Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-s2hrs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-03T17:20:50.827Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Imagining European Identity: French Elites and the American Challenge in the Pompidou–Nixon Era

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 April 2010

AURÉLIE ÉLISA GFELLER
AURÉLIE ÉLISA GFELLER*
Affiliation:
Swiss National Science Foundation/European University Institute, Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies, Via delle Fontanelle 19, I-50014 San Domenico di Fiesole (FI), Italy; aurelie.gfeller@eui.eu.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Charles de Gaulle has cast a long shadow over French political history and history writing. In exploring the French response to the United States' 1973 ‘Year of Europe’ initiative, this article challenges the dominant scholarly paradigm, which emphasises continuity between the 1960s and the 1970s. Drawing on a wide range of French and US archives, it demonstrates that renewed concerns about US power spurred the French elites both to reappraise the value of collective European action in foreign policy and to foster a pioneering concept: a politically anchored – as opposed to a geographically circumscribed – ‘European identity’.

Inventer l'identité européenne: les élites françaises et le défi américain au temps de georges pompidou et richard nixon

Charles de Gaulle a profondément marqué de son empreinte l'histoire politique française. Cet article questionne le paradigme historiographique de continuité entre l'ère gaullienne et les années 1970. Il repose sur une analyse de l'attitude française face à l'initiative américaine pour une ‘année de l'Europe’. Sur la base de documents d'archives françaises et américaines, l'auteur démontre que cette initiative, par les craintes renouvelées d'hégémonie américaine qu'elle suscita, poussa les élites françaises à donner un nouvel élan au projet d'Europe politique. Elles révisèrent ainsi leur jugement sur le principe d'une action conjointe en matière de politique étrangère. Les élites développèrent surtout un concept novateur: celui d'une ‘identité européenne’ renvoyant non plus à un héritage culturel ancré dans la géographie, mais à une entité politique.

Die vorstellung einer europäischen identität: die französischen eliten und die amerikanische herausforderung in der pompidou-nixon ära

Charles de Gaulle hat einen langen Schatten über die politische Geschichte und Historiographie Frankreichs geworfen. Das vorherrschende wissenschaftliche Paradigma, das die Kontinuität zwischen den 1960er und 1970er Jahren betont, wird mit der Untersuchung der französischen Antwort auf die amerikanische Initiative ‘Jahr Europas’ von 1973 in diesem Artikel hinterfragt. Durch die Verwendung von Dokumenten aus französischen und amerikanischen Archiven zeigt die Autorin auf, dass sich die französischen Eliten erneut mit der Macht der USA beschäftigten. Dies führte nicht nur zu einer Neubeurteilung der Möglichkeiten einer kollektiven europäischen Aussenpolitik, sondern auch zur Entwicklung eines innovativen Konzepts: einer ‘europäischen Identität’, die nicht auf einer geographischen, sondern auf einer politischen Einheit basierte.

Type
Articles
Information
Contemporary European History , Volume 19 , Issue 2 , May 2010 , pp. 133 - 149
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Bossuat, Gérard, Faire l'Europe sans défaire la France. 60 ans de politique d'unité européenne des gouvernements et des présidents de la République française (1943–2003) (Brussels: P.I.E. Peter Lang, 2005)Google Scholar; Dulphy, Anne and Manigand, Christine, La France au risque de l'Europe (Paris: Armand Colin, 2006)Google Scholar.

2 A handful of articles and one recent book on the Year of Europe ignore significant elements of the story. They either investigate the British and the US perspective, or they rely exclusively on the papers of French President Georges Pompidou: Beers, Marloes, ‘European Unity and the Transatlantic Gulf in 1973’, in Scott-Smith, Giles, ed., European Community, Atlantic Community? (Paris: Soleb, 2008)Google Scholar; Hamilton, Keith, ‘Britain, France, and America's Year of Europe, 1973’, Diplomacy & Statecraft, 17 (2006), 871–95CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hanhimäki, Jussi M., ‘Kissinger et l'Europe: entre intégration et autonomie’, Relations internationales, 119 (2004), 319–32Google Scholar; Hiepel, Claudia, ‘Kissinger's “Year of Europe” – A Challenge for the EC and the Franco-German relationship’, in van der Harst, Jan, ed., Beyond the Customs Union: The European Community's Quest for Deepening, Widening and Completion, 1969–1975 (Brussels: Bruylant, 2007), 277–96Google Scholar; Hynes, Catherine, The Year That Never Was: Heath, the Nixon Administration and the Year of Europe (Dublin: University College Dublin Press, 2009)Google Scholar; Mélandri, Pierre, ‘Une relation très spéciale. La France, les Etats-Unis et l'année de l'Europe, 1973–1974’, in Association Pompidou, Georges, ed., Georges Pompidou et l'Europe (Brussels: Editions Complexe, 1995), 89–131Google Scholar; Noble, Alastair, ‘Kissinger's “Year of Europe”, Britain's Year of Choice’, in Schulz, Matthias and Schwartz, Thomas A., eds., The Strained Alliance: US–European Relations from Nixon to Carter (Cambridge University Press, 2009)Google Scholar. The Year of Europe is also discussed in the first historical monograph on EPC: Daniel Möckli, European Foreign Policy during the Cold War: Heath, Brandt, Pompidou and the Dream of Political Unity (London: I.B. Tauris, 2009). Möckli's focus, however, is on the triangular diplomacy between Britain, France and West Germany – rather than France per se – and on key individuals within these three countries (president/prime minister, foreign ministers), with comparatively less emphasis on the views of other actors both within and outside government.

3 See Frank, Robert and Bossuat, Gérard, eds., Les identités européennes au XXe siècle. Diversités, convergences et solidarités (Paris: Publications de la Sorbonne, 2004)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 Soutou, Georges-Henri, ‘Georges Pompidou et Valéry Giscard d'Estaing: deux réconciliations et deux ruptures avec les Etats-Unis’, Relations internationales, 119 (2004), 303–18Google Scholar; Soutou, Georges-Henri, ‘L'anneau et les deux triangles: les rapports franco-allemands dans la politique européenne et mondiale de 1974 à 1981’, in Berstein, Serge and Sirinelli, Jean-François, eds., Les années Giscard. Valéry Giscard d'Estaing et l'Europe, 1974–1981 (Paris: Armand Colin, 2006), 45–79Google Scholar; Soutou, Georges-Henri, ‘Le président Pompidou et les relations entre les Etats-Unis et l'Europe’, Journal of European Integration History, 6 (2000), 111–46Google Scholar; Vaïsse, Maurice, ‘Les “relations spéciales” franco-américaines au temps de Richard Nixon et Georges Pompidou’, Relations internationales, 119 (2004), 345–62Google Scholar.

5 The only exception is an article focusing on the US perspective: Winand, Pascaline, ‘Loaded Words and Disputed Meanings: The Year of Europe Speech and Its Genesis from an American Perspective’, in van der Harst, Jan, ed., Beyond the Customs Union: The European Community's Quest for Deepening, Widening and Completion, 1969–1975 (Brussels: Bruylant, 2007), 297–315Google Scholar.

6 Kissinger, Memorandum for the President, 11 Dec. 1973, NPM, NSC, Kissinger office files, trip files, 43.

7 ‘Kissinger: Address at Associated Press Luncheon’, in USA Documents, 26 (1973).

8 The resignation of Nixon's closest aides – Bob Haldemann, his chief of staff, and John Ehrlichmann, his aide in charge of domestic affairs – lay only a few days ahead.

9 In November 1973, Kissinger complained that the NSC staff had not moved swiftly enough to prepare a new initiative on Europe (Telephone conversation (telcon) Kissinger/Peter Flanigan, 17 Nov. 1972, Nixon Presidential Materials (NPM), National Security Council (NSC), Kissinger files, telcons, 17). A week later, he commissioned a trans-departmental study of all current and future issues in transatlantic relations: National Security Study Memorandum 164 (NSC, NSSM 164, 18 Dec. 1972, NPM, NSC, Institutional files, 194).

10 NSC, NSSM 164.

11 Linking the United States’ spiralling balance-of-payments deficit to foreign defence spending, a number of US political leaders were calling for troop redeployment. See Kunz, Diane B., ‘Cold War Diplomacy: The Other Side of Containment’, in Kunz, Diane B., ed., The Diplomacy of the Crucial Decade: American Foreign Relations During the 1960s (New York: Columbia University Press, 1994), 80–114Google Scholar; Gavin, Francis J., Gold, Dollars, and Power: The Politics of International Monetary Relations, 1958–1971 (Chapel Hill, NC, and London: University of North Carolina Press, 2004)Google Scholar. At the same time, the January 1973 EC enlargement to include Britain, Denmark and Ireland implied tariff increases on sensitive products. France, moreover, insisted on including ‘reverse preferences’ in the preferential trade agreement to be (re)negotiated with former French colonies and Commonwealth countries, which the United States firmly opposed.

12 ‘Kissinger: Address at Associated Press Luncheon’.

13 Vaïsse, ‘Les “relations spéciales”‘; Soutou, ‘Georges Pompidou et Valéry Giscard d'Estaing’.

14 French officials frequently used this term to analyse US–Soviet relations. See, e.g., Jacques Kosciusko-Morizet (ambassador in Washington), diplomatic dispatch 65, 9 July 1973, French Foreign Ministry (MAE), Soviet files 1971–6, 3693.

15 MAE, oral archives, Jobert, interview, 18 Sept. 1990.

16 Ibid.

17 François de Rose (ambassador to NATO), telegram 861–70, 26 April 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 1137; Jean-Bernard Raimond (foreign policy adviser to the president), Note, 3 May 1973, Centre historique des archives nationales (CHAN), 5AG2 1021.

18 Sauvagnargues, telegram 1998–2006, 26 Apr. 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 1137.

19 Headline, Le Monde, 25 April 1973.

20 Quoted in Hamilton, ‘Britain, France, and America's Year of Europe’.

21 Quoted in ibid.

22 François Puaux (political director), Note pour le ministre, 20 Aug. 1973, MAE, EC files 1971–6, 3810.

23 Kissinger, Henry, Years of Upheaval (Boston, MA: Little, Brown, 1982), 189Google Scholar.

24 Möckli, European Foreign Policy, 166.

25 MAE, Puaux, Note pour le ministre.

26 MAE, Europe directorate, circular telegram 446, 24 Jul. 1973, MAE, EC files 1971–6, 3810.

27 MAE, Puaux, Note: rapports Europe Etats-Unis, 27 Aug. 1973, MAE, EC files 1971–6, 3810. On the Anglo-French axis, see Möckli, European Foreign Policy, 49–55.

28 MAE, Puaux, circular telegram 511, 6 Sept. 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 1137.

29 MAE, Puaux, circular telegram 523, 12 Sept. 1973, MAE, EC files 1971–6, 3792.

30 Memorandum of conversation (memcon) Kissinger/Knud Børge Andersen, 25 Sept. 1973, NPM, NSC, presidential memcons, 1027.

31 John F. Kennedy, Address at Independence Hall, 4 July 1962, available at www.jfklibrary.org/Historical+Resources/Archives/Reference+Desk/Speeches/JFK/003POF03IndependenceHall07041962.htm (last visited 2 March 2009). On Kennedy's ‘grand design for Europe’, see Pascaline Winand, Eisenhower, Kennedy, and the United States of Europe (New York: St. Martin's Press, 1993), 190–1; Mahan, Erin R., Kennedy, de Gaulle and Western Europe (Houndmills and New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2002), 126–7CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

32 Bozo, Frédéric, Deux stratégies pour l'Europe. De Gaulle, les Etats-Unis et l'Alliance atlantique, 1958–1969 (Paris: Plon, 1996), 90–1Google Scholar.

33 Roger Massip, ‘Editorial: de Copenhague à Tokyo’, Le Figaro, 24 Apr. 1973.

34 Pompidou, margin comment, 12 Dec. 1973, CHAN, 5AG2 1054/2.

35 Pierre Pélen (ambassador in Copenhagen), telegram 906–10, 18 Oct. 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 1137.

36 MAE, circular telegram 260, 28 Apr. 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 1137.

37 Jacques Jacquet-Francillon, ‘Etats-Unis: une mauvaise humeur tactique’, Le Figaro, 9–10 March 1974.

38 Burin des Roziers, telegram, 4 Oct. 1973, CHAN, 5AG2 1021.

39 Keohane, Robert O. and Nye, Joseph S., Power and Interdependence: World Politics in Transition (Boston, MA: Little, Brown, 1977)Google Scholar.

40 Burin des Roziers, telegram 3365–90, 6 Oct. 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 1137.

41 Joseph S. Nye, ‘Independence and Interdependence’, Foreign Policy, 22 (Spring 1976), 130–61.

42 Jacques Ogliastro, ‘“C'est la fin de la dispute la plus inutile du monde”, dit Jean Sauvagnargues’, Le Figaro, 20 June 1974.

43 Yves Moreau, ‘Editorial: Graves abandons’, L'Humanité, 11 Dec. 1974.

44 MAE, political directorate, circular telegram 254, 26 Apr. 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 1137.

45 Jacques de Beaumarchais (ambassador in London), telegram 2864–70, 4 Oct. 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 1137; Puaux, Note pour le ministre, 13 Oct. 1973, MAE, EC files 1971–6, 3792; ‘Le “sommet” de Reykjavik’, Le Monde, 3–4 June 1973; ‘Avant son voyage à Bonn, Moscou et Londres, Kissinger aux Neuf: “A vous de jouer . . .”’, L'Aurore, 22 March 1974.

46 Outline for a Declaration of Principles between the United States of America and the European Community and its Member States, quoted in full in MAE, Europe directorate, telegram 563, 1 Oct. 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 1137.

47 Kissinger, Talking Points for the President on European Aspects of the Trip, 22 Dec. 1973, NPM, NSC, Kissinger office files, trip files, 43 (emphasis in original).

48 Memcon Pompidou/Brandt, 27 Nov. 1973, CHAN, 5AG2 1012.

49 Kosciusko-Morizet, telegram 5928, 27 Sept. 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 1137.

50 Memcon Kissinger/Andersen, 25 Sept. 1973, NPM, NSC, presidential memcons, 1027.

51 Kissinger, Memorandum for the President, 11 Dec. 1973, NPM, NSC, Kissinger office files, trip files, 43. Brent Scowcroft to Kissinger, undated [Dec. 1973], NPM, NSC, Kissinger office files, trip files, 42.

52 De Gaulle used the phrase ‘European Europe’ on several occasions, notably in his 23 July 1964 press conference at the Elysée Palace: Charles de Gaulle, Discours et messages, 5 vols. (Paris: Plon, 1970), IV, 228.

53 Pélen, telegram 911–8, 19 Oct. 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 1137.

54 Maurice Duverger, ‘Europe européenne ou Europe américaine’, Le Monde, 1 June 1973. See also Henri de Kergorlay, ‘Entre Paris et ses partenaires: une vieille querelle qui rebondit avec chaque crise’, Le Figaro, 15 Feb. 1974; Yves Moreau, ‘L'Europe atlantique’, L'Humanité, 14 Feb. 1974.

55 ‘Declaration on European Identity’, Bulletin of the European Communities, 12 (1973), 118–22.

56 MAE, Europe directorate, Note: réunion ministérielle – relations Europe/Etats-Unis, 20 July 1973, MAE, EC files 1971–6, 3810.

57 Aron, Raymond, Plaidoyer pour l'Europe décadente (Paris: Robert Laffont, 1977)Google Scholar; de Benoist, Alain, Vu de droite. Anthologie critique des idées contemporaines (Paris: Copernic, 1977)Google Scholar; Benoist, Jean-Marie, Pavane pour une Europe défunte. L'adieu aux technocrates (Paris: Denoël-Gonthier, 1978)Google Scholar; Gobard, Henri, La guerre culturelle. Logique du désastre (Paris: Copernic, 1979)Google Scholar; Revel, Jean-François, Ni Marx, ni Jésus. De la seconde révolution américaine à la seconde révolution mondiale (Paris: Robert Laffont, 1970)Google Scholar; Thibau, Jacques, La France colonisée (Paris: Flammarion, 1980)Google Scholar.

58 Dubosclard, Alain et al. , Entre rayonnement et réciprocité. Contributions à l'histoire de la diplomatie culturelle (Paris: Publications de la Sorbonne, 2002)Google Scholar; Roche, François and Piniau, Bernard, Histoires de diplomatie culturelle des origines à 1995 (Paris: La documentation française, 1995)Google Scholar.

59 MAE, Europe directorate, Note: réunion ministérielle, 20 July 1973.

60 MAE, Coopération politique européenne CSCE (73) 65F. De l'identité européenne, 4 Sept. 1973, CHAN, 5AG2 1021.

61 European Political Cooperation GC (73) 37 UK: The Identity of the Nine vis-à-vis the United States, 4 Sept. 1973, MAE, EC files 1971–6, 3810.

62 RM (73)17P: Rapport du Comité politique sur les délibérations du Comité concernant l'identité européenne, 7 Sept. 1973, MAE, EC files 1971–6, 3792. ‘Communiqué’, Bulletin of the European Communities, 10 (1972), 14–26.

63 MAE, Europe directorate, Note: Comité politique des 12 et 13 novembre, 9 Nov. 1973, MAE, EC files 1971–6, 3795.

64 MAE, Europe directorate, Note: contenu possible d'un document à élaborer sur l'identité européenne par rapport aux Etats-Unis, 20 July 1973, MAE, EC files 1971–6, 3810.

65 Memcon Pompidou/Heath, 21 May 1973, CHAN, 5AG2 1014; Memcon Pompidou/Heath, 16 Nov. 1973, CHAN, 5AG2 1015.

66 Pompidou, margin comment on summary document dated 18 Aug. 1972, CHAN, 5AG2 1014.

67 MAE, Europe directorate, Note: Comité politique des 12 et 13 novembre.

68 Pompidou, press conference, 27 Sept. 1973, CHAN, 5AG2 1035; Pompidou, margin comment on Raimond, Note pour Monsieur Balladur, 13 Nov. 1973, CHAN, 5AG2 1035.

69 Treaty establishing the European Economic Community, Luxembourg, Publishing Services of the European Communities, undated, 5–183; ‘Treaty establishing a single Council and a single Commission of the European Communities’, Official Journal of the European Communities, 152 (1967); ‘Statement from the Paris Summit’, Bulletin of the European Communities, 10 (1972), 14–26; ‘Davignon Report’, Bulletin of the European Communities, 11 (1970), 9–14; ‘Second report on European political cooperation on Foreign Policy’, Bulletin of the European Communities, 9 (1973), 14–21.

70 On the Fouchet Plan, see the special issue of the Revue d'Allemagne et des pays de langue allemande, 29, 2 (1997). See also Vaïsse, Maurice, La grandeur. Politique étrangère du général de Gaulle, 1958–1969 (Paris: Fayard, 1998), 175–90Google Scholar.

71 Defrance, Corinne, ‘La culture dans les projets d'union politique de l'Europe (1961–1962)’, Revue d'Allemagne et des pays de langue allemande, 29, 2 (1997), 289–302Google Scholar.

72 ‘Draft Treaty – Fouchet Plan II (18 January 1962)’, in Selection of Texts Concerning Institutional Matters of the Community from 1950 to 1982 (Luxembourg: European Parliament, 1982), 119–21.

73 ‘Declaration on European Identity’.

74 On the controversy over the Christian roots of a united Europe, see Gérard Bossuat, ‘Histoire d'une controverse. La référence aux héritages spirituels dans la Constitution européenne’, Matériaux pour l'histoire de notre temps, 78 (April-June 2005), 68–82.

75 Servan-Schreiber, Jean-Jacques, Le défi américain (Paris: Denoël, 1967)Google Scholar.

76 Memcon Pompidou/Brandt, 4 July 1972, CHAN, 5AG2 1011.

77 Burin des Roziers, telegram, 4 Oct. 1973, CHAN, 5AG2 1021; Pompidou to Brandt, 16 Oct. 1973, CHAN, 5AG2 1009.

78 Geoffroy de Courcel to French embassy in Washington, telegram 749, 11 Dec. 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 721.

79 Burin des Roziers, telegram 3365–90, 6 Oct. 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 1137; René de Saint-Légier (Quai America director), Note: relations franco-américaines, 7 June 1974, MAE, US files 1970–5, 725.

80 Froment-Meurice, Note: entretien avec l'ambassadeur du Japon, 24 Oct. 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 1137.

81 Sauvagnargues, telegram 643–7, 14 Feb. 1974, MAE, economic directorate, 450.

82 Kosciusko-Morizet, Etats-Unis, Europe, France: Convergences et Obstacles, 12 Nov. 1973, MAE, US files 1970–5, 725.

83 Sauvagnargues, [Notes manuscrites rédigées pendant mes vacances d'août 1974 en Corse], Aug. 1974, MAE, Private Archives (PA), 373; Sauvagnargues, Organisation de l'Europe [Mémorandum sur le Conseil européen remis au président à mon retour de Corse], Sept. 1974, MAE, PA, 373.

84 Yann de l'Ecotais, ‘La Communauté n'est pas un club anti-américain’, Le Figaro, 18 March 1974.

85 Headline, Le Figaro, 7 Sept. 1973.

86 Maurice Delarue, ‘La réunion de Copenhague’, Le Monde, 11 Sept. 1973; Paul Fabra, ‘La crise de l'énergie: une politique commune reste à inventer’, Le Monde, 10 Dec. 1974.

87 Raymond Aron, ‘II. L'identité perdue’ (Le Figaro, 15 Feb. 1974), in Raymond Aron, Les articles de politique internationale dans Le Figaro de 1947 à 1977, 3 vols. (Paris: Editions de Fallois, 1990–1997), III, 1350.

88 SEC(73)3412-F: Déclaration faite par M. François-Xavier Ortoli, 30 Sept. 1973, Historical Archives of the European Union, Emile Noël deposit, 1566.

89 Pierre Drouin, ‘Une Communauté sans prophète’, Le Monde, 15 Dec. 1973.

90 Roger Massip, ‘Sauver la Communauté’, Le Figaro, 1 Nov. 1973.

91 Roger Massip, ‘Editorial’, Le Figaro, 9 Dec. 1973.

92 Kissinger, Years of Upheaval, 165.

93 Alexis de Tocqueville, De la démocratie en Amérique (Paris: C. Gosselin, 1835–1840).

94 Gentile, Emilio, ‘Modernity: Fascism and the Ambivalent Image of the United States’, Journal of Contemporary History, 28, 1 (1993), 7–29CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Nolan, Mary, Visions of Modernity: American Business and the Modernization of Germany (New York: Oxford University Press, 1994)Google Scholar; Beale, Marjorie A., The Modernist Enterprise: French Elites and the Threat of Modernity, 1900–1940 (Stanford University Press, 1999)Google Scholar; Ben-Ghiat, Ruth, Fascist Modernities: Italy, 1922–1945 (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2001)Google Scholar.

95 Studies of French anti-Americanism include Lacorne, Denis, Rupnik, Jacques and Toinet, Marie-France, eds., L'Amérique dans les têtes. Un siècle de fascinations et d'aversions (Paris: Hachette, 1986)Google Scholar; Kuisel, Richard F., Seducing the French: The Dilemma of Americanization (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1993)Google Scholar; Roger, Philippe, L'ennemi américain. Généalogie de l'antiaméricanisme français (Paris: Editions du Seuil, 2002)Google Scholar; Armus, Seth D., French Anti-Americanism (1930–1948): Critical Moments in a Complex History (Lanham, MD: Lexington Books, 2007)Google Scholar.

96 On the stance of the Christian democratic party, the Popular Republican Movement (MRP), on European integration see Berstein, Serge, Mayeur, Jean-Marie and Milza, Pierre, eds., Le MRP et la construction européenne (Brussels: Editions Complexe, 1993)Google Scholar. On France's European integration policy under the Fourth Republic see Bossuat, Faire l'Europe sans défaire la France, 46–81.

97 On the Europeanisation of France's Arab policy, see Aurélie Élisa Gfeller, ‘Re-envisioning Europe: France, America and the Arab World, 1973–1974’, Ph.D. thesis, Princeton University, 2008.

98 Aurélie Élisa Gfeller, ‘Valéry Giscard d'Estaing et la relance européenne: nouvel éclairage sur la création du Conseil européen et les réformes institutionnelles du sommet de Paris (1974)’, Revue d'histoire diplomatique, 4 (2009), 341–60.

99 Chopin, Thierry, ‘Le parlement européen’, in Berstein, Serge and Sirinelli, Jean-François, eds., Les années Giscard. Valéry Giscard d'Estaing et l'Europe, 1974–1981 (Paris: Armand Colin, 2006), 153–89Google Scholar.

100 On EPC and the CSCE, see Möckli, European Foreign Policy, 99–139; Angela Romano, From Détente in Europe to European Détente: How the West Shaped the Helsinki CSCE (Brussels: P.I.E. Peter Lang, 2009).

101 Megens, Ine, ‘The December 1973 Declaration on European Identity as the Result of Team Spirit among European Diplomats’, in van der Harst, Jan, ed., Beyond the Customs Union: The European Community's Quest for Deepening, Widening and Completion, 1969–1975 (Brussels: Bruylant, 2007), 317–38Google Scholar.

102 Constantinesco, Vlad, ‘Le rôle du Conseil européen dans la formation d'une identité européenne’, in Bitsch, Marie-Thérèse, Loth, Wilfried and Poidevin, Raymond, eds., Institutions européennes et identités européennes (Brussels: Bruylant, 1998), 435–47Google Scholar.

103 See, e.g., President Nicolas Sarkozy's much-remarked 2007 Strasbourg speech: MAE, Discours du président de la République devant le Parlement européen (Strasbourg, 13 Nov. 2007), available at www.diplomatie.gouv.fr/fr/europe_828/avenir-europe_14204/traitelisbonne_18255/discours-m.-nicolas-sarkozy-devant-parlement-europeen-strasbourg–13-novembre–2007_56337.html (last visited 12 May 2009).