Hostname: page-component-84b7d79bbc-rnpqb Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-30T00:51:22.090Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Ecological Explanation and the Population-Growth Thesis

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 February 2022

Kristin Shrader-Frechette
Kristin Shrader-Frechette*
Affiliation:
University of South Florida
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Many ecologists have questioned the status of proposed ecological “laws,” charging that they are devoid of empirical content and predictive power or that they are tautological, trivial, circular, or nontestable (Peters 1976, 1978,1991; Simberloff 1983, 1984; Simberloff and Boecklen 1981; Strong and Simberloff 1981; Strong and Levin 1979; see also Williams 1970; Ferguson 1976; Rosenberg 1978; Stebbins 1978; Caplan 1978; and Shrader-Frechette and McCoy 1990). As a result, a number of ecologists have urged their colleagues instead to “study … real organisms,” rather than worry about untestable theories and laws (Van Valen and Pitelka 1974, 925; Mclntosh 1982, 23).

In this essay we investigate the epistemological status of a prominent “ecological law” in order to gain insights about the characteristics of ecological explanation.

Type
Part I. Philosophy of Biology
Information
PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association , Volume 1994 , Issue 1: Volume One: Contributed Papers 1994 , 1994 , pp. 34 - 45
Copyright
Copyright © 1994 by the Philosophy of Science Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

1

The author is grateful to biologists E. D. McCoy and Peter Taylor and philosopher Bruce Silver for constructive criticisms of an earlier version of this essay. Thanks also to the National Science Foundation for Grant DIR-91-12445, “Laws and Explanation in Community Ecology,” that supported work on this project. Remaining errors are the responsibility of the author.

References

Andrewartha, H. and Birch, L. (1954), The Distribution and Abundance of Animals. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Barlow, N. (ed.) (1958), The Autobiography of Charles Darwin. New York: Norton.Google Scholar
Begon, M., Harper, J., and Townsend, C. (1986), Ecology: Individuals, Populations, and Communities. Sunderland: Sinauer.Google Scholar
Brandon, R. (1990), Adaptation and Environment. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Caplan, A. (1978), “Tautology, Circularity, and Biological Theory”, The American Naturalist 111:390–393.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cody, M.L. (1968), “On the Methods of Resource Division in Grassland Bird Communities”, The American Naturalist 102: 107–148.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Connell, J.H. (1983), “On the Prevalence and Relative Importance of Interspecific Competition: Evidence from Field Experiments”, The American Naturalist 122: 661–696.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cooper, G. (1990), “The Explanatory Tools of Theoretical Population Biology”, in Fine, A., Forbes, M., and Wessels, L. (eds.), PSA 1990, vol. 1. East Lansing: Philosophy of Science Association, pp. 165–178.Google Scholar
Dayton, P. (1979), “Ecology”, in Livingston, R. (ed.), Ecological Processes in Coastal and Marine Systems. New York: Plenum, pp. 3–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Diamond, J.M. (1975), “Assembly of Species Communities”, in Cody, M. and Diamond, J. (eds.), Ecology and the Evolution of Communities. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, pp. 332–344.Google Scholar
Diamond, J.M. and Gilpin, M. (1982), “Examination of the “Null” Model of Connor and Simberloff for Species Co-Occurrences on Islands”, Oecologia 52: 64–74.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Duhem, P. (1914), The Aim and Structure of Physical Theory. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Ehrlich, P., Breedlove, D., Brussard, P., and Sharp, M. (1972), “Weather and Regulation of Subalpine Populations”, Ecology 53: 243–247.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ferguson, A. (1976), “Can Evolutionary Theory Predict?” The American Naturalist 110: 1101–1104.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gilpin, M. and Diamond, J. (1984), “Are Species Co-Occurrences on Islands Non-Random, and are Null Hypotheses Useful in Community Ecology?” in Strong, D., Simberloff, D., Abele, L., and Thistle, A. (eds.), Ecological Communities: Conceptual Issues and the Evidence. Princeton: Princeton University Press, pp. 297–315.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gilpin, M. and Diamond, J. (1982), “Factors Contributing to Non-Randomness in Species Co-Occurrences on Islands”. Oecologia 52: 75–84.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Gray, R. (1987), “Faith and Foraging”, in Kamil, A., Krebs, J., and Pulliam, H. (eds.), Foraging Behavior, New York: Plenum, pp. 69–140.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Haila, Y. (1986), “On the Semiotic Dimension of Ecological Theory”, Biology and Philosophy 1:331–387.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hempel, C. (1966), The Philosophy of Natural Science. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.Google Scholar
Hopkins, A. (1920), “The Bioclimatic Law”, Journal of the Washington Academy of Science 10: 34–40.Google Scholar
Humphreys, W. (1979), “Production and Respiration in Animal Populations”, Journal of Animal of Ecology 48: 427–453.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hutchinson, G. (1978), An Introduction to Population Ecology. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Hutchinson, G. (1959), “Homage to Santa Rosalia”, The American Naturalist 93: 145–159.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kingsland, S. (1985), Modeling Nature. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Kingsland, S. (1982), “The Refractory Model: The Logistic Curve and the History of Population Ecology”, The Quarterly Review of Biology 57: 29–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kingsland, S. (1981), Modelling Nature. Ph.D. Thesis, Toronto: University of Toronto.Google Scholar
Kitcher, P. (1989), Explanatory Unification and the Causal Structure of the World, in Kitcher, P. and Salmon, W. (eds.), Scientific Explanation, Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, pp. 410-506.Google Scholar
Krebs, J. (1980), Ornithologists as Unconscious Theorists, Auk 97: 409-412.Google Scholar
Kripke, S. (1972), Naming and Necessity, in Davidson, D. and Hannan, G. (eds.), Semantics of Natural Language. Dordrecht: Reidel.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Levin, S. (1981a), Mathematics, Ecology, Ornithology, Auk 97: 422-25.Google Scholar
Levin, S. (1981b), The Role of Theoretical Ecology in the Description and Understanding of Populations in Heterogeneous Environments, American Zoologist 21: 865-875.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lewontin, R. (1968), Introduction, in Lewontin, R. (ed.), Population Biology and Evolution. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press, pp. 1-4.Google Scholar
Lewontin, R. (1966), Is Nature Probable or Capricious? BioScience 16: 25-27.Google Scholar
Livingston, B. and Shreve, F. (1921), The Distribution of Vegetation in the United States as Related to Climatic Conditions, No. 284. Washington, D.C.: Carnegie Institution of Washington.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
LJoyd, E. A. (1987), Confirmation of Ecological and Evolutionary Models, Biology and Philosophy 2: 277-293.Google Scholar
Loehle, C. (1990), Philosophical Tools: Reply to Shrader-Frechette and McCoy, tt 58: 115-119.Google Scholar
Loehle, C. (1988), Philosophical Tools: Potential Contributions to Ecology, Oikos 51:97-104.Google Scholar
May, R. (1977), Mathematical Models and Ecology, in Goulden, C. (ed.), The Changing Scenes in the Natural Sciences. Philadelphia: Academy of Natural Sciences, pp. 189-201.Google Scholar
Mclntosh, R. (1985), The Background of Ecology. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mclntosh, R. (1982), Some Problems of Theoretical Ecology, in Saarinen, E. (ed.), Conceptual Issues in Ecology. Dordrecht: Reidel, pp. 1-62.Google Scholar
Merriam, C. (1894), Laws of Temperature Control of the Geographic Distribution of Terrestrial Plants and Animals, National Geographic Magazine 6: 229-238.Google Scholar
Murray, B. G. (1989), Review of Shrader-Frechette and McCoy, Personal Communication, p. 7.Google Scholar
Murray, B. G. (1986), The Structure of Theory and the Role of Competition in Community Dynamics, Oikos 46: 145-158.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Murray, B. G. (1979), Population Dynamics: Alternative Models. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Orians, G. (1962), Natural Selection and Ecological Theory, The American Naturalist 96: 257-264.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pearl, R. (1927), The Growth of Populations, The Quarterly Review of Biology 2: 532-548.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pearl, R. (1925), The Biology of Population Growth. New York: Knopf.Google Scholar
Pearl, R. and Reed, L. (1920), On the Rate of Growth of the Population of the United States Since (1970) and Its Mathematical Representation, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 6: 275-288.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Peters, R.H. (1991), A Critique for Ecology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Peters, R.H. (1978), Predictable Problems with Tautology in Evolution and Ecology, The American Naturalist 112: 759-762.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Peters, R.H. (1976), Tautology in Evolution and Ecology, The American Naturalist 110: 1-12.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pyke, G. (1982), Local Geographic Distributions of Bumblebees Near Crested Butte, Colorado: Competition and Community Structure, Ecology 63: 555-573.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Popper, K. (1968), Conjectures and Refutations. New York: Harper and Row.Google Scholar
Popper, K. (1959), The Logic of Scientific Discovery. New York: Harper and Row.Google Scholar
Putnam, H. (1970), Is Semantics Possible?, in Putnam, H. (ed.), Mind, Language, and Reality. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 139-152.Google Scholar
Quine, W.V.O. (1960), Word and Object. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Quine, W.V.O. (1953), From a Logical Point of View. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Reddingius, J. (1971), Gambling for Existence, Acta Biotheoretica, Suppl. 1 20: 1-208.Google Scholar
Reddingius, J. and Den Boer, P. (1970), Simulation Experiments Illustrating Stabilization of Animal Numbers by Spreading of Risk, Oecologia 5: 240-284.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Rosenberg, A. (1985), The Structure of Biological Science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rosenberg, A. (1978). The Supervenience of Biological Concepts, Philosophy of Science 45: 368-386.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roughgarden, J. (1983), Competition and Theory in Community Ecology, The American Naturalist 122: 583-601.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Salmon, W. (1989), Four Decades of Scientific Explanation, in Kitcher, P. and Salmon, W. (eds.), Scientific Explanation, Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, pp. 3-219.Google Scholar
Schoener, T. (1984), Size Differences Among Sympatric, Bird-Eating Hawks: A Worldwide Survey, in Strong, D., Simberloff, D., Abele, L., and Thistle, A. (ed.), Ecological Communities: Conceptual Issues and the Evidence. Princeton: Princeton University Press, pp. 254-281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schoener, T. (1983), Field Experiments on Interspecific Competition, The The American Naturalist 122: 240-285.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schoener, T. (1974), Resource Partitioning in Ecological Communities, Science 185: 27-39.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Shrader-Frechette, K. (1990), Interspecific Competition, Evolutionary Epistemology, and Ecology, in Rescher, N. (ed.), Evolution, Cognition, and Realism. New York: University of Pittsburgh Center for Philosophy of Science Series in Philosophy of Science, University Press of America, pp. 47-63.Google Scholar
Shrader-Frechette, K. and McCoy, E. (1994), Applied Ecology and the Logic of Case Studies, Philosophy of Science 61, June Issue, in press.Google Scholar
Shrader-Frechette, K. (1993), Method in Ecology: Strategies for Conservation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shrader-Frechette, K. (1990), Theory Reduction and Explanation in Ecology, Oikos 58: 109-114.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simberloff, D. (1984), Properties of Coexisting Bird Species in Two Archipelagoes, in Strong, D., Simberloff, D., Abele, L., and Thistle, A. (eds.), Ecological Communities: Conceptual Issues and the Evidence. Princeton: Princeton University Press, pp. 234-258.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simberloff, D. (1983), Competition Theory, Hypothesis Testing, and Other Community Ecological Buzzwords, The American Naturalist 122: 626-635.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simberloff, D. (1982), A Succession of Paradigms in Ecology, in Saarinen, E. (ed.), Conceptual Issues in Ecology. Dordrecht: Reidel, pp. 139-153.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simberloff, D. and Boecklen, W. (1981), Santa Rosalia Reconsidered, Evolution 35: 1206-1228.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Sinclair, A. R. (1989), Animal Population Regulation, in Cherrett, J.M. (ed.), Ecological Concepts. Oxford: Blackwell, pp. 197-241.Google Scholar
Sober, E. (1984), The Nature of Selection. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Stebbins, G. (1978), In Defense of Evolution, The American Naturalist 111:386-390.Google Scholar
Strong, D. (1986), Density-Vague Population Change, Trends in Ecology and Evolution 1: 39-42.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Strong, D. (1984), Density-Vague Ecology and Liberal Population Regulation in Insects, in Price, P., Slobodchikoff, C., and Gaud, W. (eds.), A New Ecology. New York: Wiley, pp. 313-327.Google Scholar
Strong, D. (1982a), Harmonious Coexistence of Hispine Beetles on Heliconia in Experimental and Natural Communities, Ecology 63: 1039-1049.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Strong, D. (1982b), Null Hypotheses in Ecology, in Saarinen, E. (ed.), Conceptual Issues in Ecology. Dordrecht: Reidel, pp. 245-360.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Strong, D., and Levin, D. (1979), Species Richness of Plant Parasites and Growth Form of Their Hosts, The American Naturalist 114: 1-22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Strong, D. and Simberloff, D. (1981), Straining at Gnats and Swallowing Ratios: Character Displacement, Evolution 35: 810-812.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Strong, D., Simberloff, D., Abele, L., and Thistle, A. (eds.) (1984), Ecological Communities: Conceptual Issues and the Evidence. Princeton: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Taylor, P. (1986), Dialectical Biology as Political Practice, in Levidow, L. (ed.), Science as Politics. London: Free Association Books, pp. 81-109.Google Scholar
Taylor, P. (1989), Revising Models and Generating Theory, Oikos 54: 122-126.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Van Valen, L. and Pitelka, F. (1974), Commentary: Intellectual Censorship in Ecology, Ecology 55: 925-926.Google Scholar
Verhulst, P. (1845), Recherches mathematiques sur la loi daccroissement de la population, Memoirs de IAcademic Royale de la Beige 18: 1-38.Google Scholar
Verhulst, P. (1838), Notice sur laloique la population suit dans son accroissement, Correspondence Mathematique et Physique 10: 113-121.Google Scholar
Wangersky, P. (1978), Lotka-Volterra Population Models, Annual Review of Ecology and Systematic^ 9: 189-218.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wiens, J. (1983), Avian Community Ecology, in Brush, A., and Clark, G. (eds.), Perspectives in Ornithology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 355-403.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Williams, M. B. (1970), Deducing the Consequences of Evolution, Journal of Theoretical Biology 29: 343-385. CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed