Hostname: page-component-7479d7b7d-767nl Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-13T02:22:56.689Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Limits of Enterprise Autonomy: Enterprise Bargaining in the Australian Domestic Airline Industry

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2023

Mark Bray
Mark Bray*
Affiliation:
Department of Industrial Relations, University of Sydney
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper identifies a model of enterprise bargaining which has recently been advocated by some Australian employer groups. Under this ‘autonomous enterprise’model, ‘genuine’ enterprise bargaining is supposed to produce comprehensive agreements which set terms and conditions of employment which are company-specific. The experience of enterprise bargaining in the Australian domestic airline industry is then compared with that model. It is found that, contrary to the model, the two major airlines have negotiated enterprise agreements which are remarkably similar, with wage increases and workplace reforms following strong industry-wide trends. The explanation offered for the lack of enterprise autonomy focuses on both institutional factors and structural features of the industry’s product

Type
Research Article
Information
The Economic and Labour Relations Review , Volume 7 , Issue 1 , June 1996 , pp. 132 - 164
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 1996

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

Funding for this project came from the Australian Research Council and the Bowater Trust of Deakin University. The author wishes to acknowledge the contribution of the many airline employees, union officials and managers who contributed to this paper, although special thanks goes to Barry Robinson and Geoff Young. Thanks also to John Campling, Ed Davis, Russell Lansbury, Susan McGrath-Champ and Malcolm Rimmer for their comments on earlier drafts of the paper. Despite their assistance, the responsibility for remaining errors lies with the author.

References

Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (1994a) Media Statement: ACCI Report on Federal Enterprise Agreements - Legislative Reform Required, 17 September.Google Scholar
Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (1994b) Media Statement: TWU Threats Damaging and Inappropriate, 15 November.Google Scholar
Ansett Australia (1994) Enterprise Bargaining Newsletter, No. 1, January.Google Scholar
Ansett Australia (1995) 58th Annual Report.Google Scholar
Australian Industrial Relations Commission (1994) Ansett Australia Enterprise Agreement II, Print No. L8105.Google Scholar
Australian Industrial Relations Commission (1995) Qantas Airways Limited Enterprise Agreement II, Print No. L9006.Google Scholar
Ballantyne, T (1991) ‘“Bloated” Qantas to shed 3,600 jobs’, Sydney Morning Herald, 5 May, p. 5.Google Scholar
Ballantyne, T (1993a) ‘Phoenix Rising: The battle to get Qantas airborne’, Sydney Morning Herald, 18 June, p. 27.Google Scholar
Ballantyne, T (1993b) ‘Qantas: The Strong Factor’, Aircraft, December, p. 54.Google Scholar
Blain, N (1984) Industrial Relations in the Air: Australian Air Pilots, University of Queensland Press, St Lucia.Google Scholar
Bowden, B (1993) Driving Force: The History of the TWU of Australia, 1883–1992, Allen and Unwin, Sydney.Google Scholar
Bray, M (1994) ‘Unions, the Accord and Economic Restructuring’ in Brett, J., Gillespie, J., Goot, M. (eds), Developments in Australian Politics, Macmillan, Melbourne.Google Scholar
Bray, M. (forthcoming) ‘Airlines’ in Kitay, J., Lansbury, R. (eds), Changing Employment Relations in Australian Industries, Melbourne, Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Bray, M., Rimmer, M. (1987) Delivering the Goods: A History of the TWU in New South Wales, 1888–1986, Allen and Unwin, Sydney.Google Scholar
Brogden, S (1968) Australia’s Two-Airline Policy, Melbourne University Press, Melbourne.Google Scholar
Brogden, S (1986) ‘Ansett - The Man Who Built the Airline’, Aircraft, February, pp. 25–43.Google Scholar
BTCE (Bureau of Transport and Communications Economics) (1993) The Progress of Aviation Reform, AGPS, Canberra.Google Scholar
BTCE (Bureau of Transport and Communications Economics) (1995) Deregulation of Domestic Aviation in Australia 1990–1995, Information Sheet 6.Google Scholar
Cappelli, P (1995) ‘Introduction’ in Cappelli, P. (ed), Airline Labor Relations in the Global Era, ILR Press, Ithaca.Google Scholar
Carman, G (1986) ‘Ansett: 50 Years and Getting Stronger’, Aircraft, February, pp. 21–5.Google Scholar
Carman, G (1993) ‘The Changing ofthe Guard: Ta-ta Australian Airlines’, Aircraft, November, pp. 4–5, 51.Google Scholar
Confederation of Australian Industry (1991) A New Industrial Relations System for Australia, CAI, Melbourne, August.Google Scholar
Cromie, A (1992) ‘Qantas on the high wire’, Business Review Weekly, 11 December, pp. 38–45.Google Scholar
Davis, E., Lansbury, R. (1989) Consultative Councils: The Cases of Telecom and Qantas Airways Ltd, AGPS, Canberra.Google Scholar
Dooley, F (1994) ‘Deja Vu for Airline Industrial Relations’, Journal of Labor Research, 15 (2), Spring, pp. 169–90.Google Scholar
Dunphy, D., Stace, D. (1990) Under New Management, McGraw-Hill, Sydney.Google Scholar
Fisher, E., Kondra, A. (1992) ‘Canada’s Airlines: Recent Turbulence and Changing Flight Patterns’ in Chaykowski, R., Verma, A. (eds), Industrial Relations in Canadian Industry, Dryden Press, Toronto.Google Scholar
Gottliebsen, R (1992) ‘Why Murdoch stuck with Abeles’, Business Review Weekly, 31 July, pp. 42–6.Google Scholar
Grant, H (1986) ‘Ansett victory presages a mood of militancy’, Australian Financial Review, 4 April, p. 50.Google Scholar
Senior Deputy PresidentHancock, K. (1994) Ansett Transport Industries and Australian Federation of Air Pilots and others, Australian Industrial Relations Commission, Print No. L5128.Google Scholar
Hilmer, F., McLaughlin, P., Macfarlane, D., Rose, J. (1989) Enterprise-Based Bargaining Units: A Better Way of Working, Business Council of Australia, Melbourne.Google Scholar
Hilmer, F., McLaughlin, P., Macfarlane, D., Rose, J. (1991) Avoiding Industrial Action: A Better Way of Working, Business Council of Australia, Melbourne.Google Scholar
Hilmer, F., Angwin, M., Layt, J., Dudley, G., Barratt, P., McLaughlin, P. (1993) Working Relations: A Fresh Start for Australian Enterprises, Business Council of Australia, Melbourne.Google Scholar
Hooper, N (1992) ‘Wage deal tests Qantas resolve’, Business Review Weekly, 24 April, p. 31.Google Scholar
Isaac, J (1993) ‘Airline’ in National Key Centre in Industrial Relations, Enterprise Bargaining Case Studies: Workplace Bargaining Research Project Stage III, Monash University, Melbourne.Google Scholar
Johnston, M (1972) The Australian Licensed Aircraft Engineers’ Association - An Enigma in the Age of Union Amalgamation, Unpublished BComm Thesis, University of New South Wales.Google Scholar
Jones, G (1993) Award Restructuring and Workplace Reform in Australia’s Domestic Airline Industry: The Case of the Licensed Aircraft Maintenance Engineers, Unpublished BEc Thesis, University of Sydney.Google Scholar
Knight, E (1993) ‘Qantas: the long haul to mega-profits’, Sydney Morning Herald, 20 November, p. 37.Google Scholar
Maddern, Justice, et al (1989) Full Bench Decision re Aircraft Industry (Domestic Airlines) Award, 31 May, Print No. H8356.Google Scholar
Maher, Commissioner (1992) Clerks (Domestic Airlines) Award, Australian Industrial Relations Commission, Print No. K1731.Google Scholar
Maiden, S (1993) ‘Qantas merger brings clash of cultures’, Inside Enterprise Bargaining, No. 15, September.Google Scholar
Matthews, T (1994) ‘Employers’ Associations, Corporatism and the Accord: The Politics of Australian Industrial Relations’ in Bell, S., Head, B. (eds), State and Economy: Australian Essays, Oxford University Press, Melbourne.Google Scholar
May, T., et al (1986) Independent Review of Economic Regulation of Domestic Aviation - Two Volumes, AGPS, Canberra.Google Scholar
McDonald, J (1990) ‘Industrial Relations Strategies in the Air Pilots’ Dispute’, Economic and Labour Relations Review, 1(1), June, pp. 121–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Noakes, B (1994) ‘The Industrial Relations Reform Act: One Step Sideways, Two Steps Back, But Which Way Forward?’, Paper Presented to 28th Annual Conference of the Industrial Relations Society of Victoria, October.Google Scholar
Norington, B (1990) Sky Pirates: The Pilots’ Strike That Grounded Australia, ABC Books, Sydney.Google Scholar
Norington, B (1992) ‘Airlines fight Qantas’, Sydney Morning Herald, 29 April, p. 4.Google Scholar
O’Brien, J. (1994) ‘McKinsey, Hilmer and the BCA: The “New Managemen” Model of Labour Market Reform’, Journal of Industrial Relations, 36(4), December, pp. 468–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Qantas (1993) Qantas. The Australian Airline: Annual Report 1992–1993.Google Scholar
Peterson, B., Glab, J. (1994) Rapid Decent: Deregulation and the Shakeout in the Airlines, Simon and Schuster, New York.Google Scholar
Rimmer, M., Verevis, C. (1990) ‘Case Study 13: Air Transport - New South Wales’ in Progress of Award Restructuring: Case Studies, IRRC Monograph No. 28, University of New South Wales, Sydney.Google Scholar
Sandilands, B (1989) ‘The prize to the Strong’, The Bulletin, 26 September, pp. 124–6.Google Scholar
Sandilands, B (1990) ‘Ansett becomes Australian’, Business Review Weekly, 16 October, p. 138.Google Scholar
Sheldon, P., Thornthwaite, L. (1993) ‘Exparte: The Business Council of Australia and Industrial Relations Change’, International Journal of Business Studies, 1(1), October, pp. 37–55.Google Scholar
Sheridan, G (1981) ‘The wide-body battle for passengers’, The Bulletin, 20 January, pp. 55–60.Google Scholar
Stackhouse, J (1986) ‘The battle for the pie in the sky’, The Bulletin, 12 August, p. 60.Google Scholar
Stannard, B (1993) ‘Cool Hand Cowley: Murdoch’s Main Man’, Sydney Morning Herald Good Weekend, May, pp. 30–7.Google Scholar
Teicher, J (1988) ‘Union compliance and incomes policy: The Australian social contract, 1983–1987’, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations, 13, pp. 213–36.Google Scholar
Thomas, I (1994a) ‘Musical chairs in a game of flying first class’, Australian Financial Review, 18 July, p. 3.Google Scholar
Thomas, I (1994b) ‘Qantas workers to get $1,000 in free shares’, Australian Financial Review, 15 December, p. 20.Google Scholar
Way, N (1989) ‘Kelty’s crucial wage link goes on trial’, Business Review Weekly, 10 March, pp. 28–9.Google Scholar
Williams, C (1986) ‘Domestic Flight Attendants in Australia: A Quasi Occupational Community?’, Journal of Industrial Relations, 28(2), June, pp. 237–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Williams, C (1988) Blue, White and Pink Collar Workers: Technicians, Bank Employees and Flight Attendants, Allen and Unwin, Sydney.Google Scholar
Williams, P (1986) ‘Outrage as TWU pursues its ambitions’, Business Review Weekly, 4 April, pp. 20–3.Google Scholar
Yerbury, D (1983) Collective Negotiations and the Airline Pilots, 1946–1967, IRRC Monograph No. 5, University of New South Wales.Google Scholar