Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-8ctnn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-19T20:03:11.505Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

How Attachments to the Nation Shape Beliefs About the World: A Theory of Motivated Reasoning

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 April 2017

Richard K. Herrmann
Get access

Abstract

If competing beliefs about political events in the world stem largely from information asymmetries, then more information and knowledge should reduce the gap in competing perceptions. Empirical studies of decision making, however, often find just the reverse: as knowledge and the stakes in play go up, the beliefs about what is happening polarize rather than converge. The theory proposed here attributes this to motivated reasoning. Emotions inside the observer shape beliefs along with information coming from the outside world. A series of experiments embedded in a national survey of Americans finds that a primary driver of the beliefs someone forms about globalization, other countries, and the politics in the Middle East is how strongly they attach their social identity to the United States. Attachment produces more intense positive and negative emotions that in turn shape the interpretation of unfolding events and lead norms to be applied in an inconsistent fashion. People, in effect, rewrite reality around their favored course of action, marrying the logic of appropriateness to their own preferences. Beliefs, consequently, are not independent of preferences but related to them. Motivated reasoning, while not consistent with rational models, is predictable and can lead to expensive mistakes and double standards that undermine liberal internationalism.

Type
Research Article
Information
International Organization , Volume 71 , Supplement S1 , April 2017 , pp. S61 - S84
Copyright
Copyright © The IO Foundation 2017 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abdelal, Rawi, Herrera, Yoshiko M., Johnston, Alastair Iain, and McDermott, Rose. 2006. Identity as a Variable. Perspectives on Politics 4 (4):695–711.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Achen, Christopher H., and Snidal, Duncan. 1989. Rational Deterrence Theory and Comparative Case Studies. World Politics 41 (2):143–69.Google Scholar
Akerlof, George A., and Kranton, Rachel E.. 2010. Identity Economics: How Our Identities Shape Our Work, Wages, and Well-Being. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Baum, Matthew A., and Groeling, Tim. 2010. Reality Asserts Itself: Public Opinion on Iraq and the Elasticity of Reality. International Organization 64 (3):733–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bayram, A. Burcu. 2017. Due Deference: Cosmopolitan Social Identity and the Psychology of Legal Obligation in International Politics. In The Behavioral Revolution and International Relations, supplement. International Organization 71 (S1):S137–S163.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bechara, Antoine, Damasio, Hanna, Tranel, Daniel, and Damasio, Antonio. 1997. Deciding Advantageously before Knowing the Advantageous Strategy. Science 275 (5304):1293–95.Google Scholar
Behrendt, Hadar, and Ben-Ari, Rachel. 2012. The Positive Side of Negative Emotion: The Role of Guilt and Shame in Coping with Interpersonal Conflict. Journal of Conflict Resolution 56 (6):1116–38.Google Scholar
Brader, Ted, and Marcus, George E.. 2013. Emotions and Political Psychology. In The Oxford Handbook of Political Psychology, edited by Huddy, Leonie, Sears, David O., and Levy, Jack S., 165–204. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Brown, Rupert. 2000. Social Identity Theory: Past Achievements, Current Problems and Future Challenges. European Journal of Social Psychology 30 (6):745–78.Google Scholar
Carter, Jimmy. 1977. Address at Commencement Exercises. The American Presidency Project. Available at <http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu>..>Google Scholar
Castano, Emanuele, and Giner-Sorolla, Roger. 2006. Not Quite Human: Infrahumanization in Response to Collective Responsiblity for Intergroup Killing. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 90 (5):804–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cottam, Martha L., and Cottam, Richard W.. 2001. Nationalism and Politics: The Political Behavior of Nation States. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.Google Scholar
Cunningham, W.A., Van Bavel, J.J., and Johnsen, I.R.I.R. 2008. Affective Flexibility: Evaluative Processing Goals Shape Amygdala Activity. Psychological Science 19 (2):152–60.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Damasio, Antonio. 1994. Descartes’ Error: Emotion, Reason and the Human Brain. New York: Putnam.Google Scholar
Damasio, Antonio. 2010. Self Comes to Mind: Constructing the Conscious Brain. New York: Pantheon Books.Google Scholar
Desch, Michael C. 2007/08. America's Liberal Illiberalism: The Ideological Origins of Overreaction in US Foreign Policy. International Security 32 (3):7–43.Google Scholar
Fearon, James D. 1995. Rationalist Explanations for War. International Organization 49 (3):379–414.Google Scholar
Feinberg, Matthew, Willer, Robb, and Keltner, Dacher. 2012. Flustered and Faithful: Embarrassment as a Signal of Prosociality. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 102 (1):81–97.Google Scholar
Fischer, Agneta H., and Roseman, Ira J.. 2007. Beat Them or Ban Them: The Characteristics and Social Functions of Anger and Contempt. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 93 (1):103–15.Google Scholar
Fitzsimons, Gráinne M., and Shah, James Y.. 2008. How Goal Instrumentality Shapes Relationship Evaluations. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 95 (2):319–37.Google Scholar
Gartner, Scott Sigmund. 2008. The Multiple Effects of Casualties on Public Support for War: An Experimental Approach. The American Political Science Review 102 (1):95–106.Google Scholar
Gelb, Leslie, and Rosenthal, Justine A.. 2003. The Rise of Ethics in Foreign Policy: Reaching a Values Consensus. Foreign Affairs 82 (3):2–7.Google Scholar
Gelpi, Christopher. 2010. Performing on Cue? The Formation of Public Opinion toward War. Journal of Conflict Resolution 54 (1):88–116.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Glaser, Charles L. 2015. A US-China Grand Bargain? The Hard Choice Between Military Competition and Accommodation. International Security 39 (4):49–90.Google Scholar
Goff, Philip Atiba, Eberhardt, Jennifer L., Williams, Melissa J., and Jackson, Matthew Christian. 2008. Not Yet Human: Implicit Knowledge, Historical Dehumanization, and Contemporary Consequences. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 94 (2):292–306.Google Scholar
Gruenfeld, Deborah H., Inesi, M. Ena, Magee, Joe C., and Galinsky, Adam D.. 2008. Power and the Objectification of Social Targets. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 95 (1):111–27.Google Scholar
Hafner-Burton, Emilie, Haggard, Stephan, Lake, David A., and Victor, David G.. 2017. The Behavioral Revolution and International Relations. In The Behavioral Revolution and International Relations, supplement, International Organization 71 (S1):S1–S31.Google Scholar
Haidt, Jonathan. 2013. The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion. New York: Vintage.Google Scholar
Halperin, Eran, and Gross, James J.. 2011. Intergroup Anger in Intractable Conflict: Long-Term Sentiments Predict Anger Responses During the Gaza War. Group Processes and Intergroup Relations 14 (4):477–88.Google Scholar
Halperin, Eran, Russell, Alexandra G., Dweck, Carol S., and Gross, James J.. 2011. Anger, Hatred, and the Quest for Peace: Anger Can Be Constructive in the Absence of Hatred. Journal of Conflict Resolution 55 (2):274–91.Google Scholar
Haslam, Nick. 2006. Dehumanization: An Integrative Review. Personality and Social Psychology Review 10 (3):252–64.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Hastorf, Albert H., and Cantril, Hadley. 1954. They Saw a Game: A Case Study. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 49 (1):129–34.Google Scholar
Heider, Fritz. 1958. The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations. New York: John Wiley.Google Scholar
Herrmann, Richard K., and Fischerkeller, Michael P.. 1995. Beyond the Enemy Image and Spiral Model: Cognitive-Strategic Research after the Cold War. International Organization 49 (3):415–50.Google Scholar
Holsti, Ole R. 2004. Public Opinion and American Foreign Policy. Revised Edition. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
Holsti, Ole R., and Rosenau, James N.. 1984. American Leadership in World Affairs: Vietnam and the Breakdown of Consensus. Boston: Allen and Unwin.Google Scholar
Huddy, Leonie, and Khatib, Nadia. 2007. American Patriotism, National Identity, and Political Involvement. American Journal of Political Science 51 (1):63–77.Google Scholar
Huddy, Leonie, Sears, David O., and Levy, Jack, eds. 2013. The Oxford Handbook of Political Psychology. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Hurwitz, Jon, and Peffley, Mark. 1987. How Are Foreign Policy Attitudes Structured? A Hierarchial Model. American Political Science Review 81 (4):1099–120.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hurwitz, Jon, and Peffley, Mark. 1990. Public Images of the Soviet Union: The Impact on Foreign Policy Attitudes. The Journal of Politics 52 (1):3–28.Google Scholar
Jervis, Robert. 1970. The Logic of Images in International Relations. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Jervis, Robert. 1976. Perception and Misperception in International Politics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Jervis, Robert. 1989. Rational Deterrence: Theory and Evidence. World Politics 41 (2):183–207.Google Scholar
Jervis, Robert. 2010. Why Intelligence Fails: Lessons from the Iranian Revolution and the Iraq War. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Kahneman, Daniel. 2011. Thinking, Fast and Slow. New York: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux.Google Scholar
Kull, Steven, and Destler, I.M.. 1999. Misreading the Public: The Myth of a New Isolationism. Washington DC: Brookings Institution Press.Google Scholar
Kunda, Z. 1990. The Case for Motivated Reasoning. Psychology Bulletin 108 (3):480–98.Google Scholar
Lake, David A. 2010/11. Two Cheers for Bargaining Theory: Assessing Rationalist Explanations of the Iraq War. International Security 35 (3):7–52.Google Scholar
Lebow, Richard Ned. 1981. Between Peace and War: The Nature of International Crisis. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
Lebow, Richard Ned, and Stein, Janice Gross. 1989. Rational Deterrence Theory: I Think, Therefore I Deter. World Politics 41 (2):208–24.Google Scholar
Liberman, Peter. 2006. An Eye for an Eye: Public Support for War Against Evildoers. International Organization 60 (3):687–722.Google Scholar
Liff, Adam P., and Ikenberry, G. John. 2014. Racing toward Tragedy? China's Rise, Military Competition in the Asia Pacific, and the Security Dilemma. International Security 39 (2):52–91.Google Scholar
Locke, John. (1690) 1959. An Essay Concerning Human Understanding. Collated and annotated by Fraser, Alexander Campbell. New York: Dover Publications.Google Scholar
Lodge, Milton, and Taber, Charles S.. 2013. The Rationalizing Voter. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mackie, Diane M., Devos, Thierry, and Smith, Eliot R.. 2000. Intergroup Emotions: Explaining Offensive Action Tendencies in an Intergroup Context. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 79 (4):602–16.Google Scholar
Mansfield, Edward D., and Mutz, Diana C.. 2009. Support for Free Trade: Self-Interest, Sociotropic Politics, and Out-Group Anxiety. International Organization 63 (3):425–57.Google Scholar
Maoz, Ifat, Ward, Andrew, Katz, Michael, and Ross, Lee. 2002. Reactive Devaluation of an “Israeli” Vs. “Palestinian” Peace Proposal. Journal of Conflict Resolution 46 (4):515–46.Google Scholar
McDermott, Rose. 1998. Risk-Taking in International Politics: Prospect Theory in American Foreign Policy. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
McDoom, Omar Shahabudin. 2012. The Psychology of Threat in Intergroup Conflict: Emotions, Rationality, and Opportunity in the Rwandan Genocide. International Security 37 (2):119–55.Google Scholar
Mercer, Jonathan. 2010. Emotional Beliefs. International Organization 64 (1):1–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Miller, Patrick R. 2011. The Emotional Citizen: Emotion as a Function of Political Sophistication. Political Psychology 32 (4):575–600.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Monten, Jonathan. 2005. The Roots of the Bush Doctrine: Power, Nationalism, and Democracy Promotion in US Strategy. International Security 29 (4):112–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morgenthau, Hans J. 1973. Politics Among Nations: The Struggle for Power and Peace. 5th ed. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.Google Scholar
Page, Benjamin I., and Bouton, Marshall M.. 2006. The Foreign Policy Disconnect: What Americans Want from Our Leaders But Don't Get. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Pew. 2004. A Year After Iraq: Mistrust of American in Europe Ever Higher, Muslim Anger Persists. 16 March. <http://www.pewglobal.org/2004/03/16/a-year-after-iraq-war/>>Google Scholar
Rapport, Aaron. 2012. The Long and Short of It: Cognitive Constraints on Leaders’ Assessments of “Postwar” Iraq. International Security 37 (3):133–71.Google Scholar
Rathbun, Brian C. 2007. Hierarchy and Community at Home and Abroad: Evidence of a Common Structure of Domestic and Foreign Policy Beliefs in American Elites. Journal of Conflict Resolution 51 (3):379–407.Google Scholar
Redlawsk, David P., Civettini, Andrew J.W., and Emmerson, Karen M.. 2010. The Affective Tipping Point: Do Motivated Reasoners Ever “Get It”? Political Psychology 31 (4):563–93.Google Scholar
Reeder, Glenn D., Pryor, John B., Wohl, Michael J.A., and Griswell, Michael L.. 2005. On Attributing Negative Motives to Others Who Disagree with Our Opinions. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 31 (11):1498–510.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Renshon, Jonathan, J. Lee, Julia, and Tingley, Dustin. 2017. Emotions and the Micro-Foundations of Commitment Problems. In The Behavioral Revolution and International Relations, supplement, International Organization 71 (S1):S189–S217.Google Scholar
Rho, Sungmin, and Tomz, Michael. 2017. Why Don't Trade Preferences Reflect Economic Self-Interest? In The Behavioral Revolution and International Relations, supplement, International Organization 71 (S1):S85–S108.Google Scholar
Rosen, Gary, ed. 2005. The Right War? The Conservative Debate on Iraq. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rothschild, Zachary K., Landau, Mark J., Sullivan, Daniel, and Keefer, Lucas A.. 2012. A Dual-Motive Model of Scapegoating: Displacing Blame to Reduce Guilt or Increase Control. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 102 (6):1148–63.Google Scholar
Schultz, Kenneth A. 2001. Democracy and Coercive Diplomacy. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Schultz, Kenneth A. 2005. The Politics of Risking Peace: Do Hawks or Doves Deliver the Olive Branch? International Organization 59 (1):1–38.Google Scholar
Silverstein, Brett. 1989. Enemy Images: The Psychology of US Attitudes and Cognitions Regarding the Soviet Union. American Psychologist 44 (6):903–13.Google Scholar
Steinbruner, John D. 1974. The Cybernetic Theory of Decision: New Dimensions of Political Analysis. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Sullivan, D., Landau, M.J., Branscombe, N.R., and Rothschild, Z.K.. 2012. Competitive Victimhood as a Response to Accusations of Ingroup Harm Doing. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 102 (4):778–95.Google Scholar
Sullivan, John L., Fried, Amy, and Dietz, Mary G.. 1992. Patriotism, Politics, and the Presidential Election of 1988. American Journal of Political Science 36 (1):200–34.Google Scholar
Taber, Charles S., and Lodge, Milton. 2006. Motivated Skepticism in the Evaluation of Political Beliefs. Amercian Journal of Political Science 50 (3):755–69.Google Scholar
Tagar, Michael R., Federico, Christopher M., and Halperin, Eran. 2011. The Positive Effect of Negative Emotions in Protracted Conflict: The Case of Anger. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 47 (1):157–64.Google Scholar
Tajfel, Henri. 1981. Human Groups and Social Categories. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Thibodeau, Paul, Peebles, Matthew M., Grodner, Daniel J., and Durgin, Frank H.. 2015. The Wished-for Always Wins until the Winner Was Inevitable All Along: Motivated Reasoning and Belief Bias Regulate Emotion During Elections. Political Psychology 36 (4):431–48.Google Scholar
Thrall, A. Trevor. 2007. A Bear in the Woods? Threat Framing and the Marketplace of Values. Security Studies 16 (3):452–88.Google Scholar
Tingley, Dustin. 2017. Rising Power on the Mind. In The Behavioral Revolution and International Relations, supplement, International Organization 71 (S1):S165–S188.Google Scholar
Vertzberger, Yaacov Y.I. 1990. The World in Their Minds: Information Processing, Cognition, and Perception in Foreign Policy Decisionmaking. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
West, Richard F., Meserve, Russell J., and Stanovich, Keith E.. 2012. Cognitive Sophistication Does Not Attenuate the Bias Blind Spot. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 103 (3):506–19.Google Scholar
Yarhi-Milo, Keren. 2014. Knowing the Adversary: Leaders, Intelligence, and Assessment of Intentions in International Relations. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar