Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-r5fsc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T19:48:26.409Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Re-emerging Christianity in West European Politics: The Case of the Netherlands

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 February 2013

Hans J. P. Vollaard
Hans J. P. Vollaard*
Affiliation:
Leiden University
*
Address correspondence and reprint requests to: Hans J. P. Vollaard, Institute of Political Science, Faculty of Social Sciences, Leiden University, Wassenaarseweg 52, 2333 AK Leiden, The Netherlands. E-mail: vollaard@fsw.leidenuniv.nl
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Does Christianity re-emerge in politics even in the most secularized part of the world, Western Europe? In this article, the exemplary case of the Netherlands provides empirical evidence for two mechanisms of resurgent Christianity in party politics. In this way, the article also offers a more precise understanding under what conditions various dimensions of religion become (again) or remain politically significant. The first mechanism has been the incentive of secularization and secularism for remaining Christians to regroup in a so-called creative minority to convey an explicitly faith-based message to a broader public. Modernization has therefore not automatically meant less religion in politics. However, creative minorities remained a relatively minor affair in Dutch party politics, despite the large number of Christian migrants and their descendants. Second, Christian and culturally rightwing, secular parties have increasingly referred to a Judeo-Christian culture to mark the political identities of the European Union and its nations in response to Islam's growing visibility. The concept of Judeo-Christian culture foremost functioned as a sacred word to denote the liberal and secular order of the West, reflecting the re-emergence of Christianity as cultural phenomenon rather than faith in West European politics.

Type
Articles
Information
Politics and Religion , Volume 6 , Issue 1 , March 2013 , pp. 74 - 100
Copyright
Copyright © Religion and Politics Section of the American Political Science Association 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Aarts, K. and Thomassen, J.. 2008. “Dutch Voters and the Changing Party Space 1989–2006.” Acta Politica 43:203–234.Google Scholar
Aarts, K., and van der Kolk, H.. 2006. “Understanding the Dutch “No”: The Euro, the East, and the Elite.” Political Science & Politics 39:243–246.Google Scholar
Achterberg, Peter, Houtman, Dick, Aupers, Stef, de Koster, Willem, Mascini, Peter, and van der Waal, Jeroen. 2009. “A Christian Cancellation of the Secularist Truce? Waning Christian Religiosity and Waxing Religious Deprivatization in the West.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 48:687–701.Google Scholar
Arnts, L. 2006. “De Migrantenkerken (The Migrant Churches).” In Godsdienstige Veranderingen in Nederland (Religious Changes in the Netherlands), eds. Becker, J., and de Hart, J.. Den Haag: SCP.Google Scholar
Becker, J., and de Hart, J.. 2006. Godsdienstige Veranderingen in Nederland (Religious Changes in the Netherlands). Den Haag: SCP.Google Scholar
Bernts, T., Dekker, G., and de Hart, J.. 2007. God in the Nederland 1996–2006. Kampen: Kok.Google Scholar
Betz, H., and Meret, S.. 2009. “Revisiting Lepanto: The Political Mobilization against Islam in Contemporary Western Europe.” Patterns of Prejudice 43:313–334.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bolkestein, F. 1994. “De Liberale Moraal hangt af van Plaats en Tijd (The Liberal Moral depends on Place and Time).” NRC Handelsblad, December 3.Google Scholar
Brown, C.G. 2001. The Death of Christian Britain. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Bruce, S. 2002. God is Dead: Secularization in the West. Malden MA: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Buruma, I. 2006. Murder in Amsterdam: The Death of Theo van Gogh and the Limits of Tolerance. New York, NY: Penguin.Google Scholar
Byrnes, T.A., and Katzenstein, P.J.. eds. 2006. Religion in an Expanding Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Casanova, J. 1994. Public Religions in the Modern World. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Casanova, J. 2006. “Religion, European Secular Identities, and European Integration.” In Religion in an Expanding Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 65–92.Google Scholar
Casanova, J. 2007. “Rethinking Secularization: A Global Comparative Perspective.” In Religion, Globalization, and Culture. eds. Beyer, P., and Beaman, L.. Leiden: Brill, 101–120.Google Scholar
Castillo Guerra, J.E., and Steggerda, M.. 2009. “Migrantenkerken (Migrant Churches).” In Handboek Religie in Nederland: Perspectief, Overzicht, Debat (Handbook Religion in the Netherlands: Perspective, Overview, Debate), eds. Ter Borg, M., E. Borgman, M. Buitelaar, Y. Kuiper, and R. Plum. Zoetermeer: Meinema, 173–188.Google Scholar
Christen Democratisch Appel. 1991. De Betekenis van de Christen-Democratische Politieke Overtuiging voor de Komende Tien Jaar in Europese Context (The Meaning of the Christian-Democratic Political Belief for the Next Ten Years in European Context). Houten: Bohn Stafleu van. Loghum.Google Scholar
Christen Democratisch Appel. 2004a. Actieprogramma van de Europese Volkspartij (Action Programme of the European People's Party). http://www.rug.nl/dnpp/politiekepartijen/cda/vp/vpeu/2004.pdf (Accessed on May 20, 2011).Google Scholar
Christen Democratisch Appel. 2004b. Nederland Integratieland: Echte Integratie begint bij Actief Burgerschap (The Netherlands Country of Integration: Real Integration starts with Active Citizenship). Houten: Bohn Stafleu van. Loghum.Google Scholar
Christen Democratisch Appel. 2005. Vertouwen in Mensen: Plaatsbepaling en Koers van de Christen-democratie (Trust in People: Position and Direction of the Christian Democracy). Houten: Bohn Stafleu van. Loghum.Google Scholar
Christen Democratisch Appel. 2009. Verkiezingsprogramma Europees Parlement: Kracht en Ambitie (Election Manifesto European Parliament: Power and Ambition). http://dnpp.eldoc.ub.rug.nl/FILES/root/EurVerk/CDAVerkProgrEurParl2009.pdf (Accessed on May 20, 2011).Google Scholar
Christen Democratisch Appel. 2010. Slagvaardig en Samen (Effective and Together). http://dnpp.eldoc.ub.rug.nl/FILES/root/programmas/Verkiezingsprogramma/2010/Definitief/CDAverkiezingsprogramma2010.pdf (Accessed May 20, 2011).Google Scholar
Christen Democratisch Appel BSV. 2009. Het CDA-Gedachtegoed: Een Praktische Handreiking voor Lokale en Provinciale CDA-politici (CDA's Political Thought: A Practical Guide for Local and Provincial CDA Politicians).” http://www.cda.nl/Upload/HetCDA-gedachtegoed_definitief.pdf (Accessed on November 23, 2012).Google Scholar
ChristenUnie. 2005. “PvdA en ChristenUnie scoren hoog bij Migrantenkiezers (PvdA and ChristenUnie score high among Migrant Voters).” www.christenunie.nl (Accessed on May 6, 2011).Google Scholar
Coster, J.A. ed. 1998. De Eeuw in het Hart: De Bevindelijk-Gereformeerden op Weg naar de Eenentwintigste Eeuw (The Century of my Heart: The Pietistic Calvinists towards the Twenty-First Century). Houten: Den Hertog.Google Scholar
Couman, M. 2009a. “Religie en Politieke Participatie (Religion and Political Participation).” In Religie aan het Begin van de 21e Eeuw (Religion at the Beginning of the 21st Century), eds. Schmeets, H., and van der Bie, R.. Den Haag: CBS, 89–100.Google Scholar
Couman, M. 2009b. “Religie en Nationale Problemen (Religion and National Problems).” In Religie aan het Begin van de 21e Eeuw (Religion at the Beginning of the 21st Century). eds. Schmeets, H., and van der Bie, R.. Den Haag: CBS, 83–88.Google Scholar
Cuperus, R. 1996. “De Tragiek van het Christendom: Gedachten bij een Theologisch Debat van Ongelovigen (Christendom's Tragedy: Thoughts on the Theological Debate of Non-Believers).” In Cultuur, Politiek & Christelijke Traditie (Culture, Politics & Christian Tradition), eds. van Houwelingen, A., et al. Baarn: Callenbach. 87–102.Google Scholar
Dekker, G. 2006. Van het Centrum naar de Marge: De Ontwikkeling van de Christelijke Godsdienst in Nederland (From the Centre to the Margins: The Development of the Christian Religion in the Netherlands). Kampen: Kok.Google Scholar
Dolezal, M., Helbling, M., and Hutter, S.. 2010. “Debating Islam in Austria, Germany and Switzerland: Ethnic Citizenship, Church-State Relations and Right-Wing Populism.” West European Politics 33:171–190.Google Scholar
Eckstein, H. 1975. “Case Study and Theory in Political Science.” In Handbook of Political Science Volume 7, eds. Greenstein, F., and Polsby, N.. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, 79–138.Google Scholar
Everts, Ph. 2008. Publieke Opinie na de Koude Oorlog: De Nederlanders en de Wereld (Public Opinion after the Cold War: The Dutch and the World). Assen: Van Gorcum.Google Scholar
Fieret, W. 1990. De Staatkundig Gereformeerde Partij 1918–1948: Een Bibliocratisch Ideaal (The Political Reformed Party 1918–1948: A Bibliocratic Ideal). Houten: Den Hertog.Google Scholar
Foret, F., and Riva, V.. 2010. “Religion between Nation and Europe: The French and Belgian ‘No’ to the Christian Heritage of Europe.” West European Politics 33:791–809.Google Scholar
Fortuyn, P. 1995. De Verweesde Samenleving (The Orphaned Society). Utrecht: Bruna.Google Scholar
Fortuyn, P. 1997. De Islamisering van onze Cultuur: Nederlandse Identiteit als Fundament (The Islamization of our Culture: Dutch Identity as Foundation). Utrecht: Bruna.Google Scholar
Fraanje, R. 1999. “De Plaats van de Beweging Christelijke Koers in het CDA (The Position of the Movement Christian Direction in the CDA).” CD/Actueel, August 14.Google Scholar
George, A.L., and Bennett, A.. 2005. Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Gorski, Ph., and Altinordu, A.. 2008. “After Secularization.” Annual Review of Sociology 34:55–85.Google Scholar
Hastings, A. 1997. The Construction of Nationhood: Ethnicity, Religion and Nationalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Janse, C. 1985. Bewaar het Pand: De Spanning tussen Assimilatie en Persistentie bij de Emancipatie van de Bevindelijk-Gereformeerden (Save the Building: The Tension between Assimilation and Persistence in the Emancipation of the Pietistic Calvinists). Houten: Den Hertog.Google Scholar
Jenkins, Ph. 2007. God's Continent: Christianity, Islam and Europe's Religious Crisis. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
de Jong, P. 2009. “Godsdienstvrijheid niet veilig bij de Islam (Freedom of Religion not save in Islam).” Nederlands Dagblad, March 28.Google Scholar
Kalyvas, S. 1996. The Rise of Christian-Democracy in Europe. New York, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Karvonen, L. 1993. “In from the Cold? Christian Parties in Scandinavia.” Political Studies 16:25–48.Google Scholar
Kennedy, J. 1995. Nieuw Babylon in Aanbouw: Nederland in de Jaren Zestig (Building New Babylon. Cultural Change in the Netherlands during the 1960s). Amsterdam: Boom.Google Scholar
Klei, E. 2011. Klein maar Krachtig, dat maakt ons Uniek: Een Geschiedenis van het Gereformeerd Politiek Verbond 1948–2003 (Small but Powerful, that makes us Unique: A History of the Reformed Political Alliance 1948–2003). Amsterdam: Bert Bakker.Google Scholar
Koning, D. 2011. Importing God: The Mission of the Ghanaian Adventist Church and Other Immigrant Churches in the Netherlands, Ph.D. diss. Amsterdam: Vrije Universiteit.Google Scholar
Lechner, F. 2008. The Netherlands: Globalization and National Identity. New York, NY: Routledge.Google Scholar
Lijst Pim Fortuyn. 2002. Zakelijk met een Hart (Business-like with a Heart). http://dnpp.eldoc.ub.rug.nl/FILES/root/programmas/vp-per-partij/lpf/lpf02.pdf (Accessed on May 20, 2011).Google Scholar
Lucardie, A., and Ten Napel, H.-M.. 1992. “Van Confessioneel naar Liberaal-Conservatief? De Ontwikkeling van het CDA vergeleken met Christen-Democratische Partijen elders in Europa (From Confessional to Liberal-Conservative? The Development of the CDA in Comparison with Christian-Democratic Parties elsewhere in Europe).” DNPP Jaarboek 1992:53–72.Google Scholar
van der Land, J.G., van Isselt, P.M., en de Jong, G.. 2007. “Islamisten uit op Machtsovername (Islamists seeking Takeover).” Reformatorisch Dagblad, June 28.Google Scholar
Mabayoje, E. 2009. “Een Unie van Christenen (A Union of Christians).” Master's Thesis. Leiden: Leiden University.Google Scholar
Madeley, J., and Enyedi, Z., eds. 2003. Church and State in Contemporary Europe: The Chimera of Neutrality. London: Frank Cass.Google Scholar
Mathies, E., van Ark, R., Brinkel, Th., ten Napel, H.-M., and Schinkelshoek, J.. 2005. 25 Jaar CDA: Tussen Macht en Inhoud (25 Years CDA: Between Power and Substance). Baarn: Tirion.Google Scholar
Michon, L., and Tillie, J.. 2003. “Politieke Participatie van Migranten in Nederland sinds 1986 (Political Participation of Migrants in the Netherlands since 1986).” In Politiek in de Multiculturele Samenleving (Politics in the Multicultural Society), eds. Pellikaan, H., and Trappenburg, M.. Amsterdam: Boom, 126–159.Google Scholar
Nederlands Dagblad 2009. “Rechtsstaat is Dam tegen Islam (Rule of Law Protection against Islam).” June 24.Google Scholar
Nijsink, D., and Rozendaal, J.. 2009. “Islam bedreigt Rechtsstaat en Christelijke Traditie (Islam threatens Rule of Law and Christian Tradition).” Reformatorisch Dagblad, November 27.Google Scholar
Oomen, B., Guijt, J., Meijvogel, I., Ploeg, M., and Rijke, N.. 2009. Recht op Verschil? Percepties en Effecten van de Implementatie van Gelijkebehandelingswetgeving op Orthodox-Protestanten in Nederland (The Right to be Different: Perceptions and Effects of the Implementation of Equal Treatment Legislation on Orthodox-Protestants in the Netherlands). Middelburg: Roosevelt Academy.Google Scholar
Pellikaan, H. 2010. “The Impact of Religion on the Space of Competition: The Dutch Case.” Politics and Religion 3:469–494.Google Scholar
Post, H. 2009. In strijd met de Roeping der Vrouw: De Staatkundig Gereformeerde Partij en het Vrouwenkiesrecht (Against the Woman's Call: The Political Reformed Party and female suffrage). Heerenveen: Groen.Google Scholar
PVV. 2006. Verkiezingspamflet (Election Manifesto). http://dnpp.eldoc.ub.rug.nl/FILES/root/programmas/vp-per-partij/PVV/pamflet06.pdf (Accessed on May 20, 2011).Google Scholar
Ratzinger, J. 2004. “The Spiritual Roots of Europe: Yesterday, Today and in the Future.” Inside the Vatican, June/July, 44–51.Google Scholar
Reformatorisch Dagblad (2009). “SGP: Overheid moet Gesprek aangaan over Minaretten (SGP: Government should start Discussion on Minarets).” December 1.Google Scholar
Rouvoet, A. 2006. “Islam and Christian Politics.” In Ethnic and Religious Diversity in Europe, eds. Rogobete, S.E., and Otchie, A.. Amersfoort: ECPM, 66–71.Google Scholar
Rouvoet, A., and Kuiper, R.. 2001. “Anti-sharia Bepaling geeft Duidelijkheid (Anti-Sharia Provisions gives Clarity).” Trouw, February 26.Google Scholar
Rutte, M. 2008. “Liberalisme: Naar Nieuwe Woorden voor Bekende Waarden (Liberalism: Towards New Words for Known Values).” NRC Handelsblad, June 21.Google Scholar
Schipper, N. 2010. “Met Hart en Ziel: Terugblikken en Vooruitzien. Evaluatierapport Stuurgroep Tweede Kamerverkiezingen 2010 (With Heart and Soul: Looking back and forward: Evaluation Report Steering Committee Parliamentary Elections 2010).” http://www.christenunie.nl/k/nl/news/view/461705 (Accessed on May 6, 2011).Google Scholar
Schuurman, E. 2007. “Pact van Christendom en Islam helpt tegen Cultuurspanningen (Pact of Christendom and Islam helps against Cultural Tensions).” NRC Handelsblad, September 20.Google Scholar
Segers, G. 2009. “Smalle Marges voor Christelijk Nederland (Small Margins of Christians in the Netherlands).” Nederlands Dagblad, September 11.Google Scholar
SGP. 2005. De Islam in Huis: Een Politieke Plaatsbepaling. (Islam at Home: A Political Positioning). The Hague:SGP.Google Scholar
Snel, J. 2011. “De Joods-Christelijke Traditie, wat is dat nou eigenlijk? (The Judeo-Christian Tradition, What is that Actually?).” Maarten, June/Juli 3, 76–83.Google Scholar
van der Staaij, C.. 2005. “Theocratie en Democratie (Theocracy and Democracy).” http://www.sgpnieuws.sgp.nl/Media/download/20857/mr.%20C.G.%20van%20der%20Staaij,%20Theocratie%20en%20democratie,%20Den%20Haag%202005.pdf (Accessed on April 12, 2006).Google Scholar
van der Staaij, C.. 2009. “De Ene Godsdienst is de Andere niet (One Religion is not the Other).” Reformatorisch Dagblad, October 1.Google Scholar
Stoffels, H. 1995. Als een Briesende Leeuw: Orthodox-Protestanten in de Slag met de Tijdgeest (The Roaring Lion: Orthodox-Protestants fighting the Spirit of the Age). Kampen: Kok.Google Scholar
Stoffels, H. 2008. “A Coat of Many Colours: New Immigrant Churches in the Netherlands.” In A Moving God: Immigrant Churches in the Netherlands, eds. Jansen, M., and Stoffels, H.. Zürich: Lit Verlag, 13–30.Google Scholar
Stoffels, H. 2009. “Protestantisme (Protestantism).” In Handboek Religie in Nederland (Handbook Religion in the Netherlands: Perspective, Overview, Debate), eds. Ter Borg, M., E. Borgman, M. Buitelaar, Y. Kuiper, and R. Plum. Zoetermeer: Meinema, 122–145.Google Scholar
Ten Hooven, M. 2011. “Een Machtspartij met Idealen: Een Geschiedenis van het CDA 1980–2010 (A Power Party with Ideals: A History of the CDA 1980–2010).” In De Conjunctuur van de Macht: Het Christen-Democratisch Appèl 1980–2010 (The Cycle of Power: The Christian-Democratic Appeal 1980–2010), ed. Voerman, G.Amsterdam: Boom, 59–108.Google Scholar
Ten Napel, H.-M. 1992. “Een eigen weg'. De totstandkoming van het CDA (1952–1980) (Its own Direction: The Creation of the CDA (1952–1980)). Ph.D. diss. Leiden: Leiden University.Google Scholar
Ter Haar, G. ed. 1998. Strangers and Sojourners: Religious Communities in the Diaspora. Leuven: Peeters.Google Scholar
Terpstra, D. 2009. “Het CDA moet weer in het Offensief durven gaan (The CDA Should Dare to Launch the Offensive Again).” Trouw, October 13.Google Scholar
Van der Vlies, B. 2005. “Moslims en Liberalen ook bij SGP in Veilige Handen (Muslims and Liberals also in Safe Hands with SGP).” Reformatorisch Dagblad, January 13.Google Scholar
Van der Vlies, B., and van der Staaij, C.. 2004. “Ook strijden tegen Liberale Jihad (Also Fight Against Liberal Jihad).” Reformatorisch Dagblad, November 11.Google Scholar
Van der Vlies, B., and van der Staaij, C.. 2008. “Zelfde Boodschap in Andere Woorden (Same Message in Different Words).” Reformatorisch Dagblad, October 30.Google Scholar
Van der Molen, H., and Meijering, G.. 2008. “CDA gegijzeld door Integratiedebat (CDA Taken Hostage by Integration Debate).” Reformatorisch Dagblad, April 28.Google Scholar
Van Kersbergen, K. 2008. “The Christian Democratic Phoenix and Modern Unsecular Politics.” Party Politics 14:259–279.Google Scholar
Van Mulligen, R. 2010. “Tussen Evangelisch en Reformatorisch: Het Politiek Getuigenis van de RPF (1975–2003) (Between Evangelical and Reformed: The Political Testimony of the RPF (1975–2003)).” In Van de Marge naar de Macht: De ChristenUnie 2000–2010, From the Margins to Power: the ChristianUnion 2000–2010, eds. Hippe, J., and Voerman, G.. Amsterdam: Boom, 12–50.Google Scholar
Voerman, G. 2010. “Van de Marge naar de Macht: De ChristenUnie (2000–2010) (From the Margins to Power: the ChristianUnion 2000–2010).” In Van de Marge naar de Macht: De ChristenUnie 2000–2010 (From the Margins to Power: the ChristianUnion 2000–2010), eds. Hippe, J., and Voerman, G.. Amsterdam: Boom, 91–132.Google Scholar
Vollaard, H. 2006a. “Een Christelijke of Seculiere Bezieling van de Nederlandse Gemeenschap? Over de Conservatieve Avances naar SGP en ChristenUnie (A Christian or Secular Animation of the Dutch Community? On the Conservative Advances to SGP and ChristianUnion)” In Ruimte op Rechts? Conservatieve Onderstroom in de Lage Landen (The Conservative Undercurrent in the Low Countries), eds. Pellikaan, H., and van der Lubben, S.. Utrecht: Spectrum, 86–106.Google Scholar
Vollaard, H. 2006b. “De Flexibele Formules van het CDA (The Flexible Formulas of the CDA).” In Ruimte op Rechts? Conservatieve Onderstroom in de Lage Landen (The Conservative Undercurrent in the Low Countries). eds. Pellikaan, H., and van der Lubben, S.. Utrecht: Spectrum, 107–136.Google Scholar
Vollaard, H. 2010. “Christelijke Sporen in de Nederlandse Politiek: De Verhouding tussen ChristenUnie, SGP en CDA (Christian Traces in Dutch Politics: The Relationship between ChristianUnion, SGP and CDA).” In Van de Marge naar de Macht: De ChristenUnie 2000–2010 (From the Margins to Power: the ChristianUnion 2000–2010), eds. Hippe, J., and Voerman, G.. Amsterdam: Boom, 175–196.Google Scholar
VVD. 2008. Beginselverklaring (Program of Principles). http://dnpp.eldoc.ub.rug.nl/FILES/root/Beginselprogrammas/VVD/VVDbegin2008.pdf (Accessed May on 20, 2011).Google Scholar
Zúquete, J. 2008. “The European Extreme-Right and Islam: New Directions?” Journal of Political Ideologies 13: 321–344.Google Scholar
Zwart, R., and van Kessel, A.. 2005. “Van Zuil naar Brug: Het CDA en de Integratie van Minderheden (1980–2005) (From Pillar to Bridge: the CDA and the Integration of Minorities (1980–2005)).” Jaarboek Parlementaire Geschiedenis, 51–61.Google Scholar