Hostname: page-component-7bb8b95d7b-l4ctd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-09-15T22:24:07.550Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Hunger-Strike of the Lord Mayor of Cork, 1920: Irish, English and Vatican Attitudes

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

Stuart Mews
Stuart Mews*
Affiliation:
University of Lancaster
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

On 25 October 1920, a new name was added to the martyrology of Irish nationalism. On that date, the Lord Mayor of Cork, Alderman Terence MacSwiney, died in Brixton prison after a hunger-strike which had lasted 74 days. He had held office for little more than six months, his predecessor having been roused from sleep and shot, most Irish people believed, by plain clothed policemen. MacSwiney had succeeded not only to the symbolic positions of head of the municipality and titular chief magistrate, but also the less decorative but potentially more deadly positions of president of the Cork branch of Sinn Fein and commandant of the First Cork Brigade of the Irish Volunteers. Brought up in the full flood of the Catholic spiritual and Gaelic cultural revivals, MacSwiney had a long record of active commitment to the struggle for Irish independence. He had been imprisoned by the British in 1916 in the aftermath of Dublin’s Easter Rising which he had watched from Cork in an agony of indecision, developing in one English historian’s view ‘a guilt complex which he was later to expiate in the grimmest possible way’. In August 1920, only days after the introduction of courts martial to replace civilian courts in Ireland, he was arrested in the City Hall, while presiding over a meeting of the Brigade Council. Proclaiming his allegiance to the Irish Republic, the Lord Mayor challenged the right of the British Army to detain him, and immediately commenced a hunger-strike.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History , Volume 25: The Churches, Ireland and the Irish , 1989 , pp. 385 - 399
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 1989

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Townshend, Charles, The British Campaign in Ireland 1919-1921 (Oxford, 1975), p. 96 Google Scholar; Arch bishop’s House, Westminster, Bourne MS Bo 5/36, D. Cohalan to A. C. Dunlop, 19 November 1920; Nevison, H. W., Last Changes, Last Chances (London, 1928), p. 175 Google Scholar.

2 Chavasse, Moirin, Terence MacSwiney (Dublin, 1961)Google Scholar. But James Healy has implied that Mrs Chavasse has played down MacSwiney’s commitment to physical force: ‘Hunger Strikes: Other Ethical Reflections’, Millioum Studies 15(1985), p. 100.

3 Lyons, F. S. L., Culture and Anarchy in Ireland 1890-1939 (Oxford, 1982), pp. 79 Google Scholar seq; Tom Garvin, ‘Priests and Patriots: Irish separatism and fear of the modern, 1890-1914’, Irish Historical Studies, 25 (1986), pp. 67-81.

4 Townshend, Charles, Political Violence in Ireland (Oxford, 1984), p. 300 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 An account of the trial taken from the Cork Examiner is printed in O’Hegarty, P. S., A Short Memoir of Terence MacSwiney (Dublin, 1922), p. 90 Google Scholar.

6 Healy, ‘Hunger Strikes’, p. 100; Greaves, C. Desmond, The Life and Works of James Connolly (London, 1972), p. 311 Google Scholar; Levenson, Leah, With Wooden Sword. Portrait of Francis Sheehy Skeffington, Militant Pacifist (Boston, 1983), pp. 175–83 Google Scholar.

7 Typed statement of Michael Brennan, quoted in Fitzpatrick, David, Politics and Irish Life 1913-1921: Provincial experience of war and revolution (Dublin, 1977), p. 149 Google Scholar.

8 Fitzpatrick, Politics and Irish Life, p. 149.

9 Sean Luing, Idie in a good cause. A study of Thomas Ashe, idealist and revolutionary (Tralee, 1970).

10 Oxford Bodleian MS, H. A. L. Fisher diary, 9 September 1920.

11 The Times, 28, 30 August 1920; Archbishop’s House, Southwark, P. Amigo to D. Lloyd George, 5 September 1920, P. Amigo to Sir Edward Troup, 5 September 1920, P. Amigo to A. Bonar Law, 7 September 1920, P. Amigo to Sir Hamar Greenwood, 14 September 1920.

12 James, Robert Rhodes, Memoirsofa Conservative:]. C. C. Davidson’s Memoirs and Papers 1910-17 (London, 1969), p. 98 Google Scholar.

13 Bell, G.K. A., Randall Davidson, 2 vols (Oxford, 1935), 2, p. 1058 Google Scholar.

14 House of Lords, Lloyd George MS F/3/5/T13, R. T. Davidson to E. Shortt, n.d. (27 August 1920?).

15 Manchester Guardian, 26 August 1920.

16 Lloyd George MS F/31/1/40, Memorandum by J. C. C. Davidson; Jones, Thomas, Whitehall Diary III, Ireland 1918-25, ed. Middlemas, Keith (Oxford, 1971), pp. 35—7 Google Scholar.

17 Fisher diary, 9 September 1920.

18 House of Lords, Bonar Law MS 101/4/83, A. Bonar Law to Lord Stamfordham, 26 August 1920; Lloyd George MS F/51/1/44, D. Lloyd George to A. Bonar Law, 4 September 1920.

19 Rhodes Jones, Memoirs of a Conservative, p. 98.

20 Morgan, Kenneth O., Consensus and Disunity: The Lloyd George Coalition Government 1918-22 (Oxford, 1979), p. 132 Google Scholar.

21 Fisher diary, 9 September 1920.

22 Jones, Thomas, Whitehall Diary I 1916-25, ed. Middlemas, Keith (Oxford, 1969), pp. 279 Google Scholar seq.

23 A. G. Gardiner, ‘Ireland an American Question’, Literary Digest, 6 November 1920, pp. 20-1, quoted Ward, Alan J., Ireland and Anglo-American Relations 1899-1921 (London, 1969), p. 229 Google Scholar; Ellis, P. Beresford, A History of the Irish Working Class (London, 1972), p. 254 Google Scholar.

24 Spectator, 28 August 1920.

25 Lloyd George MS f/28/2/2, W. M. Hughes to D. Lloyd George, 17 August 1917; Nial Brennan, Dr Mannix (London, 1065); Thomas E. Hachey, ‘The Quarantine of Archbishop Mannix: A British Preventive Policy During The Anglo-Irish Troubles’, Irish University Review (1970), pp. 111-30.

26 During Cardinal Vaughan’s archiepiscopatc (1892-1903) not a single Irish-born bishop had been appointed to a diocese in England. In 1920 apart from the antique Bishop Lacy of Middlesborough, appointed in 1879, Cotter of Portsmouth and Keiley of Plymouth were the only two Irish bishops.

27 H. W. Nevison, Last Changes, p. 175.

28 Ibid., p. 175.

29 New Statesman, 30 November 1920.

30 Spectator, 6 November 1920.

31 The Times, 31 August 1920.

32 Tablet, 4 September 19820.

33 Ibid., 11 September; P.J. Gannon, The Ethical Aspect of the Hunger Strike, Studies, 9(1920), pp. 448-54.

34 Tablet, 6 November 1920.

35 Ibid., 20 November 1920.

36 Ibid., 6 November 1920.

37 The Times, 20 September 1920.

38 University College, Dublin MS P 48C/123, Michael Browne to Moirin Chavasse, 22 February 1954. See John Waters, ‘The Morality of the Hunger Strike’), IER 12 (1918), pp. 89-108; Patrick Cleary, ‘Some questions regarding the morality of Hunger Strikes’, IER 12 (1918), pp. 265-73; John Waters, ‘The Morality of the Hunger-Strike: A Rejoinder’, IER 13 (1919), pp. 14-26; Patrick Cleary, ‘Some further questions regarding the Morality of die Hunger-Strike’. IER 13 (1919), pp. 219-29.

39 Miller, David W., Church, Slate and Nation in Ireland 1898-1921 (Dublin, 1973), pp. 401 Google Scholar seq; Dermot Keogh, The Vatican, the Bishops and Irish Politics 1919-39 (Cambridge, 1986), pp. 60 seq.

40 Miller, Church, Slate and Nation. pp. 465 seq; Keogh, The Vatican, the Bishops and Irish Politics, pp. 60 sea.

41 Westminster Diocesan Archives, Bourne Papers 5/36; B. Basset to A Jackman, 7 November 1920.

42 Downside Abbey MS 917A Lord W. Kerr to F. A. Gasquet, 7 November 1920.

43 Bourne Papers 5/36, James Dredgfer et al. to F. Bourne, n.d. (postmark 27 October 1920).

44 Archbishop’s House, Southwark, N.S. Marchant to P. Amigo, 25 September 1920.

45 Ibid., H. S. Dean to P. Amigo, 9 September 1920.

46 Ibid., P. Amigo to N. S. Marchant, 28 September 1920.

47 Ibid., James Hope to P. Amigo, 5 November 1920, P. Amigo to James Hope, 8 November 1920.

48 Chavasse, MacSwiney, p. 185.

49 Bourne MS 5/36, H. S. Dean to A. Jackman, 24 September 1920.

50 Ibid., 5/36, Basil Baston to A. Jackman, 28 April 1921.

51 Downside Abbey MS 917A: P. Amigo to F. A. Gasquet, 25 February 1920.

52 Stuart Mews, ‘The Churches’, The General Strike, ed. Margaret Morris (Harmondsworth, 1976), pp. 330-2.

53 Bourne MS 5/36, C. Plater to Edward Eyre, 31 August 1920; F. Bourne to E. Eyre, 8 September 1920; Henry Somerville to F. Bourne, 20 October 1920.

54 James Gleeson, Bloody Sunday (London, 1962); Tom Bowden, ‘Bloody Sunday—a Reappraisal’, European Studies Review, 2 (1972), pp. 25-42; Charles Townshend, ‘Bloody Sunday—Michael Collins speaks’, European Studies Review, 9 (1974), pp. 377-85; Bourne MS 5/36, D. Lloyd George to F. Bourne, 29 November 1920.

55 Chavasse, MacSwiney, p. 159; Keogh, The Bishops, the Vatican, p. 250.

56 Downside Abbey MS 917A, Diary of F. A. Gasquet, 12 April 1921.

57 PRO, FO 380/31/433/20, de Salis to Curzon, 13 November 1920.

58 Ibid., 380/31/458/20, de Salis to Curzon, 28 November 1920.

59 Ibid., 380/31/433/20, de Salis to Curzon, 13 November 1920.

60 Tablet, 27 November 1920; Downside Abbey MS 917A, B. Cerretti to F. A. Gasquet, 3 October 1920.