Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-fscjk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T08:21:57.022Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Turkish nationalism at its beginning: Analysis of Türk Yurdu, 1913–1918

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 November 2018

Özgür Balkιlιç  and
Deniz Dölek
Özgür Balkιlιç*
Affiliation:
History, Wilfrid Laurier University, Ontario, Canada
Deniz Dölek
Affiliation:
History, Middle East Technical University, Ankara, Turkey
*
∗Corresponding author. Email: balk9720@mylaurier.ca
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Turkish nationalism became an element of the Ottoman political scene in the late nineteenth century. Although its roots can be traced back to the Hamidian period (1876–1909), Turkish nationalism emerged as one of the most important political ideologies during the Constitutional Regime. Wars that the Ottoman State participated in from 1911 to the end of the empire in 1918 resulted in population and land losses. Especially, following the Balkan Wars, most of the lands that were populated by non-Muslim and non-Turkish subjects were lost. Within this context, Turkish nationalism came to be seen as the most dominant ideological tool intended to save the Empire. This article argues that Turkish nationalism emerged as a reactive ideology that addressed Ottomanism and Islamism, which were the two other dominant state ideologies during the late Ottoman State, due to the changing political context. In this article, Türk Yurdu, a well-known and influential periodical, is used as the primary source of reference to demonstrate the basic features of Turkish nationalism in its infancy.

Keywords

Turkish NationalismTürk YurduThe Balkan WarsThe Ottoman Empire
Type
Articles
Information
Nationalities Papers , Volume 41 , Issue 2 , March 2013 , pp. 316 - 333
Copyright
Copyright © 2013 Association for the Study of Nationalities 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Agayef, Ahmed. 1998a. “Siyasiyat: Türk Alemi [Politics: Turkish World].” Türk Yurdu 1 (7). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Agayef, Ahmed. 1998b. “Türk Alemi-6 [Turkish World].” Türk Yurdu 1 (10). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Agayef, Ahmed. 1998c. “Türk Alemi-1 [Turkish World].” Türk Yurdu 1 (1). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Agayef, Ahmed. 1999a. “Tarih ve Asar-ı Atika: Türk Medeniyeti Tarihi [History and Old Vestiges: The History of the Turkish Civilization].” Türk Yurdu 2 (40). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Agayef, Ahmed. 1999b. “İçtimaiyat: İslam'da Dava-yı Millet [Sociology: Issue of Nation in Islam].” Türk Yurdu 3 (71). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Akçura, Yusuf. 1978. Türkçülük: Türkçülüğün Tarihi Gelişimi [Turkism: The Historical Development of Turkism]. İstanbul: Türk Kültür Publication.Google Scholar
Akçura, Yusuf. 1998a. “Türk Aleminde [In Turkish World].” Türk Yurdu 1 (21). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Akçura, Yusuf. 1998b. “Emel ve İdeal [Aspiration and Ideal].” Türk Yurdu 1 (16). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Akçura, Yusuf. 1998c. “Tarih ve Asar-ı Atika: Müverrih Leon Cahun ve Muallim Barthold'a Göre Cengiz Han [History and Old Vestiges: Cenghis Khan According to Historian Leon Cahun and Professor Barthold].” Türk Yurdu 1 (1). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Akçura, Yusuf. 1999a. “Geçen Yıl: 1329 Senesinde Türk Dünyası [Past Year: Turkish World in 1911].” Türk Yurdu 3 (64). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Akçura, Yusuf. 1999b. “Siyasat ve İçtimaiyat: Milliyet Fikri ve Millet Muharebeleri [Politics and Sociology: The Idea of Nation and the Battles Between Nations].” Türk Yurdu 2 (33). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Akçura, Yusuf. 1999c. “Tarih ve Asar-ı Atika: Avrupa'da Milliyet Fikrine ve Milliyet Cereyanlarına Dair [History and Old Vestiges: On the Idea of Nation and the Currents of Nationalism in Europe.” Türk Yurdu 3 (67). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Akçura, Yusuf. 1999d. “Türk Dünyasından: Cihan Harbi ve Türkler [From the Turkish World: The World War and Turks].” Türk Yurdu 4 (73). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Akçura, Yusuf. 1999e. “Talim ve Terbiye: Düşünülecek Meselelerimizden [Train and Discipline: The Matters We Should Consider].” Türk Yurdu 4 (75). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Akçura, Yusuf. 1999f. “Türklük [Being a Turk]. TürkYurdu 2. Altın Armağan. Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Alaaddin, İbrahim. 2000. “Talim ve Terbiye: Terbiye-i Bediiye-5 [Train and Discipline: Discipline of Body.” Türk Yurdu 6 (131). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Ali, Emin. 2000. “Edebiyat: Anadolu ve Cengimiz [Literature: Anatolia and Our War].” Türk Yurdu 5 (122). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Anderson, Benedict. 1992. Imagined Communities. London: Verso.Google Scholar
Arai, Masami. 1992. Turkish Nationalism in the Young Turk Era. Leiden: E. J. Brill.Google Scholar
Arif, Mehmed. 2000. “Lübnan Hatııraları [Lebanon Memories].” Türk Yurdu 7 (153). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Atuf, Nafi. 1999. “Talim ve Terbiye: Seciye [Train and Discipline: Character].” Türk Yurdu 4 (103). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Atuf, Nafi. 2000. “Talim ve Terbiye: Maarifimiz Hakkında [Train and Discipline: On Our Education System].” Türk Yurdu 5 (116). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Bora, Tanıl. 1999. “İnşa Döneminde Türk Milli Kimliği [Turkish National Character in its Construction].” In Türk Sağının Üç Hali: Milliyetçilik, Muhafazakarlık, İslamcılık, edited by Bora, Tanxl, 113–153. İstanbul: Birikim Publications.Google Scholar
Brass, Paul R. 1991. Ethnicity and Nationalism. London: SAGE Publications.Google Scholar
Breuilly, John. 1985. Nationalism and the State. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Breuilly, John. 1996. “Approaches to Nationalism.” In Mapping the Nation, edited by Balakrishnan, Gopal, 146–175. London: Verso.Google Scholar
Doğan. 1999. “Mukaddesat: Büyük Rüya [The Holy Things: The Great Dream].” Türk Yurdu 4 (102). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Edib, Halide. 1999. “Edebiyat: Padişah ve Şehzadelerimize [Literature: To Our Sultans and Princes].” Türk Yurdu 2 26. Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Emin, Mehmed. 1998. “Edebiyat: Anadolu [Literature: Anatolia].” Türk Yurdu 1 (14). Ankara: Tutibay Publications. Print.Google Scholar
Fahri, Halid. 2000. “Seyahat: Muğla Türküleri ve İçtimai Yaralar [Travel: Muğla Folk Songs and Social Wounds].” Türk Yurdu 6 (142). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Georgeon, François. 1999. Türk Milliyetçiliğinin Kökenleri: Yusuf Akçura (1876–1935) [The Roots of Turkish Nationalism: Yusuf Akçura]. Translated by A. Er. İstanbul: Tarih Vakfı Yurt Publications.Google Scholar
Gökalp, Ziya. 1999a. “İçtimaiyat: Türkleşmek, İslamlaşmak, Muasırlaşmak-1 [Sociology: Turkification, Islamization and Westernization].” Türk Yurdu 2 35. Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Gökalp, Ziya. 1999b. “İçtimaiyat: Türkleşmek, İslamlaşmak, Muasırlaşmak-7 [Sociology: Turkification, Islamization and Westernization].” Türk Yurdu 3 (56). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Gökalp, Ziya. 1999c. “İçtimaiyat: Millet ve Vatan [Sociology: Nation and Land].” Türk Yurdu 3 (66). Tutibay Ankara: Publications.Google Scholar
Gökalp, Ziya. 1999d. “İçtimaiyat: Türkleşmek, İslamlaşmak, Muasırlaşmak-8 [Sociology: Turkification, Islamization and Westernization].” Türk Yurdu 3 (62). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Gökalp, Ziya. 1999e. “Kızılelma [The Red Apple].” Türk Yurdu 2 31. Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Hakkı, Ispartalı. 2000. “Anadolumuz: Köyümden Geliyorum'dan: 19-Uzak Hatıralar, Uzak Köyler [Our Anatolia: I am Coming from My Village: The Distant Memories and Villages].” Türk Yurdu 5 (110). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Hakkı, Ispartalı. 2000. “Türk Ocaği Konferansları: Milliyet ve Terbiye [The Conferences in Turkish Hearts: Nationality and Discipline].” Türk Yurdu 7 (153). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Hanioğlu, Şükrü. 2006. “Turkism and the Young Turks, 1889–1908.” In Turkey Beyond Nationalism, edited by Keiser, Hans-Lukas, 3–20. London: I. B. Tauris.Google Scholar
Haydar, Ali. 1999. “Talim ve Terbiye: Yurt Terbiyesi [Train and Discipline: Tranining on Homeland].” Türk Yurdu 2 (31). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Heyd, Uriel. 1950. Foundations of Turkish Nationalism: The Life and Teachings of Ziya Gökalp. London: Luzac & Company Ltd. and the Harvill Press Ltd.Google Scholar
Köprülüzade, Mehmed Fuad. 1999. “İçtimaiyat: Türklük, İslamlık, Osmanlılık [Sociology: Being a Turk, Islam and Ottoman].” Türk Yurdu 2 45. Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Kushner, David. 1977. The Rise of Turkish Nationalism, 1876–1908. London, Totowa, N.J.: Cass.Google Scholar
Nami, Kazım. 1999. “İçtimaiyat ve Siyasiyat: Yeni Hayata Doğru [Sociology and Politics: Toward a New Life].” Türk Yurdu 2 26. Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Necdet, Ethem. 1999. “İçtimaiyat: Hayat Emareleri [Sociology: Life Symptoms].” Türk Yurdu 3 (53). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Nurettin, Tevfik. 1998. “Türk Esnafının Hali 1 [The Condition of Turkish Artisans].” Türk Yurdu 1 (2). Ankara: Tutibay Publications. Print.Google Scholar
Oğuz, Osman. 1998. “Türk Gençlerine [To Turkish Youngs].” Türk Yurdu 1 (4). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Özden, Mehmet. 1994. “Türk Yurdu” Dergisi ve İkinci Meşrutiyet Devri Türkçülük Akımı (1911–1918) [The Journal of Turk Yurdu and The Turkism Current in the Era of Second Constitutional Monarch]. unpublished Ph. D. diss. Hacettepe University.Google Scholar
Özden, Mehmet. 1998. “Türk Yurdu Üzerine [On Turk Yurdu].” Türk Yurdu. 1. Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Özkırımlı, Umut. 2000. Theories of Nationalism: A Critical Introduction. New York: St. Martin's Press.Google Scholar
Özkırımlı, Umut. 2005. Contemporary Debates on Nationalism: A Critical Engagement. Macmillan: Palgrave.Google Scholar
Parvus, Alexander. 1998a. “İktisat: 1327 Senesinin Ahval-i Maliyyesine Bir Nazar [Economics: A View on the Financial Conditions in 1909].” Türk Yurdu 1(13). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Parvus, Alexander. 1998b. “İktisat: Türkiye Avrupa'nın Mali Boyunduruğu Altındadır-2 [Turkey is Under the Economic Restraints of Europe].” Türk Yurdu 1 (17). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Parvus, Alexander. 1999a. “İktisat: İş İşten Geçmeden Gözlerinizi Açınız [Economics: Open Your Eyes Before Too Late].” Türk Yurdu 2 36. Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Parvus, Alexander. 1999b. “İktisadiyat: Türkiye'de Ziraatin İstikbali [Economics: The Future of Agriculture in Turkey].” Türk Yurdu 3 (49). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Risal, Paul. 1998a. “Siyasiyat: Türkler Bir Ruh-ı Milli Arıyorlar [Politics: Turks Are Searching For a National Soul].” Türk Yurdu 1 (21). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Risal, Paul. 1998b. “Siyasiyat: Türkler Bir Ruh-ı Milli Arıyorlar-2 [Politics: Turks Are Searching For a National Soul].” Türk Yurdu 1 (22). Tutibay Publications: Ankara.Google Scholar
Sacid, Feyzullah. 1999. “Edebiyat: Çanakkale [Literature: Dardanelle].” Türk Yurdu 4 (88). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Sacid, Feyzullah. 2000. “Kızılırmak.” Türk Yurdu 6 (133). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Sahir, Celal. 1999. “Türklük Şunu: Büyük Gün [The Affairs of Turkism: The Great Day].” Türk Yurdu 4 (100). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Sahir, Celal. 2000. “Edebiyat: Kardeşlik Türküsü [Literature: Song of Brotherhood].” Türk Yurdu 5 (126). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Sakaoğlu, Necdet. 2003. Osmanlı'dan Günümüze Eğitim Tarihi [The History of Education from the Ottoman Empire to Today]. İstanbul: Publications of İstanbul Bilgi University.Google Scholar
Smith, Anthony D. 1991. National Identity. London: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
Sohrabi, Nader. 2011. Revolution and Constitutionalism in the Ottoman Empire and Iran. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Subhi, Hamdullah. 2000a. “Milli Hutbeler [The National Khutbas].” Türk Yurdu 5 (128). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Subhi, Hamdullah. 2000b. “Seyahat: Halep Hatıraları [Travel: The Aleppo Memories].” Türk Yurdu 7 (151). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Toprak, Zafer. 1982. Türkiye'de Milli İktisat, 1908–1918 [The National Economy in Turkey]. Ankara: Yurt Yayınları.Google Scholar
Toprak, Zafer. 2003. İttihad-Terakki ve Cihan Harbi: Savaş Ekonomisi ve Türkiye'de Devletçilik [The Committee of Union and Progress and the World War 1: The War Economy and Statism in Turkey]. İstanbul: Homer Bookstore.Google Scholar
Tunaya, Tank Zafer. 2000. Türkiye'de Siyasal Partiler Vol. 3: İttihat ve Terakki, Bir Çağın, Bir Kuşağın, Bir Partinin Tarihi [The Political Parties in Turkey: The Comitte of Union and Progress, The History of an Age, a Generation and a Party]. İstanbul: İletişim Publications.Google Scholar
Yurdu, Türk. 1998a. “Maksat ve Meslek [Aim and Profession].” Türk Yurdu 1(1). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Yurdu, Türk. 1998b. “İktisat [Economics].” Türk Yurdu 1 (9). Tutibay Publications: Ankara.Google Scholar
Yurdu, Türk. 1999a. “Osmanlı Şimal Ordusunun Kafkasya'da İlerlemesi ve Ardahan'ın Zaptı [The Progress of the Ottoman Eastern Army in Caucasian and The Conquer of Ardahan]”. Türk Yurdu 4 (74). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Yurdu, Türk. 1999b. “Edirne İçin [For Edirne].” Türk Yurdu 2 (37). Tutibay Publications: Ankara.Google Scholar
Yurdu, Türk. 1999c. “Talim ve Terbiye: Türk Gücü [Train and Discipline: Turkish Power].” Türk Yurdu 2 (35). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Yurdu, Türk. 1999d. “Türklük Şuunu: Şirketler [The Affairs of Turkism: Corporations].” Türk Yurdu 4 (104). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Yurdu, Türk. 2000a. “Anadolumuz: Anadolu'ya Dair [Our Anatolia: On Anatolia].” Türk Yurdu 5 (108). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Yurdu, Türk. 2000b. “Türklük Şuunu: Atlı İzciler [The Affairs of Turkism: The Scouts with Horses].” Türk Yurdu 5 (107). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Yurdu, Türk. 2000c. “Türklük Şuunu: Güç Dernekleri [The Affairs of Turkism: The Power Associations].” Türk Yurdu 5 (109). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Yurdu, Türk. 2000d. “Türklük Şuunu: Genç Dernekleri [The Affairs of Turkism: The Associations of Youngs].” Türk Yurdu 5 (116). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Yurdu, Türk. 2000e. “Türklük Şuunu: Harbin Verdiği Dersler [The Affairs of Turkism: The Lessons from the War].” Türk Yurdu 5 (105). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Yurdu, Türk. 2000f. “Türklük Şuunu: Milli Bankanın Sermayesi [The Affairs of Turkism: The Capital of the National Bank].” Türk Yurdu 5 (123). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Yurdu, Türk. 2000g. “Türklük Şuunu: İttihad ve Terakki Cemiyetinin 1332 Senesi Kongresi [The Affairs of Turkism: The 1914 Congress of the Committee of Union and Progress].” Türk Yurdu 5 (119). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Yurdu, Türk. 2001 “Şuun: Kurtuluş Günlerinde Kardeş Musahabeleri [The Affairs: The Brothers’ Conversations in the Indepence Days].” Türk Yurdu 7 (157). Ankara: Tutibay Publications. Türk Yurdu. 2001.Google Scholar
Ulvi, İzzet. 1998. “Türklük Duygusu Osmanlılık Fikrine Mani mi? [Does the Sense of Being a Turk Prevent the Idea of Ottomanism?].” Türk Yurdu 1 (16). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Ülker, Erol. 2005. “Contextualising “Turkification”: Nation-Building in the Late Otoman Empire, 1908–1918.” Nations and Nationalisms 11 (4): 613–636.Google Scholar
Žižek, Slavoj. 2002. “Milletinin Keyfini Çıkar, Kendinmiş Gibi! [Enjoy the Nationalism, Like It is Yourself].” In Kırılgan Temas, edited by Somay, B. and Birkan, T. Birkan. (Trans.) T., 211–258. İstanbul: Metis Publications.Google Scholar
Zühdü, M. 2000a. “İktisat Yılı [The Year of Economy].” Türk Yurdu 5 (105). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Zühdü, M. 2000b. “İktisat: Geçen Yılda Milli İstihsal [Economics: The National Production in the Past Year].” Türk Yurdu 5 (108). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Zühdü, M. 2000c. “Geçen Yıl: İktisat Yılı [The Past Year: The Year of Economy].” Türk Yurdu 6 (132). Ankara: Tutibay Publications.Google Scholar
Zürcher, Erik Jan. 2005. Savaş, Devrim ve Uluslaşma: Türkiye Tarihinde Geçiş Dönemi (1908–1928) [The War, Revolution and Nationalization: The Transition Perion in the Turkish History]. Translated by E. Aydınoğlu. İstanbul Bilgi Üniversitesi: İstanbul.Google Scholar