Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-gb8f7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T10:39:49.818Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

What is Freedom? Competing Notions of Rights & Responsibilities in the French Caribbean

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 April 2010

Extract

According to Frantz Fanon, decolonisation starts out as ‘a programme of complete disorder’. This idea is interestingly echoed in the Creole expression ‘ce on dezod ka me lod’, which translated means that through chaos comes order. In 1998–1999 Martinique lost 23,000 working days; strikers blockaded the ports of Pointe à Pitre in Guadeloupe and Fort de France in Martinique for several weeks at a time in 1998. Trade unions have built up membership levels of eighty to ninety per cent in hotels and in public administration. In this article we will be examining some of the consequences and causes of new forms of socio-economic action and political protest that have emerged in the French Caribbean since the end of the Cold War. For a long time, the French Caribbean was a haven of relative calm and prosperity in the Caribbean. The Dutch Antilles and Aruba and the British dependent territories (now renamed UK Overseas Territories) have also generally shared this good fortune. Today the relative prosperity of the non-sovereign territories is becoming more marked as independent Caribbean states slip into economic recession and growing poverty, so that their political systems and leaders face an endemic crisis of political legitimacy.

Type
Conference: ‘Costs and Benefits of Independence in the Caribbean’
Copyright
Copyright © Research Institute for History, Leiden University 2001

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1 Wolfe, M., Elusive Development (London 1996) 170.Google ScholarPubMed

2 Glissant, Edouard et al. , Le Monde (21 January 2000).Google Scholar

3 Fanon, Frantz, The Wretched of the Earth (Harmondsworth 1963) 29.Google Scholar

4 Reverier, Jean-Loup, ‘DOM: La Nouvelle Donne’, Le Point (25 June 1999) 69.Google Scholar

5 Hintjens, Helen, ‘Governance Options in Europe's Caribbean Dependencies’, The Round Table 344 (1997) 533547.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

6 La Tribune (12 February 1999).

7 Ryan, Selwyn, ‘La Crise de Gouvemabilité dans la Caraibe Anglophone’ in: Constant, Fred and Daniel, Justin eds, Politique el Développement dans les Caraibes (Paris 1999) 2949Google Scholar; Maharaj, Niala, ‘Pathology and Power: The Failure of Democracy in the Caribbean’ in: Hippler, J. ed., The Democratisation of Disempowerment (London 1995) 109125Google Scholar and Ramharack, B., ‘Drug Trafficking and Money Laundering in the Caribbean Mini-states and Dependent Territories: The US response’, The Round Table 335 (1995) 319341.Google Scholar

8 Payne, Tony, ‘L'Alena et la Caraibe: quelles perspectives d’avenir? in: Constant, Fred and Daniel, Justin eds, Politique et DéveloppementGoogle Scholar, Thomas, Clive, ‘Globalisation, Structural Adjustment and Security: The Collapse of the Post-colonial Development State in the Caribbean’, Global Development Studies 1/1–2 (1998).Google Scholar

9 Yurick, S., ‘The Emerging Metastate versus the Politics of Ethno-nationalist Identity’ in: Nederveen, Jan and Parekh, Biku eds, The Decolonization of Imagination: Culture, Knowledge and Power (London 1995) 207.Google Scholar

10 Daniel, Justin, ‘Crise ou mutations des institutions: la quête de nouveaux modèles’ in: Constant, Fred and Daniel, Justin eds, Politique et Développement, 99153.Google Scholar

11 Libération (25 October 1999).

12 Abrams, Elliott, ‘The Shiprider Solution’, The National Interest (Spring 1996), also available on www.eppc.org/publications.Google Scholar

13 Aldrich, Robert and Connell, John, The Last Colonies (Cambridge 1998) 249.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

14 Miles, William, Bridging Mental Boundaries in a Postcolonial Microcosm: Identity and Development in Vanuatu (Honolulu 1998) 14.Google Scholar

15 Thomas, ‘Globalization’.

16 Gosling, D., ‘Obligations of Affluent Nations to the Poor in the Situation of “Radical Inequality”’ in: Twining, W. ed., Issues of Self-Determination (Aberdeen 1991) 59.Google Scholar

17 Massiah, J., ‘Women's Lives and Livelihoods: A View from the Commonwealth Caribbean’, World Development 17/7 (1989) 965.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

18 Lowenthal, David and Clarke, Colin, ‘Island Orphans: Barbuda and the Rest’, The Journal of Commonwealth and Comparative Politics 18/3 (1980) 300.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

19 Galap, Jean, ‘Stratégies identitaires des martiniques en milieu interculturel’, Cahiers d'Anthropologie et Biometrie Humaine 11/3–4 (1993) 290.Google Scholar

20 Ibid., 286.

21 Burton, Richard, ‘“Maman-France Doudou”: Family Images in French West Indian Colonial Discourse’, Diacritics 23/3 (1993).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

22 Ibid.; Hintjens, Helen, Alternatives to Independance: Explorations in Post-Colonial Relations (Aldershot 1995).Google Scholar

23 Galap, ‘Stratégies identitaires’, 291–296.

24 Burton, ‘Family Images’, 86.

25 The pun in the title of this section refers to the Free-DOM radio, television station and political movement started in the 1990s, in another French overseas department, Réunion in the Indian Ocean.

26 Galap, ‘Stratégies identitaires’, 305.

27 Ibid., 306.

28 Giraud, Michel, ‘Les identités Antillaises: entre négritude et créolité’, Cahiers des Amériques Latines 17 (1994) 141156.Google Scholar

29 Burton, ‘Family Images’, 77–78.

30 Le Monde (28 April 1998).

31 Le Monde (31 May 1998).

32 Le Monde (25 April 1998).

33 Burton, ‘Family Images’, 73.

34 Ibid., 70; Hintjens, Helen, ‘France's Love Children? The French Overseas Departments’ in: Hintjens, H. and Newitt, M. eds, The Political Economy of Small, Tropical Islands: The Importance of Being Small (Exeter 1992).Google Scholar

35 Schwartz-Bart, Simone, Between Two Worlds (London 1992).Google Scholar

36 Le Monde (21 January 2001).

37 Claude Makouke, Interview with the author (Helen Hintjens). Former leader of UPLG (Union pour la Libération de la Guadeloupe), October 1991.

38 Hintjens, Alternatives, 181–185.

39 Balibar, Etienne, Masses, Classes, Ideas: Studies on Politics and Philosophy Before and After Marx (New York/London 1994) 197.Google Scholar

40 Libération (30 October 1999).

41 Le Monde (3 July 1999).

42 L’Express (4 March 1999).

43 Giraud, ‘Les Identités Antillaises’.

44 Reverier, ‘DOM’, 68.

45 Le Figaro (30 October 1999).

46 Le Monde (28 October 1999).

47 Libération (25 October 1999).

48 L’Express (8 April 1999).

49 Le Monde (3 July 1999).

50 Le Monde (6 February 2001).

51 Le Monde (31 May 1998).

52 Le Monde (3 July 1999).

53 Le Monde, (31 May 1998).

54 Le Monde (22 March 1998).

55 L'Express (4 March 1999).

56 Conan, Eric, ‘Martinique: ce département dont le patron est indépendantiste’, L'Express (4 March 1999) 8691.Google Scholar

57 Libération (25 October 1999).

58 L’Express (4 March 1999).

59 Le Monde (3 July 1999).

60 Le Monde (2 November 1999).

61 Le Monde (22 March 1998).

62 Le Figaro (31 August 1999).

63 L’Express (4 March 1999).

64 Le Figaro (30 April 1999).

65 Dahomay, Jacky, Le Monde (10 November 1999).Google Scholar

66 Libération (15 December 2000); Le Monde (15 December 2000).

67 Le Monde (30 October 1999).

68 Reverier, ‘DOM’, 66–67.

69 Le Figaro (16 April 1996).

70 Constant, F., La retraite aux Flambeaux: société et politique en Martinique (Paris 1988)Google Scholar; Hintjens, Alternatives.

71 Libération (25 October 1999).

72 Le Monde (3 July 1999).

73 La Tribune (28 October 1999).

74 La Tribune (1 August 1998; 12 February 1999; 22 October 1999).

75 Aldrich and Conner, The Last Colonies, 248.

76 Ibid., 249.

77 Le Monde (3 July 1999).

78 Wolfe, ‘Elusive Development’, 171.

79 Le Monde (3 July 1999).

80 L'Humanite (28 September 1999).

81 Le Monde (21 January 2001).

82 Miles, Mental Boundaries, 28.

83 Galap, ‘Stratégies identitaires’.

84 Reverier, ‘DOM’, 69.

85 Libération (12 July 1999).

86 Reverier, ‘DOM’, 67.

87 La Croix (18 December 2000).

88 Le Monde (12 March 2000).

89 Christian Paul, Secretary of State for the DOM-TOM, Les Echos (18 December 2000); Le Figaro (21 January 2001)

90 Le Monde (13 July 1999).

91 La Tribune (28 October 1999); L'Humanité (8 December 2000); Le Figaro (12January 2001).