Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-ndw9j Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-17T22:19:41.672Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Comparing Same-Sex Marriage in Australia and Canada: Institutions and Political Will

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 November 2016

Carol Johnson  and
Manon Tremblay
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article explores why there have been such different trajectories in regard to same-sex marriage in Australia and Canada. Canada was one of the first countries to introduce same-sex marriage (in 2005) and, at time of writing, Australia still had not done so.1 The comparison is particularly interesting given that Australia and Canada have relatively similar political institutions except that Australia has no Charter of Rights. Miriam Smith has suggested that institutional factors explain the different trajectories of policies on same-sex marriage in Canada and the US. However, the shift in comparative lens to Canada and Australia provides new insights into the key role of factors influencing ‘political will’ in regard to same-sex marriage in both countries. Those multiple influences do include institutions but also the role played by party electoral strategies. Consequently, the article provides insights into the factors that can influence minority group rights in different national democratic settings.

Keywords

same-sex marriageAustraliaCanadagaylesbianpolitics
Type
Articles
Information
Government and Opposition , Volume 53 , Issue 1 , January 2018 , pp. 131 - 158
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s). Published by Government and Opposition Limited and Cambridge University Press 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

Carol Johnson is a Professor in the Department of Politics and International Studies at the University of Adelaide. Contact email: carol.johnson@adelaide.edu.au.

Manon Tremblay is Professor of Political Studies at the University of Ottawa. Contact email: mtrembla@uottawa.ca.

References

Abetz, E. (2015), ‘Interview with Michael Brissenden’, AM, ABC radio, www.abc.net.au/am/content/2015/s4265941.htm.Google Scholar
Abbott, T. (2013), ‘Interview with Chris Kenny’, ViewPoint, Sky News, posted 31 March, www.tonyabbott.com.au/LatestNews/InterviewTranscripts/tabid/85/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/9126/Interview-with-Chris-Kenny-ViewPoint-Sky-News.aspx.Google Scholar
Abbott, T. (2015), ‘Joint Doorstop Interview, Queanbeyan’, 12 August, www.pm.gov.au/media/2015-08-12/joint-doorstop-interview-queanbeyan.Google Scholar
Australian Christian Lobby (2007), ‘Australia Votes (Party Responses to Australian Christian Lobby Survey of Party Policies)’, www.australiavotes.org/policies/index.php?topic_ids=5.Google Scholar
Bell, D.S. (2014), ‘Political Leadership’, Government and Opposition, 49(1): 139–158.Google Scholar
Bell, S. and Hindmoor, A. (2014), ‘The Ideational Shaping of State Power and Capacity: Winning Battles but Losing the War over Bank Reform in the US and UK’, Government and Opposition, 49(3): 342–368.Google Scholar
Bernstein, M. and Naples, N.A. (2010), ‘Sexual Citizenship and the Pursuit of Relationship Recognition Policies in Australia and the US’, Women’s Studies Quarterly, 38(1&2): 132–156.Google Scholar
Bernstein, M and Taylor, V. (2013) (eds), The Marrying Kind?: Debating Same-Sex Marriage within the Lesbian and Gay Movement (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press).Google Scholar
Bob, C. (2012), The Global Right Wing and the Clash of World Politics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).Google Scholar
Bourke, L. (2013), ‘Cory Bernardi Tells Malcolm Turnbull: Stop Advocating Same-Sex Marriage or Leave Frontbench’, ABC news online, 15 December, www.abc.net.au/news/2013-12-16/malcolm-turnbull-told-to-stop-advocating-gay-marriage/5158842.Google Scholar
Brandis, G. (2013), ‘The Freedom Wars Speech to the Sydney Institute’, 7 May, http://nofibs.com.au/2013/05/09/freedom-wars-the-george-brandis-speech/.Google Scholar
Brinkerhoff, D.W. (2000), ‘Assessing Political Will for Anti-Corruption Efforts: An Analytical Framework’, Public Administration and Development, 20(3): 239–252.3.0.CO;2-3>CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brisbane Times (2010), ‘“I Believe Homosexuality is Immoral”: table based on Roy Morgan poll research’, Roy Morgan Research, http://images.brisbanetimes.com.au/file/2010/11/15/2045177/immoral.pdf?rand=1289799771462.Google Scholar
Bush, G.W. (2004), ‘President George W. Bush: President Called for Constitutional Amendment Protecting Marriage’, 24 February, www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2004/02/20040224-2.html.Google Scholar
Chappell, L. (2002), Gendering Government: Feminist Engagement with the State in Australia and Canada (Vancouver: UBC Press).Google Scholar
Croome, R. (2010), ‘Marriage Equality (State) “Same-Sex Marriage Must be Recognized”: The Movement for State Same-Sex Marriage Laws Gathers Pace’, blog, 11 November, www.rodneycroome.id.au/weblog?id=C0_90_1.Google Scholar
Eekelaar, J. (2014), ‘Perceptions of Equality: The Road to Same-Sex Marriage in England and Wales’, International Journal of Law Policy and the Family, 28(1): 1–25.Google Scholar
Franklin, M. (2010), ‘ALP Brawls over Gay Unions, Greens’, The Australian, 30 November, www.theaustralian.com.au/news/nation/alp-brawls-over-gay-unions-greens/story-e6frg6nf.Google Scholar
Ganghof, S. (2016), ‘Reconciling Representation and Accountability: Three Visions of Democracy Compared’, Government and Opposition, 51(2): 209–233.Google Scholar
Gauja, A. (2010), Political Parties and Elections: Legislating for Representative Democracy (Farnham: Ashgate).Google Scholar
Gillard, J. (2012), ‘Transcript, Prime Minister Gillard Joins Q&A’, Q&A, broadcast, 11 June, www.abc.net.au/tv/qanda/txt/s3517695.htm.Google Scholar
Hammergren, L. (1998), Political Will, Constituency Building, and Public Support in Rule of Law Programs (Washington, DC: US Agency for International Development).Google Scholar
High Court of Australia. (2013), ‘Media Release: The Commonwealth of Australia v the Australian Capital Territory [2013] Hca 55’, 12 December, www.hcourt.gov.au/assets/publications/judgment-summaries/2013/hca55-2013-12-12.pdf.Google Scholar
Howard, J. (2003), ‘Doorstop Interview, Darwin’, 5 August, www.pm.gov.au/news/interviews/Interview406.html.Google Scholar
Howard, J. (2004), ‘Address to the National Marriage Forum’, Parliament House, Canberra, 4 August, transcript in possession of author.Google Scholar
Human Rights Commission (Australia) (2012), ‘Equality Means Access to Civil Marriage for All Couples’, 18 September, www.humanrights.gov.au/news/stories/equality-means-access-civil-marriage-all-couples.Google Scholar
Human Rights Commission (Australia) (2013), ‘Marriage Equality’, 18 June, www.humanrights.gov.au/marriage-equality.Google Scholar
Johnson, C. (2003), ‘Heteronormative Citizenship: The Howard Government’s Views on Gay and Lesbian Issues’, Australian Journal of Political Science, 38(1): 45–62.Google Scholar
Johnson, C. (2007), Governing Change: From Keating to Howard (Perth: Network Books).Google Scholar
Johnson, C. (2013), ‘Fixing the Meaning of Marriage: Political Symbolism and Citizen Identity in the Same-Sex Marriage Debate’, Continuum: Journal of Media and Cultural Studies, 27(2): 242–253.Google Scholar
Johnson, C., Maddison, S. and Partridge, E. (2011), ‘Australia: Parties, Federalism and Rights Agendas’, in M. Tremblay, D. Paternotte and C. Johnson (eds), The Lesbian and Gay Movement and the State: Comparative Insights into a Transformed Relationship (Farnham: Ashgate): 27–42.Google Scholar
Kaplan, M.B. (1997), Sexual Justice: Democratic Citizenship and the Politics of Desire (London: Routledge).Google Scholar
Koziol, M. (2016), ‘Same-sex Marriage Plebiscite Dead after Labor Caucus Agreed to Block Legislation’, Sydney Morning Herald, 11 October, www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/samesex-marriage-plebiscite-dead-after-labor-caucus-agreed-to-block-legislation-20161010-grzdkj.html.Google Scholar
Kpundeh, S. and Dininio, P. (2006), ‘Political Will’, in R. Stapenhurst, N. Johnston and R. Pelizzo (eds), The Role of Parliament in Curbing Corruption (Washington, DC: World Bank Institute): 41–8.Google Scholar
Kinsman, G. and Gentile, P. (2010), The Canadian War on Queers: National Security as Sexual Regulation (Vancouver: UBC Press).Google Scholar
Langstaff, A. (2011), ‘A Twenty-Year Survey of Canadian Attitudes towards Homosexuality and Gay Rights’, in D. Rayside and C. Wilcox (eds), Faith Politics and Sexual Diversity (Vancouver: UBC Press): 49–66.Google Scholar
Larocque, S. (2006), Gay Marriage: The Story of a Canadian Social Revolution (Toronto: Lorimer).Google Scholar
Maddox, M. (2014), ‘Right-wing Christian Intervention in a Naïve Polity: The Australian Christian Lobby’, Political Theology, 15(2): 132–150.Google Scholar
Malena, C. (ed.) (2009), From Political Won’t to Political Will: Building Support for Participatory Governance (Johannesburg: CIVICUS).Google Scholar
Matthews, J.S. (2005), ‘The Political Foundations of Support for Same-Sex Marriage in Canada’, Canadian Journal of Political Science, 38(4): 841–866.Google Scholar
Millbank, J. (2009), ‘De Facto Relationships, Same-Sex and Surrogate Parents: Exploring the Scope and Effects of the 2008 Federal Relationship Reforms’, Australian Journal of Family Law, 23(3): 1–34.Google Scholar
Mintzberg, H. (1983), Power In and Around Organizations (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall).Google Scholar
Parliament of Canada (2005), Debates (Hansard), 16 February, 15:35, www.parl.gc.ca/HousePublications/Publication.aspx?Language=E&Mode=1&Parl=38&Ses=1&DocId=1640291#T1535.Google Scholar
Plibersek, T. (2015), ‘Radio Interview ABC AM’, 27 April, http://tanyaplibersek.com/2015/04/abc-am-monday-27-april-2015/.Google Scholar
Post, L.A., Raile, A.N.W. and Raile, E.D. (2010), ‘Defining Political Will’, Politics and Policy, 38(4): 653–676.Google Scholar
Reference re Same-Sex Marriage [2004] 3 S.C.R (Supreme Court Report) 698.Google Scholar
Rayside, D. (2008), Queer Inclusions, Continental Divisions: Public Recognition of Sexual Diversity in Canada and the United States (Toronto: University of Toronto Press).Google Scholar
Rudd, K. (2006), ‘Faith in Politics’, The Monthly, October: 22–30.Google Scholar
Rudd, K. (2013), ‘Church and State Are Able to Have Different Positions on Same Sex Marriage’, web post, 20 May, www.kevinruddmp.com/2013/05/church-and-state-are-able-to-have.html.Google Scholar
Ryan, C. and Gamson, W.A. (2006), ‘The Art of Reframing Political Debates’, Contexts, 5(1): 13–18.Google Scholar
Shanahan, D. and Kelly, P. (2010), ‘I’ll Do It My Way, Declares Julia Gillard’, The Australian, 20 August, www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/ill-do-it-my-way-declares-julia-gillard/story-fn59niix-1225907498894.Google Scholar
Shorten, B. (2015), ‘Doorstop’, University of New South Wales, 30 April, http://billshorten.com.au/doorstop-university-of-nsw-bbott-governments-cuts-to-science-and-research-justice-ministers-ministerial-directive.Google Scholar
Smith, M. (1999), Lesbian and Gay Rights in Canada. Social Movements and Equality-Seeking, 1971–1995 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, M. (2005), ‘Social Movements and Judicial Empowerment: Courts, Public Policy, and Lesbian and Gay Organizing in Canada’, Politics and Society, 33(2): 327–353.Google Scholar
Smith, M. (2007), ‘Framing Same-Sex Marriage in Canada and the United States: Goodridge, Halpern, and the National Boundaries of Political Discourse’, Social and Legal Studies, 16(1): 5–26.Google Scholar
Smith, M. (2008), Political Institutions and Lesbian and Gay Rights in the United States and Canada (New York: Routledge).Google Scholar
Smith, M. (2010), ‘Federalism and LGBT Rights in the US and Canada: A Comparative Analysis’, in M. Haussman, M. Sawer and J. Vickers (eds), Federalism, Feminism and Multilevel Governance (Farnham: Ashgate): 97–109.Google Scholar
Smith, M. (2011), ‘Canada: The Power of Institutions’, in M. Tremblay, D. Paternotte and C. Johnson (eds), The Lesbian and Gay Movement and the State: Comparative Insights into a Transformed Relationship (Farnham: Ashgate): 73–87.Google Scholar
Stone, A.L. (2012), Gay Rights at the Ballot Box (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press).Google Scholar
Supreme Court (2015), ‘Obergefell et al. v. Hodges, Director, Ohio Department of Health, et al.’, www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/14pdf/14-556_3204.pdf, downloaded 13 July 2015.Google Scholar
Textor, M. (2014), ‘Record Support for Same-Sex Marriage’, survey results posted on Crosby Textor Group website, 15 July, www.crosbytextor.com/news/record-support-for-same-sex-marriage.Google Scholar
Treadway, D.C., Hochwarter, W.A., Kacmar, C.J. and Ferris, G.R. (2005), ‘Political Will, Political Skill, and Political Behavior’, Journal of Organizational Behavior 26(3): 229–245.Google Scholar
Tremblay, M. (2014), ‘Secular Humanism vs Social Conservatism: Analysing Canadian House of Commons Debates on Same-sex Marriage’, Scholars Worlds–IRMJCR, 2(1): 1–18.Google Scholar
Turnbull, M. (2015), ‘Response to Questions without Notice’, Parliamentary Debates, House of Representatives, 15 September (Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia): 10228.Google Scholar
Ward, A. (2012), Parliamentary Government in Australia (Melbourne: Australian Scholarly Publishing).Google Scholar
Waylen, G. (2015), ‘Engendering the “Crisis of Democracy”: Institutions, Representation and Participation’, Government and Opposition, 50(3): 495–520.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Whitlam, G. (1970), ‘Abortion, Sex Law Reforms “Not Party Issues”’, The Australian, 6 October.Google Scholar
Willett, G. (2010), ‘Howard and the Homos’, Social Movement Studies, 9(2): 187–199.Google Scholar
Wong, P. (2010a), ‘Interview Transcript’, Meet the Press, 25 July. http://ten.com.au/media/MTP_25_July_2010.doc.Google Scholar
Wong, P. (2010b), ‘In the Name of Equality, Labor Must Adopt Gay Marriage, Speech to South Australian Labor Party State Conference’, 29 November, www.crikey.com.au/2010/11/29/wong-in-the-name-of-equality-labor-must-adopt-gay-marriage.Google Scholar
Wong, P. (2011), ‘Marriage of Equality is a Core Value for All to Hold Dear’, Sydney Morning Herald, 19 November, www.smh.com.au/opinion/politics/marriage-of-equality-is-a-core-value-for-all-to-hold-dear-20111118-1nn28.html.Google Scholar
Woocher, L. (2001), ‘Deconstructing “Political Will”: Explaining the Failure to Prevent Deadly Conflict and Mass Atrocities’, Princeton Journal of Public and International Affairs, 12(Spring): 179–206.Google Scholar
Wroe, D. (2013), ‘Malcolm Turnbull: Australia out of Touch on Same-Sex Marriage’, Sydney Morning Herald, 16 December, www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/malcolm-turnbull-australia-out-of-step-on-gay-marriage-20131215-2zfbu.html.Google Scholar