Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gxg78 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-22T15:06:13.108Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Standards of Medical Care Based on Consensus Rather than Evidence: The Case of Routine Bedrail Use for the Elderly

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 April 2021

Howard S. Rubenstein ,
Frances H. Miller ,
Sholem Postel  and
Hilda B. Evans
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

“An 88-year-old male patient was found on his hands and knees on the floor beside his bed. The bedrails were up.”—From an indent report filed by a nurse at the Stillman Infirmary, University Health Services, Harvard University, in May 1980.

Finding elderly patients lying on the floor beside their beds despite the presence of elevated bedrails seems paradoxical: how can a patient fall out of bed when the bedrails are up? Surprisingly, this paradox constitutes one of the leading incidents plaguing hospitals in the United States today. It exemplifies a much larger problem created, we believe, by the uncritical adoption of measures designed to enhance patient welfare, but which may in fact undermine it. This article documents our experience with bedrails, reviews the literature, and comments on the rationale for routine adoption of bedrails for the hospitalized elderly. It concludes by advocating that a randomized, controlled study be conducted to determine whether bedrails constitute protection or a hazard to the average elderly patient.

Type
Article
Information
Law, Medicine and Healthcare , Volume 11 , Issue 6 , December 1983 , pp. 271 - 276
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Law, Medicine and Ethics 1983

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Fagin, I.D. Vita, M., Who? Where? When? How?— An Analysis of 868 Inpatient Accidents, Hospitals 39(16): 60–65 (August 16, 1965) [hereinafter referred to as Analysis of 868 Accidents]; Ludlam, J.E., Bedrails: Up or Down? Hospitals 31(22): 46–47 (November 16, 1957) [hereinafter referred to as Bedrails]; Ludlam, J.E., Guide to a Planned Safety Program, Hospitals 29(12): 68–72 (December 1955) [hereinafter referred to as Safety Program]; Nelson, S., Keeping the Hospital Accident Toll Down, Hospitals 18(5): 30–31 (May 1944).Google Scholar
Betty, Y. Hu, Senior Programmer-Analyst, Office of Information Technology, Harvard University, performed the statistical analyses in this study.Google Scholar
Sehested, P. Severin-Nielsen, T., Falls by Hospitalized Elderly Patients: Causes, Prevention, Geriatrics 32(4): 101, 104 (April 1977) [hereinafter referred to as Falls by Hospitalized Elderly Patients]; Parrish, H.M. Weil, T.O., Patient Accidents Occurring in Hospitals: Epidemiologic Study of 614 Accidents, New York State Journal of Medicine 58(6): 838-46 (March 15, 1958) [hereinafter referred to as Epidemiologic Study]; Weil, T.P. Parrish, H.M., How Did It Happen? An Analysis of the Causes of 2,036 Patient Accidents at New York's Mourn Sinai Hospital, Hospitals 32(17): 43, 44 (September 1, 1958) [hereinafter referred to as How Did It Happen].Google Scholar
Greenlaw, J., Failure to Use Siderails: When Is It Negligence? Law, Medicine & Health Care 10(3): 125–28 (June 1982), citing Burks v. Christ Hosp., 249 N.E.2d 829 (Ohio 1969); Howard v. Research Hosp. & Medical Ctr., 563 S.W.2d 111 (Mo. App. 1978); Smith v. West Calcasieu-Cameron Hosp., 251 So.2d 810 (La. App. 1971); Weipert v. General Rose Mem. Hosp. Ass'n, 487 P.2d 615 (Colo. App. 1971).Google Scholar
See generally Watkins, J.S. Robson, P., The Hazards of Rehabilitation, Annals of the Royal College of Surgeons of England 63(6): 386-89 (November 1981) [hereinafter referred to as Rehabilitation]; Elliot, D.F., Accidents in Nursing Homes: Implications for Patients and Administrators, in Current Issues in Clinical Geriatrics (Miller, M.B., ed.) (Tiresias Press, New York) (1977) at 97-137 [hereinafter referred to as Accidents in Nursing Homes]; Scott, C.J., Accidents in Hospital with Special Reference to Old People, Health Bulletin (Edinburgh) 18: 33–35 (1976) [hereinafter referred to as Special Reference to the Old]; Buehrle, R., Where, When, How and Why of Accidents Among Patients, Hospital Administration in Canada 11: 24-26 (1969) [hereinafter referred to as Why of Accidents]; Analysis of 868 Accidents, supra note 1, at 61; Petrovsky, C.C., Accidents in the Hospital, Medical Journal of Australia 2: 943-47 (1965); Bain, T.D., Hospital Accidents to Staff and Patients, Medical Services Journal of Canada 15: 570-75 (1959); How Did It Happen, supra note 3, at 47; Epidemiologic Study, supra note 3; Bedrails, supra note 1, at 46; Price, A.L., Short Side Guards are Safer, Hospital Management 82(4): 86, 90 (October 1956) [hereinafter referred to as Short Side Guards]; Safety Program, supra note 1, at 69; Keeping the Hospital Accident Toll Down, supra note 1, at 30; Haigh, C. Hayman, J.M., Why They Fell out of Bed, Modern Hospitals 47(6): 45 (December 1936) [hereinafter referred to as Why They Fell]. Tyndall, Thelma M., of University Health Services at Harvard University, greatly facilitated the search through the literature.Google Scholar
See King, J.H., The Law of Medical Malpractice (West Publishing Co., St. Paul, Minn.) (1977) at 36–80 (hornbook discussion).Google Scholar
Bedraiis, , supra note 1, at 46.Google Scholar
Ladimer, I., Accidents in the Aged, New York State Journal of Medicine 75(3): 381, 383, 384 (February 1975).Google Scholar
How Did It Happen, supra note 3, at 47, 48.Google Scholar
Bedrails, supra note 1, at 47.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Analysis of 868 Accidents, supra note 1, at 63.Google Scholar
How Did It Happen, supra note 3, at 45.Google Scholar
Epidemiologic Study, supra note 3, at 845.Google Scholar
Bedrails, supra note 1.Google Scholar
Fine, W., An Analysis of 277 Falls in Hospital, Gerontologia Clinica 1: 292, 296 (1959) [hereinafter referred to as Falls in Hospital].Google Scholar
Short Side Guards, supra note 5, at 86, 90.Google Scholar
Safety Program, supra note 1, at 69.Google Scholar
Epidemiologic Study, supra note 3, at 843; Accidents in Nursing Homes, supra note 5.Google Scholar
Id.; Analysis of 868 Accidents, supra note 1, at 64; Why They Fell, supra note 5, at 62.Google Scholar
Rehabilitation, supra note 5, at 387.Google Scholar
National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), Malpractice Claims (Final Compilation): Medical Malpractice Closed Claims, July 1, 1975, Through June 30, 1978 (NAIC, Brookfield, Wise.) (vol. 2, 1980).Google Scholar
Safety Factors, in Harvard University, University Health Services, Nursing Procedures Manual (unpublished, rev. 1982).Google Scholar
Massachusetts General Hospital, Manual of Nursing Procedures (Little, Brown & Co., Boston, Mass.) (2nd ed. 1980).Google Scholar
Rehabilitation, supra note 5, at 387; Morris, E. V. Isaacs, B., The Prevention of Falls in a Geriatric Hospital, Age and Ageing 9(3): 181–85 (August 1980) [hereinafter referred to as Prevention]; Snell, W.E., Accidents to Patients in Hospital, Lancet 2: 1202 (December 8, 1956); Falls in Hospital, supra note 16, at 292.Google Scholar
Berry, G. Fisher, R.H. Lang, S., Detrimental Incidents, Including Falls, in an Elderly Institutional Population, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 29(7): 322, 323 (July 1981); Feist, R.R., A Survey of Accidental Falls in a Small Home for the Aged, Journal of Gerontological Nursing 4: 15-17 (1978); Scott, C.J., Special Reference to Old People, supra note 5; Manjam, N.V.B. MacKinnon, H.H., Patient, Bed, and Bathroom: A Study of Falls Occurring in a General Hospital, Nova Scotia Medical Bulletin 52(1): 25 (February 1973); Falls by Hospitalized Elderly Patients, supra note 3, at 103; Why of Accidents, supra note 5.Google Scholar
Sheldon, J.H., On the Natural History of Falls in Old Age, British Medical Journal 2: 1685–90 (December 10, 1960).Google ScholarPubMed
Bedraiis, , supra note 1, at 46; Safety Program, supra note 1, at 68.Google Scholar
Prevention, , supra note 25, at 181–85.Google Scholar
Amulree, Lord Exton-Smith, A.N. Crockett, G.S., Proper Use of Hospital in Treatment of the Aged Sick, Lancet 1: 123–26 (January 20, 1951).Google ScholarPubMed
See generally Schafer, A., The Ethics of the Randomized Clinical Trial, New England Journal of Medicine 307 (12): 719–24 (September 16, 1982); Annas, G.J. Glantz, L. Katz, B., Informed Consent to Human Experimentation: The Subject's Dilemma (Ballinger Publishing Co., Cambridge, Mass.) (1977).Google Scholar
45 C.F.R. §§46.110, 46.116 (1982).Google Scholar
45 C.F.R. §46.102(e) (1982).Google Scholar
45 C.F.R. §46.116(c)(2) (1982).Google Scholar
45 C.F.R. §46.102(g) (1982).Google Scholar
Schimmel, E.M., The Hazards of Hospitalization, Annals of Internal Medicine 60(1): 100, 109 (January 1964).Google ScholarPubMed
Clements, C.D. Sider, R.C., Medical Ethics’ Assault upon Medical Values, Journal of the American Medical Association 250(15): 2011–15 (October 21, 1983).Google ScholarPubMed