Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gvvz8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-28T01:39:34.330Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Entering the Professions: Women Library Educators and the Placement of Female Students, 1887–1912

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 February 2017

Joanne Passet
Joanne Passet*
Affiliation:
Indiana University School of Library and Information Science American Studies and in the Women's Studies Program
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Turn-of-the-century women, armed with college or professional education, encountered many barriers as they attempted to enter the professions. Although circumstances in such male-dominated areas as science and medicine differed from the feminized fields of nursing and librarianship, some similarities existed. Margaret Rossiter, in Women Scientists in America, revealed that colleges and universities were more willing to educate than employ female scientists and, as a result, women developed several strategies to infiltrate the field. The most successful approach was segregation, both topical (women gained control over such feminine areas as home economics and hygiene/physical education) and hierarchical (women gained employment as lab assistants under male supervision). Medicine, according to Gloria Moldow, provided an even greater challenge to women who wished to become doctors. Although marginal medical schools welcomed them as students, female graduates encountered great difficulties as they sought legitimation from hospitals and professional associations directed by men. Moreover, after 1900, these associations successfully drove the less-orthodox areas of medicine from the profession.

Type
Articles
Information
History of Education Quarterly , Volume 31 , Issue 2 , Summer 1991 , pp. 207 - 228
Copyright
Copyright © 1991 by the History of Education Society 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Rossiter, Margaret W., Women Scientists in America: Struggles and Strategies to 1940 (Baltimore, 1982); Moldow, Gloria, Women Doctors in Gilded-Age Washington: Race, Gender, and Professionalization (Urbana, Ill., 1987).Google Scholar

2. Reverby, Susan D. M., Ordered to Care: The Dilemma of American Nursing, 1850–1945 (New York, 1987); Melosh, Barbara, “The Physician's Hand”: Work, Culture, and Conflict in American Nursing (Philadelphia, 1982), 5.Google Scholar

3. Glazer, Penina M. and Slater, Miriam, Unequal Colleagues: The Entrance of Women into the Professions, 1890–1940 (New Brunswick, N.J., 1987), 232.Google Scholar

4. Garrison, Dee, Apostles of Culture: The Public Librarian and American Society, 1876–1920 (New York, 1979).Google Scholar

5. Crunden, Robert M., Ministers of Reform: The Progressives' Achievement in American Civilization, 1889–1920 (Urbana, Ill., 1984).Google Scholar

6. Solomon, Barbara Miller, In the Company of Educated Women: A History of Women and Higher Education in America (New Haven, Conn., 1985), 118; Myerowitz, Joanne J., Women Adrift: Independent Wage Earners in Chicago, 1880–1930 (Chicago, 1988).Google Scholar

7. U.S. Bureau of Education, Public Libraries in the United States of America: Their History, Condition, and Management (Washington, D.C., 1876).Google Scholar

8. Maack, Mary Niles, “Women in Library Education: Up the Down Staircase,” Library Trends 34 (Winter 1986): 401–32.Google Scholar

9. Sharp, Katharine L. to Clarke, Louise, 12 Nov. 1897, and Sharp, to Thompson, Mary, 20 Dec. 1897, Library School Director's Letterpress, University of Illinois Archives, Urbana.Google Scholar

10. Williamson, Charles C., Training for Library Work (New York, 1921), 143.Google Scholar

11. Ahern, Mary E. to Simpson, Frances, 31 Mar. 1908, box 1, Library School Director's Office, General Correspondence, 1905–62, University of Illinois Archives; Ahern, to Marvin, Cornelia, 3 Dec. 1908, box 1, RGL8: 61–8/1, Oregon State Library Correspondence, Oregon State Archives, Salem.Google Scholar

12. Sharp to Kidder, Ida A., 19 Feb. 1907, Kidder Library School Alumni File, University of Illinois Archives.Google Scholar

13. Sharp to Henry, William E., 9 Mar. 1905, and 1 June 1905, L971, Indiana State Library Correspondence, Indiana State Archives, Indianapolis.Google Scholar

14. Kidder, to Hazeltine, Mary E., 5 Mar. 1909, Wisconsin Library School Placement Files, University of Wisconsin–Madison Archives; Dickey, Margaret H. to Miller, Zana K., Mar. 1909, box 3, ser. 1076, Wisconsin Free Library Commission, State Historical Society of Wisconsin Archives, Madison.Google Scholar

15. Hickey, Ethel A. to Secretary, , Wisconsin Free Library Commission, 24 Oct. 1910, Milner, Ida S. to Hazeltine, , 17 Dec. 1912, and Hitt, J. M. to Hazeltine, , 1907, Wisconsin Library School Placement Files.Google Scholar

16. Batterson, Mayme to Windsor, Phineas L., 11 Apr. 1910, Mayme Batterson Library School Alumni File, University of Illinois Archives.Google Scholar

17. Simpson, to Marvin, , 13 Dec. 1911, Mabel, G. West Library School Alumni File, University of Illinois Archives; Plummer, Mary Wright to Marvin, , 27 Nov. 1905, box 2, and Sharp, to Marvin, , 26 July 1906, box 12, RGL8: 61–8/1, Oregon State Library Correspondence; Sharp, to Henry, , 1 June 1905, L971, Indiana State Library Correspondence; and Rathbone, Josephine to Marvin, , 13 Dec. 1911, box 2, RGL8: 61/8–1, Oregon State Library Correspondence.Google Scholar

18. Hazeltine, to Reynolds, Mabel M., 19 Feb. 1910, and Hazeltine, to Blome, R. H. H., 12 Jan. 1912, Wisconsin Library School Placement Files.Google Scholar

19. Garver, Willia K. to Simpson, , 11 July 1907, and Garver, to Sharp, , 23 July 1907, Garver Library School Alumni File, University of Illinois Archives; Hazeltine, to Kiemle, Katherine, 22 May 1911, Wisconsin Library School Student Record, University of Wisconsin–Madison Archives.Google Scholar

20. Reynolds, to Sharp, , 15 Oct. 1901, Reynolds, Mabel M. Library School Alumni File, and Mabel G. West to Sharp, 21 Aug. 1900, West Library School Alumni File, University of Illinois Archives; Harriet A. Wood to Hazeltine, 27 Apr. 1909, 7/20/2–1, Mary E. Hazeltine General Correspondence; MacPherson, Maud R. to Hazeltine, , 15 Nov. 1912, Wisconsin Library School Placement Files.Google Scholar

21. Hazeltine, to Schauers, Jennie, 9 July 1908, Wisconsin Library School Placement Files; Katherine Wootten to Carrie Dailey, 21 Dec. 1907, Library School Alumni File, Special Collections Department, Emory University, Atlanta, Ga.; Sharp, to Jackson, Charlotte M., 31 May 1906, Library School Director's Letterpress, University of Illinois Archives.Google Scholar

22. Ahern, to Marvin, , 11 Jan. 1911, box 1, RGL8: 61/8–1, Oregon State Library Correspondence.Google Scholar

23. The New York State Library School, with Melvil Dewey and his male successors, attracted by far the most (approximately 20 percent) male students of any library school between 1887 and 1920.Google Scholar

24. Simpson, to Reynolds, , 26 Apr. 1906, Reynolds Library School Alumni File, University of Illinois Archives.Google Scholar

25. Kidder, to Sharp, , [Feb. 1907], Kidder Library School Alumni File; Sharp, to Lewis, Lucy M., 12 Nov. 1906, Library School Director's Letterpress, University of Illinois Archives.Google Scholar

26. Garver, to Sharp, , 15 Jan. 1907, Garver Library School Alumni File; Irene Warren to Sharp, 30 Oct. 1896, box 1, Sharp, Katharine L. Papers, and Forrest, Elizabeth to Sharp, , 10 Jan. 1907, Elizabeth Forrest Library School Alumni File, University of Illinois Archives; Batterson to Anna Price [1910], Batterson Library School Alumni File; Sharp to Evans, Laura B., 19 Oct. 1906, Library Director's Letterpress, University of Illinois Archives.Google Scholar

27. Gray, Lily to Sharp, , 30 Jan. 1907, Lily Gray Library School Alumni File, University of Illinois Archives; Sharp, to Henry, , 11 June 1902, L971, Indiana State Library Correspondence; Sharp, to Cheney, J. V., 12 Apr. 1901, Jones, Frances E. Library School Alumni File, and Sharp to Dean Kinley, 15 Apr. 1907, Josephine Meissner Library School Alumni File, University of Illinois Archives.Google Scholar

28. Hazeltine, to McIntyre, Mary J., 22 May 1907, Wisconsin Library School Placement Files.Google Scholar

29. Tyler, Alice S. to Marvin, , 16 June 1916, box 4, RGL8: 61/8–2, Plummer, to Wright, Ruth, 26 Apr. 1910, box 12, RGL8: 61/8–1, Young, Olive Pratt to Isom, Mary Frances, 23 Jan. 1908, box 2, RGL8: 61/8–1, Corwin, Ella F. to Henry, , 30 July 1909, box 2, RGL8: 61/8–1, and Young, to Isom, , 23 Jan. 1908, box 2, RGL8: 61/8–1, Oregon State Library Correspondence.Google Scholar

30. Reynolds, to Simpson, Frances, 18 Apr. 1906, and Simpson, to Reynolds, , 2 Apr. 1907, Reynolds Library School Alumni File.Google Scholar

31. Mrs. William Turple to Sharp, 1 Dec. 1896, Forrest Library School Alumni File.Google Scholar

32. Sharp, to Marvin, , 26 July 1906, box 12, RGL8: 61–8/1, Oregon State Library Correspondence, Walton, Genevieve M. to Hazeltine, , 10 June 1908, Lena Brownell Wisconsin Library School Student Record, University of Wisconsin–Madison Archives; Isom, to Marvin, , 22 Sep. 1911, box 17, RGL8: 61–8/1, Oregon State Library Correspondence.Google Scholar

33. Calhoun, Helen V. to Hitt, , 9 Aug. 1907, box 19, Washington State Library Correspondence, Washington State Archives, Olympia, Wash.; Hazeltine, to Jennings, Judson T., 3 June 1912, Wisconsin Library School Placement Files; Sharp, to Marvin, , 6 Dec. 1905, box 2, RGL8: 61/8–2, Oregon State Library Correspondence.Google Scholar

34. Hazeltine, to Hadley, Chalmers, 9 Mar. 1912, Wisconsin Library School Placement Files; Sharp, to Marvin, , 6 Dec. 1905, Library School Director's Correspondence, University of Illinois Archives; Hazeltine, to Fawcett, Eleanor, 29 Oct. 1918, Fawcett Library School Student Record, University of Wisconsin—Madison Archives.Google Scholar

35. Plummer, to Marvin, , 27 Nov. 1905, box 2, RGL8: 61/8–2, Oregon State Library Correspondence; Hazeltine to Hadley, 18 Apr. 1912, Wisconsin Library School Placement Files.Google Scholar

36. Sharp, to Blackwelder, Paul, 28 Nov. 1906, Library Director's Letterpress, and Sharp, to Hawley, Miss P. B., 9 Feb. 1904, Sparks, Marion E. Library School Alumni File, University of Illinois Archives.Google Scholar

37. Hazeltine, to Kidder, , 18 Mar. 1909, Hazeltine, to Blome, , 12 Jan. 1912, Wisconsin Library School Placement Files.Google Scholar

38. Hazeltine, to Sharp, , 27 Oct. 1906, Gray Library School Alumni File; Stearns, Lutie E. to Sharp, , 29 Jan. 1903, Reynolds Library School Alumni File.Google Scholar

39. MacPherson, Maud R. to Marvin, , 29 Mar. [1913], box 2, RGL8: 61–8/1, Oregon State Library Correspondence; Kidder, to Sharp, , [Feb. 1907], Kidder Library School Alumni File; Ahern, to Windsor, , 10 Oct. 1912, Osgood, Mary A. Library School Alumni File, University of Illinois Archives.Google Scholar

40. Marvin, to Ahern, , 19 Dec. 1914, box 1, RGL8: 61/8–1, Oregon State Library Correspondence.Google Scholar