¹ “Sacrae nempe Praedicatorum religionis, non nisi sapientiam toto orbe resonantis instituto, iuvenis admodum, Deo initiatus, dum haud quamquam segniter virtutum actibus adipiscendisque litteris sese totum impenderet, praeceptorem eiusdem professionis aevo illo philosophorum ac theologorum sapientissimum, Valentinum Perusia oriundum eidem Dominus praeparavit, sub cuius magisterio brevi dierum spatio sic harum scientiarum assecutus est apicem ac culmen conscendit, ut id adolescens adipisceretur honoris quod non nisi veterani milites vix reportant.” Cited by M.-H. Laurent, “Les premières biographies de Cajétan,” Revue Thomiste (1934), Suppl.: 450.Google Scholar

The following abbreviations will be employed: AFP = Archivum Fratrum Praedicatorum (Rome, 1930–); AGOP IV = Archivio Generale Domenicano (Convento di Santa Sabina, Rome), MS series IV: “Registra Magistrorum ac Procuratorum Generalium Ordinis Praedicatorum”; Brotto-Zonta, Facoltà = Brotto, G. and Zonta, G., La facoltà teologica dell'Università di Padova. I (secoli XIV e XV) (Padua, 1922); Contarini, Notizie = Contarini, G. Notizie storiche circa li pubblici professori nello studio di Padova scelti dall'ordine di San Domenico (Venice, 1769); Gargan, Studio = Gargan, L., Lo studio teologico e la biblioteca dei Domenicani a Padova nel Tre e Quattrocento (Padua, 1971); Masetti, Monumenta = P.-T. Masetti, Monumenta et antiquitates veteris disciplinae Ordinis Praedicatorum in Romana Provincia, vol. 1 (Rome, 1864); MOPH = Monumenta Ordinis Praedicatorum Historica (Rome, 1896–).Google Scholar

² “Magister Valentinus Camers, magne scientie vir, nonnulla insignia volumina composuit.” See Creytens, R., “Les écrivains dominicains dans la chronique d'Albert de Castello (1516),” AFP 30 (1960): 289.Google Scholar

³ “Valentinus Camer Perusino baiulans utrisque manibus commentaria super Methaphysicam Aristotelis cum nonnullis aliis opusculis egregiis qui anno elapso Perusii uita excessit.” De viris illustribus Ordinis Praedicatorum (Bologna, 1517), fol. 154r.Google Scholar

⁴ Quétif, J. and Echard, J., Scriptores Ordinis Praedicatorum (Paris, 1719–21), 2:32; Contarini, Notizie, 137–39; Masetti, Monumenta, 1:447–50; Brotto-Zonta, Facoltà, 197–98; Gargan, Studio, 155–56.Google Scholar

⁵ Cossio, A., Il Cardinale Gaetano e la Riforma (Cividale, 1902), 24–25; M.-J. Congar, “Bio-bibliographie de Cajétan,” Revue Thomiste (1934), Suppl.: 4.Google Scholar

⁶ Perugia, Biblioteca Comunale Augusta, MS 1141, “Chronica Dominici, Conventus S. de Perusio,” fols. 66r–67v. This text was partially published by Masetti, Monumenta, 1:448–50. Since Masetti's transcription is vitiated by errors and selective omissions, I present the text in its entirety as an appendix.Google Scholar

⁷ “Postquam per centum et plures annos hec intermissa est chronica de glorioso obitu fratrum Sancti Dominici de Perusio; uel uiuentium neglectu uel obliuione seu negligentia, uel quia libellus iste ad tempus latuerit; quare et studiosos animos ad hoc opus prosequendum excitare nequiuit. Visum est mihi fratri Dominico quondam Francisci Ballienii de Perusio dominici Perusini conuentus originali filio, pium opus (quo in Dominiceo agro laborantium memoria non omnino deperit) deo duce pro uiribus innouare …” Perugia 1141, fol. 60v.Google Scholar

⁸ “Frater Vincentius … hunc et septem alios sequentes reperperi in quodam libro Romane Prouincie … Qui sequuntur hos inueni in quodam breui notula manu cuiusdam fratris Juliani de Perusio …” Ibid., fol. 61r.Google Scholar

⁹ “Omnes qui sequntur propriis uidi oculis et cognoui et uita functi sunt, quorum egregia acta fideliter scribam.” Ibid., fol. 64r.Google Scholar

¹⁰ Masetti, , Monumenta, 447, attributes to Valentino the surname “Evangelisti” but does not give his source. I suspect that Masetti transformed the patronymic “di Evangelista.”Google Scholar

¹¹ Magistrorum ac Procuratorum Generalium Ordinis Praedicatorum Registra Litterarum Minora (1469–1523). in MOPH 21, ed. Meersseman, G. and Planzer, D. (Rome, 1947), 43 n. 50.Google Scholar

¹² The faculty of theology of the University of Perugia was founded by Gregory IX on 11 October 1371. See Bini, V., Memorie Istoriche della Perugina Università degli Studii (Perugia, 1816), 54–60, 237–65; Ermini, G., Storia della Università di Perugia (Bologna, 1947), 18, 195–96.Google Scholar

¹³ Masetti, , Monumenta, 1:447.Google Scholar

¹⁴ Kaeppeli, T., Inventari di libri di San Domenico di Perugia (1430–80) (Rome, 1962), 186.Google Scholar

¹⁵ Masetti, Monumenta, 1:448.Google Scholar

¹⁶ “Magister Valentinus de Camereno habuit litteras sue absolutionis ab officio prioratus Perusini ad beneplacitum … Datum Rome 3 Julii ?1478〈.” AGOP IV, 3, fol. 307r.Google Scholar

¹⁷ Acta Capitulorum Generalium Ordinis Praedicatorum (1380–1498). in MOPH 8, ed. Reichert, B. M. (Rome, 1900), 346.Google Scholar

¹⁸ Kaeppeli, , Inventari, 309.Google Scholar

¹⁹ MOPH 8:354.Google Scholar

²⁰ Ibid., 364.Google Scholar

²¹ “Magister Valentinus de Camereno et frater Christoforus de Perusio fuerunt instituti procuratores syndici conuentus sancti Dominici de Perusio cum plenaria auctoritate colligendi redditus et respondendi et comparendi in iudicio ecclesiastico uel seculari ac instituendi procuratores pro emergentibus causis conuentus et remouendi et omnia alia facendi que syndici conuentus facere consueuerunt et cansantur [!] omnes alii syndici a Reuerendissimo vel a predecessoribus seu inferiore factis et qualitercunque et nullus inferior super [?] potest aliud ordinare. In contrarium faciendis non obstantis quibuscunque. Datum Florentie die 30 Julii 1483.” AGOP IV, 6, fol. 79r.Google Scholar

²² “Magister Valentinus de Camereno fuit institutus regens conuentus Perusini cum omnibus gratiis et priuilegiis et immunitatibus talibus dare consueuit et mandatur ei in uirtute Spiritus Sancti et sancte obedientie quatenus hoc onus acceptet et mandatur presidenti conuentus ut ipsum recipiat. Datum Rome die 3 Septembris 1483.” Ibid., fol. 81r.Google Scholar

²³ MOPH 8:381.Google Scholar

²⁴ “Mag. Valentino Camotti, priori conventus Minervae, committuntur vices magistri ordinis super conventu Perusino cum potestate omnia faciendi, quae Magister Ordinis potest, etsi mandatum exigerent speciale. Romae 18 Oct. 1484.” MOPH 21:43 n. 50.Google Scholar

²⁵ “Magistro Valentino priori Perusino mandatur ut retinent fratres Raphaelem et Franciscum de Pisis nouitios. Pisis die 3a Septembris ?1488〈.” AGOP IV, 9, fol. 79v.Google Scholar

²⁶ Contarini, , Notizie, 137.Google Scholar

²⁷ Brotto-Zonta, , Facoltà, 197.Google Scholar

²⁸ Contarini, , Notizie, 137–38, reproduces the decree of appointment.Google Scholar

²⁹ Gargan, , Studio, 156 n. 1.Google Scholar

³⁰ “Magister Valentinus conuentus Perusini fit uicarius eiusdem conuentus in temporalibus et spiritualibus, in capitibus et in membris cum potestate confirmandi priore?m〈 electum etc. Die 19 Junii Venetiis 1493.” AGOP IV, 10, fol. 79r.Google Scholar

³¹ Masetti, , Monumenta, 1:448.Google Scholar

³² “Capitulum prouinciale assignatur Ferrarie in capitulo generali. Die 29 Martii. ?1494〈.” AGOP IV, 10, fol. 81v.Google Scholar

³³ “Magister Valentinus de Camereno conuentus Perusinii confirmatur in prouincialem Romane prouincie cum plena potestate; die 21 Maii ?1484〈.” Ibid., fol. 83v. Masetti, Monumenta, 1:445. Panella, E., “Frammenti del Capitolo Generale Ferrara 1494,” AFP 61 (1991): 131–35.Google Scholar

³⁴ “Magister Joannes Caroli de Florentia fit uicarius generalis prouincie in absentia prouincialis. Die 22 Maii ?1494〈.” AGOP IV, 10, fol. 83v.Google Scholar

³⁵ “Die 2 Junii 1494. Theologiae, S. Valentinus, Magister F. de Perusio in Patavino Gymnasio Metaphysicam agens, Principem adiit, cui se supplicem praebuit: cum electus fuisset Romanae Provinciae Visitator provincialis, petiit ut ad id munus per unum mensem obeundum, sibi concedi, quod cum substitutione alterius Magistri ad lectiones docendas, quousque redierit, obtinuit.” Rossi, A., “Cronaca,” cited by Contarini, Notizie, 139.Google Scholar

³⁶ Masetti, , Monumenta, 1:448.Google Scholar

³⁷ “Reuerendus Magister Valentinus de Perusio absoluitur ab officio prouincialatus prouincie Romane ad suum beneplacitum, post mensem augusti, et idem remanet uicarius prouincie et elections etc. et post absolutionem prouincialatus et uicariatus prouincie committitur cura eidem conuentum Perusini cui datur uicarius. Die 14 Junii ?1498〈 Ferrarie.” AGOP IV, 12, fol. 46r.Google Scholar

³⁸ “Magister Valentinus Camers conuentus Perusii absoluitur ab officiio prouintialatus: et magister Ludouico de Viterbio instituitur uicarius dicte prouintie … Die 14 Januarii ?1499〈 Rome.” Ibid., fol. 48v.Google Scholar

³⁹ La “Cronaca” del convento Domenicano di Romano S. di Lucca, ed. Verde, A. F. and Corsi, D., in Memorie Domenicane, N.S. 21 (1990): xlii, xliii, 174, 193.Google Scholar

⁴⁰ MOPH 8:422.Google Scholar

⁴¹ “Magister Valentinus de Perusio fit regens Perusinus cum gratiis etc. Die 20 ut supra ?Maii 1499〈.” AGOP IV, 12, fol. 51v.Google Scholar

⁴² “Commit?ti〈tur magistro Valentino de Perusio quod possit citare fratrem Thomam de Augubio etc. ut coram eo compareat cum censuris et penis etc. quia habet contra se suspitionem furti comissi in monasterio s. Margarite de Augubio etc. potest in ista causa reddere partibus iustitie complementum etc. et casu quo non comparieat habetur pro conuicto etc. et mandatur prioribus conuentuum cuiusuis prouintie etc. ut eum incarcerent etc. etiam cum auxilio brachii secularis si erit expediens etc. et cassantur omnes commissiones cuiusuis facte in causa ista etc. In con?trarium〈 etc. Die 4 ut supra ?Maii 1500〈.” Ibid., 13, fol. 43v.Google Scholar

⁴³ “R.do Magistro Valentino conuentus Perusini conceditur ut ex bonis quondam fratris Dominici Theotorici possit recipere usque ad 7 ducatos quod sibi mutuauit etc. Die 10 Octobris ?1501〈, Rome.” Ibid., 15, fol. 62v.Google Scholar

⁴⁴ Acta Capitulorum Generalium Ordinis Praedicatorum (1501–1553). in MOPH 9, ed. Reichert, B. M. (Rome, 1901), 82.Google Scholar

⁴⁵ Masetti, , Monumenta, 1:448.Google Scholar

⁴⁶ “Magister Valentinus de Perusio debet visitare monasterium Santi Pauli de Urbeveteri cum plenissima auctoritate super omnes illius personas utriusque sexus ubicumque existentes, quibus mandatur sub poena gravioris culpae, ut ei oboediant. 26. Febr. ?1509〈 Romae.” Registrum Litterarum Fr. Thomae de Vio Caietani Ordinis Praedicatorum Magistri Ordinis 1508–1513 in MOPH 17, ed. A De Meyer (Rome, 1935), 113 n. 83.Google Scholar

⁴⁷ “Magister Valentinus de Camerino, conventus Perusini, instituitur vicarius provinciae Romanae cum auctoritate solita illorum vicariorum super conventus, monasteria et personas tertii habitus, quae solent regi a provinciali, quousque provincialis electus, confirmatus et praesens exstiterit in provincia; et imponitur ei in remissionem peccatorum, ut acceptet; et praecipitur omnibus, ut ei oboediant. In contrarium facientibus etc. 20. Nov. ?1509〈 Pisis.” Ibid., 126 n. 154.Google Scholar

⁴⁸ “Magister Valentinus de Camerino fit vicarius super conventus Minervae, de Urbe, Perusinum et Cortonensem, et super personas tertii habitus ab illi gubernari solitis, cum auctoritate provincialis in temporalibus et spiritualibus; et praecipitur fratribus illorum conventuum, ut ei in omnibus oboediant. In contrarium etc. 20 Dec. (1509) Senis.” Ibid., 129 n. 268.Google Scholar

⁴⁹ Ibid., 135 n. 205.Google Scholar

⁵⁰ Cajetan's second register (1514–18) is lost.Google Scholar

⁵¹ “Studio Perusino ordinatur … De praeteritis officialibus vero Magister Valentinus iudicare et compellere possit ad rationem reddendam et satisfaciendum etc … 8 Sept. ?1510〈 Reate.” MOPH 17:137 n. 220.Google Scholar

⁵² “Die 25 ?Iunii 1510〈. Fr. Baptistae Tifernatis in conventus Castellani priorem per patentes litteras confirmatur electio, ipso eodem prius a conventus Fulginatis prioratu absoluto eique instituendi electionis vicarium auctoritate concessa, mag. vero Valentino confirmandi cassandique electionem seu electiones.” Kaeppeli, T., “Il registro di Sebastiano Bontempi O.P., priore provinciale romano (1510–15),” AFP 31 (1961): 310.Google Scholar

⁵³ “Die 21 Aprilis 1514. Feci praeceptum fr. Thomae de Pavia conventus Perusini sub poena gravioris culpae et carceris ne accedat Cortonium, sed praesentet se priori Minervae coram mag. Valentino …” Ibid., 321.Google Scholar

⁵⁴ “Die 20 Iulii ?1514〈. Dedi R.mo generali coram priore conventus et camerario et mag. Valentino in claustro ecclesiae veteris ducatos 15 pro contributione anni 1514.” Ibid., 321–22.Google Scholar

⁵⁵ The claim was first made by Quétif and Echard, Scriptores (n. 4 above), 2: 14, who mistakenly believed that the convent of Gaeta belonged to the Congregation of Lombardy at the time of Cajetan's reception. Equally unfounded is the assertion, that Cajetan became a member of the Province (!) of Lombardy by transfiliating from the convent of Gaeta to that of Ferrara, made by Andrea Rovetta da Brescia, Bibliotheca Chronologica Provinciae Lombardiae O.P. (Bologna, 1691), 111.Google Scholar

⁵⁶ “Thomas de Vio Cayetanus, de Provincia Regni … Qui et majorum operam in reformando Ordine nonnumquam risit, etsi ab ineunte aetate in observantia Neapolitana educatus …” Olmeda, S., Chronica Ordinis Praedicatorum (Rome, 1936), 188.Google Scholar

⁵⁷ See Miele, M., La Riforma Domenicana a Napoli nel periodo post-Tridentino (1583–1725) (Rome, 1963), 53.Google Scholar

⁵⁸ See A. D'Amato, “Sull'introduzione della riforma domenicana nel Napoletano per opera della Congregazione Lombarda (1489–1501),” AFP 26 (1956): 249–75.Google Scholar

⁵⁹ For example, one of Cajetan's first acts after his election as Master General in 1508 was to concede to a relative the chamber which he had previously constructed at his own expense in the convent of Gaeta. See MOPH 17:153 n. 11.Google Scholar

⁶⁰ “Fr. Thomas de Vio de Caieta assignatur Bononiae. Caietae 8. Apr. 1485.” MOPH 21:47.Google Scholar

⁶¹ “Fr. Thomas de Vio de Gaieta assignatur studens artium Bononie … Datum Rome 18. Junii 1488.” AGOP IV, 9, fol. 98v.Google Scholar

⁶² “Fr. Thomas de Vio potest ire ad prouinciam et conuentum suum Gaietanum, ibique morari et stare quousque plenam recuperauit sanitatem. Datum Rome 4. Decembris 1488.” Ibid., fol. 105v.Google Scholar

⁶³ “Ego frater Thomas Caietanus provincie Regni Sicilie pro meo felici ingressu solvi duos aureos, anni domini 1491 die 24 maii, existente magistro studentium fratre Hieronimo de Monopoli.” Vicenza, Bib. Bertoliana, MS 3.II.9 cited by Gargan, Studio, 157 n. 1. For Merlino's regency at this time see ibid., 150.Google Scholar

⁶⁴ “In conventu Paduano in provincia Dominici, S. in regentem damus et in bachalarium pro primo et secundis annis fratrem Iacobum … pro tercio et quarto fratrem Ieronimum de Monopoli; in biblicum pro primo et secundo annis fratrem Ieronimum de Monopoli predictum, pro tercio vero fratrem Iohannem de Ragusio; in magistrum studencium pro primo et secundo anno fratrem Iohannem de Ragusio predictum, pro tercio anno fratrem Thomam de Vio de Gaeta …” MOPH 8: 404.Google Scholar

⁶⁵ This table is constructed from the information provided in Gargan, Studio (for individuals, see index of names).Google Scholar

⁶⁶ “Die 10 Maii ?1492〈 Padue. Frater Joannes de Ragusio fit biblicus, bacchallaureus extra ordinarius frater Onofrius et magister studii frater Thomas de Gaieto.” AGOP IV, 10, fol. 60v.Google Scholar

⁶⁷ “1493 indictione 11 martis 19 – mart. in eccl. cath. in capella Georgii, S. Incorporatio et bachalaureatus ven. et religiosi d. fr. Thomae de Vio Cayetani provinciae Regni ord. praed. praesentati per sacrum collegium dominorum theologorum studii paduani. Coram rev. patre d. Leonardo Contareno Vic. – existente decano mag. Iohanne Gotula ord. min. regente vero mag. Vincentio Merlino ord. praed … Et cum eo dispensatum fuit super dilatione temporis in cursu lecturae …” Padua, Archivio dell'Università, MS 660, fol. 92, cited by Brotto-Zonta, Facoltà, 198 n. 5.Google Scholar

⁶⁸ Gargan, , Studio, 157.Google Scholar

⁶⁹ Contarini, , Notizie, 150–52; Brotto-Zonta, Facoltà, 195–96; Gargan, Studio, 150–51.Google Scholar

⁷⁰ “Tommaso de Vio … Succedette a Valentino da Perugia del medesimo ordine. Nessun pubblico documento però ci pervenne a tale riguardo.” Brotto-Zonta, Facoltà, 199.Google Scholar

⁷¹ Gargan, , Studio, 155 n. 1.Google Scholar

⁷² See Laurent, “Les premières biographies” (n. 1 above), 451.Google Scholar

⁷³ “Gratiasque mecum agant Salvatori nostri Iesu Christo, Qui opus hoc in conventu Brixiensi, Anno Christianae salutis Millesimo quadrigentesimo nonagesimo sexto, In die Sacratissimae Nativitatis suae consummari concessit, etc.” Cajetan, In Praedicabilia Porphyrii, Praedicamenta, et libros Posteriorum Analyticorum Aristotelis commentaria (Venice, 1587), 212.Google Scholar

⁷⁴ “Fratri Thome de Gaeta magistro sub excommunicationis pena mandatur ut fratri Bernardo de Gaeta soluat ducatos 7 uel cum eo componat in termino 3 menssium etc. Die 19 Dec. ?1495〈 Bononie.” AGOP IV, 11, fol. 82v.Google Scholar

⁷⁵ “Valentinus Camers, Theologiae Magister doctissimus in Ordine Praedicatorum, magnus Peripatheticus, et Thomista, ac Cardinalis Ioannis [!] de Vio Gaietani magister. Scripsit plusquam 150 quaestiones super Metaphisicam. Eius opera asservantur M.S. in Bibliotheca Dominici, Conventus S. Perusiae …” Ludovicus Iacobillus, Bibliotheca Umbriae (Foligno, 1658), 264.Google Scholar

⁷⁶ “Valentinus Perusinus in Umbria, alii dicunt de Camerino, Picenus doctissimus Magister, ac celeberrimus Peripateticus, Praeceptor Thomae de Vio Caietani scripsit. Centum quinquaginta quaestiones metaphysicas, quam m.s. circumferuntur inter nostrates Provinciae Etruriae.” Ambrosius de Altamura, Bibliothecae Dominicanae (Rome, 1677), 222.Google Scholar

⁷⁷ Milan, Biblioteca Ambrosiana, MS G 69 Inf. This codex is a late sixteenth-century compilation of very disparate items (fol. 171r bears the annotation “A. D. MDLXXVI. Oct, M. Pist?oriae〈).” For a description and list of contents see: Kristeller, P. O., Iter Italicum. I (London-Leyden, 1963), 290–91; Gabriel, A. L., A Summary Catalogue of Microfilms of One Thousand Scientific Manuscripts in The Ambrosiana Library, Milan (Notre Dame, 1968), 141–42.Google Scholar

⁷⁸ Milan G 69 Inf., fols. 151r–168v.Google Scholar

⁷⁹ The history of the debate on this issue in the Thomistic school has been traced by Krempel, A., La doctrine de la relation chez Saint Thomas (Paris, 1952). Krempel was not familiar with either Valentino's quaestio or Silvestro da Prierio's extensive and bitter attack on Cajetan (see n. 80 below).Google Scholar

⁸⁰ See Silvester Prierias, Conflatum ex Thoma S. (Perugia, 1519), q. 28, fols. 206r–207v; Chrisostomus Javellus, Quaestiones super XII Metaphysices (Venice, 1534, but completed 1532), V, q. 22. See Opera Omnia (Lyon, 1580), 1: 767–68.Google Scholar

⁸¹ BN MS Latin 3076.Google Scholar

⁸² Milan G 69 Inf., fols. 131r–137v. It should be noted that the compiler of the codex expresses a doubt about the attribution of this quaestio to Valentino but fails to provide any substantive argument (ibid., fol. 139r).Google Scholar

⁸³ I have discussed Silvestro da Prierio's attack on Cajetan in my “Silvestro da Prierio and the Pomponazzi Affair” which is to appear in Renaissance and Reformation. Google Scholar

⁸⁴ See “De Commentariis Francisci de Sylvestris Ferrariensis” in Thomas Aq., Opera Omnia, ed. Leonina (Rome, 1918), 13:xli.Google Scholar

⁸⁵ See: M.-H. Laurent, “Introductio. Le Commentaire de Cajétan sur le De Anima,” in Thomas de Vio Cardinalis Caietanis, Scripta philosophica: Commentaria in de Anima Aristotelis, ed. Coquelle, P. I. (Rome, 1938), 1: vii–liii; Gilson, E. “Autour de Pomponazzi. Problématique de l'immortalité de l'Ame en Italie au début du XVIe siècle,” Archives d'Histoire Doctrinale et Littéraire du Moyen Age 36 (1961): 163–279 and “L'affaire de l'immortalité de l’âme à Venise au début du XVIe siècle,” Umanesimo europeo e umanesimo veneziano, ed. Branca, V. (Florence, 1963), 31–61; Di Napoli, G., L'immortalità dell'anima nel rinascimento (Turin, 1963).Google Scholar

⁸⁶ See Spina's Propugnaculum Aristotelis de immortalitatae animae contra Thomam Caietanum in Opulscula [!] edita per fratrem Bartholomeum de spina pisanum ordinis praedicatorum (Venice, 1519).Google Scholar

⁸⁷ Iavelli presented two critiques of Cajetan, in Quaestiones naturales super III de Anima (Venice, 1534) and Tractatus de animae humanae indeficentia (Venice, 1536). See Opera Omnia (n. 80 above), 1: 674–79 and 2:39–55.Google Scholar

¹ See Cajetan, , In III De Anima. ed. Picard, G. and Pelland, G. (Bruges-Paris, 1965), nn. 92–98.Google Scholar

² De Anima I, 403a 10–16.Google Scholar

³ De Anima I, 403a 3–9.Google Scholar

⁴ Cajetan employs in his commentary the medieval, verbo e verbo, Latin translation of the De Anima confected by William of Moerbeke. Valentino prefers the Renaissance Latin translation made by Iohannes Argyropylus in 1460. Revised several times and first printed in 1496, it gradually became the standard translation. The University of Padua, nonetheless, continued to use the Moerbeke translation to the end of the sixteenth century. See Cranz, F. E., “The Renaissance Reading of the De Anima,” in Platon et Aristote à la Renaissance (Paris, 1976), 359–76.Google Scholar

⁵ See Cajetan, , In De Anima. ed. Coquelle, P. I. (Rome, 1938), 1: n. 47.Google Scholar

⁶ De Anima III, 431a15, 4231b2.Google Scholar

⁷ See Cajetan, , In III De Anima (n. 1 above), n. 115.Google Scholar

⁸ Ethica, 1100a9–b6.Google Scholar

⁹ Metaphysica XII, 1072b18, 29.Google Scholar

¹⁰ See Cajetan, , In III De Anima, n. 98.Google Scholar

¹¹ De Anima III, 430a23–25.Google Scholar

¹² See Cajetan, , In III De Anima, nn. 93–94.Google Scholar

¹³ De Anima III, 430a17.Google Scholar

¹⁴ Ibid., 430a21–22.Google Scholar

¹⁵ Ibid., 430a22–23.Google Scholar

¹⁶ Albert, , De Homine (“Summa de Creaturis, IIa”), in Opera Omnia (“Ed. Paris.”), ed. Borgnet, A. (Paris, 1896), 35:q. 55, aa. 3–4.Google Scholar

¹⁷ I have not been able to trace this reference. A work bearing such a title does not appear among either Albert's opera authentica or the opera spuria. Google Scholar

¹⁸ Albert, , De Anima. in Opera Omnia (“Ed. Colon.”), ed. Stroick, C. (Münster, 1968), 7.1:204–05.Google Scholar

¹⁹ Ibid., 210–11.Google Scholar

²⁰ De Anima III, 430a14–16.Google Scholar

²¹ De Generatione Animalium II, 736b28.Google Scholar

²² See Cajetan, , In De Anima (n. 5 above) I, n. 45.Google Scholar

²³ De Anima II, 413a2–9, 413b25–6.Google Scholar

²⁴ De Anima III, 429a17–429b5.Google Scholar

²⁵ Analytica Posteriora I, 86a31–32.Google Scholar

²⁶ De Anima II, 413b25.Google Scholar

²⁷ De Anima III, 430a22–23.Google Scholar

²⁸ Metaphysica XII, 1070a26.Google Scholar

²⁹ Averroes, , Aristotelis Opera cum Averrois Commentariis, 8 (Venice, 1562), textus 16, fol. 302v H.Google Scholar

³⁰ Cajetan, , In De Ente et Essentia, ed. M.-H. Laurent (Turin, 1934), chap. V, n. 104, ad 4um, 169.Google Scholar

³¹ De Generatione Animalium 2.736b21–28.Google Scholar

³² Pseudo-Aristotle, , De Causis Proprietatum Elementorum, in Aristotelis … operum, 7 (Venice, 1560), fols. 279v–286v.Google Scholar

³³ De Generatione Animalium 2.736b21–29.Google Scholar

³⁴ See Cajetan In Iam, q. 90, a. 2, IV, in Thomas Aq., Opera Omnia (“Editio Leonina”), V (Rome, 1889), 387.Google Scholar

³⁵ Albert De Anima (n. 8 above), 192–95.Google Scholar

³⁶ Ibid., 193, 36–39.Google Scholar

³⁷ Natalis, Hervaeus, In IV Sententiarum Commentaria (Paris, 1647), IV, d. 1, q. 1, 308 D.Google Scholar

³⁸ Physica I, 192a25–9.Google Scholar

³⁹ De Anima III, 429a27.Google Scholar

⁴⁰ Analytica Posteriora 1, 85b16–9.Google Scholar

⁴¹ De Anima II, 412a1–412b9.Google Scholar

⁴² Ibid., 412a27.Google Scholar

⁴³ Ibid., 412b10–15.Google Scholar

⁴⁴ Ibid., 413a4–413a10.Google Scholar

⁴⁵ De Anima III, 429a15.Google Scholar

⁴⁶ Ibid., 430a20–5.Google Scholar

⁴⁷ Averroes, , Commentarium Magnum in Aristotelis De Anima libros. ed. Crawford, F. S. (Cambridge, Mass., 1953) 3: 5, 17–22.Google Scholar

⁴⁸ Ethica I, 1102b30–1103a3.Google Scholar

⁴⁹ De Anima III, 433a7–14.Google Scholar

⁵⁰ De Anima III, 433b27–434a5.Google Scholar

⁵¹ Cajetan In III De Anima (n. 1 above), n. 98.Google Scholar

⁵² Ethica X, 1178a8.Google Scholar

⁵³ De Anima III, 430a17.Google Scholar

⁵⁴ Ibid., 430a20–21.Google Scholar

⁵⁵ Albert De Anima (n. 18 above), 205–6.Google Scholar

⁵⁶ Albert De Homine (n. 16 above), q. 57, a. 1.Google Scholar

⁵⁷ De Anima III, 430a22–23.Google Scholar

⁵⁸ Metaphysica VII, 1032a21.Google Scholar