Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-q99xh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-24T22:11:55.910Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The old boy network: are the professional networks of female executives less effective than men's for advancing their careers?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 February 2022

Marie Lalanne  and
Paul Seabright Open the ORCID record for Paul Seabright [Opens in a new window]
Marie Lalanne*
Affiliation:
University of Turin & Collegio Carlo Alberto; Piazza Arbarello 8, 10122 Turin, Italy
Paul Seabright
Affiliation:
Toulouse School of Economics & Institute for Advanced Study in Toulouse; 1 esplanade de l'Université, 31080 Cedex 06, Toulouse, France
*
*Corresponding author. Email: marie.lalanne@carloalberto.org
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

We investigate the impact of professional networks on men's and women's earnings, using a dataset of European and North American executives. The size of an individual's network of influential former colleagues has a large positive association with remuneration, with an elasticity of around 21%. However, controlling for unobserved heterogeneity using various fixed effects as well as a placebo technique, we find that the real causal impact of networks is barely positive for men and significantly lower for women. We provide suggestive evidence indicating that the apparent discrimination against women is due to two factors: first, both men and women are helped more by own-gender than other-gender connections, and men have more of these than women do. Second, a subset of employers we identify as ‘female friendly firms’ recruit more women but reward networks less than other firms.

Keywords

Executive compensationgender wage gapplacebo techniqueprofessional networksJ16J31J33M12
Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Institutional Economics , Volume 18 , Issue 5 , October 2022 , pp. 725 - 744
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Millennium Economics Ltd.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Adusei, M. and Sarpong-Danquah, B. (2021), ‘Institutional Quality and the Capital Structure of Microfinance Institutions: The Moderating Role of Board Gender Diversity’, Journal of Institutional Economics, 17(4): 641–661.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Agarwal, S., Qian, W., Reeb, D. M. and Sing, T. F. (2016), ‘Playing the Boys Game: Golf Buddies and Board Diversity’, American Economic Review, 106(5): 272–276.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ahern, K. R. and Dittmar, A. K. (2012), ‘The Changing of the Boards: The Impact on Firm Valuation of Mandated Female Board Representation’, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 127(1): 137–197.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Albanesi, S., Olivetti, C. and Prados, M. J. (2015), ‘Gender and Dynamic Agency: Theory and Evidence on the Compensation of Top Executives’, Research in Labor Economics, 42: 1–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Allemand, I., Bédard, J., Brullebaut, B. and Deschênes, J. (2021), ‘Role of old Boys’ Networks and Regulatory Approaches in Selection Processes for Female Directors’, British Journal of Management.Google Scholar
Athey, S., Avery, C. and Zemsky, P. (2000), ‘Mentoring and Diversity’, American Economic Review, 90(4): 765–786.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beaman, L., Keleher, N. and Magruder, J. (2018), ‘Do Job Networks Disadvantage Women? Evidence From A Recruitment Experiment in Malawi’, Journal of Labor Economics, 36(1): 121–157.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Belliveau, M. A. (2005), ‘Blind Ambition? The Effects of Social Networks and Institutional Sex Composition on the Job Search Outcomes of Elite Coeducational and Women's College Graduates’, Organization Science, 16(2): 134–150.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Berardi, N., Lalanne, M. and Seabright, P. (2019), ‘Professional Network and their Coevolution with Executive Careers: Evidence from North America and Europe’, SAFE Working Paper No.243.Google Scholar
Bertrand, M. and Hallock, K. F. (2001), ‘The Gender Gap in Top Corporate Jobs’, Industrial & Labor Relations Review, 55(1): 3–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bertrand, M., Goldin, C. and Katz, L. F. (2010), ‘Dynamics of the Gender Gap for Young Professionals in the Financial and Corporate Sectors’, American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 2(3): 228–255.Google Scholar
Bertrand, M., Black, S. E., Jensen, S. and Lleras-Muney, A. (2019), ‘Breaking the Glass Ceiling? The Effect of Board Quotas on Female Labour Market Outcomes in Norway’, The Review of Economic Studies, 86(1): 191–239.Google Scholar
Bloom, N., Kretschmer, T. and Van Reenen, J. (2011), ‘Are Family Friendly Workplace Practices A Valuable Firm Resource?’, Strategic Management Journal, 32(4): 343–367.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brown, R., Gao, N., Lee, E. and Stathopoulos, K. (2012), ‘What Are Friends for? CEO Networks, Pay and Corporate Governance’, in S. Boubaker, B. D. Nguyen and D. K. Nguyen (eds), Corporate Governance, Berlin and Heidelberg: Springer, pp. 287–307.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bu, N. and Roy, J.-P. (2005), ‘Career Success Networks in China: Sex Differences in Network Composition and Social Exchange Practices’, Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 22(4): 381–403.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chevrot-Bianco, E. (2021), ‘It only takes a strong tie: Board gender quotas and network-based hiring’, Working Paper.Google Scholar
Comi, S., Grasseni, M., Origo, F. and Pagani, L. (2020), ‘Where Women Make A Difference: Gender Quotas and Firms’ Performance in Three European Countries’, ILR Review, 73(3): 768–793.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cullen, Z. B. and Perez-Truglia, R. (2019), ‘The old boys’ club: Schmoozing and the gender gap’, Working Paper.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
David-Barrett, T., Rotkirch, A., Carney, J., Izquierdo, I. B., Krems, J. A., Townley, D., McDaniell, E., Byrne-Smith, A. and Dunbar, R. I. (2015), ‘Women Favour Dyadic Relationships, but Men Prefer Clubs: Cross-Cultural Evidence From Social Networking’, PLoS One, 10(3): e0118329.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Dennissen, M., Benschop, Y. and van den Brink, M. (2019), ‘Diversity Networks: Networking for Equality?’, British Journal of Management, 30(4): 966–980.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ductor, L., Goyal, S. and Prummer, A. (2020), ‘Gender & Collaboration’, in S. Lundberg (ed.), Women in Economics, London: CEPR Vox eBook, pp. 75–80.Google Scholar
Engelberg, J., Gao, P. and Parsons, C. A. (2013), ‘The Price of A CEO's Rolodex’, Review of Financial Studies, 26(1): 79–114.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fernandez, R. M. and Rubineau, B. (2019), ‘Network Recruitment and the Glass Ceiling: Evidence From two Firms’, RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences, 5(3): 88–102.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Fernandez, R. M. and Sosa, M. L. (2005), ‘Gendering the Job: Networks and Recruitment at A Call Center’, American Journal of Sociology, 111(3): 859–904.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fischer, C. S. and Oliker, S. J. (1983), ‘Research Note on Friendship, Gender, and the Life Cycle’, Social Forces, 62(1): 124–133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Flabbi, L., Macis, M., Moro, A. and Schivardi, F. (2019), ‘Do Female Executives Make A Difference? The Impact of Female Leadership on Gender Gaps and Firm Performance’, The Economic Journal, 129(622): 2390–2423.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Forret, M. L. and Dougherty, T. W. (2004), ‘Networking Behaviors and Career Outcomes: Differences for Men and Women?’, Journal of Organizational Behavior, 25(3): 419–437.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fortin, N. M., Bell, B. and Böhm, M. (2017), ‘Top Earnings Inequality and the Gender pay gap: Canada, Sweden, and the United Kingdom’, Labour Economics, 47: 107–123.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fracassi, C. and Tate, G. (2012), ‘External Networking and Internal Firm Governance’, The Journal of Finance, 67(1): 153–194.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Friebel, G. and Seabright, P. (2011), ‘Do Women Have Longer Conversations? Telephone Evidence of Gendered Communication Strategies’, Journal of Economic Psychology, 32(3): 348–356.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Friebel, G., Lalanne, M., Richter, B., Schwardmann, P. and Seabright, P. (2021), ‘Gender Differences in Social Interactions’, Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 186: 33–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Galenianos, M. (2013), ‘Learning About Match Quality and the use of Referrals’, Review of Economic Dynamics, 16(4): 668–690.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gayle, G.-L., Golan, L. and Miller, R. A. (2012), ‘Gender Differences in Executive Compensation and Job Mobility’, Journal of Labor Economics, 30(4): 829–872.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gertsberg, D., Intintoli, V. and Kahle, K. (2021), ‘Gender quotas and support for women in board elections’, NBER Working Paper, (28463).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Giannetti, M. and Wang, T. Y. (2020), ‘Public attention to gender equality and the demand for female directors’, CEPR Discussion Paper No. DP14503.Google Scholar
Goldin, C. (2014), ‘A Grand Gender Convergence: Its Last Chapter’, American Economic Review, 104(4): 1091–1119.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Granovetter, M. S. (1973), ‘The Strength of Weak Ties’, American Journal of Sociology, 78(6): 1360–1380.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Greene, D., Intintoli, V. and Kahle, K. (2020), ‘Do Board Gender Quotas Affect Firm Value? Evidence From California Senate Bill no. 826’, Journal of Corporate Finance, 60: 101526.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Greguletz, E., Diehl, M.-R. and Kreutzer, K. (2019), ‘Why Women Build Less Effective Networks Than men: The Role of Structural Exclusion and Personal Hesitation’, Human Relations, 72(7): 1234–1261.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hampole, M., Truffa, F. and Wong, A. (2021), ‘Peer effects and the gender gap in corporate leadership: Evidence from MBA students’, Working Paper.Google Scholar
Hensvik, L. and Skans, O. N. (2016), ‘Social Networks, Employee Selection, and Labor Market Outcomes’, Journal of Labor Economics, 34(4): 825–867.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hodigere, R. and Bilimoria, D. (2015), ‘Human Capital and Professional Network Effects on Women's Odds of Corporate Board Directorships’, Gender in Management, 30(7): 523–550.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Holzer, H. J. (1987), ‘Hiring procedures in the firm: Their economic determinants and outcomes’, NBER Working Paper, (w2185).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Horton, J., Millo, Y. and Serafeim, G. (2012), ‘Resources or Power? Implications of Social Networks on Compensation and Firm Performance’, Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 39(3–4): 399–426.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hwang, B.-H. and Kim, S. (2009), ‘It Pays to Have Friends’, Journal of Financial Economics, 93(1): 138–158.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hwang, S., Shivdasani, A. and Simintzi, E. (2018), ‘Mandating women on boards: evidence from the united states’, Working Paper.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kramarz, F. and Thesmar, D. (2013), ‘Social Networks in the Boardroom’, Journal of the European Economic Association, 11(4): 780–807.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kulich, C., Trojanowski, G., Ryan, M. K., Haslam, S. A. and Renneboog, L. (2011), ‘Who Gets the Carrot and Who Gets the Stick? Evidence of Gender Disparities in Executive Remuneration’, Strategic Management Journal, 32(3): 301–321.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lindenlaub, I. and Prummer, A. (2021), ‘Network Structure and Performance’, The Economic Journal, 131(634): 851–898.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Linehan, M. and Scullion, H. (2008), ‘The Development of Female Global Managers: The Role of Mentoring and Networking’, Journal of Business Ethics, 83(1): 29–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Liu, Y. (2014), ‘Outside Options and CEO Turnover: The Network Effect’, Journal of Corporate Finance, 28: 201–217.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lyness, K. S. and Thompson, D. E. (2000), ‘Climbing the Corporate Ladder: Do Female and Male Executives Follow the Same Route?’, Journal of Applied Psychology, 85(1): 86.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Marsden, P. V. (1994a), ‘The Hiring Process: Recruitment Methods’, American Behavioral Scientist, 37(7): 979–991.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marsden, P. V. (1994b), ‘Selection Methods in US Establishments’, Acta Sociologica, 37(3): 287–301.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Matsa, D. A. and Miller, A. R. (2013), ‘A Female Style in Corporate Leadership? Evidence From Quotas’, American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 5(3): 136–169.Google Scholar
McPherson, M., Smith-Lovin, L. and Cook, J. M. (2001), ‘Birds of A Feather: Homophily in Social Networks’, Annual Review of Sociology, 27(1): 415–444.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mengel, F. (2020), ‘Gender Differences in Networking’, The Economic Journal, 130(630): 1842–1873.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Metz, I. and Tharenou, P. (2001), ‘Women's Career Advancement: The Relative Contribution of Human and Social Capital’, Group & Organization Management, 26(3): 312–342.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Moore, G. (1990), ‘Structural Determinants of Men's and Women's Personal Networks’, American Sociological Review, 55(5): 726–735.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Neugart, M. and Zaharieva, A. (2018), ‘Social Networks, Promotions, and the Glass-Ceiling Effect’, Bielefeld Working Papers in Economic and Management No. 07-2018.Google Scholar
Nguyen, B. D. (2012), ‘Does the Rolodex Matter? Corporate Elite's Small World and the Effectiveness of Boards of Directors’, Management Science, 58(2): 236–252.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Obukhova, E. and Kleinbaum, A. M. (2020), ‘Scouting and Schmoozing: A Gender Difference in Networking During Job Search’, Academy of Management Discoveries. https://doi.org/10.5465/amd.2020.0075.Google Scholar
Seabright, P. (2012), The War of the Sexes: How Conflict and Cooperation Have Shaped Men and Women From Prehistory to the Present, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Selody, K. (2011), ‘Board Independence and the Gender Pay Gap for Top Executives’, Retrieved from Cornell University, ILR School, Compensation Research Initiative site, http://digitalcommons.ilr.cornell.edu/cri/16.Google Scholar
Shue, K. (2013), ‘Executive Networks and Firm Policies: Evidence From the Random Assignment of MBA Peers’, Review of Financial Studies, 26(6): 1401–1442.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, N., Smith, V. and Verner, M. (2013), ‘Why are so Few Females Promoted Into CEO and Vice President Positions? Danish Empirical Evidence, 1997–2007’, Industrial & Labor Relations Review, 66(2): 380–408.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tattersall, A. and Keogh, C. (2006), ‘Women, Networking and the Impact on Pay, Position and Status in the UK ICT Industry’, Unpublished Manuscript.Google Scholar
Tyrefors, B. and Jansson, J. (2017). ‘Gender quotas in the board room and firm performance: evidence from a credible threat in Sweden’, IFN Working Paper.Google Scholar
Zeltzer, D. (2020), ‘Gender Homophily in Referral Networks: Consequences for the Medicare Physician Earnings Gap’, American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 12(2): 169–197.Google Scholar
Zhu, M. (2018), ‘Job Networks through College Classmates: Effects of Referrals for Men and Women’, Working Paper.Google Scholar
Zimmerman, S. D. (2019), ‘Elite Colleges and Upward Mobility to Top Jobs and Top Incomes’, American Economic Review, 109(1): 1–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Supplementary material: PDF

Lalanne and Seabright supplementary material

Appendix

Download Lalanne and Seabright supplementary material(PDF)
PDF 118.3 KB