Hostname: page-component-84b7d79bbc-g78kv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-27T06:47:58.420Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Experiments in the Courtroom: Social Dynamics and Spectacles of Proof in Early Modern English Witch Trials

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

Orna Alyagon Darr
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article presents the composite social context surrounding the “experiments” that were used to prove witchcraft accusations in early modern England. It demonstrates that legal proof was not imposed by elite legislators and judges, or fashioned in accordance with the voice of scientific experts, but was shaped through complex social dynamics in which the middling sort and petty gentry fulfilled a crucial role. Through this process, popular beliefs percolated into judicial proceedings. Members of influential provincial families were the social agents who reconstructed old supernatural methods of proof into innovative rational experiments, often replicating public displays of proof that helped bolster the criminal charges and provided a competing arena of evidence. The article claims that the judges' cooperation with these “experiments” might have been an endeavor by the official legal system to circumvent the threat posed by a popular grassroots alternative to the exclusive jurisdiction of the court system.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 39 , Issue 1 , Winter 2014 , pp. 152 - 175
Copyright
Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 2014 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References

Ady, Thomas 1655. A Candle in the Dark: Shewing the Divine Cause of the Distractions of the Whole Nation of England and of the Christian World. London: Robert Ibbitson.Google Scholar
Almond, Philip C. 2012. The Lancashire Witches: A Chronicle of Sorcery and Death on Pendle Hill. London: I. B. Tauris.Google Scholar
Alyagon Darr, Orna 2011. Marks of an Absolute Witch: Evidentiary Dilemmas in Early Modern England. Farnham, UK: Ashgate.Google Scholar
Anon, . 1613. Vvitches Apprehended, Examined and Executed, for Notable Villanies by Them Committed Both by Land and Water: With a Strange and Most True Triall How to Know Whether a Woman Be a Witch or Not. London: Edward Marchant.Google Scholar
Anon, . 1650. Wonderfull News from the North, or, a True Relation of the Sad and Grievovs Torments, Inflicted Upon the Bodies of Three Children of Mr. George Muschamp, Late of the County of Northumberland. London: T. H.Google Scholar
Anon, . 1682. A Tryal of Witches, at the Assizes Held at Bury St. Edmonds for the County of Suffolk, on the Tenth Day of March, 1664: Before Sir Matthew Hale Kt. Then Lord Chief Baron of His Majesties Court of Exchequer. London: William Shrewsbery.Google Scholar
Anon, . 1712. The Case of the Hertfordshire Witchcraft Consider'd: Being an Examination of a Book, Entitl'd, a Full and Impartial Account of the Discovery of Sorcery & Witchcraft, Practis'd by Jane Wenham of Walkern, Upon the Bodies of Anne Thorne, Anne Street, &C. 1712. London: John Pemberton.Google Scholar
Austin, John Langshaw. 1962. How to Do Things with Words. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Bacon, Francis 1857–1874. Sylva Sylvarum: Or a Natural History in Ten Centuries. In The Works of Francis Bacon, ed. Spedding, James, Ellis, Robert Leslie, and Heath, Douglas Denon Boston: Riverside Press.Google Scholar
Baker, John Hamilton 1990. An Introduction to English Legal History. London: Butterworths.Google Scholar
Baker, John Hamilton 2000. Why the History of English Law Has Not Been Finished. Cambridge Law Journal 59 (1): 62–84.Google Scholar
Bartlett, Robert 1986. Trial by Fire and Water: The Medieval Judicial Ordeal. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Bernard, Richard 1627. A Guide to Grand‐Iury Men. London: Blackmore.Google Scholar
Braddick, Michael J., and Walter, John 2001. Negotiating Power in Early Modern Society: Order, Hierarchy and Subordination in Britain and Ireland. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Bradwell, Stephen 1603. Marie Glovers Late Woefull Case: Together WIth Her Joyfull Deliverance Written Upon Occasion of Dr. Jordens Discourse of the Mother …: With a Defence of the Truthe against D. J. His Scandalous Impugnations. London.Google Scholar
Bragge, Francis. 1712. A Full and Impartial Account of the Discovery of Sorcery and Witchcraft, Practis'd by Jane Wenham of Walkerne. London: E. Curll.Google Scholar
Byville, Eric 2011. How to Do Witchcraft Tragedy with Speech Acts. Comparative Drama 45 (2): 1–33.Google Scholar
Clark, Stuart. 1977. King Jame's Daemonologie: Witchcraft and Kingship. In The Damned Art, ed. Anglo, Sydney, 156–181. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
Clark, Stuart. 1984. The Scientific Status of Demonology. In Occult and Scientific Mentalities in the Renaissance, ed. Vickers, Brian, 351–374. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Clark, Stuart. 1997. Thinking with Demons: The Idea of Witchcraft in Early Modern Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Collins, H. M. 1992. Changing Order: Replication and Induction in Scientific Practice. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Cooper, Thomas. 1617. The Mystery of Witch‐Craft: Discouering, the Truth, Nature, Occasions, Growth and Power Thereof. Together with the Detection and Punishment of the Same. As Also, the Seuerall Stratagems of Sathan, Ensnaring the Poore Soule by This Desperate Practize of Annoying the Bodie… . London: Nicholas Okes.Google Scholar
Cotta, John 1616. The Triall of Vvitch‐Craft: Shewing the True and Right Methode of the Discouery: With a Confutation of Erroneous Wayes. By Iohn Cotta, Doctor in Physicke. London: Samuel Rand.Google Scholar
Culpeper, Jonathan, and Semino, Elena 2000. Constructing Witches and Spells: Speech Acts and Activity Types in Early Modern England. Journal of Historical Pragmatics 1 (1): 97–116.Google Scholar
Dear, Peter 2001. Revolutionizing the Sciences: European Knowledge and Its Ambitions, 1500–1700. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Eamon, William 1994. Science and the Secrets of Nature. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Eisenstein, Elizabeth L. 1979. The Printing Press as an Agent of Change: Communications and Cultural Transformations in Early Modern Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Filmer, Sir Robert 1653. An Advertisement to the Jury‐Men of England, Touching Witches: Together with a Difference between an English and Hebrew Vvitch. London: Richard Royston.Google Scholar
Fisher, George 1997. The Jury's Rise as Lie Detector. Yale Law Journal 107:575–713.Google Scholar
French, Roger K. 1994. William Harvey's Natural Philosophy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Gaskill, Malcolm 2000. Crime and Mentalities in Early Modern England. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Gaskill, Malcolm 2005. Witchfinders: A Seventeenth‐Century English Tragedy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Gaule, John. 1646. Select Cases of Conscience Touching Vvitches and Vvitchcrafts. By Iohn Gaule, Preacher of the Word at Great Staughton in the County of Huntington. London: Richard Clutterbuck.Google Scholar
Geis, Gilbert, and Bunn, Ivan 1997. A Trial of Witches: A Seventeenth‐Century Witchcraft Prosecution. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Gibson, Marion. 1999. Reading Witchcraft: Stories of Early English Witches. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Gibson, Marion. 2000. Early Modern Witches: Witchcraft Cases in Contemporary Writing. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Glanvill, Joseph. 1668. A Blow at Modern Sadducism in Some Philosophical Considerations About Witchcraft: To Which Is Added the Relation of the Fam'd Disturbance by the Drummer in the House of Mr. John Mompesson, with Some Reflections on Drollery and Atheisme. London: James Collins.Google Scholar
Great News from the West of England: Being a True Account of Two Young Persons Lately Bewitch'd in the Town of Beckenton in Somerset‐Shire … And of the Old Witch Being Carryed Several Times to a Great River, into Which Her Legs Being Tied, She Was Thrice Thrown In … Afterwards by Order from a Justice of the Peace She Was Search'd by a Jury of Women and Such Signs and Marks Being Found About Her… . 1689. London: T. M.Google Scholar
Green, Thomas Andrew 1985. Verdict According to Conscience: Perspectives on the English Criminal Trial Jury, 1200–1800. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Greenwel, Thomas 1704. A Full and True Account of the Discovering, Apprehending and Taking of a Notorious Witch : Who Was Carried before Justice Bateman in Well‐Close, on Sunday, July the 23: Together with Her Examination and Commitment to Bridewel, Clerkenwel. London: H. Hills.Google Scholar
Hackett, Jeremiah 2007. Experience and Demonstration in Roger Bacon: A Critical Review of Some Modern Interpretations. In Experience and Demonstration: The Sciences of Nature in the 13th and 14th Centuries, ed. Werner, Doothee, Antolic, Pia, and Hoffmann, Peter, 41–58. Berlin: Akademie Verlag.Google Scholar
Harrison, Peter 2011. Experimental Religion and Experimental Science in Early Modern England. Intellectual History Review 21 (4): 413–433.Google Scholar
Helmholz, R. H. 1996. The Spirit of Classical Canon Law. Athens: University of Georgia Press.Google Scholar
Ho, H. L. 2003–2004. The Legitimacy of Medieval Proof. Journal of Law & Religion 19:259–298.Google Scholar
Hole, Christina 1957. A Mirror of Witchcraft. London: Chatto & Windus.Google Scholar
Holmes, Clive. 1984. Popular Culture? Witches, Magistrates and Divines in Early Modern England. In Understanding Popular Culture: Europe from the Middle Ages to the Nineteenth Century, ed. Kaplan, S. L., 85–111. Berlin: Mouton.Google Scholar
James, I. 1597. Daemonologie: In Forme of a Dialogue, Diuided into Three Bookes. Edinburgh: Robert Walde‐graue.Google Scholar
Johns, Adrian 1999. Identity, Practice, and Trust in Early Modern Natural Philosophy. Historical Journal 42 (4): 1125–1145.Google Scholar
Kerr, Margaret H., Forsyth, Richard D., and Plyley, Michael J. 1992. Cold Water and Hot Iron: Trial by Ordeal in England. Journal of Interdisciplinary History 22 (4): 573–595.Google Scholar
Kittredge, George Lyman 1929. Witchcraft in Old and New England. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Kuhn, Thomas S. 1976. Mathematical vs. Experimental Traditions in the Development of Physical Science. Journal of Interdisciplinary History 7 (1): 1–31.Google Scholar
Lake, Peter 1988. Anglicans and Puritans? Presbyterianism and English Conformist Thought from Whitgift to Hooker. London: Unwin Hyman.Google Scholar
Levack, Brian P. 1995. The Witch‐Hunt in Early Modern Europe. New York: Longman.Google Scholar
MacDonald, Michael. 1991. Witchcraft and Hysteria in Elizabethan England: Edward Jorden and the Mary Glover Case. In Tavistock Classics in the History of Psychiatry. London: Tavistock/Routledge.Google Scholar
Martin, Julian 1992. Francis Bacon, the State and the Reform of Natural Philosophy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
McAuley, Finbarr 2006. Canon Law and the End of the Ordeal. Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 26 (3): 473–513.Google Scholar
McCreery, John L. 1995. Negotiating with Demons: The Uses of Magical Language. American Ethnologist 22 (1): 144–164.Google Scholar
The Most Strange and Admirable Discouerie of the Three Witches of Warboys: Arraigned, Conuicted, and Executed at the Last Assises at Huntington, for the Bewitching of the Fiue Daughters of Robert Throckmorton Esquire, and Diuers Other Persons… . 1593. London: Thomas Man and Iohn Winington.Google Scholar
Perkins, William. 1608. A Discourse of the Damned Art of Witchcraft: So Farre Forth as It Is Reuealed in the Scriptures, and Manifest by True Experience. Framed and Deliuered by M. William Perkins, in His Ordinarie Course of Preaching… . Cambridge: Vniuersitie of Cambridge.Google Scholar
Pihlajamaki, Heikki 2000. “Swimming the Witch, Pricking for the Devil's Mark”: Ordeals in the Early Modern Witchcraft Trials. Journal of Legal History 21 (2): 35–58.Google Scholar
Pollock, Sir Frederick, and Maitland, Frederic William 1895. The History of English Law Before the Time of Edward I. Cambridge: University Press.Google Scholar
Popper, Karl Raimund 2004. The Logic of Scientific Discovery. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Reiber DeWindt, Anne 1995. Witchcraft and Conflicting Visions of the Ideal Village Community. Journal of British Studies 34 (4): 427–463.Google Scholar
Rosen, Barbara 1972. Witchcraft. In Stratford‐Upon‐Avon Library. New York: Taplinger.Google Scholar
Sargent, Rose‐Mary 1989. Scientific Experiment and Legal Expertise: The Way of Experience in Seventeenth‐Century England. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A 20 (1): 19–45.Google Scholar
Searle, John R. 1969. Speech Acts: An Essay in the Philosophy of Language. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Shapin, Steven 1994. A Social History of Truth: Civility and Science in Seventeenth‐Century England. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Shapin, Steven 1996. The Scientific Revolution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Shapin, Steven 2010. Never Pure: Historical Studies of Science as If it Was Produced by People with Bodies, Situated in Time, Space, Culture, and Society, and Struggling for Credibility and Authority. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
Shapin, Steven, and Schaffer, Simon 1985. Leviathan and the Air‐Pump: Hobbes, Boyle, and the Experimental Life. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Shapiro, Barbara J. 1969. Law and Science in Seventeenth‐Century England. Stanford Law Review 21 (4): 727–766.Google Scholar
Shapiro, Barbara J. 1991. “Beyond Reasonable Doubt” and “Probable Cause”: Historical Perspectives on the Anglo‐American Law of Evidence. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Shapiro, Barbara J. 2000. A Culture of Fact: England, 1550–1720. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Shapiro, Barbara J. 2008. The Beyond Reasonable Doubt Doctrine: “Moral Comfort” or Standard of Proof? Law and Humanities 2 (2): 149–173.Google Scholar
Sharpe, James A. 1996. Instruments of Darkness: Witchcraft in England 1550–1750. London: Hamish Hamilton.Google Scholar
Sharpe, James A. 2000. The Bewitching of Anne Gunter: A Horrible and True Story of Deception, Witchcraft, Murder, and the King of England. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Sofer, Andrew 2009. How to Do Things with Demons: Conjuring Performatives in Doctor Faustus. Theatre Journal 61 (1): 1–21.Google Scholar
Stearne, John 1648. A Confirmation and Discovery of Witchcraft: Containing These Severall Particulars: That There Are Witches … Together with the Confessions of Many of Those Executed since May 1645. London: William Wilson.Google Scholar
Thomas, Keith. 1971. Religion and the Decline of Magic. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.Google Scholar
The Tryal of Richard Hathaway: Upon an Information for Being a Cheat and Imposter, for Endeavouring to Take Away the Life of Sarah Morduck, for Being a Vvitch, at Surry Assizes, Begun and Held in the Burrough of Southwark, March the 24th, 1702… . 1702. London: Isaac Cleave.Google Scholar
W. W. 1582. A True and Iust Recorde, of the Information, Examination and Confession of All the Witches, Taken at S. Oses in the Countie of Essex … Wherein All Men May See What a Pestilent People Witches Are, and How Vnworthy to Lyue in a Christian Commonwealth. Written Orderly, as the Cases Were Tryed by Euidence. London: Thomas Dawson.Google Scholar
Werrett, Simon 2011. Watching the Fireworks: Early Modern Observation of Natural and Artificial Spectacles. Science in Context 24 (2): 167–182.Google Scholar
Whitman, James O. 2008a. The Origins of Reasonable Doubt: Theological Roots of the Criminal Trial. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Whitman, James O. 2008b. Response to Shapiro. Law and Humanities 2 (2): 175–189.Google Scholar
The Witches of Northampton‐Shire: Agnes Browne. Ioane Vaughan. Arthur Bill. Hellen Ienkenson. Mary Barber. Witches. Who Were All Executed at Northampton the 22. Of Iuly Last. 1612. 1612. London: Arthur Iohnson.Google Scholar
Witchcraft Act, 33 Hen. VIII, c. 8 (1542).Google Scholar
Witchcraft Act, 5 Eliz., c. 16 (1563).Google Scholar
Witchcraft Act, 1 Jac. I, c. 12 (1604).Google Scholar
Witchcraft Act, 9 Geo. II c. 5 (1735).Google Scholar
Witchcraft Act, 33 Hen. VIII, c. 8 (1542).Google Scholar
Witchcraft Act, 5 Eliz., c. 16 (1563).Google Scholar
Witchcraft Act, 1 Jac. I, c. 12 (1604).Google Scholar
Witchcraft Act, 9 Geo. II c. 5 (1735).Google Scholar