2 Giliomee, , The Afrikaners, 286Google Scholar.

3 Lewsen, Phyllis, Reverberations -A Memoir (Cape Town 1996) 110Google Scholar.

4 University of Stellenbosch Library, A.C. Cilliers, Collection, Letter to editor of Union Review, 26 January 1945.

5 Duncan, Patrick, The Road Through the Wilderness (Johannesburg 1953)Google Scholar; See also Scholtz, G.D., Het die Afrikaanse volk ‘n toekoms? (Johannesburg 1955) 126–131Google Scholar.

6 Yudelman, David, The Emergence of South Africa (Westport 1983) 13–14Google Scholar. For a similar view, holding that the difference between the English and the Afrikaners on the race question is a ‘a difference of degree and not of principle’, see Welsh, David, ‘English-speaking Whites and the Racial Problem’ in: Villiers, André de ed., English-speaking South Africa Today (Cape Town 1976) 236Google Scholar.

7 Hexham, Irving, ‘Letter to the Editor’, National Post (Canada) 11 Oct. 1999Google Scholar.

8 Breytenbach, Breyten, Dog Heart (Cape Town 1998) 185Google Scholar.

9 Moodie, T. Dunbar, The Rise of Afrikanerdom (Berkeley 1975)Google Scholar.

10 Schoeman, Karel first made this point about the song in his Die Laaste Afrikaanse Boek (Cape Town 2002) 164Google Scholar.

11 Gerwel, C.J., ‘Afrikaner, Afrikaans, Afrika’, address to Afrikaanse Skrywersgilde, 20 May 1976Google Scholar.

12 van der Walt, Johan, ‘Lewe na die taal se selfmoord’, Rapport, 14 Sept 2003Google Scholar.

13 Thompson, Leonard, The Unification of South Africa (Cape Town 1960) 135Google Scholar.

14 van der Merwe, N.J., Marthinus Theunis Steyn (Cape Town 1921) 227–279Google Scholar; Malan, F.S., Die Konvensie-Dagboek (Cape Town 1951) 41Google Scholar; Thompson, , Unification, 192–198Google Scholar.

15 May, Henry John, The South African Constitution (Cape Town 1955) 623Google Scholar.

16 Preller, Gustav, ‘The Union and the Boer’, The State 1, 6 (1909) 638Google Scholar.

17 Markham, Violet, The South African Scene (London 1913) 187Google Scholar.

18 Nicholls, G. Heaton, South Africa in my Time (London 1961) 283Google Scholar.

19 Engelenburg, F., Louis Botha (London 1929) 230Google Scholar.

20 Louw, N.P. van Wyk, Versamelde Prosa 2 (Cape Town 1986) 350.Google Scholar(The article was first published in 1957.)

21 Omotoso, Kole, Season of Migration to the South (Cape Town 1994) 114Google Scholar.

22 Wilkins, Ivor, ‘This Man who Guides the Ordinary People’, Sunday Times, 19 April 1981Google Scholar.

23 Breytenbach, Breyten, ‘The Alienation of White South Africa’ in: Guma, Alex la ed., Apartheid (New York 1977) 142Google Scholar.

24 A perceptive account is by Bruyn, Johannes du, ‘Swartes in die Afrikaner geskiedskrywing’ in: Bredekamp, H.C. ed., Afrikaanse Geskiedskryuiing en Letterkun.de: Hede, Verlede en Toekoms (Bellville 1992) 71–85Google Scholar.

25 Heever, C.M. van den, ‘Die Afrikaanse gedagte’ in: Heever, C.M. van den and Pienaar, P. de V. eds, Die Kultuurgeskiedenis van die Afrikaner 3 (Kaapstad 1950) 1–32Google Scholar. This is also a leading theme in the work of Scholtz, G.D., Die Ontwikkeling van die Politieke Denke van die Afrikaner 8 (Johannesburg 1967-1984)Google Scholar and Klerk, W.A. de, Puritans in Africa (Harmonds-worth 1975)Google Scholar. See also the work of Jaarsveld, F.A. van, Die Ontwaking van ‘n Afrikaner Neisionale Beujussyn, 1868-1881 (Johannesburg 1959)Google Scholar. The latter work is a sophisticated essay, but the basic idea is still that of people ‘waking up’ to the idea of belonging to a volk rather than that of political and cultural entrepreneurs cultivating and propagating such an idea.

26 Grundlingh, Albert, ‘Politics, Principles and Problems of a Profession: Afrikaner Historians and their Discipline, c. 1920 - c. 1965’, Perspectives in Education 12 (1990) 11Google Scholar.

27 Robinson, Joan, Economic Philosophy (London 1962) 42Google Scholar.

28 Hutt, W.H., The Economics of the Colour Bar (London 1964) 42Google Scholar.

29 For a statement by a Stellenbosch contemporary of mine see Kapp, Pieter, Verantwoorde. Verlede: Die Verhaal van die Studie van Geskiedenis aan die (Universiteit van Stellenbosch, 1904-2004 (Stellenbosch 2004)Google Scholar.

30 Gooch, G.P., History and Historians in the Nineteenth Century (London 1952) 72–97Google Scholar.

31 Naipul, V.S., The Return of Eva Peron (New York 1980) 99Google Scholar.

32 Wright, Harrison, The Burden of the Present (Cape Town 1977)Google Scholar.

33 Moodie, , The Rise of Afrikanerdom, ix, 15Google Scholar.

34 Furlong, Patrick, Between Crown and Swastika: The Impact of the Radical Right on the Afrikaner Nationalist Movement in the Fascist Era (Johannesburg 1991) 102, 224–226Google Scholar.

35 For a critical study see my ‘The Making of the Apartheid Plan’, Journal of Southern African Studies 29/2 (2003) 373–392Google Scholar.

36 Schöpflin, George, ‘Nationalism and National Minorities’, Journal of International Affairs 45/1 (1991) 51–52Google Scholar.

37 For a recent multi-facetted discussion see Schlemmer, Lawrence, ‘Factors in the Persistence or Decline of Ethnic Group Mobilisation: A Conceptual Review and Case Study of Cultural Group Responses among Afrikaners in Post-apartheid South Africa’ (Doctoral diss. UCT 1999) 25–86Google Scholar.

38 Olivier, Gerrit, N.P. van Wyk Louiv (Cape Town 1992) 216–217Google Scholar.

39 Sanders, M., ‘Complicities: On the Intellectual’ (Doctoral diss. Columbia University 1998) 232Google Scholar.

40 Walzer, Michael, The Company of Critics: Social Criticism and Political Commitment in the Twentieth Century (New York 1988)Google Scholar.

41 Walzer, Michael, Interpretation and Social Criticism (Cambridge 1987) 58Google Scholar.

42 See the incisive analysis by Louw, Andrew Nash of and Degenaar, in his ‘The Dialectical Tradition in South Africa’ (Doctoral diss. University of Cape Town 2000) 140–164Google Scholar.

43 See particularly his Voortbestaan in Geregtigheid (Cape Town 1980)Google Scholar.

44 Elphick, Richard and Giliomee, Hermann eds, The Shaping of South African Society, 1652-1840 (Cape Town 1979)Google Scholar.

45 Thompson, Leonard ed., Oxford History of South Africa (co-edited by Wilson, Monica); the two volumes came out in 1969 and 1971Google Scholar.

46 Legassick, Martin, ‘The Frontier Tradition in South African Historiography’ in: Marks, Sheila and Atmore, Anthony eds, Economy and Society in Pre-lndustrial South Africa (London 1980) 44–79Google Scholar.

47 May, Stephen, Language and Minority Rights: Ethnicity, Nationalism and the Politics of Language (Harlow 2001) 7–16Google Scholar.

48 O'Meara, Dan, Volkskapitalisme, Class, Capital and Ideology in the Development of Afrikaner Nationalism, 1934-1948 (Cambridge 1983)Google Scholar.

49 Steenekamp, T.J., ‘n Ekonomiese ontleding van sosio-politieke groepvorming met spesiale verwysing na die Afrikaner’ (Doctoral diss. Unisa 1989) 206–209Google Scholar.

50 Scribner, Charles, Moral Man and Immoral Society (New York 1932)Google Scholar.

51 Cited in Marquard, Leo, South Africa and Her People (London 1957) 136Google Scholar.

52 Alexander, Peter, Alan Paton (Oxford 1994) 300Google Scholar.

53 Adam, , Modernizing Racial Domination: South Africa's Political Dynamics (California 1971)Google Scholar.

54 H Giliomee, ermann, ‘Afrikaner Politics’ in: Adam, Heribert and Giliomee, Hermann, Ethnic Power Mobilized: Can South Africa Change? (New Haven 1979) 256–257Google Scholar.

55 Woodward, C. Vann. ‘The Search for Southern Identity’ in: The Burden of Southern History (Vintage Books, 1960)Google Scholar.

56 Woodward, C. Vann, The Burden of Southern History (New York 1960) 18–21Google Scholar.

57 Warren, Robert Penn, Segregation: The Inner Conflict in the South (New York 1956) 115Google Scholar.

58 Saunders, Christopher, The Making of the South African Past (Cape Town 1988) 3Google Scholar.

59 Review by Wright, John, South Africa International 19/2 (1988) 107Google Scholar.

60 Giliomee, Hermann, ‘The Communal Nature of the Conflict’ in: Giliomee, Hermann and Schlemmer, Lawrence eds, Negotiating South Africa's Future (New York 1989) 114–129CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

61 Giliomee, Hermann and Schlemmer, Lawrence, From Apartheid to Nation-building (Cape Town 1990) 156Google Scholar.

62 Giliomee, Hermann, ‘The Elusive Search for Peace’ in: Giliomee, Hermann and Gagiano, Jannie eds, The Elusive Search for Peace: South Africa, Israel and Northern Ireland (Cape Town 1990) 310Google Scholar. See also my ‘Afrikaner Politics, 1977-1987: From Afrikaner Nationalist Rule to Central State Hegemony’ in: Brewer, John ed., Can South Africa Survive: Five Minutes to Midnight (London 1989) 108–135CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

63 Mbeki, Thabo, Africa: The Time Has Come (Cape Town 1998) 8–26Google Scholar.

64 For a debate that took place just after the conference among Breyten Breytenbach, Jordan, Pallo and myself see Die Suid-Afrikaan 13 (February 1988) 22–29Google Scholar.

65 My review of the book was published in South Africa International 21/3-4 (1991) 183–190Google Scholar.

66 Cape Times, 9 April 2003Google Scholar. For a critique of Sparks's view of contemporary South Africa see Johnson's, R.W. review of his latest book Beyond the Miracle in the Culture section of the (London)Google ScholarSunday Times, 17 August 2003Google Scholar.

67 Woodward, C. Vann, Thinking Back: The Perils of Writing History (Louisiana 1986) 114–115Google Scholar.

68 Kiewiet, C.W. de, Anatomy of South African Misery (London 1957) 45Google Scholar.

69 Foster, Roy, ‘Fashion for Apology Can Invite Danger of Amnesia’, Sunday Independent, 25 July 1999Google Scholar.

70 Judt, Tony, ‘The Story of Everything’, New York Review of Books, 21 Sep. 2000, 66Google Scholar.

71 Piterberg, Gabriel, ‘Hannah Arendt in Tel Aviv’, New Left Review 21 (2001) 145Google Scholar.

72 Text of speech at the ceremony where he received the Alan Paton prize for 1998.

73 Stone, Lawrence, ‘The Revival of Narrative’, Past and Present 85 (Nov. 1979) 3–24CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

74 I elaborate on Schoeman's comments on my drafts in a contribution to the book of essays on him edited by Burger, Willie and Vuuren, Helize van eds, Sluiswagters by die dam van stemme (Pretoria 2002) 98–106Google Scholar.

75 Butterfield, Herbert, The Whig Interpretation of the Past (New York 1965) 28Google Scholar.

76 Comments by F. A. van Jaarsveld in an interview with him conducted in 1992. See Blussé, Leonard et al., Pilgrims to the Past (Leiden 1996) 269Google Scholar.

77 Ferguson, Niall, Virtual History: Alternatives and Counter-factuals (London 1997) 1Google Scholar.

78 Alexander, , Alan Paton, 387Google Scholar.

79 Louw, N.P. van Wyk, ‘Die Versamelde Verse van Jan Celliers’, Standpunte 1/3-4 (1946) 34Google Scholar.

80 Ribeiro, Luiz Fernando Ferreira da Rose, ‘Apartheid and Democracia Racial: South Africa and Brazil in Contrast’ (Doctoral diss. University of Utrecht, 1960) 33Google Scholar.

81 Mazrui, Alt A., The African Condition: A Political Diagnosis (London 1980)Google Scholar.

82 Text of testimony of F.W. de Klerk to TRC hearing, 14 May 1997.

83 Cape Times, 19 Feb. 1998Google Scholar; Die, Burger, 19 Feb. 1998Google Scholar.

84 Meiring, Piet, Kroniek van die Waarheidskommissie (Vanderbijlpark 1999) 336–337Google Scholar.

85 Hobsbawm, Eric, Interesting Times: A Twentieth-Century Life (London 2002) 417Google Scholar.

86 Horowitz, Donald, Ethnic Groups in Conflict (California 1985)Google Scholar; Huntington, Samuel and Nelson, Joan, No Easy Choice: Political Participation in Developing Countries (Harvard 1976)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

87 Ferguson, , Virtual History, 2Google Scholar. I wish to thank Jannie Gagiano for discussing this issue with me.

88 Seekings, Jeremy, ‘Providing for the Poor: Welfare and Redistribution in South Africa,’ Inaugural lecture, University of Cape Town, 23 April 2003Google Scholar.

89 Fukuyama, Frances, Trust: The Social Virtues and the Creation of Prosperity (New York 1995) 44–45Google Scholar.

90 I am drawing here on an article by Chua, Amy L, ‘Democracy and Ethnicity’, The Yale Law Journal 81 (1998) 1–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar and her book World on Fire (New York 2003)Google Scholar.

91 Huntington, and Nelson, , No Easy Choice, 19–25Google Scholar; Horowitz, , Ethnic Groups in Conflict;Google Scholar and Chua, , ‘Markets, Democracy’Google Scholar.

92 Gann, Lewis, ‘Liberal Interpretations of South African History’, Rhodes-Livingstone Journal 25 (1959) 40–57Google Scholar.

93 Horowitz, , Ethnic Groups in Conflict, 95–140Google Scholar.

94 Berlin, Isaiah, The Crooked Timber of Humanity (New York 1992) 13Google Scholar.

95 Ignatieff, Michael, ‘The Politics of Destruction’, New York Review of Books (2 Sep. 1995) 25Google Scholar.

96 Hoernlé, R.F. Alfred, Race and Reason (Johannesburg 1945) 96–97Google Scholar.

97 The Star, 25 Sep. 1931Google Scholar; Die Vaderland, 18 June 1935Google Scholar.

98 Paton, Alan, Hofmeyr (Cape Town 1971) 232Google Scholar.

99 Millar, Roberta, ‘Science and Society in the Early Career of H.F. Verwoerd’, Journal of Southern African Studies 19/4 (1993)Google Scholar.

100 It was published also in Cillie, Piet, Baanbrekers vir die Vryheid (Cape Town 1990) 60–76, the quotes are on 65Google Scholar.

101 Cape Times, 14 June 2001Google Scholar.

102 Davenport, Rodney, South Africa: A Modem History (Johannesburg 1987) 541Google Scholar.

103 Davenport, Rodney, ‘History in South Africa in the 1980s’, South Africa International 19/2 (1988) 99Google Scholar.

104 Hancock, W.K., Smuts Fields of Force 2 (Cambridge 1968) 229Google Scholar. For an in-depth discussion of race issues under the Smuts government see Brits, J.P., Op die vooraand van apartheid: Die rassevraagstuk en die blanke politiek in Suid-Afrika (Pretoria 1994)Google Scholar.

105 Goldstone, Richard, ‘Foreword’ in: Minow, Martha, Between Vengeance and Forgiveness (Boston 1998) xiiiGoogle Scholar.

106 Die Suid-Afrikaan 5 (1985) 21–23Google Scholar.

107 Tutu, Desmond, ‘Foreword’ in: Davenport, Rodney and Saunders, Christopher, South Africa: A Modern History (Johannesburg 2000) xixGoogle Scholar.

108 Mulholland, Stephen, ‘Saddam Hussein’, Finance Week, 11 June 2003Google Scholar.

109 Kiewiet, C.W. de, ‘Loneliness in the Beloved Country’, Foreign Affairs 42/3-4 (1964) 413–427CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

110 Time, 26 Aug. 1966, 25Google Scholar.

111 Die Burger, 27 Sep. 2003Google Scholar.

112 Gordin, Jeremy, ‘Move our Marx, Focus on Women and Religion’, The Star, 19 June 2003Google Scholar.

113 ‘The ties that bound’, The Economist, 19 July 2003, 68–69Google Scholar.