Cognitive impairment can affect an individual’s ability to perform routine tasks. In this study, we investigate how cognitive abilities relate to the accuracy and efficiency of performance on a naturalistic cooking task completed in older adults’ home environments. We hypothesized a positive association between task accuracy and global cognitive status, and task efficiency and executive functioning. We further hypothesized a negative association between omission errors and immediate and delayed memory recall.

Fourteen community-dwelling older adults (Age, M = 73.92 years; Female = 9; Education, M = 16.38 years) along the continuum from normal aging to mild dementia completed a “Cooking Task” in their home environment. Specifically, participants were instructed to fry or scramble an egg, prepare slice of toast with jelly, serve side of sliced apple, pour glass of water, bring prepared items to table, and clean dishes used. Participants received ingredients necessary for task completion and a task list to reference. The task efficiency score (range 0-6) was based on multi-tasking and organizational skills (e.g., beginning the egg task early in session, plating items as prepared). Overall accuracy was computed by identifying error types (e.g., inefficiencies, substitutions, omissions, and subtasks attempted) and scaling accuracy (range 1-5) for each subtask, then summing all six subtask accuracy scores to get overall accuracy (range 6-30). Participants also completed a range of neuropsychological assessments, which included the Telephone Interview for Cognitive Status, Letter and Category Fluency from the Delis-Kaplan Executive Function System, and immediate and delayed recall measures from the Repeatable Battery for the Assessment of Neuropsychological Status. Due to the small sample size, findings are preliminary, and scatterplots were evaluated for outliers that might influence findings.

Consistent with hypotheses, as overall accuracy on the Cooking Task increased so did performance on the global cognitive measure (TICS: r = 0.61, p = 0.02). Lower rates of omission errors were also associated with better performance on both immediate (r = -0.75, p < 0.01) and delayed (r = -0.55, p = 0.04) recall indices. However, these findings were not specific, as overall accuracy also significantly correlated with the memory indices and verbal fluency measures (ps < 0.05). Additionally, lower rates of omission errors significantly correlated with performance on the TICS and the D-KEFS Letter Fluency (ps < 0.05). Contrary to our hypothesis, no significant associations were found between cooking task efficiency and executive functioning (D-KEFS subtests). There were also no significant correlations between cooking task efficiency and global cognitive status or memory.

The present study supported our hypotheses that better overall task accuracy is associated with higher cognitive status and lower rates of omission errors correlate with better immediate and delayed recall abilities. However, the findings were not specific to these domains of functioning but rather suggest that clinical assessments measuring a range of cognitive abilities are related to the accuracy of daily task performance and omission errors on routine daily tasks. Future research will explore the validity of the efficiency measure.