Hostname: page-component-84b7d79bbc-g5fl4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-08-04T08:13:06.472Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Cattle Raising in the Argentine Northeast: Corrientes, c. 1750–1870

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 February 2009

Thomas Whigham
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Though Argentina has long been synonymous with trackless pampas and teeming livestock herds, this common image requires some qualification. Before the late nineteenth century, when refrigerated transport made possible a large international market for Argentine beef, cattle played a less important role in the economy of the Río de la Plata than is usually assumed. Except for Buenos Aires province, where stockraising was predominant even in the colonial period, ranchers often had to struggle hard and insistently to find their niche in the overall commerce of the region. Grazing conditions were excellent in many areas of the Río de la Plata, but because the port of Buenos Aires always enjoyed a near-exclusive control over external trade, the porteños effectively blunted the development of any stockraising that threatened to compete with their own exports. In the northeastern provinces, this resulted in a cattle industry marked by technological backwardness and erratic growth. The chaotic politics of the post-independence era reinforced these conditions, though reform-minded ranchers and government officials consistently tried to improve provincial standards of stockraising.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Latin American Studies , Volume 20 , Issue 2 , November 1988 , pp. 313 - 335
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1988

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 A radical Member of Parliament and a well-known Scottish adventurer and pioneer, R. B. Cunninghame-Graham participated in several military campaigns in Argentina during the 1870s. The quote is taken from South American Sketches (Norman, 1978), p. 26.Google Scholar The best general work on the gaucho is Slatta, Richard W., Gauchos and the Vanishing Frontier (Lincoln and London, 1983).Google Scholar

2 Maeder, Ernesto J. A., ‘La evolutión de la ganadería en Corrientes (1810–1854)’, Cuadernos de estudios regionales 4 (1983), pp. 7–21.Google Scholar

3 Cortesão, Jamie (ed.), Do Tratado de Madri a Conquista dos Sete Povos (1750–1802) (Rio de Janeiro, 1969)Google Scholar, passim; Donghi, Tulio Halperín, Politics, Economics and Society in Argentina in the Revolutionary Period (Cambridge, 1975), pp. 16–19.Google Scholar

4 de Azara, Félix, Memoria sobre el estado rural del Río de la Plata en 1801 (Madrid, 1847), p. 8.Google Scholar

5 Informe of the Cabildo of Corrientes [1701] in Archivo General de la Provincia de Corrientes. Actas Capitulares [hereafter cited as AGPC-AC], libro 13 (1698–1704).

6 Bando of Governor Manuel Prado Maldonado, 14 July 1701 in AGPC-AC 13 (1698–1704); Governor Baltasar García Ros to the Cabildo of Corrientes, 28 Mar. 1716, in AGPC-AC 15 (1715–1718).

7 Maeder, Ernesto J. A., Historia económica de Corrientes en el período virreinal, 1776–1810 (Buenos Aires, 1981), pp. 219–24.Google Scholar

8 Maeder, Ernesto J. A., ‘La formación territorial y económica de Corrientes entre 1588 y 1750’, Folia Histórica del Nordeste 1 (1974), pp. 33–75Google Scholar; Gómez, Hernán Félix, El município de Saladas (Buenos Aires, 1942).Google Scholar

9 Maeder, , Historia económica, p. 222Google Scholar, mentions two straight years of drought, 1737–39; see also Acta of 19 Oct. 1739 in AGPC-AC 20 (1737–1749).

10 Maeder, , Historia económica, p. 223.Google Scholar

11 de Aguirre, Juan Francisco, ‘Diario del capitán de fragata de la Real Armada Don…’ Revista de la Biblioteca Nacional de Buenos Aires 17–20 (1949–1951), 1, pp. 377–8.Google Scholar

12 Aguirre, , ‘Diario del capitán…’ iii, p. 370Google Scholar notes that in Conceptión del Uruguay ‘There are now [1796] present in the port eight lanchas that carry 1,000 hides each, that do nothing except transport the same to Buenos Aires.’

13 Maeder, , Historia económica, p. 237.Google Scholar

14 Cardiff, Guillermo Furlong, Misiones y sus pueblos de guaraníes (Buenos Aires, 1962), pp. 402–10.Google Scholar

15 Sepp, Anton and Boehm, Anton, Reisebeschreibung: Wie nemlichen dieselbe auss Hispanien in Paraquarium kommeni und kurzer Bericht der denchwuerdigslen Sachen selbiger Landscbaft, Voelkein und Arbeitung der sich alldort befinden (Ingolstatt, 1712), p. 233.Google Scholar

16 Hernández, Pablo, Misiones del Paraguay. Organizatión social de las doctrinas de la Campañía de Jesús, 2 vols (Barcelona, 1913), I, p. 544.Google Scholar

17 Cabildo of Corrientes to Francisco de Paula Bucarelli, 6 July 1769 in Archivo General de la Natión, Buenos Aires, room IX, cabinet 3, shelf 3, legajo 7 [hereafter cited as AGN 9–3–3–7].

18 The guías for the 1770–79 period describe only those cattle exported to Misiones by way of the Uruguay and Alto Paraná. See Maeder, , Historia económica, pp. 227–32.Google Scholar

19 Maeder, , Historia económica, pp. 231–2.Google Scholar

20 Maeder, Ernesto J. A., ‘El caso Misiones, su proceso histórico y su posterior distributión territorial’, in Randle, P. H. (ed.), La geografía y la historia en la identidad nacional, 2 vols (Buenos Aires, 1981), 11, 153–7.Google Scholar

21 Aquirre, , ‘Diario del capitán …’ 11Google Scholar, primera parte, p. 383; Azara emphasised these same points, noting that as a result of such conditions, ‘the cows of Paraguay begin to breed only when three years old, whereas those of Montevideo produce young at the age of two’. He also stressed that Paraguayan stockraising suffered from the absence of barrero, a saline soil devoured by cattle in other parts of the Plata and ‘without which they perish’. Adequate supplies of salt were also lacking in Misiones. See Azara, , The Natural History of the Quadrupeds of Paraguay and the River La Plata (Edinburgh, 1838), pp. 64–5Google Scholar; Huret, Jules, La Argentina. De Buenos Aires al Gran Chaco (Paris, n.d.), pp. 436–8.Google Scholar

22 Maeder, Ernesto J. A., ‘La producción ganadera de Corrientes entre 1700 y 1810’, in Bicentenario del virreinato del Río de la Plata, 2 vols (Buenos Aires, 1977), 1, pp. 329, 343–5.Google Scholar See also guías of 1782–84 in AGN 9–3–27–7.

23 Acuerdo of 2 June 1783 in AGPC (Papeles de gobernador Alonso de Quesada).

24 Alonso de Quesada to Governor-Intendant Francisco de Paula Sanz, Sept. 1787, in AGN 9–3–4–1.

25 Maeder, , Historia económica, p. 235.Google Scholar

26 J. P., and Robertson, W. P., Letters on South America Comprising Travels on the Banks of the Paraná and the Río de la Plata, 3 vols (London, 1843), iii, PP. 58–9, 82–7.Google Scholar

27 See, for example, Juan José López to the Consulado of Buenos Aires, 3 June 1803, in AGN 9–4–6–4 (folio 211).

28 Decrees of 18 June 1792 and 18 May 1795 in AGPC AC 27 (1790–97).

29 Informe of Serapio Benítez, 27 May 1795 in AGPC AC 27 (1790–97).

30 AGPC Documentos de Gobierno 37 (1803) and 40 (1806–7).

31 Acta of 19 Aug. 1803 cited in Maeder, , Historia económica, pp. 244–5.Google Scholar

32 Ibid.

33 Regarding the ‘Andresito’ campaign, see Cabral, Salvador, Andresito Artigas en la emancipatión americana (Buenos Aires, 1980).Google Scholar

34 Informe of José Ignacio Aguirre, commandant of San Roque, cited in Mantilla, Manuel Florencio, Crónica histórica de Corrientes, 2 vols (Buenos Aires, 1928–29), 1, p. 182.Google Scholar

35 Maeder, , ‘La evolutión de la ganadería,’ p. 14Google Scholar; Gómez, Hernán Félix, La ciudad de Curuzú Cuatiá. Antecedentes de su fundación y su dominio jurisdictional (Corrientes, 1929).Google Scholar

36 Regarding the career of Fernández Blanco, see Mantilla, , Crónica histórica, 1, pp. 236–41Google Scholar; and Palma, Federico, ‘Cronología de gobernantes correntinos 1588–1963’, Archivo General. Cuadernos de Historia, serie 1:1 (1964), p. 15.Google Scholar

37 Law of 29 Dec. 1821, and Decree of 19 May 1822, in Registro oficial de la provincia de Corrientes (1821–1859), 8 vols, reprint (Corrientes, 1929–31) [hereafter ROPC], 1, pp. 63, 115–16 respectively.

38 Law of 7 Feb. 1825 in ROPC 1, p. 366.

39 Law of 13 May 1831 in ROPC iii, pp. 25–6.

40 D'Orbigny, Alcides, Viaje a la América meridional, 4 vols (Buenos Aires, 1945), 1, pp. 203–5.Google Scholar D'Orbigny, a French traveller who visited the northeast between 1826 and 1833, remarked that the Riograndense cattle were originally stolen by Mission Indians; the Indians were despoiled of their prize by Correntino troops and subsequently took revenge by raiding Curuzú Cuatiá in 1827.

41 Maeder, , ‘La evolutión de la ganadería’, pp. 4–5.Google Scholar

42 Law of 23 Dec. 1829, in ROPC ii, p. 3 30, nonetheless permitted the export of bulls and oxen; law of 31 Oct. 1835 in Ibid., iii, pp. 229–30; decree of 26 July 1838 in Ibid., iv, pp. 80–3; and decree of 11 May 1838 in Ibid., iv, pp. 76–7.

43 Law of 27 Jan. 1835 in Ibid., iii, p. 268.

44 Ibid.; see also Law of 31 Oct. 1834 in Ibid., iii, pp. 229–30.

45 Brown, Jonathan, A Socioeconomic History of Argentina 1776–1860 (Cambridge, 1979), pp. 110–11.Google Scholar

46 Ibid.; see also Latham, Wilfred, The States of the River Plate: Their Industries and Commerce (London, 1866), pp. 6–11, 113–25.Google Scholar

47 Ferré's defence of interior interests over those of Buenos Aires was longstanding. See Pedro Ferré to the Government of Buenos Aires, Corrientes, 3 March 1825 in AGN 10–5–7–2. See also Burgin, Miron, The Economic Aspects of Argentine Federalism, 1820–1852 (Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1946), pp. 148–51, 228–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

48 Law of 26 June 1827 in ROPC ii, pp. 117–22. The tax paid for the upkeep of a rural police force.

49 Twenty years later, the situation for sheep raising had improved in the northeast, thanks to the expanding carpet and weaving industries of France and Belgium, which fostered an increased demand for wool from the region.

50 Provincial census of 1854 in AGPC Censos 8, 9, 10.

51 Maeder, , ‘Evolución de la ganadenía en Corrientes’, p. 12.Google Scholar

52 Manifiesto general de haciendas, año 1834 [sic], 4 Mar. 1833 in AGPC Expedientes Administrativos [hereafter EA] (1833), p. 38.

53 Decree of 30 Apr. 1839 in Archivo Nacional de Asuncioń, Sectión Histórica [hereafter ANA SH], vol. 2.

54 Gelly, Juan Andrés, Paraguay: lo que fue, lo que es, y lo que será (Paris, 1926), p. 55Google Scholar, argues that the massacre of livestock was designed to reduce the herds of private ranchers while leaving state holdings untouched. In fact, the April decree applied to all animals regardless of ownership. Diseased cattle were still being reported at Paraguayan ports of entry as late as 1844. See Santiago Marín to Carlos Antonio López, Pilar, 8 Aug. 1844, in ANA SH, vol. 395.

55 José Mariano de Matos to Ignacio José de Oliveira Guimaraens, Alegrete, 2; Aug. 1839 in Arquivo Histórico do Rio Grande do Sul [hereafter AHRGS], Coleção Varela, no. xxi; Domingos José de Almeida to José Mariano de Matos, Caleira, 26 July 1841, AHRGS, Coleção Varela no. xxviii.

56 Joaquín Madariaga to Barão de Caxias, Villanueva, 16 Mar. 1844 in AGPC Copiador de Notas, Ministerio de gobierno, no. 9.

57 Leitman, Spencer Lewis, Raízes Sócio-Económicos da Guerra dos Farrapos (Rio de Janeiro, 1979), p. 95Google Scholar; Paraguay had been the chief source of mules for Rio Grande do Sul in th early period of the war, but sporadic disputes with the Correntinos cut the trade drastically by 1838.

58 Treaty of Villanueva, cited in El Republicano (Corrientes) 20 Aug. 1843; for consequences of the treaty, see Mantilla, , Crónica histórica., ii, pp. 88–9.Google Scholar

59 Decree of 20 Mar. 1843 in ROPC v, p. 115.

60 Ibid., pp. 301, 303.

61 AGPC EA 1840, legajos 61–2; 1841, legajo 63; Maeder, , Historia económica, p. 245.Google Scholar

62 ROPC vi, pp. 112, 232–3, 349–51, 360, 459–60.

63 AGPC Comprobantes del Libro de Caja 1848, legajos 57–8; 1849, legajos 59–61; 1850, legajos 62–4. See also Rivera, Alberto A., ‘El comercio de cabotage desde el puerto de Corrientes. Exportaciones entre 1848–1855’, Cuadernos de Estudios Reginales, no. 7 (1984), p. 41Google Scholar, for a somewhat larger figure of just over 160,000 hides exported.

64 AGPC Censos, legajos 8, 9, 10.

65 Maeder, , ‘La evolutión de la ganadería’, p. 14.Google Scholar

66 This seems to be the same Hughes who was instrumental in early attempts to open Paraguay to British commerce. He visited Asunción in October 1841, and was well received by the consular government of Carlos Antonio López and Mariano Roque Alonzo. See notice of 15 Aug. 1855 in El Comercio (Corrientes), 23 Aug. 1855.

67 Page, Thomas J., La Plata, the Argentine Confederation and Paraguay (New York, 1859), p. 303.Google Scholar

68 La Opinión (Corrientes), 11 Apr. 1858.

69 M. G., and Mulhall, E. T., River Plate Handbook, Guide, Directory, and Almanac for 1863 (Buenos Aires, 1863), p. 225.Google Scholar

70 La Opinión, 25 Sept. 1857.

71 Page, La Plata, p. 295; see also Quesada, Ernesto, ‘Pujol y la época de la confederatión’, Revista argentina de ciencias políticos 8 ( 1917), 257–92.Google Scholar

72 He argued specifically that this measure did not attack the right of property. See Pujol, Juan, Corrientes en la organizatión nacional, 10 vols (Buenos Aires, 1911), v, p. 9.Google Scholar

73 El Progreso (Corrientes), 4 Dec. 1864.

74 Kennedy, A. J., La Plata, Brazil and Paraguay during the Present War (London, 1869), p. 37.Google Scholar Another eyewitness stated that 100,000 head of confiscated cattle accompanied the Paraguayans across the river during their retreat from Corrientes some weeks later. See Thompson, George, The War in Paraguay (London, 1869), p. 97.Google Scholar

75 Neddermann, Ursula I., ‘El proceso ganadero y el poblamiento en la provincia de Corrientes (1854–1914)’, Cuadernos de Estudios Regionales 4 (1982), p. 29.Google Scholar

76 Ibid., pp. 21–50.