Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-dlnhk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T11:20:15.741Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Convertible Husbandry vs. Regular Common Fields: A Model on the Relative Efficiency of Medieval Field Systems

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 June 2004

HARRY KITSIKOPOULOS
HARRY KITSIKOPOULOS
Affiliation:
Clinical Associate Professor, Department of Economics, New York University, 269 Mercer Street, 7th Floor, New York, NY 10003. E-mail: hk20@nyu.edu
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The existing literature on the economy of medieval England views the practice of convertible husbandry as a more efficient alternative to regular common fields. The article challenges this view by measuring the productivities of the systems, which are found to be approximately equivalent. In interpreting this finding, it is suggested that edaphic conditions and wrongful managerial practices account for the poor performance of convertible husbandry during the Middle Ages, whereas the greater productivity achieved by the system in the early modern period is attributed to the introduction of fodder legumes, such as clover, which were absent in previous centuries.

Type
ARTICLES
Information
The Journal of Economic History , Volume 64 , Issue 2 , June 2004 , pp. 462 - 499
Copyright
© 2004 The Economic History Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Alcock N. W. 1970 “An East Devon Manor in the Later Middle Ages.” Transactions of the Devonshire Association 102: 141– 87.Google Scholar
Bailey Mark. 1989. A Marginal Economy? East Anglian Breckland in the Later Middle Ages. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Baker A. R. H. 1973. “Field Systems of Southeast England” In Studies of Field Systems in the British Isles, edited by Alan Baker and Robin Butlin, 377– 429. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Biddick Kathleen. 1989. The Other Economy: Pastoral Husbandry on a Medieval Estate. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press
Biddick Kathleen (with Catrien Bijleveld). 1991. “Agrarian Productivity on the Estates of the Bishopric of Winchester in the Early Thirteenth Century: A Managerial Perspective” In Land, Labour and Livestock: Historical Studies in European Agricultural Productivity, edited by Bruce Campbell and Mark Overton, 95– 123. Manchester: Manchester University Press
Bishop T. A. M. 1938 “The Rotation of Crops at Westerham, 1297–1350.” Economic History Review 9: 38– 44.Google Scholar
Blith W. 1652. The English Improver Improved. London: John Wright
Brandon P. F. 1962 “Arable Farming in a Sussex Scarp–foot Parish During the Late Middle Ages.” Sussex Archaeological Collections 100: 60– 72.Google Scholar
Brandon P. F. 1971 “Demesne Arable Farming in Coastal Sussex During the Later Middle Ages.” Agricultural History Review 19, Part 2: 113– 34.Google Scholar
Brandon P. F. 1971 “Agriculture and the Effects of Floods and Weather at Barnhorne, Sussex, During the Late Middle Ages.” Sussex Archaeological Collections 109: 69– 93.Google Scholar
Brandon P. F. 1972 “Cereal Yields on the Sussex Estates of Battle Abbey During the Later Middle Ages.” Economic History Review second series, 25, no. 3: 403– 20.Google Scholar
Brandon P. F. 1988. “Farming Techniques: South–eastern England” In The Agrarian History of England and Wales, II: 1042–1350, edited by H. E. Hallam, 312– 25. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Caird James A. 1888 “Recent Experiences in Laying Down Land to Grass.” Journal of the Royal Agricultural Society of England second series, 24: 124– 56.Google Scholar
Campbell Bruce. 1991. “Land, Labour, Livestock, and Productivity Trends in English Seignorial Agriculture, 1208–1450” In Land, Labour and Livestock: Historical Studies in European Agricultural Productivity, edited by Bruce Campbell and Mark Overton, 144– 82. Manchester: Manchester University Press
Campbell Bruce. 1992 “Commercial Dairy Production on Medieval English Demesnes: The Case of Norfolk.” Anthropozoologica 52: 107– 18.Google Scholar
Campbell Bruce. 1995. “Measuring the Commercialisation of Seigneurial Agriculture c. 1300” In A Commercializing Economy: England 1086 to c. 1300, edited by Richard Britnell and Bruce Campbell, 132– 93. Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press
Campbell Bruce. 2000. English Seigniorial Agriculture, 1250–1450. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Campbell Bruce, James A. Galloway, Derek Keene, et al. 1993. A Medieval Capital and its Grain Supply: Agrarian Production and Distribution in the London Region c. 1300. Belfast and London: The Queen's University of Belfast and the Centre for Metropolitan History, Institute of Historical Research, University of London
Campbell Bruce, and Mark Overton. 1993 “A New Perspective on Medieval and Early Modern Agriculture: Six Centuries of Norfolk Farming c. 1250–c. 1850.” Past and Present 141 (November): 38– 105.Google Scholar
Campbell Bruce, Kenneth Bartley, and John Power. 1996 “The Demesne Farming Systems of Post–Black Death England: A Classification.” Agricultural History Review 44, Part 2: 131– 79.Google Scholar
Clark G. 1991. “Labour Productivity in English Agriculture, 1300–1860” In Land, Labour and Livestock: Historical Studies in European Agricultural Productivity, edited by Bruce Campbell and Mark Overton, 211– 35. Manchester: Manchester University Press
Clark G. 1992 “The Economics of Exhaustion, the Postan Thesis, and the Agricultural Revolution”, This JOURNAL 52, no. 1 (March): 61– 84.Google Scholar
Cooke G. 1967. The Control of Soil Fertility. London: Crosby Lockwood & Son
Cooter W. S. 1978 “Ecological Dimensions of Medieval Agrarian Systems.” Agricultural History 52, no. 4 (October): 458– 77.Google Scholar
Crutchley J. 1794. General View of the Agriculture in the County of Rutland, with Observations on the Means of its Improvement. London: W. Smith
Dyer Christopher. 1972 “A Small Landowner in the Fifteenth Century.” Midland History 1, no. 3 (Spring): 1– 14.Google Scholar
Dyer Christopher. 1980. Lords and Peasants in a Changing Society: The Estates of the Bishopric of Worcester, 680– 1540. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Dyer Christopher. 1981. Warwickshire Farming, 1349–c. 1520: Preparations for Agricultural Revolution, Dugdale Society Occasional Papers 27, Oxford: Oxford University Press
Dyer Christopher. 1989. Standards of Living in the Later Middle Ages: Social Change in England c. 1200– 1500. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Elliot R. H. 1908. The Clifton Park System of Farming. London: Simpkin, Marshall, Hamilton, Kent & Co.
Farmer D. L. 1983 “Grain Yields on Westminster Abbey Manors, 1271–1410.” Canadian Journal of History 18, no. 3 (December): 331– 47.Google Scholar
Farmer D. L. 1988. “Prices and Wages” In The Agrarian History of England and Wales, II: 1042–1350, edited by H. E. Hallam, 716– 817. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Farmer D. L. 1991. “Prices and Wages, 1350–1500” In The Agrarian History of England and Wales, III: 1348–1500, edited by E. Miller, 431– 525. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Finberg H. P. R. 1951. Tavistock Abbey: A Study in the Social and Economic History of Devon. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Fox H. S. A. 1972 “Field Systems of East and South Devon. Part I: East Devon.” Report and Transactions of the Devonshire Association, 104: 81– 135.Google Scholar
Fox H. S. A. 1991. “Farming Practice and Techniques: Devon and Cornwall” In The Agrarian History of England and Wales, III: 1348–1500, edited by E. Miller, 303– 23. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Grigg David. 1982. The Dynamics of Agricultural Change. New York: St Martin's
Hallam H. E. 1988. “Farming Techniques: Southern England” In The Agrarian History of England and Wales, II: 1042–1350, edited by H. E. Hallam, 341– 68. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Hallam H. E. 1988. “Farming Techniques: Eastern England” In The Agrarian History of England and Wales, II: 1042–1350, edited by H. E. Hallam, 272– 312. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Harrison Barry. 1995 “Field Systems and Demesne Farming on the Wiltshire Estates of St Swithun's Priory, Winchester, 1248–1340.” Agricultural History Review 43, Part 1: 1– 18.Google Scholar
Hatcher John. 1970. Rural Economy and Society in the Duchy of Cornwall, 1300–1500. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Havinden M. A. 1974. “Lime as a Means of Agricultural Improvement: The Devon Example” In Rural Change and Urban Growth, 1500–1800, edited by C. W. Chalklin and M. A. Havinden, 104– 34. London and New York: Longman
Howell C. 1983. Land, Family and Inheritance in Transition: Kibworth Harcourt, 1280–1700. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Kerridge Eric. 1968. The Agricultural Revolution. New York: Augustus M. Kelley
Kershaw Ian. 1973. Bolton Priory: The Economy of a Northern Monastery, 1286–1325. Oxford: Oxford University Press
Kitsikopoulos Harry. 2000 “Standards of Living and Capital Formation in Pre–plague England: A Peasant Budget Model.” Economic History Review 53, no. 2 (May): 237– 61.Google Scholar
Kitsikopoulos Harry. 2002 “The Impact of the Black Death on Peasant Economy in England, 1350–1500.” The Journal of Peasant Studies 29, no. 2 (January): 71– 90.Google Scholar
Laurence J. 1726. A New System of Agriculture. London: T. Woodward
Lisle E. 1757. Observations in Husbandry (Westmead, Farnborough, Hants., England: Gregg International Publishers, 1970, originally published in
Loomis R. S. 1978 “Ecological Dimensions of Medieval Agrarian Systems: An Ecologist Responds.” Agricultural History 52, no. 4 (October): 478– 83.Google Scholar
Low A. J. 1955 “Improvements in the Structural State of Soils Under Leys.” Journal of Soil Science 6: 179– 99.Google Scholar
Mate Mavis. 1985 “Medieval Agrarian Practices: The Determining Factors.” Agricultural History Review 33, Part 1: 22– 31.Google Scholar
Mate Mavis. 1997. “Agricultural Technology in Southeast England, 1348–1530” In Medieval Farming and Technology: The Impact of Agricultural Change in Northwest Europe, edited by Grenville Astill and John Langdon, 251– 74. Leiden: Brill
MacDonald S. 1980 “Agricultural Responses to a Changing Market During the Napoleonic Wars.” Economic History Review second series, 33, no. 1 (February): 59– 71.Google Scholar
McIntosh Marjorie. 1986. Autonomy and Community: The Royal Manor of Havering, 1200–1500. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Miller E. 1975 “Farming in Northern England During the Twelfth and Thirteenth Centuries.” Northern History 11: 1– 16.Google Scholar
Miskimin Harry. 1969. The Economy of Early Renaissance Europe: 1300–1460. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall
Moore H. I. 1950 Grassland Husbandry. London: George Allen & Unwin, 4th edition.
Newman E. I., and P. D. A. Harvey. 1997 “Did Soil Fertility Decline in Medieval English Farms? Evidence from Cuxham, Oxfordshire, 1320–1340.” Agricultural History Review 45, Part 2: 119– 36.Google Scholar
Page F. 1934. The Estates of Crowland Abbey. London: Cambridge University Press
Postgate M. R. 1962 “The Field Systems of Breckland,” Agricultural History Review 10, Part 2: 80– 101.Google Scholar
Postgate M. R. “Field Systems of East Anglia.” 1973. In Studies of Field Systems in the British Isles edited by Alan Baker and Robin Butlin, 281– 324. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Richardson H. L. 1938 “The Nitrogen Cycle in Grassland Soils: With a Special Reference to the Rothamsted Park Grass Experiment.” Journal of Agricultural Science 28: 73– 121.Google Scholar
Roberts E. J. 1932 “The Effect of Wild White Clover on the Live Weight Increments from a Temporary Pasture.” Welsh Journal of Agriculture 8: 84– 93.Google Scholar
Roden D. 1966 “Field Systems in Ibstone, a Township of the South–west Chilterns During the Later Middle Ages.” Records of Buckinghamshire 18: 43– 57.Google Scholar
Roden D. “Field Systems of the Chiltern Hills and their Environs.” 1973. In Studies of Field Systems in the British Isles edited by Alan Baker and Robin Butlin, 325– 76. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Searle Eleanor. 1974. Lordship and Community: Battle Abbey and its Banlieu. Toronto: Pontifical Institute of Mediaeval Studies
Shiel Robert. 1991. “Improving Soil Productivity in the Pre–fertilizer Era” In Land, Labour and Livestock: Historical Studies in European Agricultural Productivity, edited by Bruce Campbell and Mark Overton, 51– 77. Manchester: Manchester University Press
Van Slyke L. L. 1932. Fertilizers and Crop Production. New York: Orange Judd
Smith R. A. L. 1943. Canterbury Cathedral Priory: A Study in Monastic Administration. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Stapledon G. 1943. The Way of the Land. London: Faber and Faber
Stapledon G., and W. Davies, 1948. Ley Farming. London: Faber and Faber
Stewart J. G., and G. E. Fussell, 1929 “The Alternate Husbandry: A Lesson from History.” Journal of the Ministry of Agriculture 36: 214– 21.Google Scholar
Stone David. 1997 “The Productivity of Hired and Customary Labour: Evidence from Wisbech Barton in the Fourteenth Century.” Economic History Review 50, no. 4: 640– 56.Google Scholar
Thompson L. M., and Frederick R. T Troeh. 1978 Soils and Soil Fertility. New York: McGraw–Hill, 4th edition.
Thornton Christopher. 1991. “The Determinants of Land Productivity on the Bishop of Winchester's Demesne of Rimpton, 1208 to 1403” In Land, Labour and Livestock: Historical Studies in European Agricultural Productivity, edited by Bruce Campbell and Mark Overton, 183– 210. Manchester: Manchester University Press
Von Thunen J. H. 1966. The Isolated State, edited by P. Hall. Oxford: Pergamon Press
Titow J. Z. 1972. Winchester Yields: A Study in Medieval Agricultural Productivity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Ugawa K. 1962 “The Economic Development of Some Devon Manors in the Thirteenth Century.” Transactions of the Devonshire Association 94: 630– 83.Google Scholar
Williams T. E. 1960 “Leys and Subsequent Arable Productivity.” Journal of the British Grassland Society 15: 189– 94.Google Scholar
Williams T. E., C. R. Clement, and A. J. Heard. 1960 “Soil Nitrogen Status of Leys and Subsequent Wheat Yields.” Proceedings of the 8th International Grassland Congress: 237– 41.
Youd G. 1961 “The Common Fields of Lancashire.” Transactions of the Historic Society of Lancashire and Cheshire, 113: 1– 41.Google Scholar