Article contents
Why they shared: recovering early arguments for sharing social scientific data
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 15 March 2021
Argument
Most social scientists today think of data sharing as an ethical imperative essential to making social science more transparent, verifiable, and replicable. But what moved the architects of some of the U.S.’s first university-based social scientific research institutions, the University of Michigan’s Institute for Social Research (ISR), and its spin-off, the Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research (ICPSR), to share their data? Relying primarily on archived records, unpublished personal papers, and oral histories, I show that Angus Campbell, Warren Miller, Philip Converse, and others understood sharing data not as an ethical imperative intrinsic to social science but as a useful means to the diverse ends of financial stability, scholarly and institutional autonomy, and epistemological reproduction. I conclude that data sharing must be evaluated not only on the basis of the scientific ideals its supporters affirm, but also on the professional objectives it serves.
Keywords
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Science in Context , Volume 33 , Issue 2: Power, Politics, and the Development of Political Science in the Americas , June 2020 , pp. 101 - 119
- Copyright
- © The Author(s) 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
References
References
Bentley Historical Library, University of Michigan (Ann Arbor, Michigan)
Campbell, Angus. Personal Papers.
1956a. Pendleton Herring to Campbell, 10.5.56. Folder: SSRC Correspondence 1950–59, Box 8.
1956b. Campbell to Pendleton Herring, 10.22.56. Folder: SSRC Correspondence 1950–59, Box 8.
1957a. Campbell, “A General Purpose National Sample for Behavioral Scientists,” March 1957. Folder: SSRC Correspondence 1950–59, Box 8.
1957b. Bernard Berelson to Donald Marquis, 7.12.57. Folder: Michigan, University of, Ford Foundation Grants 1957–58, Box 6.
1959a. Samuel Eldersveld and Warren Miller to Department of Political Science, Univ. of Michigan, 5.12.59. Folder: Michigan, University of, Ford Foundation Grants, 1959–60, Box 6.
1959b. “The Objectives and Needs of the Graduate Degree Program in Political Behavior,” October 1959. Folder: Michigan, University of, Ford Foundation Grants, 1959–60, Box 6.
1960a. Campbell to Freeman D. Miller, Assoc. Dean, Rackham School of Graduate Studies, 3.9.60. Folder: Michigan, University of, Ford Foundation Grants, 1959–60, Box 6.
1960b. Charles H. Berry, memo. November 1960. Folder: SSRC Correspondence, 1960–68, Box 8.
1960c. Peter H. Rossi, memo. 11.15.1960. Folder: SSRC Correspondence, 1960–68, Box 8.
1960d. Charles H. Berry, “Conference on Survey Research Facilities,” 12.16.60. Folder: SSRC Correspondence, 1960–68, Box 8.
1961a. William Riker and Charles Sellers. “A Proposal for an SSRC Committee on Electoral Behavior,” 5.10.61. Folder: SSRC Correspondence, 1960–68, Box 8.
1961b. William Riker and Charles Sellers to Lee Benson, Angus Campbell, Samuel P. Hays, V.O. Key, Richard McCormick, Duncan MacRae, Jr., Warren Miller, Richard Scammon, 5.12.61. Folder: SSRC Correspondence, 1960–68, Box 8.
Converse, Philip. 1997. Oral history interview. (Erik Austin, interviewer). August 19. VHS tape and typed transcript. Institute for Social Research (ISR) Oral History project.
Institute for Social Research (ISR) Records.
1947. ISR/SRC Executive Committee Minutes, 7.30.47, Folder: ISR/SRC Exec. Committee Nov. 1946 – Dec. 1948, Box 26.
1948a. Angus Campbell to Burton Fisher, 8.17.48. Folder: Project # 36, Library of Congress, Box 41 (SRC Projects).
1948b. ISR/SRC Exec. Committee Minutes 9.28.48. Folder: ISR/SRC Exec. Committee Nov. 1946 – Dec. 1948, Box 26.
Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research (ICPSR) Records.
No date. Index to Grant Proposals. Folder: Grants and Project Proposals: Grant Proposals Index, 1963–2002, Box 16.
1965a. Warren Miller and Lee Benson to Pendleton Herring, SSRC, May 1965. Folder: SSRC Committee on Archives for Quantitative Social Science Data, 1965, Box 3.
1965b. “Policy Statement on Research Training for Advanced Graduate Students and Faculty Members Participating in ICPR Activities,” November 1965. Folder: Educational Activities, Summer Training Program, General 1965-1992, Box 20.
Miller, Warren E. Personal Papers.
1957a. Miller to Joseph Greenblum, 6.11.57. Folder: Correspondence March to August 1957, Box 4.
1957b. Miller to George Belknap, 7.25.57. Folder: Correspondence March to August 1957, Box 4.
1957c. Miller to Richard Christie, 8.2.57. Folder: Correspondence March to August 1957, Box 4.
1957d. Miller to Bill Glaser, 8.16.57. Folder: Correspondence March to August 1957, Box 4.
1959. Miller to Angus Campbell, 1.14.59. Folder: Correspondence, Topical: Angus Campbell 1958–59, Box 3.
1961. Miller to Samuel Eldersveld, 3.8.61, Folder: Correspondence: Eldersveld, Samuel J., 1960–61, Box 3.
Miller, Warren. 1997. Oral history interview. (Erik Austin, interviewer). July 20. VHS tape and typed transcript. Institute for Social Research (ISR) Oral History project.
Rockwell, Richard. 1998. Interview appearance in “In the Public Interest: 50 Years of Social Research at the Institute for Social Research,” University of Michigan documentary film.
Rockefeller Archive Center (Sleepy Hollow, New York)
1955a. Survey Research Center, University of Michigan. “A Proposal for a Study of the Psychological Sources of Political Behavior,” 6.29.55. Folder 4993: University of Michigan - Survey Research Center - Voting Behavior (1955–1957), Box 583, Record Group 1.2, Series 200S, Rockefeller Foundation Archives.
1955b. Angus Campbell to Leland DeVinney, 9.29.55. Folder 4993: University of Michigan - Survey Research Center - Voting Behavior (1955–1957), Box 583, Record Group 1.2, Series 200S, Rockefeller Foundation Archives.
1957. David Truman to Kenneth W. Thompson, 9.9.57. Folder 4993: University of Michigan - Survey Research Center - Voting Behavior (1955-1957), Box 583, Record Group 1.2, Series 200S, Rockefeller Foundation Archives.
A correction has been issued for this article:
- 3
- Cited by
Linked content
Please note a has been issued for this article.