies: 1936, vol. 2, part 1, Denominations A to J: Statistics, History, Doctrine, Organizalion, and Word (Washington, 1941), pp. 49–51.Google Scholar

41 The Divine Liturgy, p. 63.

42. “What France Thinks of Us,” The Negro Churchman 3 (05 1925): 2.Google Scholar