Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-21T03:44:38.906Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Feeding in the Workhouse: The Institutional and Ideological Functions of Food in Britain, ca. 1834–70

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 November 2013

Ian Miller
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

How adequate was the mid-Victorian workhouse diet? Basing their arguments on modern nutritional analyses of dietary tables, some historians have concluded that the workhouse diet fulfilled the basic nutritional needs of inmates and that the idea that workhouse dietary regimes were inadequate is the result of a “mythology” created by contemporaries—including Charles Dickens. In these accounts, Dickens's infamous scene where Oliver Twist becomes so overwhelmed with hunger that he asks for more food is construed as an exaggerated rendering of workhouse life. This article argues that efforts to impose modern nutritional techniques onto past configurations can produce misleading results and generate simplistic historical interpretations. The cultural categories historically surrounding food demand thorough attention and must be reconciled with modern scientific approaches if the boundaries between workhouse realities and mythologies are to be rendered less obscure.

Type
Articles
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 52 , Issue 4 , October 2013 , pp. 940 - 962
Copyright
Copyright © The North American Conference on British Studies 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Smith, Leonard, Thornton, Sue J., Reinarz, Jonathan, and Williams, Andrew N., “Please, Sir, I Want Some More,” British Medical Journal 337 (2008): a2722CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

2 See Dickens, Charles, The Adventures of Oliver Twist (Philadelphia, 1839), 19Google Scholar.

3 Digby, Anne, Pauper Palaces (London, 1978), ixGoogle Scholar.

4 Ibid., 146, 229–32.

5 The value of cultural approaches toward food has been persuasively demonstrated in works such as Flandrin, Jean-Louis and Montanari, Massimo, eds., Food: A Culinary History (New York, 1999)Google Scholar; Vernon, James, Hunger: A Modern History (Cambridge, MA, 2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gilman, Sander, Fat: A Cultural History of Obesity (Cambridge, 2008)Google Scholar.

6 Dietary tables can be located in Second Annual Report of the Poor Law Commissioners, Reports of Commissioners, Cmd., 1836, vol. 29, pt. l.1 (595), 38–40.

7 von Liebig, Justus, Research on the Chemistry of Food, trans. Gregory, William (Lowell, 1848)Google Scholar.

8 Miller, Ian, A Modern History of the Stomach: Gastric Illness, Medicine and British Society, 1800–1950 (London, 2011), 11–38Google Scholar.

9 Hodgkinson, Ruth G., The Origins of the National Health Service: The Medical Services of the New Poor Law, 1834–1871 (London, 1967)Google Scholar; Flinn, Michael W., “Medical Services under the New Poor Law,” in The New Poor Law in the Nineteenth Century, ed. Fraser, Derek (London, 1976), 45–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Digby, Pauper Palaces, 166–79; Crowther, Margaret Anne, The Workhouse System, 1834–1929: The History of an English Social Institution (London, 1981), 156–92Google Scholar.

10 For a fuller statistical analysis, see Johnston, Valerie, Diet in Workhouses and Prisons, 1835–1895 (New York, 1985)Google Scholar.

11 Crowther, Workhouse System, 26.

12 Report from His Majesty's Commissioners for Inquiring into the Administration and Practical Operation of the Poor Laws, Reports of Commissioners, Commons, 1834, vol. 27.1 (44), 31.

13 King, Stephen, Poverty and Welfare in England, 1700–1850: A Regional Perspective (Manchester, 2000)Google Scholar.

14 Driver, Felix, Power and Pauperism: The Workhouse System, 1834–1884 (Cambridge, 1993), 48Google Scholar.

15 Second Annual Report of the Poor Law Commissioners, 313.

16 Ibid., 315.

17 First Annual Report of the Poor Law Commissioners, Reports of Commissioners, Cmd., 1835, vol. 35.107 (500), 98–100; Englander, David, Poverty and Poor Law Reform in Nineteenth Century Britain, 1834–1914 (London, 1998), 39–40Google Scholar.

18 First Annual Report of the Poor Law Commissioners, 63–66.

19 Digby, Power and Pauperism, ix. See also Burnett, John, Plenty and Want: A Social History of Diet in England from 1815 to the Present Day (London, 1966 [1979]), 41Google Scholar.

20 Fifth Annual Report of the Poor Law Commissioners, Reports of Commissioners, Cmd., 1839, vol. 20.1 (239), 1–2.

21 “Poor-Law Commission,” 1 April 1841, Parliamentary Debates, Commons, 3rd ser., vol. 57 (8 March 1841–6 May 1841), cols. 878–80.

22 “Poor-Law Commission,” 28 September 1841, Parliamentary Debates, Commons, 3rd ser., vol. 59 (19 August 1841–7 October 1841), cols. 972–74.

23 First Report from the Select Committee on the Poor Law Amendment Act, Reports of Committees, Commons, 1837–38, vol. 28, pt.1.51 (136), 25; Second Report from the Select Committee on the Poor Law Amendment Act, Reports of Committees, Commons, 1837–38, vol. 28, pt.1.71 (138), 44.

24 Seventh Report from the Select Committee on the Poor Law Amendment Act, Reports of Committees, Commons, 1837–38, vol. 28, pt.1.223 (161), 15.

25 Thirteenth Report from the Select Committee on the Poor Law Amendment Act, Reports of Committees, Commons, 1837–38, vol. 28, pt.1.425 (194), 59–60.

26 Seventh Report from Select Committee, 19–22.

27 Crowther, Workhouse System, 212.

28 First Annual Report of the Poor Law Commissioners for England and Wales, Reports of Commissioners, Cmd., 1835, vol. 35.107 (500), 60.

29 Ibid., 61.

30 Third Report from the Select Committee on the Poor Law Amendment Act, Reports of Committees, Commons, 1837, vol. 17, pt.1.219 (225), 33.

31 Ibid., 45.

32 Sixth Report from the Select Committee on the Poor Law Amendment Act, Reports of Committees, Commons, 1837, vol. 17, pt.1.457 (226), 17–20.

33 Seventh Annual Report of the Poor Law Commissioners, Reports of Committees, Cmd., 1841 Session 1, vol. 11.291 (327), 73–75.

34 See Levene, Alysa, “Children, Childhood and the Workhouse: St Marylebone, 1769–1781,” London Journal 33, no. 1 (2008): 41–59CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

35 J. Phillips Kay, “Report on the Training of Pauper Children,” in Fourth Annual Report of the Poor Law Commissioners, Reports of Commissioners, Cmd., 1837–38, vol. 28.145 (147), 228.

36 Ibid., 229.

37 For fuller discussion, see Roberts, David, “How Cruel Was the Victorian Poor Law?” Historical Journal 6, no. 1 (1963): 97–107CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

38 Letter from Harry White, Clerk to the Guardians of the Blything Poor Law Union, 21 December 1836, The National Archives (TNA), MH 12/11730/176, ff. 383–88.

39 “Poor Law—Dudley Dietaries,” 12 March 1838, Parliamentary Debates, Lords, 3rd ser., vol. 41 (22 February 1838–20 March 1838), cols. 741–49.

40 Vernon, Hunger, 18–20.

41 Ibid., 81–117.

42 “Effects of Dietaries on the Human Body,” Lancet 30 (31 March 1838): 19–22Google Scholar.

43 Ibid., 22.

44 “Pereira, Davidson, Truman on Diet,” British and Foreign Medical Review 33 (January 1844): 49–51Google Scholar.

45 For more on children in workhouses, see Driver, Power and Pauperism, 95–105. For the elderly, see Digby, Pauper Palaces, 161–79; Englander, Poverty and Poor Law Reform, 68–72; Thane, Pat, Old Age in English History: Past Experiences, Present Issues (Oxford, 2000), 165–93Google Scholar.

46 Combe, Andrew, A Treatise on the Physiological and Moral Management of Infancy, 6th ed. (Edinburgh, 1847), 29Google Scholar.

47 Ibid., 73–74.

48 Williams, Karel, From Pauperism to Poverty (London, 1981), 6Google Scholar.

49 Flinn, “Medical Services under the Poor Law,” 45–66.

50 Crowther, Workhouse System, 72.

51 Ibid., 73.

52 Thane, Pat, “Women and the Poor Law in Victorian and Edwardian England,” History Workshop Journal 6, no. 1 (1978): 35CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

53 Rose, Michael, The Relief of Poverty, 2nd ed. (London, 1972 [1986]), 26Google Scholar.

54 See Astruther, Ian, The Scandal of the Andover Workhouse (London, 1973)Google Scholar.

55 Report from the Select Committee on Andover Union, 1846, Reports of Committees, Commons, vol. 5, pt.i.1; vol. 5, pt.ii.1 (663–i; 663–ii), f. vii.

56 Unaddressed draft report of John Thomas Graves, 5 September 1848, TNA, MH/12/14019/234, ff. 362–67.

57 Letter from Alfred Power to the Poor Law Commission, 11 May 1842, TNA, MH/12/14017/284, ff. 401–06.

58 Letter from Henry Saunders to the Poor Law Board, 17 February 1849, TNA, MH/12/14019/346, ff. 532–33.

59 Draft letter from Poor Law Board to John Kirkland, 12 September 1856, TNA, MH 12/9531/112, f. 120.

60 Letter from Charles Hart to the Poor Law Board, 11 June 1856, TNA, MH 12/5970/167, ff. 313–15.

61 Letter from David Evans to the Poor Law Board, May 1849, TNA, MH 12/16545/182, ff. 251–55.

62 Letter from Thomas N. Firmin to the Poor Law Board, 22 June 1853, TNA, MH 12/11000/67, ff. 124–26.

63 Letter from Thomas N. Firmin to the Poor Law Board, 28 July 1854, TNA, MH/12/11000/233, ff. 433–34.

64 Extract from Hampshire Independent, 27 August 1853, TNA, MH 12/11000/88, f. 166.

65 Loudon, Irvine, Medical Care and the General Practitioner, 1750–1850 (Oxford, 1987), 245–46Google Scholar.

66 Harris, Jose, Private Lives, Public Spirit: A Social History of Britain, 1870–1914 (Oxford, 1993), 237Google Scholar.

67 Rose, Michael, introduction to The Poor and the City: The English Poor Law in Its Urban Context, 1834–1914 (Leicester, 1985), 1–18Google Scholar.

68 Lees, Lynn Hollen, The Solidarities of Strangers: The English Poor Laws and the People, 1700–1948 (Cambridge, 1998), 12–16Google Scholar.

69 Driver, Power and Pauperism, 35.

70 Rose, Relief of Poverty, 36. For British and Irish perspectives on specialist childhood health management in institutions, see Miller, Ian, “Constructing Moral Hospitals: Childhood Health in Irish Reformatories and Industrial Schools, c.1851–1890,” in Growing Pains: Childhood Illness in Ireland, 1750–1950, ed. MacLellan, Anne and Mauger, Alice (Dublin, 2013), 105–22Google Scholar.

71 Harris, Private Lives, 239.

72 Crowther, Workhouse System, 168.

73 Lees, Solidarities of Strangers, 16.

74 See Miller, Ian, Reforming Food in Post-Famine Ireland: Medicine, Science and Improvement, c.1845–1922 (Manchester, 2014), chaps. 1, 3–5CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

75 “The Lancet Sanitary Commission for Investigating the State Infirmaries of Workhouses,” Lancet 86 (July 1865): 14Google Scholar.

76 Kidd, State, Society and the Poor, 52–53.

77 “The Lancet Sanitary Commission for Investigating the State Infirmaries of Workhouses,” 20.

78 “The Lancet Commission on Workhouse Infirmaries,” Lancet 90 (2 November 1867): 556Google Scholar.

79 “The Lancet Commission on Workhouse Infirmaries,” Lancet 86 (5 August 1865): 154–55Google Scholar.

80 “Dietaries of the Poor in the Metropolis,” Medical Times and Gazette i (16 March 1866): 255–56Google Scholar.

81 Driver, Power and Pauperism, 69. For Smith, see Barker, Theo C., Oddy, Derek J., and Yudkin, John, The Dietary Surveys of Dr. Edward Smith, 1862–3 (London, 1970)Google Scholar.

82 “New Workhouse Dietary,” Medical Times and Gazette ii (18 May 1867): 581Google Scholar.

83 This theme has been touched upon in Huff, Joyce L., “Corporeal Economies: Work and Waste in Nineteenth-Century Constructions of Alimentation,” in Cultures of the Abdomen: Diet, Digestion and Fat in the Modern World, ed. Forth, Christopher E. and Carden-Coyne, Ana (New York and Basingstoke, 2005), 16–30, 31Google Scholar.

84 Workhouse Dietaries: Papers relating to Workhouse Dietaries, Accounts and Papers, House of Commons, 1867, vol. 60.57 (435), 9.

85 Ibid., 16.

86 Huff, “Corporeal Economies,” 16–30.

87 Workhouse Dietaries, 12.

88 Ibid., 13.

89 Ibid., 15.

90 Ibid., 16.

91 Ibid.

92 Ibid., 13–14.

93 Ibid., 14–15.

94 Ibid., 9.

95 Ibid., 12.

96 Ibid., 26–27.

97 Ibid., 27.

98 Ibid., 8.

99 Twenty-First Annual Report of the Poor Law Board, 1868–69, Reports of Commissioners, Cmd., vol. 28.1 (4197), 41–42.

100 Workhouse Inspection Report, 25 June 1847, TNA, MH12/14588/40, ff. 58–59.

101 Dietary tables A and B, 6 August 1857, TNA, MH 12/14589/21, f. 300.

102 Letter from James Robinson Tomlin to Reeth Poor Law Union, 10 September 1868, TNA, MH/12/14590/245, ff. 336–44.