Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dzt6s Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-22T15:53:01.416Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Deindustrialization and the Moral Economy of the Scottish Coalfields, 1947 to 1991

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 January 2014

Jim Phillips
Jim Phillips*
Affiliation:
University of Glasgow, UK
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The long-running deindustrialization in the Scottish coalfields, the consequence of political decisions, took place in three distinct periods analyzed here: “restructuring,” 1958–1967, when, in response to union activism, a large number of closures was offset by government and industry initiatives to provide or stimulate alternative employment; “stabilization,” 1968–1977, when closures were minimized as the broader industrial economy slowed; and then “accelerated contraction,” 1978–1987, within the larger program of economic restructuring engineered by Margaret Thatcher's Conservative UK governments. Moral economy arguments shaped the debate about deindustrialization in the first two phases: closures were legitimate only where agreed to by the workforce, who would in turn receive guaranteed economic security. These factors did not apply in the final phase, when closures were enforced and redundant miners had limited employment alternatives.

Type
Crumbling Cultures: Deindustrialization, Class, and Memory
Information
International Labor and Working-Class History , Volume 84: Crumbling Cultures: Deindustrialization, Class, and Memory , Fall 2013 , pp. 99 - 115
Copyright
Copyright © International Labor and Working-Class History, Inc. 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

NOTES

1. Bluestone, Barry and Harrison, Bennett, The Deindustrialization of America. Plant Closings, Community Abandonment, and the Dismantling of Basic Industry (New York, 1982)Google Scholar; Cowie, Jefferson and Heathcott, Joseph, “The Meanings of Deindustrialization,” in Beyond The Ruins. The Meanings of Deindustrialization, ed. Cowie, and Heathcott, (Ithaca, 2003), 1–15 Google Scholar; High, Steven, Industrial Sunset. The Making of North America's Rust Belt, 1969–1984 (Toronto, 2003)Google Scholar.

2. Devine, T. M., The Scottish Nation, 1700–2000 (London, 1999), 591–99Google Scholar; Finlay, Richard, Modern Scotland, 1914–2000 (London, 2004), 341–51Google Scholar; Harvie, Christopher, No Gods and Precious Few Heroes: Twentieth Century Scotland (Edinburgh, 1998), 164Google Scholar.

3. Cameron, Ewen A., Impaled Upon A Thistle: Scotland Since 1880 (Edinburgh, 2010), 236–44Google Scholar; Knox, W. W., Industrial Nation: Work, Culture and Society in Scotland, 1800-Present (Edinburgh, 1999), 254–64Google Scholar; Lee, C. H., Scotland and the United Kingdom: the Economy and the Union in the Twentieth Century (Manchester, 1995), 58–70 Google Scholar; Peden, G. C., “A New Scotland? The Economy,” in The Oxford Handbook of Scottish History, ed. Devine, T. M. and Wormald, Jenny (Oxford, 2012), 652–70Google Scholar.

4. Chang, Ha-Joon, 23 Things They Don't Tell You About Capitalism (London, 2010), 88–101 Google Scholar.

5. General Registry Office (hereafter GRO), Census 1971 Scotland: County Report, Fife (Edinburgh, 1973), 2Google Scholar.

6. Portelli, Alessandro, They Say in Harlan County. An Oral History (Oxford, 2011)Google Scholar.

7. Hutton, Guthrie, Fife: The Mining Kingdom (Ochiltree, 1999)Google Scholar.

8. Thompson, E. P., “The Moral Economy of the English Crowd in the Eighteenth Century,” Past and Present 50 (1971): 76–136 Google Scholar.

9. Tomlinson, J., “Reinventing the ‘Moral Economy’ in Post-war Britain,” Historical Research 84 (2011): 350–73Google Scholar.

10. Employment Policy (London, 1944), Cmnd. 6527, 15–20 Google Scholar.

11. The National Plan (London, 1965), Cmnd. 2764, 84–100, 120–22Google Scholar.

12. Ashworth, W., The History of the British Coal Industry, Volume 5, 1946–1982: The Nationalised Industry (Oxford, 1986), 261–62Google Scholar.

13. Cowie, Jefferson, Stayin' Alive: The 1970s and the Last Days of the Working Class (New York, 2011)Google Scholar.

14. Hood, Neil and Young, Stephen, Multinationals in Retreat: The Scottish Experience (Edinburgh, 1982)Google Scholar.

15. Phillips, Jim, Collieries, Communities and the Miners' Strike in Scotland, 1984–1985 (Manchester, 2012)Google Scholar.

16. Oglethorpe, Miles K., Scottish Collieries. An Inventory of the Scottish Coal Industry in the Nationalised Era (Edinburgh, 2006)Google Scholar, 20, Figures 3.8 and 3.9.

17. Tomlinson, J., “A ‘Failed Experiment’? Public Ownership and the Narratives of Post-war Britain,” Labour History Review 73 (2008): 199–214 Google Scholar.

18. Taylor, Andrew, The NUM and British Politics. Volume 1: 1944–1968 (Aldershot, 2003)Google Scholar.

19. Perchard, Andrew, The Mine Management Professions in the Twentieth-Century Scottish Coal Mining Industry (Lampeter and Lewiston, 2007), 216–64Google Scholar.

20. Eric Clarke, interview with author, Newtongrange, August 25, 2009.

21. Perchard, Andrew and Phillips, Jim, “Transgressing the Moral Economy: Wheelerism and Management of the Nationalised Coal Industry in Scotland,” Contemporary British History 25 (2011): 387–405 Google Scholar.

22. “Replanning a Coalfield,” Mining Review, 2nd Year, No. 10 (1949), directed by Peter Pickering, produced for Data Film Productions, sponsored by the National Coal Board (hereafter NCB), commentary by John Slater. The film features on the DVD, National Coal Board Collection, Volume One, Portrait of a Miner (London, 2009)Google Scholar.

23. Heughan, Hazel, Pit Closures at Shotts and the Migration of Miners (Edinburgh, 1953)Google Scholar.

24. William Page, Secretary, Mary Colliery Consultative Committee, to Mr. Gough, NCB Scottish Division (hereafter NCBSD), Fife Area, Assistant Surface Estates Manager, September 20, 1960, CB 353/3/1, National Records of Scotland (hereafter NRS).

25. Ashworth, British Coal Industry, 38–39, 678–79; Robens, Alf, Ten Year Stint (London, 1972), 58–87 and 88–108 Google Scholar.

26. George Bolton, Interview with Willie Thompson, May 1986.

27. The Guardian, June 24 and 27, 1959.

28. National Union of Mineworkers Scottish Area (hereafter NUMSA), Executive Committee (hereafter EC), June 29, 1959, National Mining Museum of Scotland (hereafter NMMS); The Times, June 26, 1959.

29. L. R. Milligan, Industrial Relations Director, NCBSD, to K. G. Smith, Secretary, NCBSD, June 17, 1959, and William Summers, Alloa Area General Manager, NCBSD, to K. G. Smith, Secretary, NCBSD, March 15, 1960, CB 276/14, NRS; NUMSA, EC, March 21, 1960, NMMS.

30. Perchard, Andrew, “The Mine Management Professions and the Dust Problem in the Scottish Coal Mining Industry, c. 1930–1966,” Scottish Labour History 40 (2005): 227Google Scholar.

31. Notes on the Special Consultative Meeting held to discuss the future of Mary Colliery, August 10, 1962, CB 353/14/1, and Notes on the Special Consultative Meeting held to discuss the future of Aitken Colliery, August 14, 1962, CB 201/14/2, both NRS.

32. NCBSD, Proposed Colliery Closures and Concentration; Manpower Redeployment West Fife, Aitken. Provisional Date April 25, 1959, CB 201/14/2, NRS.

33. W. Rowell, NCBSD, West Fife General Manager, to L. R. Milligan, NCBSD Industrial Relations Director, January 27, 1959, CB 201/14/2, NRS.

34. T. Scrimgeour, NCBSD, Fife Area General Manager, to L. R. Milligan, NCBSD Deputy Chairman, November 1, 1962, CB 201/14/2, NRS.

35. Notes on the Meeting of the Special Consultative Committee, together with Board and Trade Union representatives, to discuss the future of Aitken Colliery, November 28, 1962, CB 201/14/2, NRS.

36. Notes on the Special Consultative Meeting held to discuss the future of Mary Colliery, August 10, 1962, CB 353/14/1, NRS.

37. NUMSA, EC, August 13, 1962, NMMS.

38. Phillips, Jim, The Industrial Politics of Devolution: Scotland in the 1960s and 1970s (Manchester, 2008), 19–27 Google Scholar.

39. Bluestone and Harrison, Deindustrialization, 15.

40. Scott, Peter, “Regional Development and Policy,” in The Cambridge Economic History of Modern Britain. Volume III, Structural Change and Growth, 1939–2000, ed. Floud, Roderick and Johnson, Paul (Cambridge, 2004), 332–67Google Scholar.

41. Foster, John, “The Twentieth Century, 1914–1979,” in The New Penguin History of Scotland, ed. Houston, R. A. and Knox, W. W. J. (London, 2001), 467–72Google Scholar.

42. McKinlay, Alan and Knox, Bill, “Working for the Yankee Dollar. US Inward Investment and Scottish Labour, 1945–1970,” Historical Studies in Industrial Relations 7 (1999): 1–26 Google Scholar.

43. Cowling, David, An Essay For Today: The Scottish New Towns, 1947 to 1997 (Edinburgh, 1997)Google Scholar.

44. Oglethorpe, Scottish Collieries, 157–58.

45. Cowling, Scottish New Towns, 29–30.

46. GRO, Edinburgh, Census 1971 Scotland. Economic Activity: County Tables, Part II (Edinburgh, 1975)Google Scholar, Table 3.

47. Scottish Miner, December 1965.

48. Oglethorpe, Scottish Collieries, 175–76, 183–84.

49. NCBSD, Closure of Glencraig, no date, presumed March 1966, CB 305/5/1, NRS.

50. NUMSA, EC, May 9, 1966, NMMS.

51. Note of proceedings at the Meeting between representatives of the NCBSD and the NUMSA and SCEBTA [tradesmen's union], January 18, 1966, and Minute of Meeting on the Proposed Closure of Glencraig Colliery, March 11, 1966, both CB 305/5/1, NRS.

52. National Plan, 97, 100.

53. NCBSD, Closure of Glencraig, CB 305/5/1, NRS.

54. NCBSD Colliery Closures—Glencraig, note of a meeting between representatives of the NCB and the NUM, April 27, 1966, CB 305/5/1, NRS.

55. NUMSA, EC, May 30, 1966, NMMS.

56. Ministry of Power, Fire at Michael Colliery, Fife. Report on the causes of, and circumstances attending, the fire which occurred at Michael Colliery, Fife, on September 9, 1967, by H. S. Stephenson, H. M. Chief Inspector of Mines and Quarries (London, 1968)Google Scholar, Cmnd. 3657.

57. NCB, Scottish North Area (hereafter NCBSNA), Michael Colliery: Brief Report on Future Prospects, September 18, 1967, CB 360/21/1, NRS.

58. NCB, Michael Colliery, Press Statement, 11.30 a.m., November 21, 1967, CB 260/14/1, NRS.

59. John G. Fortheringham, on behalf of Trade Unions Committees at Michael Colliery, to Lord Robens, November 23, 1967, CB 260/14/1, NRS.

60. J. E. Pardoe, NCBSNA, Deputy Director, to James Hamill, Scottish Development Department, August 5, 1970, CB 260/14/1, NRS.

61. NCBSNA, Minute of Meeting regarding closure of Blairhall Colliery, March 11, 1969; McGahey to Rowell, April 23, 1969; Minute of Meeting to discuss the position of the men affected by the Blairhall Colliery, April 29, 1969; and Blairhall Colliery Closure: Redeployment Proposals after initial individual interviews, May 7, 1969; all in CB 235/5/5, NRS; NUMSA, EC, 8 April 1969 and May 12, 1969, NMMS.

62. NCBSNA, Place of Residence by Categories, Blairhall, week commencing February 28, 1969, CB 235/5/5, NRS.

63. Oglethorpe, Scottish Collieries, 28.

64. Ashworth, British Coal Industry, 256.

65. Ashworth, British Coal Industry, 263.

66. Ministry of Power, Fuel Policy (London, HMSO, 1967)Google Scholar, Cmnd. 3428; “Miners prepare for White Paper with black face,” The Guardian, November 14, 1967.

67. Portelli, Harlan County, 281–85.

68. High, Industrial Sunset, 167–91.

69. Phillips, Industrial Politics of Devolution, 37–39.

70. Campbell, Alan, The Scottish Miners, 1874–1939. Volume One: Work, Industry and Community; and Volume Two: Trade Unions and Politics (Aldershot, 2000)Google Scholar.

71. McIlroy, John and Campbell, Alan, “McGahey, Michael (Mick), (1925–1999),” in Dictionary of Labour Biography. Volume XIII (Houndmills, Basingstoke, 2010), ed. Gildart, Keith and Howell, David, 242–51Google Scholar.

72. Cowie, Stayin' Alive, 21–26.

73. Phillips, Industrial Politics of Devolution, 119–20.

74. Glasgow Herald, November 20, 1968 and December 2, 1968.

75. Scottish Miner, May 1971, and The Times, July 4, 1973.

76. Phillips, Industrial Politics of Devolution, 121–41.

77. NUMSA Annual Conference, Dumfries, June 14–16, 1967, Presidential Address, NMMS.

78. Oglethorpe, Scottish Collieries, 158–59.

79. NCBSD, Closure of Glencraig, CB 305/5/1, NRS.

80. Oglethorpe, Scottish Collieries, 81–82, 108, 138–41, 218, 227.

81. I. R. Duncan, Regional Development Division, St. Andrew's House, to A. H. J. Herpels, EEC Social Affairs Division, September 21, 1971, SEP 4/57, NRS.

82. W. Mackenzie, Regional Development Division, Burroughs Machines: background note, December 23, 1970, SEP 4/3869, NRS.

83. “Burroughs Image Losing its Shine,” The Scotsman, May 9, 1972, clipping, SEP 4/3550, NRS.

84. Regional Development Division, St. Andrew's House, Note for Lady Tweedsmuir's Visit to Glenrothes on March 2, 1971, SEP 4/57, NRS.

85. Glenrothes Develoment Corporation, Progress Report, Quarter Ended December 31, 1974, SEP 4/57, and “Burroughs Closing Glenrothes,” The Scotsman, March 2, 1982, clipping, SEP 4/3869, both NRS; Parliamentary Debates, Commons, Sixth Series, 20 (March 24, 1982), 376.

86. Andrew Taylor, The NUM and British Politics. Volume 2: 1969–1995 (Aldershot, 2005), 113–17.

87. Oglethorpe, Scottish Collieries, 20, 160–61.

88. Robinson, Colin and Marshall, Eileen, What Future for British Coal? Optimism or Realism on the Prospects to the Year 2000 (London, 1981)Google Scholar.

89. Hannah, Leslie, “A Failed Experiment: The State Ownership of Industry,” in Cambridge Economic History, eds. Floud, and Johnson, , 84–111 Google Scholar.

90. Ashworth, British Coal Industry, 414–15.

91. Monopolies and Mergers Commission, National Coal Board (London, 1983)Google Scholar, Cmnd.8920. Volume One, 363–66, and Volume Two, Appendices 3.3 and 3.5(a).

92. Cutler, T., Haslam, C., Williams, J., and Williams, K., “The Aberystwyth Report on Coal,” in Debating Coal Closures: Economic Calculation in the Coal Dispute, 1984–1985, eds. Cooper, D. and Hopper, T. (Cambridge, 1988), 161–94Google Scholar.

93. Glyn, A., “The Economic Case Against Pit Closures”, in Debating Coal Closures: Economic Calculation in the Coal Dispute, 1984–1985 (Cambridge, 1988), eds. Cooper, D. and Hopper, T., 57–94 Google Scholar.

94. NUMSA, EC, August 29, 1983, NMMS.

95. Iain McCaig, interview with Willie Thompson, March 12, 1986.

96. Brotherstone, Terry and Pirani, Simon, “Were There Alternatives? Movements from Below in the Scottish Coalfield, the Communist Party, and Thatcherism, 1981–1985,” Critique 36–37 (2005): 99–124 Google Scholar.

97. Phillips, Miners' Strike, 110–42.

98. Portelli, Harlan County, 344–65; Strangleman, Tim, “Networks, Place and Identities in Post-Industrial Mining Communities,” International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 25 (2001): 253–67Google Scholar.

99. Author calculations, based on GRO, Edinburgh, Census 1951 Scotland, Table 13; GRO, Edinburgh, Census 1971 Scotland. Economic Activity Tables (Edinburgh, HMSO, 1978)Google Scholar; GRO for Scotland, 1991 Census. Economic Activity. Scotland (Edinburgh, HMSO, 1994)Google Scholar, Table 11.

100. Oglethorpe, Scottish Collieries, passim.

101. Interview with Iain Chalmers, Cowdenbeath, July 30, 2009; Interview with Eric Clarke; Interview with Nicky Wilson, Culross, August 18, 2009.

102. EKOS, Evaluation of the Coalfields Regeneration Trust Activity in Scotland: Report for the Coalfields Regeneration Trust (Glasgow, 2009), 69–74 Google Scholar.